13 ms·
Covid drug drives viral mutations – and now some want to halt its use
- sunkenvicar 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- elhudy 4y agoWhat's the alternative for those who are at high risk of being hospitalized or experiencing permanent damage from covid? Until there is a clear alternative, this drug probably isn't going anywhere.
- AmericanChopper 4y agoFrom the article: > Sarah Otto, an evolutionary biologist at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, Canada, says the paper is another blow to the continued use of molnupiravir. She notes that a large-scale UK study found that the drug had no effect on hospitalizations or deaths
- elhudy 4y agoI read the article and my point still stands. Put yourself in the shoes of the patient (who largely drives their own care for these situations). You get covid, you go into the dr with a cough and say "dr, this is getting bad, and I'm obese and scared!" The dr goes, "well, we have this drug that was proven to be slightly effective in double blind placebo controlled trials. It has no adverse side-effects. But a large scale study showed it might not actually be effective. Would you like to try that?" The patient, who is probably on medicare or hit their deductible, is going to say yes give me that shit. People have been saying this same thing about the over-prescription of antibiotics for ages but nothing has changed.
- sarchertech 4y agoIn this case there is a much more effective drug available—-Paxlovid.
- elhudy 4y agoTotally agreed, however... >There are 636 drugs known to interact with Paxlovid (nirmatrelvir/ritonavir), along with 5 disease interactions, and 2 alcohol/food interactions. Of the total drug interactions, 236 are major, 360 are moderate, and 40 are minor. Of these interactions, several are with: statins, blood thinners, hormonal birth controls, and other heart medications. The exact high-risk population who is taking these drugs, have potential interactions with paxlovid. That wipes out a significant portion of the general population from eligibility.
- sarchertech 4y ago636 interactions sounds impressive. But almost any drug that’s been around for a while (like Ritonavir has) will have hundreds of interactions listed. Drug interaction databases aren’t complete nonsense, but you should take them with a huge grain of salt. The vast majority of those interactions won’t prevent a physician from prescribing Paxlovid, and for most of the rest there are either alternatives or patients can lower dosages or stop taking them for the duration of treatment.
- elhudy 4y agoFor better or worse, I'm fairly certain statins do prevent drs from prescribing paxlovid on occasion. Happened to a family member. Tons of high risk / older Americans are on statins.
- sarchertech 4y agoThere are statins that can be taken with Paxlovid. The general recommendations are to either to stop taking them 12 hours before through a few days after treatment or switch temporarily to one of the statins that can be take with Paxlovid.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- superkuh 4y agoDespite the phrasing of this title there's always been a better alternative and the problems were well known. Paxlovid is better in every way and it was approved for sars-cov-2 first. Molnupiravir should never have been approved for sars-cov-2 caused covid-19 for out patient use. It was never given except in the context of supervised hospital care for other viral diseases. There's an argument that it could've been approved for this limiting situation but out-patient use was and is absurd.
- kec 4y agoPaxlovid apparently has interactions with a large number of relatively common medications, Molnupiravir does not (and one would hope it is only being used in cases where paxlovid is unavailable).
- westcort 4y agoNot so: Clinical data supporting this EUA are based on data from 1,433 randomized subjects in the Phase 3 MOVe-OUT trial (NCT04575597). MOVe-OUT is a randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind clinical trial studying LAGEVRIO for the treatment of non-hospitalized patients with mild-to-moderate COVID-19 who are at risk for progressing to severe COVID-19 and/or hospitalization. Eligible subjects were 18 years of age and older and had one or more pre-defined risk factors for disease progression: over 60 years of age, diabetes, obesity (BMI ≥30), chronic kidney disease, serious heart conditions, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, or active cancer. https://dailymed.nlm.nih.gov/dailymed/fda/fdaDrugXsl.cfm?setid=1b0da643-ab23-4a0b-a9ec-a434522446d0 https://dailymed.nlm.nih.gov/dailymed/fda/fdaDrugXsl.cfm?set...
- superkuh 4y agoSo. From the updated EUA for paxlovid which includes the date of the original EUA, https://www.fda.gov/media/155049/download https://www.fda.gov/media/155049/download >On December 22, 2021, the FDA issued an EUA for emergency use of PAXLOVID for the treatment of mild-to-moderate COVID-19 in adults and pediatric patients (12 years of age and older weighing at least 40 kg)... And from your linked document, >LAGEVRIO™ (molnupiravir) capsules, for oral use Original EUA Authorized Date: 12/23/2021 Paxlovid was approved 1 day before molnupiravir. Everything I said was true.
- loeg 4y ago> What's the alternative for those who are at high risk Paxlovid, which was approved first and is more effective.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- qbasic_forever 4y agoWear high quality N95 masks around the general public and people you haven't personally trusted to test negative that day.
- mrob 4y agoOr better yet, a N100 or equivalent half-face respirator, which will likely be more comfortable because of the soft elastomeric seal, as well as being more effective.
- keyanp 4y agoHeadline is a bit misleading, the important conclusion is near the end: “Bloom thinks the researchers make a good case that molnupiravir treatment is yielding some highly mutated viruses with the capacity to spread. But it’s not clear whether this could contribute to new coronavirus variants, or whether it is simply creating weakling viruses that are unlikely to spread very far.” If it’s the former then I imagine the case is pretty strong to discontinue usage and switch to Paxlovid.
- yosito 4y agoThe former and the latter seem like two sides of the same coin.
- elif 4y agoYa it seems like an overessentialized dichotomous understanding imposed logically over what is essentially unsupervised gambling.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- KVFinn 4y ago>If it’s the former then I imagine the case is pretty strong to discontinue usage and switch to Paxlovid. Molnupiravir is already the last line treatment, it's been that way from the start. It should never be used in cases where the patient can take Paxlovid. Well it's above Convalescent Plasma, but that's because that's barely beneficial and I don't know if anyone is even using it now. In order of preference: 1. Paxlovid 2. Remdesivir 3. Various IV Monoclonals 4. Molnupiravir 5. Plasma https://twiv.s3.amazonaws.com/COVID+treatment+summary+020223.pdf https://twiv.s3.amazonaws.com/COVID+treatment+summary+020223...
- cameldrv 4y agoYeah it seems like Remdesivir doesn’t get mentioned much anymore. IIRC it had not so great efficacy numbers in earlier studies where it was given later after someone came to the hospital with COVID. Also IIRC it trialed pretty well if given early on an outpatient basis. It seems like it could fill some of the hole left now that mAbs don’t work, especially for people who can’t take Paxlovid.
- barathr 4y agoAnd this was known to be a problem a year ago and Merck kept pushing it forward despite its low efficacy and risk for driving mutation. Meanwhile Paxlovid is underprescribed despite its effectiveness.
- nikolay 4y ago[flagged]
- thepangolino 4y agoWhat really bothers me with Ivermectin is that it used to be one of the cheapest and most available drugs yet it instantly became taboo to even talk about for in the context of covid. Why a known, safe, cheap and readily available drug couldn’t be used off label in the context of an unprecedented (at least in terms of social restrictions measures) global pandemic will always remain a mystery.
- bawolff 4y agoWell merck isn't without blame here, i feel like this is what the fda is for.
- logifail 4y agoIt can be hard to believe the FDA is sufficiently independent when one reads about the revolving door straight to Big Pharma[0][1] [0] https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2016/09/28/495694559/a-look-at-how-the-revolving-door-spins-from-fda-to-industry https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2016/09/28/4956945... [1] https://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/politics/452654-for-big-pharma-the-revolving-door-keeps-spinning/ https://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/politics/452654-for-...
- pixl97 4y agoOther than the taste side effect I had, paxlovid was a miracle drug. Covid symptoms started disappearing very quickly after I took it.
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- dukeofdoom 4y ago[flagged]
- loeg 4y agoPlease avoid generic, off-topic screeds.
- dukeofdoom 4y agoIt's on topic, because it's inline with the same type of behaviour of causing the problem and benefiting from selling a solution. If tobacco company started selling a cancer drug, and taking out life insurance policies on it's smoking employees. At some point, you would think people would start to notice the apparent synchronicity
- jasonhansel 4y agoOk. How does that compare to the number of lives saved by good drugs?
- dukeofdoom 4y agoMaximize the good, minimize the the bad. I think phrasing the problem in such a broad way lets the companies do shady things for profits. It's like Gun companies saying their guns can save your life. They're probably right on that point. But it's not like guns don't cause a lot of unnecessary deaths.
- chapium 4y agoHow are cookie consent forms like this legal?
- nostromo 4y agoSince the vaccines didn’t stop transmission, can’t the same be said of them?
- loeg 4y agoMajolnurnur's primary mechanism of action is deliberately causing viral mutations, with the aim of preventing successful replication. This is somewhat different from chance mutations in vivo.
- defrost 4y agoIn the same way that seatbelts don't stop deaths from motor vehicle accidents but do significantly reduce them, vaccines don't stop transmission but they do significantly reduce the transmission rates. Similar statistical model as control rods in a nuclear reactor - they don't stop neutrons, they significantly reduce the numbe of free neutrons flying about and avoid an exponential increase and runaway chain reaction.
- ifyoubuildit 4y agoAccording to the cdc: > Seat belts reduce serious crash-related injuries and deaths by about half Do you have some evidence that the vaccines are in that ballpark against infection/transmission in 2023?
- benjaminwootton 4y agoIn the highly unlikely case that they did reduce transmission by 50%, people would still catch the same mild disease, it would just slow transmission. So that argument has a time limit which is way less than the 3 years we’ve been playing this game. And even if it was 99% effective, it certainly doesn’t justify leaving drugs in the market where one mutation potentially has humanity ending consequences. The Covid vaccine was great for helping the elderley and vulnerable from day one. For the rest of us, it was a busted flush.
- busymom0 4y agoNo they do not reduce transmission. That was clear when delta hit, they found same viral loads in vaxxed and unvaxxed even if mild symptoms. And a vax which merely reduced symptoms gives a false sense of safety where they end up becoming silent spreaders of the virus. This happened here in Ontario where during delta, an over 50s hockey league had an outbreak where 15 fully vaxxed got infected, 1 elderly died and then their family wondered how this happened. Similar thing happened in Manitoba where 80% of an elderly long term care facility got infected despite everyone being fully vaxxed. Comparing a seat belt to a permanent medical procedure inside the body is asinine. Seat belts don’t go inside the body, can be taken off, don’t need a new belt on top of old one every few months, get recalled if defective, manufacturer can be sued, belts don’t cause blood clot or heart inflammation.
- fasteddie31003 4y agoI'm not a doctor, but I had this exact thought when Molnupiravir came out. I left a comment on HN Jan 11 2022 about how I was worried about how Molnupiravir could create new variants. Also, I'd love to see the long term data on cancer rates of the people who took this drug since its mechanism seems very carcinogenic to me.
- chromatin 4y agoThe FDA approval of molnupiravir is shocking. As you note, there absolutely is the risk of incorporation of the viral nucleoside analogues into host genomic dna and ultimately cancer. of the two rodent genotoxicity / mutagenesis assays, only ONE passed. The other was equivocal. The FDA concluded that based on the short 5 day course, the risk was acceptable. This decision was, IMO, colored by COVID hysteria that still permeates many aspects of medicine and government. The types of risks (genotoxic, but also viral mutagenesis) of Molnupiravir would never be acceptable or approved in any other context.
- imrane 4y agoThe vaccines do the same thing. They are a large population forcing function for viral mutation.
- raisin_churn 4y agoThe vaccines do NOT do the same thing. Molnupiravir directly modifies the RNA in the SARS-CoV-2 active in the patient's body. That vaccines can serve as a forcing function for viruses is not new information, but so does immunity from previous infections, and vaccination comes with the benefit of preventing a non-zero number of infections and transmissions relative to immunity from previous infection. Vaccines in general, including the COVID vaccines, remain the single best tool for disease prevention.
- logicchains 4y ago>preventing a non-zero number of infections and transmissions You could argue it prevented transmissions, but given the vast majority of people everywhere have been infected, it's hard to argue the covid vaccines prevent infection, no? They only delay it.
- qbasic_forever 4y agoYou think infection only happens once? People are racking up 3rd, 4th, 5th etc. infections now. Each one is another chance to create mutations. It will not stop until we stop transmission. The more vaccinated/up to date boosted the population then the less chance for overall spread and transmission, leading to less mutations.
- raisin_churn 4y agoEvery exposure to COVID results in one of two possible outcomes: infection, or no infection. The COVID vaccines without a doubt increase the frequency of the second outcome and decrease the first, although their efficacy by this metric has been waning for over a year (they still seem superb at preventing serious illness and death). "Infections" doesn't mean "people who have ever been infected," which at this point is approaching 100% of the human population, it means "infections." The COVID vaccines prevent infections.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoIt would drive non-immune related mutations, and in general most mutations are towards less severity.
- cookiengineer 4y agoAnybody here on HN involved in phage research? As far as I understand, viruses tend to be only resistant in one direction: either antibiotics or phages, but they can't be resistant to both. In the 2010s there were a lot of public talks at the DKFZ (German cancer research center) where research teams were looking for getting more attention and funds for that area, but I have no clue what happened to that. Sars-cov-2 was kind of the prime example of a virus that you can't beat with antibiotics, so I was assuming that every pharma company would now direct their research at bacteriophage research...but there's not much information about it as far as I can tell. Anyone have some interesting papers on that?
- lolsowrong 4y agoI am not involved with phage research. However, antibiotics do not work on viruses. I believe you mean bacterial infections, which seem to either evolve protections against antibiotics or protections against bacteriophages, but not both.
- woke_neolib 4y agoPhage is short for bacteriophage. They are viruses that attack bacteria. As far as I know there are not viruses that target other viruses, except as a side effect - the viral life cycle is dependent on a host, and a coronavirus has little to offer a bacteriophage. Similarly, antibiotics target bacteria, not viruses. Antivirals often have very different mechanisms of action.
- etiam 4y agoWell described. There are viruses which affect other viruses with arguably more than a side effect ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virophage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virophage ), but for natural reasons it seems a bit off from fully analogous to bacteriophages. Coronaviruses are at the high end of size and complexity among RNA-viruses, but it's still hard for me to see that virophages would be relevant to combat SARS-CoV-2.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoI have a couple years of phage research. Unfortunately we haven't really seen phage-attacking viruses yet. I know the "first known virovore" made its rounds here a while back, but in the case of a phage attacking another virus, neither really has a "metabolism" to exploit. Your point about bacterial resistance to antibiotics vs phages is almost correct; increasing resistance against one attack broadly tends to decrease efficacy defending against the other, though as I am not familiar with the mechanisms for this, my uninformed hypothesis would be that the gene expression required comes at a high price - you can't defend against antibiotics and phage and outcompete your Petri-dishmates. I suspect that for the future, medicine will be antibiotics in combination with phage cocktails of several phage strains that sabotage in different ways (targeting capsular polysaccharides vs surface proteins vs flagella, for example), to prevent a repeat of antibiotic resistance.
- seydor 4y agoI think it's increasingly become evident that the right course of action should have been containment of the virus which would allow humanity at least a decade of research on treatments. Covid is such a bad virus, with so many long-term effects and unknown outcomes in the future that live experiments don't seem warranted anymore. We overestimated how prepared we are to deal with it. There is still simple measures we can be taking, today, in winter months, to halt the spread with lifestyle changes, but there is not even talk of it anymore
- nathias 4y agothis is magical thinking, we demonstrated beyond all that we can not contain viruses that spread that fast
- seydor 4y agoSome places demonstrated that it is possible. I don't see really evidence that the reverse is inevitable.
- thinkingemote 4y agoyou answered your own question. Some places can do it. All places cannot. Geography and international politics. Poverty, education, corruption, actual warzones, famines and natural disasters, even month long riots in developed countries - all these are happening now and happened every year since 2019. It's completely impossible for the world to stop the virus as a world.
- nathias 4y agodo you mean the small island states?
- scotty79 4y agoI wonder if there's any further research on fluvoxamine: https://www.covid19treatmentguidelines.nih.gov/therapies/miscellaneous-drugs/fluvoxamine/ https://www.covid19treatmentguidelines.nih.gov/therapies/mis... Every research so far indicated some benefit in covid (if patients managed to adhere to treatment protocol). And yet no research was solid enough to merit any type of recommendation.
- cm2187 4y agoAre mutations a problem? I think I was told that mutations typically downgraded the virus, and it seems to be what happened to covid. Don't you want to create less dangerous strains if the drug has other benefits?
- corcorcorcor 4y ago>Are mutations a problem? Oh yes! Where I am (UK), the public messaging during the later stages of Covid had everyone convinced that we needed to both vaccinate and keep up all sorts of existing restrictions, to stop Covid spreading and mutating. Everyone who doesn't take all the precautions and catches Covid is a potential source of the next variant that might kill grandma!!
- TheBigSalad 4y agoThat was the common line of thinking before Covid. Covid also seems to be mutating and getting weaker, although maybe more contagious. I suppose mutations are bad mostly because they evade the vaccine.
- raydiatian 4y agoRapture, Ryan. Rapture, Ryan.
- uwagar 4y agoi never even got covid once.