5 ms·
These pieces don’t diminish the necessity of police reform, or excuse the actions of other people wrongs. And I think some people do need a reminder that it’s
by kube-system 4y ago
These pieces don’t diminish the necessity of police reform, or excuse the actions of other people wrongs.
And I think some people do need a reminder that it’s not helpful to generalize large groups of people. Humans have a natural tendency try to fit their ideas about the world into neat little black and white boxes. It’s important to have balance and remember that the world is more complicated than we all sometimes want to believe.
If all police were bad, it would be easy to solve police brutality, just get rid of them. The hard part is fixing an organization that has some good people and some bad people.
- tinus_hn 4y agoThese pieces enrage people because it makes them feel they are being manipulated. Because as it shows they clearly are.
- rocket_surgeron 4y ago[flagged]
- genocidicbunny 4y ago> All hotbeds of police brutality, I'm sure. Hotbeds? Probably not. Problematic? Ooooh yeah. All four of your example countries have well established histories with oppressive and heavy-handed policing at various times throughout the last century, with incidents as recent as this year. If anything, you're providing strong evidenced that this is not an America-only problem, but a more general one that many societies with a police force will suffer from. The fact that duck rescue feel-good stories work outside of America ain't exactly a revelation from the burning bush.
- orwin 4y agoJust a point : we don't have riot for the retirement age. Unions security forces won't allow it yet. It's just the largest manifestation and strike we have in years.
- genocidicbunny 4y agoPerhaps on that point I was a bit misinformed then. I edited that out from my post above. With all that said, the French police aren't strangers to dealing with riots even in recent history, so I think my overall point above stands.
- tablespoon 4y ago> This article is manipulating you more than the duck rescue articles. > Duck rescue stories have existed for as long as the media has. They are light feel-good stories often tacked on to the end of news broadcasts or space filler for newspapers.... > They do not appear in response to anything. They appear because ducklings always fall into storm drains.... > Anyone who thinks there is a coordinated campaign by police PR departments all over the country to improve their image after an incident of police brutality is an actual, literal, idiot. > This is older than time itself, and a global phenomenon. The GP shouldn't be flagged. They're absolutely correct, and that the fact their comment got flagged reflects poorly on HN. These stories are probably even more commonly written about firefighters than police, and a lot are even written about regular citizens: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34628962 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34628962. If these stories are police PR meant to distract from police brutality, why write more of them about firefighters, city workers, kids, and other people?
- krageon 4y ago> it would be easy to solve police brutality, just get rid of them It is that simple - what exactly makes you imply that it is not? I don't see argumentation here at all, it's left as an exercise for the reader. Which is a little unsatisfying as it is the core point of your post.
- automatic6131 4y ago>It is that simple - what exactly makes you imply that it is not? Have you thought about that statement for literally more than a minute? If you abolish the police, and fire every officer, what do you replace them with? Here are some options: Literally nothing - Okay, and the next time a man murders his partner, does that man just carry on? Who arrests him, who investigates? This option is clearly worse than the existing system. The rich pay for private security and the poor are terrorised by organised criminal gangs. Something about "community policing" - Who appoints them? Who pays them? Are you, at best, just recreating the police with zero institutional knowledge and experience? At worst, this is just a power vacuum that will be filled by the only other organised violent group - criminal gangs. Something about despatching social workers before interpersonal crime happens, and maybe abolish capitalism so theft and sexual assault will (magically) no longer be an issue - wishful thinking. Do you have any better options?
- shakes_mcjunkie 4y ago> Something about despatching social workers before interpersonal crime happens, and maybe abolish capitalism so theft and sexual assault will (magically) no longer be an issue - wishful thinking. Nice job conflating a real solution in with a bunch of straw men.
- Tostino 4y agoBut if they didn't use strawman arguments it wouldn't have been so easy for GP to throw up their hands and say "I guess we shouldn't do anything at all then" in essence.
- pksebben 4y ago
- watwut 4y agoHumans in institutions act the way institution shapes them - they react to what is punished, what is rewarded, on peer pressure, on what they are taught in training. When you add a good person into corrupt institution, they become enablers at best, punished and sidelined if they insist on not adjusting and at most likely very their worldview and behavior shifts to match the institution. Cops are not independent individuals exercising individual judgement calls. They are powerful armed organization with special privileges over civilians. They have strong hierarchy and act the way that is rewarded.
- ilostmyshoes 4y agoThis is the answer. Someone may go in with the best of intentions but are quickly and easily molded by the president The entire saying is "a few bad apples spoils the bunch"
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoThe hard part is fixing an organization that has some good people and some bad people This is just the "not all cops" with more words. Where are the good cops? They aren't turning people in. They aren't speaking out. If they do such things, they get fired. They aren't getting promoted: Speaking out makes you untrustworthy. They aren't doing this so much that we know there are police gangs. With tattoos and everything. Surely, folks knew, but nothing happened. Simply not acting like the bad cops isn't enough to be a good cop. The only real reason we have evidence of police misconduct is because of modern technology: The only reason Rodney King's abuse got nationwide coverage is because it happened to be on video, and now everyone has a camera in their pockets. And little has changed. Where, exactly, are these good cops and what are they doing?
- ARandomerDude 4y agoThis is just “yes it is all cops” with more words.
- Kiro 4y agoSo you're saying every single cop is bad. I have a hard time believing that, but on the other hand I live in a country that does not have a problem with police brutality.
- shakes_mcjunkie 4y ago> I live in a country that does not have a problem with police brutality. Yea I really doubt that. You're likely just not the target.
- threatofrain 4y agoA lot of western peers have Very Few deaths per year involving police interaction.
- ceejayoz 4y agoDeath isn't the only form of police brutality.
- fzeroracer 4y agoI mean, when your organization is killing the good people to protect the bad (See: the death of Houston Tipping) then your argument no longer works.
- shakes_mcjunkie 4y ago> And I think some people do need a reminder that it’s not helpful to generalize large groups of people. Being a cop is not an identity.
- threatofrain 4y agoBeing a teacher is an identity. Being a programmer is an identity. Descriptively speaking, without even thinking about why things happen some way, people identify themselves and others with their work. Being homeless is an identity too.
- cycomanic 4y agoThere is a big difference though, being police is also an institution. One could maybe argue the same for teaching (although ironically teachers face much more scrutiny about their behavior than cops, despite not having the power over life or death), but not for programming or homelessness.
- lukas099 4y agoSure it is.
- seanicus 4y agoSo many cops live in cop neighborhoods, surrounded by their cop friends, with blue lives matter stickers & flags, going to their FOP meetings & get-togethers regularly, & all the other signifiers. Their self-identification as a cop is stronger than 90% of how anyone self-identifies about even the most intrinsic elements of themselves like ethnicity and upbringing.
- pydry 4y ago>And I think some people do need a reminder that it’s not helpful to generalize large groups of people. It certainly can be if they are all part of the same institution, because the institution shapes how they act. I think some people need a reminder that "cops" are a distinctly different type of group to say, "Jews" or "black people".
- kube-system 4y agoThere are over 15,000 different police departments in the US.
- seanicus 4y agoIf one good cop won't snitch on one bad cop then there are no good cops.