13 ms·
The Black Ships Shock: A Historic Encounter That Changed Japan
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- notadev 4y agoIn short, Commodore Perry wanted to trade with Japan. Being isolationist they declined. So Perry believed they would have to be persuaded by force. He launched a barrage of cannons while anchored in Tokyo Bay. Supposedly they were just gunpowder explosions celebrating US Independence Day, but it was likely a show of force that eventually persuaded the Japanese to open trade relations. If this were in the US or UK, Perry would likely be hated for whatever and his statue torn down. In Japan, they have multiple statues and celebrate Perry’s opening of trade relations every year with the Black Ship festival in Shimoda, Japan. The festival includes food stalls and even a parade. I’ve gone a few times, it’s nothing particularly interesting but a good experience overall.
- LarryMullins 4y agoWhat boggles my mind is that less than 100 years after this happened, the Imperial Japanese Navy was able to give the US Navy a serious run for their money. The rapid industrial and technological development of Japan is hard to comprehend. Medieval feudalism to an industrial powerhouse in just a few decades.
- hangonhn 4y agoIIRC, Japan had a very robust banking system by the time this happened so were able to finance a lot of the capital intensive developments and industrialization necessary for them to quickly catch up.
- benzofuran 4y agoDan Carlin's Hardcore History (episode 1: https://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-62-supernova-in-the-east-i/ https://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-62-supern...) recently did a great series "Supernova in the East" on the modernization of Japan and the internal politics. If you've got some time (drive or such), it's well worth the listen and there's a great diversity of sources.
- caycep 4y agodoes he have a book list for that period?
- cocacola1 4y agoOP replied in case you didn't see it: https://www.goodreads.com/list/show/177152.Dan_Carlin_s_Hardcore_History_Supernova_in_the_East https://www.goodreads.com/list/show/177152.Dan_Carlin_s_Hard...
- benzofuran 4y agoBook list: https://www.goodreads.com/list/show/177152.Dan_Carlin_s_Hardcore_History_Supernova_in_the_East https://www.goodreads.com/list/show/177152.Dan_Carlin_s_Hard... For some reason it didn't get appended to the podcast descriptions
- JoeDaDude 4y agoNot to mention giving China and Russia a run for their territory, first in the 1894 Sino-Japanese war, only some 40 odd years after opening up to world trade and rapidly industrializing.
- wkat4242 4y agoThe Japanese navy was pretty weak which was the main reason for this sneaky Pearl Harbor attack. In a direct conflict they'd have had no chance and they tried to take out as much of the fleet off the board as they could. Of course they failed miserably by hitting the legacy battleships and missing the carriers which fit better with modern doctrine.
- chanandler_bong 4y agoTheir biggest miss was not hitting the fuel dumps and repair facilities. Taking out a few ships, even carriers, would be easy to replace. Wiping out the logistics support capability would mean that ships would have to return to the US west coast to refuel/repair. That would have been a major disaster. Pearl Harbor was just an irritant and catalyst.
- credit_guy 4y agoThat's not quite correct. First of all, take a look at the map [1] of Perl Harbor from wikipedia. The oil storage tanks are listed as A, and you'll notice that they formed two different groups. By my count each had 27 tanks. If you take a look at [2], you'll see that these tanks were well separated, with an earth wall between them. It is clear that when they were built precautions were taken to prevent the spread of (accidental of intentional) fire. So, taking out the oil tanks was not as simple as dropping one bomb. You probably needed multiple passes. After the first successful pass, all others had to deal with the smoke, and more or less guess where their targets were. Of course, they would have to deal with the anti-air defenses. The second wave already took quite heavy losses, the third wave was guaranteed to incur much heavier ones. Let's say in the best case scenario, the hypothetical third Japanese wave would have destroyed half of the 54 oil tanks. It would not have made a difference. Only a success rate of 90% would have, maybe. In any case, that third wave was never planned. See [4] (written by one of hte co-authors of Shattered Sword) for convincing evidence that only 2 waves were planned, and Admiral Nagumo carried them as per the plan. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attack_on_Pearl_Harbor#/media/File:Pearlmap2.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attack_on_Pearl_Harbor#/media/... [2] https://pearlharbor.org/pearl-harbors-third-strike-what-could-have-been/ https://pearlharbor.org/pearl-harbors-third-strike-what-coul... [3] https://medium.com/war-stories/the-one-key-thing-not-destroyed-at-pearl-harbor-c73b287a719 https://medium.com/war-stories/the-one-key-thing-not-destroy... [4] https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1601&context=nwc-review https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?articl...
- Maursault 4y ago> the Imperial Japanese Navy was able to give the US Navy a serious run for their money. Sure, but not before taking out half the US Navy's battle fleet and leaving them out of commission for nearly half a year. Eventually, most damaged vessels were returned to service, but with escorts needed in the Atlantic, the Fleet was spread thin facing an opponent with more battleships with better torpedos, more carriers with better trained pilots flying (in a lot of ways) superior aircraft. Against the advice and strong objection of many high ranking naval officers, President Roosevelt's "eggs in one basket"-strategy ordering the Fleet to and to remain at Pearl Harbor as a show of force was a disastrous blunder that ultimately ensured the US would be dragged into the War under-prepared. Had Roosevelt not subsequently ordered Yamamoto taken out in 1943, the Pacific may very well have been lost.
- senthil_rajasek 4y ago"If this were in the US or UK, Perry would likely be hated for whatever and his statue torn down." I am originally from India. There are still monuments commemorating British kings ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gateway_of_India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gateway_of_India) personally I want them to be torn down. I am not comparing Japan with Colonial India but I know that in 2023 colonialism and imperialism should not be celebrated.
- hef19898 4y agoIf the statutes of british monarchs were raised during their reign, or shortly after, those statues now represent history. A bad bit of history, but history none the less. If they were erected way later, they celebrate this bad pit of history and can be torn down. History does not have to be celebrated, it definitely has to be remembered so.
- senthil_rajasek 4y agoIf walls can become memories, statues and monuments can be torn down without losing their place in history.
- bboygravity 4y agoWhat?
- pfisch 4y agoDon't tell thanksgiving.
- blipvert 4y agoJapan has a very compliant and deferential citizenship - how do you think you’d get along with that? (Edit: had -> has. flippin’ phone)
- linksnapzz 4y agoThe Japan-American Society of RI has a complementary Black Ships festival in Newport & Bristol; not a huge show but there's usually a formal dinner & taiko concert with representatives from the City of Yokohama and the JMSDF.
- leviathant 4y ago>If this were in the US or UK, Perry would likely be hated for whatever and his statue torn down. You're being ridiculous, @notadev. While I realize that by engaging, I'm falling into the trap of wrestling with a pig, no one's torn down any statues of Matthew Perry in the US.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI think the gp meant that if some foreign figure had forced their way into to the US or UK with martial threats, they would not be celebrated today the way he is in Japan - though I also wonder how enthusiastic this celebration is, as opposed to politely commemorating it.
- zizee 4y ago> If this were in the US or UK, Perry would likely be hated for whatever and his statue torn down I'm not much of a history buff, but the UK has been subject to invasions/colonialism multiple tines in tbeir history, and there are statues and events to commemotate these events. I haven't much time, but here is an example, commemorating the Battle of Hastings: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-sussex-37649912 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-sussex-37649912 I'm sure there are many other and better examples to be found.
- wrp 4y ago> If this were in the US or UK, Perry would likely be hated... The context you are missing is that the forcible opening of Japan led to the overthrow of the Shogunate and advent of the Meiji era, which was/is seen by most Japanese as a very good thing.
- fomine3 4y agoMoreover, US nuked Japan twice and bombed civilians but there have been military alliance and good feelings (at least JP to US). People know that beating closed Tokugawa shogunate and pre-WW2 regime were finally somewhat good thing so they don't blame them so much.
- idiocrat 4y agoInterestingly, during the isolation there was not a complete informational blockade. The progressive Japanese knew what is going on in Europe and how China/Asia is suffering from European colonization. So to preempt being colonized they worked on the Japan's opening and planned a rapid industrialization. (The Meiji Revolution) The Perry's conquering of Japan is a concession to the West by Japanese.
- dekhn 4y agoDon't forget- the Dutch and Porteguese both had limited trading outposts (basically monopolies, but incredibly restricted). See https://iisg.nl/exhibitions/japaneseprints/ships.html https://iisg.nl/exhibitions/japaneseprints/ships.html and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dejima https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dejima
- user982 4y ago22 years later, Japan copied this gunboat tactic closely to force the opening of Korea, taking the first steps toward annexation and empire (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japan%E2%80%93Korea_Treaty_of_1876 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japan%E2%80%93Korea_Treaty_of_...).
- BitwiseFool 4y agoReminds me of that anti-drug commercial from the 80's. >"Who taught you how to do this?" >"You, dad! I learned it from watching you!"
- labrador 4y agoI almost know how they felt because the first time I saw a US aircraft carrier up close I felt a similar sense of awe and curiosity at this immense machine and it's operation.
- xrd 4y agoIt's really fascinating to think about isolation and what that does to a culture. The almost two hundred years in which Japan implemented self ordered isolation is important to consider when comparing their modern culture to other, especially Asian, nations. I feel like Brazil, being the only country in South America that speaks Portuguese, is a similar case study. Being different and not following the herd is a strength.
- Someone 4y ago> The almost two hundred years in which Japan implemented self ordered isolation _Almost_ isolation. They traded with the Portuguese and, later, the Dutch at Dejima (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dejima https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dejima) Reading that article, I also think it was almost 300 years, from 1570 to 1854.
- xrd 4y agoYes, you are right. But that trade was the exception and there was almost no contact with westerners at all inside the country.
- boomboomsubban 4y ago>They traded with the Portuguese and, later, the Dutch at Dejima They also traded with China and Korea.
- rippercushions 4y agoIs it? That hasn't worked out great for Brazil so far.
- xrd 4y agoIMHO Brazil has a thriving tech scene that outperforms other Latin American countries. It's a complicated country for sure, but I think it is a success. As they say, "Brazil is the country of the future and always will be."
- CogitoCogito 4y ago
- DoreenMichele 4y agoDozens of different kawaraban were published after Perry’s fleet arrived, with each one said to have run to around 1,000 copies. This is a tiny number compared to newspaper circulation today, but the total printed in a short period was unprecedented in the Edo period (1603–1868), and they gave people a detailed picture of the treaty negotiations. I found the section about the kawaraban especially interesting. The above detail captures some sense of how newsworthy these events were and the scope of the impact it had on Japan.
- croes 4y ago> persuaded by force Or simply forced
- tkgally 4y agoAn American journalist named Bayard Taylor was in Shanghai in 1853 when Perry stopped there on his way to Japan. Taylor enlisted in the U.S. Navy so that he could join Perry’s expedition as a clerk [1], and the notes he kept were later incorporated into the official U.S. report of the expedition [2]. Taylor’s own later account of their arrival in Japan makes good reading [3]. More Western writing about Japan in the 19th and early 20th centuries is collected in my Japan As They Saw It [4]. [1] https://archive.org/details/cu31924031232360/page/360/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/cu31924031232360/page/360/mode/2... [2] https://archive.org/details/narrativeofexped00perr/page/n5/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/narrativeofexped00perr/page/n5/m... [3] https://archive.org/details/cu31924031232360/page/410/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/cu31924031232360/page/410/mode/2... [4] https://www.gally.net/jatsi/index.html https://www.gally.net/jatsi/index.html
- totetsu 4y agoYou can go sit under the (regrowth of) the original tree that these treaties were signed next to near Yamashita park in Yokohama. Also the wifi password for a public event venue on the waterfront there is something like Perry1854
- totetsu 4y agoActually the wifi password is 'perry0602' which seems to correspond to "June 2 Fleet moves from Shimoda to Naha." .. so its commemorating the the day Perry left the mainland X'D
- ekm2 4y agoObligatory quote from Asimov's "The Gods Themselves": about two and a half centuries ago, the American naval commander Matthew Perry led a flotilla into Tokyo harbor. The Japanese, till then isolated,found themselves faced with a technology considerably beyond their own and decided it was unwise to risk resistance. An entire warlike nation of millions was helpless in the face of a few ships from across the sea.Did that prove that Americans were more intelligent than the Japanese were, or merely that Western culture had taken a different turning? Clearly the latter, for within half a century, the Japanese successfully imitated Western technology and within another half a century were a major industrial power despite the fact that they were disastrously beaten in one of the wars of the time.
- blackflame7000 4y ago[dead]