18 ms·
Screw motivation, what you need is discipline
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- marifjeren 4y agoSo.. you should do the things you're supposed to do, even when you don't want to do them? Isn't this already plainly obvious to literally everyone?
- Madmallard 4y agoMake it a matter of life and death. It does wonders for motivation and discipline.
- froidpink 4y agoI needed this, thanks! Now I'm motivated to be disciplined! Let's see how long that lasts
- ghastmaster 4y agoWhat I needed was sleep. In order to get that sleep, I had to have my gallbladder removed. Once that was done, I had to stop eating dairy. Now I can sleep again. I feel much much younger. I cannot believe how long I was going on listlessly, unknowing that my laziness was a side effect of health issues.
- voisin 4y agoHow did you come to realize you needed your gallbladder removed?
- swamp40 4y agoIt usually tells you quite loudly.
- ghastmaster 4y agoIt took me nearly 20 years to realize it was dragging me down, which is now known to be common in my maternal genes. I had a night after dinner with fever, queasy, lack of urination, and upset stomach. I was subsequently affected with stomach and bowel pain and inflammation when I ate for a couple days. About a month prior to this episode, I had a slight sharp pain on the right side under my rib cage(typical location for male gallbladder symptoms). At the time I figured this was due to a misalignment in my spine(quite typical for me at the time). I put together the current condition(associated with food intake) and the previous pain to conclude that I needed to have my gallbladder checked. I went with the least invasive, lowest false negative, and least expensive check first, an ultrasound. Thankfully(more on this later), it showed a polyp near the base of the gallbladder. With my symptoms and ultrasound report, I was a candidate for removal. Two years after the described episode I had it removed. I opted out of pathology and let the surgeon open up the gallbladder and report to me. He found no polyp! It was full of stones. They varied in size from a grain of sand to 7mm. The ultrasound technician was correct in their assessment of the image, however, the image was misleading. Every one of my siblings and my mother have suffered for years without any of the typically significant acute symptoms of cholecystitis. One of my brothers suffers occasionally like I did, but every single test for gallbladder issues comes back negative. Anecdotally, I ran into a person who had all tests show negative gallbladder issues, yet had it removed to see if it helped. It cured her bowel issues. Prior to my knowing what the issues were(20 years), here are the symptoms I can 100% associate with my gallbladder problem. Walking up stairs caused increased heart rate and fatigue after smoking a cigarette. Occasional slight queasiness after eating meals(they must have been high in fat). Rare episodes of fever, nausea, bowel discomfort after a meal that I wrote off as food poisoning or altitude sickness in one instance. General malaise. My mother and I both were very aware of some of our symptoms, but it was incredibly easy to associate them with other things we had come in contact with. Mold and fragrances are two that come to mind. When I was eating "healthy" I noticed significant improvements in my energy. At the time I didn't realize the "healthy" eating I was doing was low fat. That low fat was reducing inflammation in my gallbladder allowing me to get proper rest. Not eating dairy(maternal genes as well) is reducing inflammation in my gut, allowing me to get proper rest. Good luck and godspeed!
- dlahoda 4y agoyeah. 75÷ of my lazyness, lack of motivation and no discipline comes from fast harbonhydrates, caffeine and no excercise. and they work in downward spiralling you.
- dobbysfirstsock 4y agoHow did you get "diagnosed" with this issue? Some days I feel "normal" but some days I have 0 motivation at all. Not sure if that's a normal pattern or not but its frustrating to deal with. Might be worth talking to a Dr about but not sure what they would even do or say.
- JohnFen 4y agoI think that everyone has days where they're not feeling motivated. That's when habit can carry you through.
- drdebug 4y agoIf you have 0 motivation, it could mean you're just getting bored or saturated or stressed out or simply overwhelmed. In any case, do NOTHING for a day or two, don't feel guilt (that's KEY), tell yourself you're taking a break, play games, go ride your bike, walk in a forest, go to a restaurant, whatever suits you. Make yourself feel good. Take a break. Then the next day start by doing something very very simple. If you're working on a very hard problem then run a simple experiment to validate a case, corner case or not. If you feel like you don't feel like it, then just do some silly 5min task, it may be enough to get you restarted and just feel better. Feel good, enjoy life, then get back to work. Changing Job may do the trick too. Or take some vacation, the idea is to just break the cycle.
- dobbysfirstsock 4y agoThis has actually helped a lot. I did a lot of this over the past week. Week before was pretty bad. There is definitely truth to this :)
- bad_username 4y ago
- hnthrowaway0315 4y ago+1 unfortunately I cannot remove the source so have to keep myself sleepy for the a few extra years.
- ghastmaster 4y agoCan you elaborate?
- wccrawford 4y agoI suspect they are referring to children.
- magarnicle 4y agoYep. A friend who just had a kid put it like this: "life now is about being, not doing". Still taking me a long time to get that into my head.
- aantix 4y agoAgree. Nail the building blocks. Nutrition. Sleep. It will all fall into place, instead of having to beat yourself into submission to be “disciplined”.
- hnthrowaway0315 4y agoIt is just so difficult to get them done right. It's almost impossible. How many people are getting quality sleep? I'm afraid that's a very expensive commodity and even rich people might not do that right. Just a note that my completion rate and tolerance to grit increase dramatically when I had a good sleep, which is very very rare nowadays.
- npteljes 4y agoRich people have more pills, from what I've seen. I agree that it's very difficult. But it's also very valuable.
- SantalBlush 4y agoSame here. What I thought was a procrastination problem actually turned out to be a sleep problem. Good sleep makes all the difference.
- cultofmetatron 4y agofor anyone interested, here's a book full of good actionable advice https://www.amazon.com/Power-Habit-What-Life-Business-ebook/dp/B0055PGUYU/ref=sr_1_1?crid=2D9U44OFT0534&keywords=the+power+of+habit&qid=1675778094&sprefix=the+power+of+habit%2Caps%2C136&sr=8-1 https://www.amazon.com/Power-Habit-What-Life-Business-ebook/...
- sonabinu 4y agoMotivation gets you started, discipline keeps you going
- pif 4y agoNo! You get yourself started, and you keep going. Motivation is fine if it happens, otherwise you do without.
- seba_dos1 4y agoComments like this remind me of how foreign the experience of living without ADHD would be to me.
- MrDrDr 4y agoI agree with you. Getting started (and getting other people to start) requires motivation, wherever that might come from. But seeing things through takes discipline - and the two are not the same.
- pif 4y agoIn other words, you need to grow up.
- RalfWausE 4y agoFuck growing up.
- JohnFen 4y agoI, too, would rather have benevolent parents that protect me and make sure my needs are all covered for the rest of my life. But that's just not how the world works.
- selimthegrim 4y agoOften when a manager or professor says that it translates to “I can’t be bothered helping with your career advancement, just do this minimum project and get out of my face”
- vishnugupta 4y agoIndeed. All my life I had the causality backwards. Personally for me, it's the discipline that leads to motivation. Motivation on its own is almost useless. As a saying goes (don't remember the author), you need to be boring and predictable in day to day life so that you can be wild and unpredictable in work.
- gonzo41 4y agoDiscipline is tricky. A LOT of the signalling in modern life is just to tempt you into distractions. You're probably reading this on a rectangle that distracts you all the time. I think everyone likes to talk about motivation, because we all want the calm mania like flow state that effortlessly provides willpower over obstacles that would otherwise frustrate a disciplined person. When I was younger I used to worry about having the right goals to work towards. Now I consider it more important to be moving towards something. You eat an elephant in small bites.
- ethanbond 4y agoIMO this makes the most important point at the very end. “Being disciplined” itself is a consequence of motivation, or is effectively that. Building habits however, requires very little discipline or motivation so long as you build them strategically - I.e. start so small it’d be ridiculous not to do it regardless of how motivated or disciplined you are. And by “start small” I mean “floss one tooth per night for 3 months to build a flossing habit” small. Let your good habits progressively and slowly consume more time, similar to what bad habits do. For all intents and purposes you should just assume both discipline and motivation are completely mythical and you should construct a system of high-leverage habits to obviate the need for them. You don’t rise to the level of your talents/motivation/discipline, you fall to the level of your habits.
- dobbysfirstsock 4y agoYep. I will say though, its always possible, barring any sort of medical reasons, to get disciplined. I've had months where I go to the gym and then something happens and its easy to not go. There's nothing on this earth stopping me from picking that back up, other than myself... which reminds me, I need to start going again. Crazy thing is you _know_ you'll feel better but getting up and going can be a drag sometimes.
- mach1ne 4y ago>Crazy thing is you _know_ you'll feel better but getting up and going can be a drag sometimes. Yeah, that’s because most of your agency is hooked up to the monkey brain. You’re not really fighting anything, your apparent incentives just don’t drive you to go.
- dobbysfirstsock 4y agoFor sure. I just can't get over how I know full well that I'll feel better, yet in the moment its like "meh don't wanna go"
- O__________O 4y agoRelated pop culture book on the topic of habits titled “Atomic Habits” by James Clear: - https://www.amazon.com/Atomic-Habits-Proven-Build-Break/dp/0735211299/ https://www.amazon.com/Atomic-Habits-Proven-Build-Break/dp/0...
- youssefabdelm 4y agoScience calls BS: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0146167216676480 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/014616721667648... If the day-to-day isn't fun, it'll never get done.
- hnthrowaway0315 4y agoTrick: Put yourself into a situation that you have some pressure to do what you want to do but not necessarily always fun. That's why I always want to learn on work instead of opening all those projects without finishing any. Sadly most companies don't agree with me :) They always want to hire experienced players. Can't blame them though.
- 300bps 4y agoScience calls BS That's an extreme watering down of a complex topic. Essentially the study you link is saying that PIC (Positive, Immediate, Certain) outcomes are stronger than PDU (Positive, Delayed, Uncertain) outcomes. Well, of course. Taking the inverse - a NIC (Negative, Immediate, Certain) outcome of putting your hand on a hot stove will quickly teach you to not put your hand on the stove. Compare this to cheating a bit on your taxes where the consequence is NDU (Negative, Delayed, Uncertain). Beyond that, I disagree with your premise that something must be immediately fun for it to get done. There is a lot of literature on this - I recommend highly, "Solving the Procrastination Puzzle".
- youssefabdelm 4y ago> That's an extreme watering down of a complex topic. Fair point. A person can force themselves... until they break. So in that sense it needn't be fun as long as you can finish the task before the breaking point. But there's a threshold beyond which the person cannot sustain the behavior. Because it's a form of consistent lying to oneself. A person's brain, on a moment-to-moment basis is trying to pick the 'optimal' choice. The 'optimal' is: most pleasure, least pain. If the most pleasure, least pain option is beneficial to you in the long-run, the "game" that we play of trying to convince ourselves to do something else disappears. Which diet will win in the long run: 1. One that tastes better than all available options (including any takeout, or delivery, ice cream, or restaurant you know of) 2. One that tastes worse My critique is with this flawed concept of "discipline" which to my mind translates to "forcing yourself" aka "lying to yourself for as long as possible"
- notacoward 4y agoTreating motivation and discipline as alternatives is a mistake. In fact you need both. Think about "getting stuff done" as a high-jump (or pole-vaulting) bar. Motivation increases your height and discipline lowers the bar. Some people need to jump higher even when the bar's already low. Some people are already jumping as high as they can and need the bar to be lower. Some people are in both states at different times, and recognizing which one you're in is an important life skill.
- justsocrateasin 4y agoIt's funny though because you only need a short amount of discipline. Because after you use discipline for a while, it just gets way easier as it becomes a habit. Reminds me of this great Bojack Horseman clip - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R2_Mn-qRKjA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R2_Mn-qRKjA Years and years ago I started training seriously for a triathlon. Then a half ironman. Then a marathon, and after 2-3 years of having a few races a year on the calendar, I just started exercising every day. At the start, a lot of the days took discipline/motivation to get out the door. After a while, it was just a few days of discipline a week. Then a few days a month, then a few days a year. Now it's automatic, and something I actually look forward to rather than dread (obviously in a hard training cycle there are some sessions I dread, but it's almost like my brain turns off and my body subconsciously gets my stuff and gets me out the door). The longer you do something the easier it is.
- nradov 4y agoFor endurance sports I find it helps to put yourself on some kind of structured training plan leading up to each event. There are lots of free or cheap training plans available and any of them will work well enough for a casual age group athlete. This removes the daily decision making process and allows you to focus on execution.
- beckingz 4y agoThe follow up linkedin to at the end is full of more specific guidance on how to do this.
- h0l0cube 4y ago> Successful completion of tasks brings about the inner states that chronic procrastinators think they need to initiate tasks in the first place. A good hack to bootstrap the dopamine cycle is to start your day with a small easy win, and snow ball from there
- voisin 4y agoThis reminds me of the book “Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother” (admittedly by the since somewhat disgraced for other reasons, Amy Chua) where the central argument is that by pushing children to continue doing something even (especially) when it gets hard, they will find confidence and fulfillment. Children need to “borrow” their parents’ discipline in the beginning until the flywheel starts moving in them and they develop their own discipline.
- voisin 4y agoFrom the inestimable Rich Roll: “Mood follows action”
- jmartrican 4y agoThe author is not wrong. I would just like to add that motivation is akin to free discipline. A highly motivated person is hard to get them to stop. Highly motivated need discipline to stop. lol. So, if you can somehow hack yourself to become motivated, the discipline issue is solved, at least temporarily, until the motivation dies down. in which case you are back to discipline or another dose of motivation.
- nradov 4y agoMotivation is great when you have it. But motivation is unreliable and seldom lasts. Discipline is far more persistent.
- lanstin 4y agoIt seems there are two different uses of the word motivation. One is more fleeting - oh wow, I really feel like waking early and jamming out the rest of this code in my head - and one is more long lasting, my god I don’t know if I can read this story once again, but I am really committed to helping this small human grow up and become a kind and intelligent member of society, so reading it is something I am ready and willing to do, again and again. The longer term motivation, having a big picture in which your work, fun and dull, is understood to be important and useful, makes both discipline and ephemeral motivation a lot easier to come by. This operates at many scales - I may try very hard to please a difficult boss, both for the pleasure of approval and as a sort of technical self-challenge exercise (not as a substitute for finding a better boss, but to make the wait more pleasant). Overall, I find my life most fulfilling when it is dedicated to the well being of things larger than just my self, family, society, profession, species, the general goodness of existence. Other people have long term goals of success or power, and from that desire can spring an impressive amount of discipline and motivation. If you have to hammer yourself down to get thru your tasks, you might want to think about how a change would be possible.
- SamBam 4y agoUndated, but I think this is at least (2016). Edit: D'oh, is dated, apologies. In any case, should have date in HN title.
- 37 4y ago13 Jan 2015
- TAKEMYMONEY 4y agoDiscussion from eight years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8976451 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8976451
- Ambolia 4y agoTo me those are good skills, but at the end of the day the important thing is to work in a way in which after going through a project (or after getting some rest in between projects), you have as much or more energy that before starting the project. Discipline can be fine for 3 or 6 months to finish a very tough deadline, but if you go through 5 years of discipline where every day you are more tired that the previous day the quality of the work will suffer a lot.
- Fricken 4y agoDiscipline is merely the embrace of long term goals for which the expected reward is delayed, and at the expense of short term desires. Motivation still comes first. You can't discipline yourself if you aren't motivated to do so. You can't do anything if you aren't motivated to do so.
- Aerroon 4y agoThis is why activities that constantly motivate you are easier to do. Eg video games or sports (physical activity). They give you rewards while you're doing them, so you keep doing them. Starting them is hard, but it's easy to keep them going.
- dgb23 4y agoExactly my thought. The author doesn't understand what motivation is. From the article: > By contrast, discipline is like an engine that, once kickstarted, actually supplies energy to the system. That's literally how motivation works. Discipline is just a cultural framing of it of things like motivation and rigor. The thing is that yes, cultivating habits or even just _small_ goals and wins can snowball into you getting more and more disciplined. I know this from first hand experience having suffered depression and severe motivation issues. The only way out is to start with small goals and celebrating your tiny seemingly pathetic achievements. If I'm allowed to play armchair psychologist, I think this article might just be that. A celebration of having built habits and getting more motivated. Call it discipline because that sounds stronger. If that's true: Great! I congratulate OP. It's hard and it _should_ be celebrated.
- photochemsyn 4y agoI agree with this. Motivation is the why you might want to do something, and discipline is part of the how you get that something done. Clinical depression, a not uncommon issue, is characterized by having no motivation to do anything, and discipline won't help much in that situation. Also, one's state of mind can be managed by discipline if one is motivated to do so - for example, I have a ~20-min routine to get into the proper frame of mind for writing or coding, which basically is a bit of cleaning up the workspace, a bit of breathing exercises, a bit of physical exercise, quick shower/brush teeth/etc if needed, then I can work for a few hours in a focused positive state of mind. Discipline means initiating that whole process on a regular schedule.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI feel as if self-discipline is one of the most important of my attributes. It's worked out well for me. This is especially true, if I want to ship software, as opposed to just writing it. Shipping requires a hell of a lot of "not-fun" stuff. Discipline ensures that it gets done. Also, things like localization, accessibility, and anomaly management are things that often get left on the shelf. They are usually a complete bitch to retrofit, but not such a big deal, to add, at first. "Winners do what they have to do. Losers do what they want to do." - Unknown
- rcarmo 4y agoI stopped reading at "I AM SO PASSIONATE ABOUT THESE SPREADSHEETS" because as an engineer by training, I find spending hours debating and crafting Office documents with equally very senior people who can go to almost extreme lengths to avoid saying "I don't know" (how to deal with an issue, or sometimes, even, how to change font formatting) to be soul-crushing and utterly abhor the fact that they seem to take up most of your time as your career progresses. I do agree about making chores routine work, though. After a while your brain starts being able to do things in parallel and you breeze through the annoyances while pondering actually interesting things--the only caveat is that in a chaotic organization it becomes really hard to establish a routine, and thus all the habit forming effort you put into work may be widely off the mark. So if you are having trouble with motivation _and_ discipline, the problem may not actually lie with you (alone).
- bad_username 4y agoAnd what you need for discipline is habits.
- mrleinad 4y agoIf you want to know what true self-discipline looks like, check out David Goggins' book.
- epolanski 4y agoI say it to my friends too. Motivation comes and goes, discipline keeps you marching.
- aatd86 4y agoSeems like some people are motivated by discipline to me. :) I still think that without motivation, one doesn't do any thing. Discipline is simply how people reach the goal targeted by the initial spurt of motivation. It only works if by discipline, people are able to reach intermediary steps toward their goals whoch further motivates them to keep going. Th rest is pain tolerance, patience, certainty of results etc...
- jrvarela56 4y ago> How do I make my feelings inconsequential and do the things I consciously want to do without being a little bitch about it?”. > The point is to cut the link between feelings and actions, and do it anyway. We all wish our feelings had no impact on what actions we take. If we could just get stuff done without caring for what the monkey in us 'feels', we'd be wealthier, happier and our problems would go away. I just don't work that way. Of course having a bad day is going to impact my ability to get shit done. I fear taking a stance like the one in the article would get me in the habit of ignoring the way I feel - and lead to a permanent sense of guilt/shame/uneasiness and lack of confidence in my hunches. This would have a negative impact in my creativity and joy. In my case, cultivating motivation has made me productive. When I feel like procrastinating, I question: what believe about this task makes it feel like I want to run away from it? Writing about my longer term plans helps me spot where I lack conviction. Identifying these items where conviction is low, makes me explore my motivations, look up data to validate my claims and breakdown my plans further. As I 'debug' my plans, it makes it easier for me to link day-to-day stuff to my long-term plans. I do this writing probably every ~3 weeks and it has done wonders to keep me on task as I have a clear 'why'.
- draw_down 4y ago[dead]
- 100011_100001 4y agoThis is what gets me. Of course, if I could do the thing regardless of my feelings I wouldn't read about self-discipline, it would already be handled. My biggest frustration with the self-help industry is that nothing addresses the fundamental action that needs to be taken. It's little tricks and hacks. They might work temporarily but then that goes away...because guess what you need discipline for sticking with the little tricks and hacks as well. On the flip side, if you hate what you do, why do it?
- MattDemers 4y ago>My biggest frustration with the self-help industry is that nothing addresses the fundamental action that needs to be taken. It's little tricks and hacks. They might work temporarily but then that goes away...because guess what you need discipline for sticking with the little tricks and hacks as well. This is worse when the book is just... anecdotes? Stories about hypothetical clients (or ones they swear exist, but don't), which you can't really port over to yourself. The thing is, you're never going to get that "manual" from a self-help book. Maybe from a therapist or a coach, but the majority of the work and exploration has to be done by yourself; to the people that feel hopeless, discouraged, depressed and alone (the people who may be buying these books) this is a hard thing to sell, so the authors don't.
- dgs_sgd 4y agoThis is a good article but it frames motivation and discipline in terms of getting a task done. I think another important aspect of discipline is the ability to *not* do something you want to avoid (think abstaining from a negative habit). In my experience cultivating discipline to *not* do something has always been harder.
- badcppdev 4y agoIs it an ad hominem attack to point out that the author is a raving racist? "For one, a solid proportion of Uber drivers are one bad day away from committing a terror attack, such as allahuakbarramming a van into pedestrians, "[0] 0 - http://www.wisdomination.com/my-islamist-uber-driver-and-modern-slavery/ http://www.wisdomination.com/my-islamist-uber-driver-and-mod...
- icepat 4y agoNot an adhom, it's valid to point out to give context to any sideways ideology that might show up. Often times these "discipline, hard world, grind" bloggers are set in a certain ideological context. So pointing that out helps contextualize what you're reading. The idea of "be careful who you take advice from". For example, I would not take advice from someone who believes: `Impostor syndrome – Pangs of realistic self-reflection in impostors.` or: `Harassment (sexual) – Flirting attempts by ugly, short, fat, poor, or otherwise undesirable men.` or: `Misogyny – Women who hate men imagining that men hate them back.` or: `Planned parenthood – An eugenics programme posing as a human rights campaign` or: https://www.wisdomination.com/the-breathing-cure-for-depression/ https://www.wisdomination.com/the-breathing-cure-for-depress... That breathing better is a cure for depression. People who hold really toxic, and in this case overtly Misogyny beliefs, tend to leak it into the rest of their advice and writings. Adhom would be attacking them for it to detail the argument. Rather, you're just indicating "this guy has some horrible beliefs, be careful". Which is valid when you're getting the kind of exposure a HN top post does.
- badcppdev 4y agoThank for that clear response. There probably is an argument that different approaches work for different people. And the things you write about might help someone else decide if your advice might work for them
- TAKEMYMONEY 4y ago"Sensationalist news" plus the terrible writing in general was a tell. I guess this is so old the "fake news!" cliché wasn't popular yet? Their Twitter is currently ranting about "unstable schizoneurotic bullies, currently trans allied" so not an expert in psychological advice I'm guessing...
- dkarl 4y agoIn my experience, the best overall, top-to-bottom analysis of the psychology of doing hard things over the long term is Mike Israetel's breakdown [0]. I don't normally drop competing links into discussions, but the source is maybe outside the usual range of HN, and it's a big step up in quality and usefulness from the posted source. Israetel breaks the psychology of weight loss down into different pieces that each have their own strengths and weaknesses and different roles they play in the process. The pieces in his breakdown are inspiration, motivation, intention, discipline, habit, and passion. For example, the first factor he breaks down is inspiration. Inspiration is the spark that gets you interested. It's the prime mover that helps you get the process started and allows the other factors to come into play. It lasts a few hours, maybe a day. What I like about Israetel is that he doesn't bag on anything. He doesn't say inspiration is worthless. He tells you what you can and can't expect it to accomplish for you. Passion is a cliché topic here, so here's what Israetel says about it: passion takes years to develop. But it's optional! Passion is being in love with the process. It's powerful if you can get it, but you can be extremely successful over the long haul without it. Nobody needs "passion" to brush their teeth every day. Habit is sufficient. Many people succeed, and not all of them fall in love with the process. Finally, a very relevant point he makes is that most of the people pitching you "passion" or "motivation" or "discipline" are really in the business of providing inspiration: a little spark of excitement that lasts a few minutes or hours. They may talk about discipline, or motivation, but they get clicks and get shared because people experience inspiration while consuming their content. Which is fine in the content is useful, but you should be clear about why it feels good. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bcKthx5LTbI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bcKthx5LTbI
- Manjuuu 4y agoNowadays I just recommend "Read atomic habits", since I've noticed that just saying the same thing in the title, hinting at the importance of small habits is not enough to convince people. But I recommend that with the intent of the reading being conductive for some self reflection and attempts at improving via trial and error, I'm aware that that are no easy solutions for the problem of procrastination since there are a multitude of possible causes, and real life issues can't be fixed blindly applying what you read in some self help book. Not much to see in the post, btw.
- cybrexalpha 4y agoThis is effectively the usual advice that some neurotypical people give to others, with little appreciation for how others may be different. "Get some discipline", "build a habit", etc. If this approach works for you then that's great, I'm sure it will work for many people. But to suggest it will work for anyone and everyone is ridiculous.
- thisismyswamp 4y agoI wonder how many of the people who upvoted this first checked out the website's header.
- unity1001 4y agoLove all these attempts at solving everything with one single 'magic' solution'. You need both - motivation and discipline. Art and engineering. Organization and experimentation. Centralization and syndication. The key to everything is in balance.
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoMy experience with discipline is to have exterior pressure, both social and mechanical. Asking a teen if they took the trash out, and also having a recurring alarm on their calendar that the day is trash day are the exterior pressures I am suggesting. This trains the expected pattern of behavior.
- m3kw9 4y agoOur minds like to freely pursue whatever looks interesting, that’s why you need “discipline” to help you stay focused. Motivation is another way staying disciplined because the motivation keeps your mind from pursuing other ideas. Main point is staying in the focus in the area and not stray off too far. This is difficult because sometimes you need to pursuit/pivot ideas when they may not work. Or you need rest. The balance is difficult to handle and they are all not sure bets. My experience is to do whatever it takes for you to stay in the zone. Everyone is built different
- GistNoesis 4y agoQuite often when you need motivation, it's because there is something wrong with the situation you are in. Sometimes discipline can help you push through, but it is a double edge sword, as quite often, you would be better by changing your situation. You need to get reward some times. Nowadays most jobs are structured like slot machines. They dangle positive completion stats, only for them to be meaningless when it comes to give you cold hard cash, or whatever you are expecting. If you find yourself fishing in a skating rink for someone else's profit, the solution is not motivation or discipline, but noticing it and leaving for a better deal. The cake is a lie.
- javier_e06 4y agoDaniel-san wanted to stop the beatings in High School. That was the carrot. Mr. Miyagi showed Daniel-san how to stand up to the the bullies through discipline. That was the stick. Come to think of it, if it wasn't because the Cobra Kai jerks Daniel-san would have never learned karate and self-discipline. There has to be certainty. Like Mr Miyagi said it more or less: "You either do it or you don't, if you stand in the middle you'll get squashed like a grape"
- Krontab 4y agoJocko Willink has been saying this one for a long time too https://youtu.be/sut_6KGzIlI https://youtu.be/sut_6KGzIlI
- Overtonwindow 4y agoI have severe ADHD. Discipline is very difficult for me, because at the core of my predicament is a lack of dopamine production. My brain is stuck always hunting for stimulation. This in turn creates anxiety because you can't get anything done! Discipline is wonderful, but what helps more than discipline is constant reminders of steps and tool to continuously nudge myself back on track.
- toss1 4y agoSo, discipline is like courage. Courage is not the absence of fear (which is likely ignorance of the real situation or just stupidity), it is having the fear and doing the right thing anyway. Similarly, discipline is not being motivated, it is lacking motivation and doing the right thing anyway. EDIT, add: One motto of Ben Franklin was: "Never put off until tomorrow what you can get done today." I'm pretty sure that for many of those things he did, he did not feel "motivated" at the time. Yet his legacy in science, diplomacy, and role in founding a nation is unparalleled.
- civilized 4y agoThis echoes the old cognitive behavioral therapy slogan: "motivation follows action, not the other way around".
- 50yearsold 4y agoAtomic Habits
- hbn 4y agoI've noticed a pattern in a lot of people that when they get super motivated, it just leads them to making big grand plans for how they're going to improve themself with X and Y strategy, but when it's finally time to execute, the motivation has worn off and they do absolutely nothing. I've heard before that you get the same kind of dopamine hit from saying you're going to do something that you do from actually accomplishing a goal. And that definitely seems in line with this behaviour I've noticed in people. I personally try to not announce any grand plans I have to anyone. Maybe that's just out of fear of commitment, but I find the idea of announcing something and then having nothing to show embarrassing. But sometimes I do execute on my plans, and it feels good having the results to show.
- ozarker 4y agoSimilarly, I feel the same way about telling others about plans or small successes. I've had so many projects where I've made a prototype that is kinda cool, shown it off to friends, and immediately lost motivation to keep working on it. I've made a rule for myself now that I can only show projects off if I've hit a point where my motivation is derived from my joy working on the project itself and not for gratification from others if that makes sense.
- ilikecakeandpie 4y ago> I've noticed a pattern in a lot of people that when they get super motivated, it just leads them to making big grand plans for how they're going to improve themself with X and Y strategy, but when it's finally time to execute, the motivation has worn off and they do absolutely nothing. A lot of this correlates with a manic episode from someone who is manic-depressive
- kayodelycaon 4y agoEh. I'm bipolar and I wouldn't compare this to a manic episode. Lots of people to the whole big grand plans things every New Years. (Authors do it every time they get a story idea.) It's just part of being human. Thinking about the thing is easier than doing the thing.
- raydiatian 4y ago> Motivation, broadly speaking, operates on the erroneous assumption that a particular mental or emotional state is necessary to complete a task. A similar dismissive argument can be made of discipline. “Discipline, broadly speaking, operates on the erroneous assumption that you can dominate yourself to execute endlessly without fear of utterly snapping.” At some point you look up and realize you’ve wasted the best decade of your life trying to build something nobody wants, at which point you start considering the shape of objects you might put in your mouth besides food. There’s a lot to be said for going with the flow.
- the-mitr 4y agoI would say motivation is needed, at least initially, to be disciplined. A personal anecdote. When I was in school, I had really bad handwriting bordering to illegible. Then I met someone who had almost calligraphical handwriting. I so much wanted to have that kind of handwriting. I tried and gave up. But the motivation was there. So I decided that I will change one alphabet at a time. And thus it began. I started with "a" till I made it as perfect as I could, without worrying about other letters. Then "b" and other letters followed one by one. The initial few letters were the real test of discipline. By the time I was through, I no longer had the motivation to be a calligrapher, but I was much better with my handwriting. Though later I did practice calligraphy, it was not for my original motivation but more for my own pleasure.
- user3939382 4y agoI can't prove it but I'm suspicious this was ripped off from a recent Theo Von discussion with Jocko Willink which just came out 3 weeks ago https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pkJQDueUtww https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pkJQDueUtww and makes the exact point.
- Cpoll 4y agoIt's much older. Here's an HN thread from 2015 about this article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8976451 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8976451
- user3939382 4y agoThanks for clarifying.
- nevinera 4y agoDiscipline, at its core, is the consistent application of executive power to create desired outcomes. It is a solution to many _many_ of life's problems, and I encourage everyone to cultivate it and exercise it. However.. for some people that's not useful advice. A surprising fraction of us (13% and trending up) have some form of ADHD, often including "executive dysfunction", which essentially makes this type of suggestion _hot garbage_. There's nothing wrong with a post like this, it proposes a solution that will probably be useful to a fair majority of people, and is worth exploring. But if you find this approach to be ineffective and counter-productive, there's not necessarily something wrong with you. Or, depending on how you think of it, there _is_, but it's not your fault, and it's wrong with a lot of other people too.
- nathias 4y agowhat one needs is an understading of how a habit will improve one's life and the self-discipline to form it
- koprulusector 4y agoYeah, but why should I bother with discipline? Oh. Er. I guess I need motivation to practice discipline.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ranprieur 4y agoI guarantee, highly productive people aren't going through the day forcing themselves to do stuff they don't feel like doing. Gordon Ramsay is not like, "Oh lord, another cooking show that I have to discipline myself to do." Highly productive people are obsessed. They're in the flow. And there are techniques to work yourself into obsession or a flow state, but it's much more tricky and difficult than the author suggests. He says, "discipline is like an engine that, once kickstarted, actually supplies energy to the system." Kickstarting an engine is easy. What he's talking about is more like building an engine.
- PaulHoule 4y agoI think of the great controversy between Jim Collins and Richard Covey seen in the books https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_to_Great https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_to_Great vs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_7_Habits_of_Highly_Effective_People https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_7_Habits_of_Highly_Effecti... Jim Collins would say that a "great" company doesn't need to build alignment, everyone who works at a WalMart or McDonalds understands how the company creates value for customers and how their role makes that happen. (Whereas I've worked at startups where the only person who would claim to know the answer to that question is the CEO and the rest of the people would tell you they are not so sure about the CEO) Collins criticizes Covey for making it appear that alignment is something you can get from hiring a consultant or otherwise paint on. Covey might point you to building habits that embody discipline whereas Collins would say having the right motivation makes it all happen naturally. My take is that highly disciplined people who don't have intrinsic motivation are not in a sustainable situation and likely to burn out. I know somebody who was an alcoholic in high school, then was super-disciplined for 10 years but also lonely and miserable, one day he started drinking again and started relating to people better but then he got in multiple DWIs and he found he really had to quit drinking. For him strict discipline turned out to be not sustainable and he had to scale back and really rebuild his life from zero.
- charlieflowers 4y agoFYI, Stephen Covey (not Richard)
- PaulHoule 4y agoThanks for the correction!
- aatd86 4y agoIf you're not motivated toward the end-goal, what do you apply your discipline to? Achieving a goal starts with motivation and continues thanks to motivation. Discipline is simply what keeps people on track and guarantees that the intermediary motivation boosts due to progress are reached consistently. You need both but motivation is more important. Discipline can be superseded by having fun with the process.
- atoav 4y ago> If you're not motivated toward the end-goal, what do you apply your discipline to? To everything you do. Does a carpenter leave in a crooked nail? Probably not, and that is not discipline, this is just their professional ethos, or pride. Discipline and a certain quality standard needs to be one's modus operandi, not the special sauce you apply in special situations. And before this comes across as over the top, I truly think that there are people who care about quality and being precise no matter what they do — having such a mode of operation will inevitably lead you down a different road in your career, because caring about the wuality of your craft/work makes you care about the result of your work even if you don't care about the object/project in itself. The only way to truly break such people to constantly force them to deliver bad quality.
- aatd86 4y agoThe way I understand it, the carpenter is disciplined here because they are motivated by the end goal. The goal being to create the best product they can to satisfy their clients. Discipline just ensures that this goal is reached. But one should have motivation and remain motivated during the process. Motivation still seems to come first.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoSo what do you do when conventional discipline doesn't work? I'm bipolar, so let's throw every single piece of advice out the window, including any suggestions you think you have for me. :) My solution is managed chaos. It takes advantage of motivation by seeking to reducing activation energy. Start by throwing away any concept of measurement or success. This is a best effort system. - Keep tasks really small and don't commit to them. You need the option to abort early if you lack sufficient energy. If you're sitting down, your only goal is standing up. You can always sit back down. - Forget about efficiency. Seriously. Stop. Inefficient but done is better than not doing it. - If you're motivated to something productive, do it, even if it's not what you want to do most. - Do not "remember to do things". Attention is precious. If something is important, do it immediately or stick it on a calendar to ignore later. (Use timed reminders, not todo lists.) Don't keep them in your head unless absolutely necessary. - If you're not motivated, look for ways to reduce activation energy later. I like to cleaning up or organizing my living area. - If you're going to watch YouTube videos, try to do something else at the same time. Hope this helps someone else. :)
- aktuel 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BRCEmx5nL2Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BRCEmx5nL2Y
- schwarzrules 4y agoScrew discipline. what you need is my paid medium subscription "the power of YES". Currently accepting new subscribers at www.notarealnewsletter.com/couldbearealnewsletter/subscribe?utm_medium=email&utm_source=yc&utm_content=1249871092
- rednerrus 4y agoIt's really important to remember for a subset of the population pain avoidance, and not reward, is the main driver of motivation. It's very hard to build discipline with pain avoidance as your main driver. If you don't have this it will be very hard for you to understand.
- Gud 4y agoWhat you need is happiness!! I’ve had this beaten in to me many times, that you need discipline. But for me, what eventually worked was learning to love myself and to relax. Life is a marathon and tomorrow is another day. Whatever issues I had was not a lack of motivation nor discipline; I had an inner turmoil that was disrupting my ability to execute.
- hirvi74 4y agoBut those days can add up to weeks, and then to months, and then to years. Sure, one day or one week is not an issue in the grand scheme of things, but when you have been having difficulty executing for multiple weeks, months, or years, then I think there is a more serious issues that should be addressed. For me, I figured out the cause, but I have yet to find any helpful, long-term solutions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- srcreigh 4y agoWhat was the cause for you?
- tmshu1 4y agoWould be curious to hear what you’ve discovered the cause to be, and potential solutions you’ve considered. In my experience with my own difficulties executing, I’ve found that ineffective action comes from inner struggle. Inner struggle comes from an inaccurate view about how thought works. See my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34692137#34699010 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34692137#34699010. With less inner turmoil, inspired, effective action becomes effortless to do and maintain.
- tmshu1 4y ago100% this. Screw motivation. Screw discipline too. Tricking yourself (motivation, discipline, etc.) to do something means you don’t really want to it. This results in a feeling of struggle, and also repression. And thus, ineffective outcomes as you sabotage yourself or fail to “stick with” something. We all naturally know what it is we really want to do. So stop. Relax. Listen to what that inner voice whisper, right now. Not to what others say you “should” do. Ask yourself: “what would I love to create?” Listening to oneself may not come naturally. We are trained by society, our parents, and schools to listen to “authorities”. So thoughts about what we “should” do run rampant in our minds. But who’s the greatest authority of your life? You. Once, I truly internalized the above, everything changed. It can happen to you too.
- racl101 4y agoI read the title in an Austrian accent for some reason.
- zackmorris 4y agoThe advice in this article probably won't work for neurodivergent people like many of us reading HN. That's because for stuff like ADHD, we have infinite enthusiasm for stuff we want to do, and zero enthusiasm for other tasks. It's like someone versed in music telling someone to "just play the piano" when that part of the brain hasn't been developed in the other person. We can replace that missing functionality with todo lists, reminders and digital assistants. But in the end, we must face the fact that we may never develop a flow state for tasks that feel mundane to us beyond a certain point. Meaning that those tasks may always feel manual to us, forcing us to pay an ongoing tax that others don't often perceive. After experiencing profound burnout just before the pandemic, I learned a couple of things about my mental models that might be useful. Keep in mind that the only thing real is reality, so I'm not saying that these models are how it all works, just that they touch on other insights that make things easier: 1) Anxiety about finishing an upcoming school or work assignment is a physical response in the body identical to excitement. That's why when under extreme pressure, we somehow find the energy to comment on social media or play video games instead of studying or working. The problem isn't a lack of motivation or energy, but where it's directed. 2) The mind is separate from the brain. This may be a hard pill to swallow for people who identify with their prowess in certain mental fields like programming. If doing a task feels insurmountable, it's not a problem with our problem-solving skills, but something physical in our brain chemistry. It's like the oomph to trip the neuron threshold voltage is too low, so it takes additional manual effort to think. What finally worked for me was NOT to keep exercising my motivation and discipline (which are already overtrained by 2 orders of magnitude), but to rehab and strengthen the other areas of my life which had been neglected. Loosely, that means having dessert before dinner. Here are some examples: * I carved out Saturdays for myself. Regardless of how much work I have to do, or how many plans I have to cancel, or even if I have bills to pay, I spend my free day now on Wikipedia deep dives and geeking out on various physics spreadsheets like Tony Stark, living my best life. * I turned correcting my deficiencies into acts of gratitude and love. I feel that burnout is the full loss of all automatic thinking and habits after the brain stops cooperating. So even the simplest act like brushing one's teeth can feel insurmountable. The fix is to remove time from the equation and stop thinking about any step beyond the current one. Which also eliminates any subsequent step or the knowledge of how many more times the step will need to be performed over a lifetime. Instead, find a fond feeling or memory and linger in it while brushing your teeth, so that your mind comes to associate it with pleasure instead of pain. * I learned to meditate with my eyes open, surrounded by distraction. Just quiet all internal dialog and observe the matrix unfolding before you. The mind is the nexus of an infinite fractal of intersecting probability curves, so the slightest change in perception affects the whole reality. The brain struggles for a bit to hog your attention before finally giving up, then becomes more open to new ideas because it so enjoys being heard. This allows one to shift between tasks without expending effort because the mind moves along the multiverse until it finds the reality where the brain is already eager to get to work. Basically the above is about setting boundaries, prioritizing yourself, mindfulness and most importantly: coordinating them with action so something manifests. I suspect that the rampant outbreaks of procrastination and burnout in tech have more to do with opportunity cost than shortcomings in work ethic. I also think that the global awakening gives us a rare opportunity to grow out of that dysfunction. ..and I just spend an hour writing this when I should have been working. But now I really really want to get to work because I've gotten it out of my system!
- Apocryphon 4y agoSaw this in a comment yesterday, and this is incredibly good. Forget motivation or discipline: the real answer is to always keep the task in mind: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QWIxElEnc8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QWIxElEnc8
- POiNTx 4y agoSort of related to this, what works for me (more often than not) is writing down one task I need to do, and focus on that. I've conjured up a quick tool for myself where I can write down the task and complete it once it's done. I call it the one item todo list. Keeps me from being overwhelmed with all the complexity that surrounds the goal I want to achieve. I know if I just focus on this one thing, I'll be one step closer. https://todo.wout.space/ https://todo.wout.space/ https://github.com/woutdp/one-item-todo-list https://github.com/woutdp/one-item-todo-list
- Jeff_Brown 4y agoPeriodically rethinking and questioning what you do isn't a bad thing. So many PhD candidates, to name just one of tens of thousands of demographics, have squandered so many disciplined years executing a plan they later regretted.
- gdubs 4y agoI like the David Burns "Feeling Good" approach, which is to commit to just one simple task — like, "I'm gonna open up my IDE. I can commit to that." Then maybe one more, "I'm gonna document that method I wrote." It's amazing how effective this can be at getting the ball rolling. My problem with saying "discipline is what you need" is that to many people that just adds even more pressure when they're maybe feeling overwhelmed or unhappy. But it's easy to commit to a very small task, and it's surprising how often you'll find a whole afternoon of work has passed.
- Jeff_Brown 4y agoDictators and psychopaths are motivated. Only conditional on wanting the right thing is discipline what you need. Lack of motivation is, I believe, generally a half-assed search for a better option, which impulse can be very good.
- moremetadata 4y agoMotivated or disciplined to do some activity, without knowing the consequences seems illogical to me. What's the range of consequences when thinking of the butterfly effect in Chaos Theory?
- h0p3 4y agoWhat do you think of The Dialetheia?
- FigurativeVoid 4y agoIt's hard, but I find action begets more action. I try and get one small feature done on Monday, and that sets me up for success the whole. The best way to want to workout more is to workout. It's a frustrating fact, but getting started in the most important thing.
- mrexroad 4y ago“Action comes before motivation.” I repeat this constantly to my kids, and sometimes I even remember it myself.
- miika 4y agoNo. Actually when you have a vision and do something you love, really, then you don’t need motivation or discipline. Then you just need every possible moment to execute it, and you will feel relaxed while “working” on it. So consider to just sit down quiet until you know what ignites you like that.
- highspeedbus 4y agoThis is a really hard topic. The article goes in the right direction that feelings should be consciously suppressed to make "unpleasant" things a habit. Like washing the dishes. A sense of responsibility over "feeling like doing it" must be cultivated. The meta game of all of this is that, to get anything done by discipline, you need to want that, in the same sense that one wants a glass of water. No sequence of characters are guaranteed to make you stand up and act without a sincere will to do it. Trying to reprogram yourself to want it is an exercise of luck where some succeed, some not. Then one day you wake up and have it, like a blessing. I decided to go to the gym 4 weeks ago after years of trying and failing. Since then I've been going consistently even when not feeling like doing it. Can't pinpoint a motive other than god updated my firmware with the will to do it. I hope it lasts long enough. "You're free to do what you want, but you're not free to want what you want"
- PuffinBlue 4y agoI wrote about this too, a long time ago and perhaps a bit more directly[0] I didn't write much since, mostly because I have been achieving the goals I set myself and returning to write things on my blog is not one of those current goals. So I think what I had to say worked, for me at least. [0] https://www.josharcher.uk/blog/motivation-is-dangerous/ https://www.josharcher.uk/blog/motivation-is-dangerous/
- glass3 4y agoDoes this lead to the same results? It feels like the difference between a paid article and a comment on a social network. Both have their place, but it's not fun to read a wall of paid recommendations for a restaurant.
- glass3 4y agoIf somebody is skilled to write engagingly with discipline, shouldn't they have been able to create something even more beautiful if they had followed their instincts?
- doh 4y agoIt’s said that life is a marathon rather than a sprint. But I think it’s mix of both. More challenge one takes on, more they have to sprint. To me this favors willpower (shorter bursts) than discipline (long periods). Obviously one needs to brush teeth every day, but that’s in my book a habit. It becomes fairly automatic and low stakes over time. But pushing through a final in a school, or working on a presentation for your boss on Friday night is different. Willpower also favors lazy people like me. It allows me to do whatever most of the time and then push hard for short bursts.
- newlikeice 4y agoMike Tyson has said that “discipline is doing what you hate like you love it” it’s a great quote that I always remember.
- yurodivuie 4y agoTLDR: ask yourself "why don't I want to do this?" Pay attention to the feeling, be honest, and try to address the problem it points at. In my personal experience, negative emotions are strong indicators that should not be ignored, overridden by external motivation, or powered through with discipline. Emotions seem to be like mental shorthand for different kinds of problems, or like flashing signals from the subconscious trying to get my attention. If I interrogate that feeling, I have a chance to address the root of the problem. Or I discover that I'm never going to solve the problem, so I need to find a way to accept it. The reasons for being stuck, feeling unmotivated, or whatever, usually boil down to a few simple problems. I don't know what to do next, I don't know how to get started, I don't want to do this thing I have to do, I don't think I should be doing this at all, I don't think I can do this well... blah blah blah. All of those problems translate into the same kind of emotional malaise, but there are different strategies for addressing each. The strategies aren't very complicated, but I first have to acknowledge the feeling and try to understand it. (Note - as an ADHD-enhanced person, this experience may only be relatable to others with the same gift. Maybe neurotypicals have magical executive function juice that lets them power through anything, but then... why are they reading this article?)
- hiepph 4y agoBuilding a day-to-day fixed routine was a life-changing decision for me. 1. I have stable point to rely on when life turns chaotic. 2. I have an overview of my life, and make it balance: physical health and mental health, work and relax. To quote Haruki Murakami [^1] > I keep to this routine every day without variation. The repetition itself becomes the important thing; it’s a form of mesmerism. I mesmerize myself to reach a deeper state of mind. [^1] https://balancethegrind.co/daily-routines/haruki-murakami-daily-routine/ https://balancethegrind.co/daily-routines/haruki-murakami-da...
- mharig 4y agoDidn't read the article, but I'm sure the author meant 'self-discipline'. Which can be achieved with the right amount of discipline in childhood.
- hyperthesis 4y agoYou don't have to feel like doing something to do it. You can just decide to do it. This was freeing for me, because I didn't even realize I somehow believed I had to feel motivated. But obviously you need wisdom in your choice of what to do - especially now that you're overriding the instinctive test of feeling.