9 ms·
What Jobs Do the Top 1% Have?
- hnwh 15y agoso basically, about 1% of everyone is in the 1%.. surprise
- tocomment 15y agoWhats the deal with managers ranking above CEO s.
- gghootch 15y agoAbsolutely speaking managers rank higher, but that's a trivial figure considering there are significantly more managers out there than CEOs. Relatively CEOs are better off than managers.
- chaz 15y agoCompanies have many managers, but one CEO.
- spacemanaki 15y agoThe visualization is a bit confusing, but it makes sense that the manager box is larger than the CEO box since as others have pointed out there are more managers than CEOs, however notice that the CEO box is noticeably darker than the manager box, indicating that CEOs are more likely to be in the 1% than managers. It's not a terrific visualization. It's a bit difficult to compare box sizes and colors.
- nazar 15y agoCEOs are also managers :)
- hypnotist 15y agoHmm... I'm thinking top 1% people do not have a job anymore, other people are working for them. Or at least this is what I would do if I would be in top 1% :)
- mjwalshe 15y agoThe 1% don't have "Jobs" even the high paid banker with a 2 million bonus isn't realy one of the 1%
- ldite 15y agoWell, according to the other NYT article on the front page the annual household income required to be in the top 1% is $383,000. Many people in the top 1% probably don't consider themselves to be all that wealthy... https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2012/01/15/business/one-percent-map.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2012/01/15/business/one-...
- brainless 15y agoAnnual household income => $383K is a bit surprising? Or do I just have a wrong picture of rich people. I thought it would be much more.
- gigantor 15y agoI thought this as well, but you may be comparing against a Forbes richest people list. The majority of the people I talk to (even devs) think $100,000 is a very large sum of money. Also, just by having a decent salary in the US/Canada, income-wise you're easily the top 1% of the world: http://www.globalrichlist.com/ http://www.globalrichlist.com/
- senor_mills 15y agoJust to clarify, that URL is about annual income whereas the list of Forbes billionaires is about net worth. annual income != net worth (aka wealth)
- mjwalshe 15y agoI was thinking more the guy I met at first Tuesday a few years ago I thought he looks familiar. He was sporting the red VC badge I looked down one word "Rosthchild". And it was a Napoleonic era portrait of Nathan Rothschild who helped finance the UK Finance the Napoleonic wars that I was recalling R
- micheljansen 15y agoInterestingly, this graph visualises the jobs of people in the wealthiest households. It does not mean that those jobs actually bring in the wealth. I was surprised to see the relatively large box of elementary school teachers. Surely those jobs don't pay that well. It might be one of those cases where correlation is mistaken for causation: perhaps a lot of people who dream to be a teacher are able to realise it because they have a wealthy banker for a spouse or something.
- patio11 15y agoTwo married schoolteachers in a wealthy suburban school district near their peak earning years will gross nearly $200k for the household. (I'm related to multiple examples.) The BLS collects copious stats on how much different occupations are paid. Reports of them being working poor are highly exaggerated.
- johncch 15y agoMy anecdotal evidence points to otherwise. On the other hand though, I believe 200k is close, but insufficient to place one into the 1%.
- mikek 15y agoThe the top 1% is $383K and up.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- drumdance 15y agoI've never heard teachers described as "working poor." Just middle income.
- burgerbrain 15y ago
- andr3w321 15y agoThey should do this for the top .1% and show that 90% of them are in finance.
- hkmurakami 15y agoI'm actually keen on this as well. The U.S. population is currently about 300 million people. So 1% is 3 million people, which is an awfully large number. I've read in several places that it's the 0.1% who have the true wealth and stature to control the legislature for their own benefit. So who's in the 0.1%? I'd definitely like to know.
- anonLSD 15y agoOf course this is not the same, statistically, but one thing I have done in the past is to find the most ridiculously expensive property in an area, look up the tax records online, and then google the owners. It takes a bit of work, but the picture that emerges is quite interesting. For example, I live in the Seattle area, and I know where the mega-wealthy enclaves are here. Who owns the biggest mansions? Microsoft executives, members of the Nordstrom family, members of the construction family who built the Space Needle, people connected with Daniel's Broiler, some guy who invented a new kind of eyeglasses, a congressman's ex-wife, a woman who grew and sold her IT consulting firm, a guy who built a successful condo listing website, doctors, the founder of an investment firm, a commercial real estate developer... In short, it was mainly key players in big local businesses, entrepreneurs, and a small handful of physicians. I imagine if one did this for NYC, the picture would look predictably different. EDIT: I forgot, the site virtualglobetrotting.com makes this easier. Hamptons example: http://virtualglobetrotting.com/map/lloyd-blankfeins-house/nearby/?d=50 http://virtualglobetrotting.com/map/lloyd-blankfeins-house/n...
- andyking 15y agoFor anyone interested, a similar list for the UK was published in the Guardian a couple of months ago. There are a few visualisations available, and the data's also there for download: http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/2011/nov/25/highest-paid-jobs-uk-2011 http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/2011/nov/25/highest-paid-job...
- nvarsj 15y agoI tried looking for programmer, and this is what I found. I really hope this is just a poor job on the guardian's part! 22. IT strategy/planning professional £43,667 -8.5% 10th pct: £24,000. 80th pct✝: £63,693. Also known as: Analyst-programmers; computer programmers; software engineers; systems analysts; systems designers. What they do: Provide advice on the effective utilisation of IT in order to enhance business functions. Well I never: A recent poll suggested IT consultants have unusually adventurous personalities.
- bluedevil2k 15y agoThis was a particularly interesting article. You had to spend some time to look through it to find some good take-aways. - Physicians and dentists are not only a large number of the 1%, the proportion of dentists and physicians who become part of the 1% is extremely high - about 20% combined. - I was struck by the seemingly high number of secretaries on the list. Yes, I know the chart represents "1% households", but this made me smile, since I figured it means a lot of powerful men are marrying their secretaries. - For the ridiculous amounts of money that athletes seem to earn (and I don't have a problem with them earning that much), they are a very small share of the 1%, and the chances of a professional athlete becoming a 1%er is low too, only 2% of them. - And since this is a tech/programmer site, the relatively low numbers of computer science/software people in the 1% seems to indicate that our chosen profession "tops out" at a certain income level below that 1%.
- loceng 15y agoRe: Secretaries - Or hiring their partner to be their secretary, although the partnership likely makes sense if they get along that well (co-founders in a way)
- gcp 15y agoAnd since this is a tech/programmer site, the relatively low numbers of computer science/software people in the 1% seems to indicate that our chosen profession "tops out" at a certain income level below that 1% This is an interesting point to take away. If you are smart and want to get rich, going into engineering is not your best bet. Same for scientists. No wonder there are shortages, eh?
- devs1010 15y agoMost programmers who make it there would have to be entrepreneurial so I'm guessing they may get filed under a different "hat" so to speak such as management. Also, I'm guessing this is just based off yearly income so if someone cashed out with stock from an IPO but either sold it all at once years ago (and made a ton of money) or hasn't sold the stock yet I'm guessing it wouldn't be reflected on here. I think the paths that programmers take to reaching the 1% aren't well reflected in a chart like this so its hard to tell how many of these people "have been programmers" at some point.
- jerfelix 15y agoThis is a bit misleading. They incorrectly haphazardly swap "income" and "wealth": The subtitle says "Explore the occupations and industries of the nation’s wealthiest households." Yet the chart note is "The chart counts the number of individual workers living in households with an overall income in the top 1 percent nationwide." This implies that a retired multimillionaire with a 300K passive income isn't in the wealthiest one percent, and a couple with a negative net worth (e.g. bought a $2 million dollar house that's now only worth a million; and no savings), with two $190K jobs is in the wealthiest one percent. Of course this is nonsense.
- jws 15y agoPlus, most of the entries are a mess of "spouse" jobs. e.g. They have 8k receptionists in the top 1% and 7k laborers. Dropping the lowest income household earners that weren't required in order to reach 1% would focus the data better.
- spitfire 15y agoInteresting to note, the three largest boxes Physician, Lawyer and Teacher are all legally protected professions.
- DilipJ 15y agoyes exactly. The reason for the escalating healthcare and education costs have to do with the guilds these professions enforce to prevent newcomers from undercutting their wages. If the U.S. were to abolish the AMA and the teacher's union, the medical and education costs in this country would plummet, and the coming medicare debt could be halved.
- wpietri 15y agoWhat's your evidence for those statements? I'm especially skeptical about teachers; I don't know anybody who avoided becoming a teacher because the certifications or the jobs were too hard to get, but I know a number of people who didn't do it (or did it and quit) because the pay and social standing was too low compared with the difficulty of the work.
- forensic 15y agoTeachers just negotiate for job stability rather than wage. For some reason, teachers are extremely risk averse and would rather be paid crappy, forever, no matter how bad they are. The teachers associations ensure no teachers can ever be fired no matter how incompetent. Teachers get summers off and big pensions and so they lobby for these and other lifestyle perks.
- cemery 15y agoThe visualization was confusing for me at first. It's important to realize that if <1% of a group is in the 1% there is a fair chance that they are not the ones bringing in the wealth. Instead they have married into wealth. The darkness of the squares is much more informative then the size of the squares. In some ways I feel the graphic is misleading since I'm not horribly interested in what groups happen into the 1%, and much more interested in what groups create the 1%.
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoI'm not a UX guy, but I love this graph. Lots of data in an easy-to-explore format. Having said that, I'm not sure if the colors were important enough to merit being included. Do I really care that some occupation gives people a better chance of being in the 1%? Probably not. I'd rather see how many total dollars we are talking about. For instance, do the 1% working securities law make a bunch more than the 1% who are construction managers? By how much? I'll attempt a tl;dr, although you really should read the article. The 1% consists mostly of: managers, physicians, and lawyers, maybe with elementary and middle-school administrators thrown in as well. I would caution to be careful of drawing too many conclusions, however. Every time we have these discussions it's the little details that always get you. It's very easy to feel like you are learning more than you actually are. Always be suspicious of aggregated data, especially when you are looking for insight. I blogged about this last month. (http://www.whattofix.com/blog/archives/2011/12/management-by-s.php http://www.whattofix.com/blog/archives/2011/12/management-by...) Guys like lawyers and school principals fit into nice, little boxes. Entrepreneurs don't. I run into this every time I fill out a government form. For instance I know a guy locally who runs a couple of convenience stores, sells fuel on the side (by "on the side" I mean hundreds of thousands of gallons or more a month through home heating oil trucks, propane, etc.) , has a go-cart track, and is getting into e-commerce. What do you call him? A fuel speculator? Grocery manager? Entertainer? We talk about this all the time on HN, even though we don't know it. Take your average startup, say Stripe, are they a technology company? We would probably say so, but they also look a lot like a financial services company. How about the guy who's a lawyer and helps startups in a participatory manner for equity. Is he a VC? A lawyer manager? A partner? Yes, I know the IRS has legal definitions, but when looking at data like this the legal definitions don't really fit the discussion -- it just leaves us more questions than we started with. The category of many of these business alone is problematic, much less trying to figure out job titles. Real innovation happens between the cracks. It doesn't fit into nice little boxes. The economy works because people are free to pick and choose little bits of all kinds of things to refashion them into something new that never existed before, so the parts that aren't being tracked here are the most important. Once you start looking at aggregates, averages, and deviations, you can make numbers say about anything you want.
- rhino42 15y ago
- crgt 15y ago"The picture is clear; entry into the top 0.5% and, particularly, the top 0.1% is usually the result of some association with the financial industry and its creations." This article makes an important distinction between the top 1% and the top .1% that the NYT piece glosses over: http://www2.ucsc.edu/whorulesamerica/power/investment_manager.html http://www2.ucsc.edu/whorulesamerica/power/investment_manage...
- rudiger 15y agoIndeed, it's not that the conclusion of the article is wrong; the top 1% (whether measured by wealth or by income) are actually a pretty diverse group of people (in terms of occupations). However, the top 0.1% or even 0.01% are possibly a much more monolithic group, perhaps largely involved in the financial services and banking industries? This may be the more relevant group to discuss.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoYour article is a bit deceptive - "some association with the financial industry" can mean an entrepreneur who made their money by building equity in a startup rather than earning a salary: One of our clients, net worth in the $60M range, built a small company and was acquired with stock from a multi-national. Stock is often called a "paper" asset. Another client, CEO of a medium-cap tech company, retired with a net worth in the $70M range. The bulk of any CEO's wealth comes from stock, not income, and incomes are also very high... Another client with a net worth in the $10M range is the ex-wife of a managing director of a major investment bank, while another was able to amass $12M after taxes by her early thirties from stock options as a high level programmer in a successful IT company. So by their criteria, Larry and Sergei, Steve Jobs, etc, all made their money "as a result of some association with the financial industry".
- senor_mills 15y agoI think the problem with drawing the line at the 99% vs 1% is that it let's the bottom 90% of the 1% side with the top 10% of the 1%. (Refering to this previously mentioned link: http://www2.ucsc.edu/whorulesamerica/power/investment_manager.html http://www2.ucsc.edu/whorulesamerica/power/investment_manage...) "We are the 99.9%" isn't as catchy but strategically it would make sense.
- tedsuo 15y agoPaul Krugman with the breakdown for the top .1%: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/01/15/but-the-top-0-1-percent-isnt-diverse/ http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/01/15/but-the-top-0-1-...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mdda 15y agoWho else was expecting to open up the diagram and find a bright red box in the top left with Finance written on it? How surprising it was to see that the 1% that everyone is complaining about are faceless managers, doctors and lawyers... Naturally, I'll need to see the .1% diagram, so that the hateful Financiers are in the position they deserve. (I'm paraphrasing some of the other comments on this topic)
- jonstjohn 15y agoExact same feeling here. Perhaps it should be 'Occupy Your Doctor's Office' rather than Wall Street.
- joe_the_user 15y agoUh but while the graph may be "full of information", other posters have made good arguments that the information it gives isn't revealing (mixing wealth and incomes, aggregating occupations in confusing ways, etc). A simple graph of the occupations of those in the top of 1% of income and the top 1% of wealth (along with the overall source of that wealth) would be more revealing for the debates that have recently raged.
- vannevar 15y agoThe Financiers are spread over several boxes, but taken together they are indeed right where we'd expect them (hated or not).
- hnta 15y agoInteresting. I just did two years to get M.Sc. and started working full-time in IT myself. It is strange.. I always figured I'd eventually be making good money, and I didn't think much more of it. Now soon 30, some of my friends are making a lot more than I do. Only lately do I realize that when my uncle said I should specialize in something other than pure IT 10 years ago (himself having worked in IBM the past.. 10-20 years?), he was right.. This is mostly considering the money-aspect of it. I'll always program, but I don't feel it HAS to be my full-time job, it could be my hobby. Maybe I could have done smart things in the financial service, for instance? Or the oil sector.. I guess the only way to richness in IT is startups or a do other things than program. But it is really hard to do programming full-time at work and then focus on my own thing in my "free-time". Ah well. Another life.
- rhino42 15y agoThe data in this graph is flawed. I only see one major box categorized as "engineer", and it says that 1/4 of all engineers are architecture or surveying. Try 1/20, perhaps. 1/4 is way too large. The only engineering majors that large are EECS and Mechanical, I bet.
- ww520 15y agoTeachers can make lots of money, via tutoring. I know teachers, besides their regular jobs, who have been charging $80 to $100 a hour for tutoring, for 10 to 20 hours a week. Also their regular jobs only take 9 months so they got time for other jobs. They can easily pull in 150K to 180K a year.
- RobLach 15y agoCashiers... :|
- amorphid 15y agoOn what planet could a cashier make that much money? I need to research this!
- redwood 15y agoAssuming this is only looking at 'income' and not capital gains / dividends, this is highly misleading because many wealthy live off the former, though it's a bit difficult to find numbers. Also if everyone is listing their occupations, it's only natural that many choose generic ones rather than "I live off inherited family money dividends" or equivalent