7 ms·
FCC proposes $504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emergency Alert System tones
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-proposes-504k-fine-against-fox-eas-violations https://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-proposes-504k-fine-against-...
- antiterra 4y agoIt looks like this is the incident as broadcast: https://youtu.be/-AKV57rtYfo https://youtu.be/-AKV57rtYfo Also: The FCC document references the 18 Fox owned stations and says nothing about the 200+ affiliate stations. Are those stations culpable if they also broadcast Fox produced content that was in violation of EAS rules?
- jacquesm 4y agoNo low that advertisers won't stoop to, apparently. Incredible that they thought this was a good idea and that nobody put a stop to it. Maybe they figured that whatever the penalty they'll make it up in sales?
- Waterluvian 4y agoI think it’s more thoughtlessness than anything. The ad contractor probably thought it was a cool campaign theme. Like when they throw sirens and car horns on radio ads. It’s not like those times that Hanes Underwear played the “brown noise” on AM radio. What a commute that was.
- bagels 4y agoIs this a joke?
- Waterluvian 4y agoThe brown noise is just an urban legend. But I’m confident that FOX isn’t calculating the trade-off for a fine. I think they just had an advertising contractor who didn’t know any better. Thought it was a cool angle for an ad.
- ibejoeb 4y agoI'm not even sure if there's a car audio system that could reproduce that range.
- jacquesm 4y agoIt's just DTMF I don't see why not. The base frequencies are all around the 1 KHz band which even the most boneheaded amp + speaker implementation should be able to reproduce.
- throwanem 4y agoI think the question is whether a car stereo could reproduce the so-called "brown note", which as I recall is supposedly somewhere around 12Hz. SAME BFSK uses frequencies iirc between 1 and 2 kHz, and the attention signal is an equal mix of 853 and 960 hertz.
- jacquesm 4y agoAh yes, you are right. Indeed, that's way lower than any stereo other than the weird ones that some kids build into the backs of their cars (note to self: do not lend your car out to junior employees that like subsonics, hi R. I know you're reading HN). Besides that, those would be filtered out on the transmitter end long before they were allowed to modulate the signal. Especially AM transmitters may do some pretty wild stuff when you drive them with frequencies that low, fair chance that you'll find that you hold them 'on' long enough that you're going to find the limits of either the power supply or the cooling system. Both on the high end (5KHz and up in theory, but more like 3KHz in practice) and on the low end (100Hz in theory, but you can go as low as 50 Hz in practice). So I highly doubt that story is true.
- antiterra 4y agoIt seems incredibly boneheaded like some production team possibly didn’t even know these tones were still a real & serious thing. Whatever oversight existed around content also completely failed. If there was evidence that the creators actually did a calculation to determine that the base fine of $144,000 was worth it, that’d be a nightmare for them
- duxup 4y agoYeah there had to be an adult along the line who said "guys this is a bad idea, these tones are for real emergencies".
- ryandrake 4y agoYou'd be surprised at what happens in a lot of companies, totally open loop, with no adult in the room to advise caution. Especially when all you're thinking about is "Lumbergh said this is my last chance--I gotta hit my marketing numbers this quarter or I'm out of a job!"
- scotty79 4y ago> ... didn’t even know these tones were still a real & serious thing. Why are they though?
- Retric 4y agoMany people have a TV or radio on as background noise. Even a minute warning for things tornadoes etc can save lives, but this only works if people associated these sounds with significant issues and start paying attention.
- capableweb 4y agoSo just so I don't misunderstand, it is illegal to reproduce that sound? Just for TV or in general, literally illegal tones? Seems to be just two tones put together (853 and 960 Hz), weird if you could make such a thing illegal. According to what I can find, it's missing something called a SAME header that the tones are supposed to be prefixed by, maybe that's why FOX thought they could get away with it? Edit: For clarification, the particular message that needs o be sent to be considered "Emergency Broadcast" is not just the "Attention signal", it's has many other vital parts (like the header in the message that it begins with). Besides that, the Attention Signal has to be at least 8 seconds long as long, otherwise I'm assuming it should be considered one. The one FOX broadcasted seems to have been ~3 seconds.
- dekhn 4y agoIt's obviously more complicated than that. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Alert_System#Tone_usage_outside_of_alerts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Alert_System#Tone_us...
- MBCook 4y agoI would assume it’s illegal on public airwaves when not an actual emergency where EAS was activated. This makes sense because advertisers could misuse it to grab attention (exactly as Fox did) and cause people to start to ignore the sound due to false signals. Just like it’s usually illegal to have lights and sirens on your car. I’d be interested in the story of how this happened. How did no one say “that’s probably not a good idea”? Even without knowing the law existed?
- throwanem 4y ago> I would assume it’s illegal on public airwaves when not an actual emergency where EAS was activated. Correct. CFR Title 17, Part 11 [1] specifies the technical and operational aspects of EAS. Section 45: > No person may transmit or cause to transmit the EAS codes or Attention Signal, or a recording or simulation thereof, in any circumstance other than in an actual National, State or Local Area emergency or authorized test of the EAS. Broadcast station licensees should also refer to §73.1217 of this chapter. [1] https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2010-title47-vol1/pdf/CFR-2010-title47-vol1-part11.pdf https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2010-title47-vol1/pd...
- neodypsis 4y agoWhy does it look like it was made in the 80s?
- renewiltord 4y agoIt's supposed to imitate this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rF4BCMs-8BE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rF4BCMs-8BE
- scotty79 4y agoIt doesn't explain why 2011 invention looks like 1960 jank.
- worthless-trash 4y agoIts probably a combination of "this shouldnt look like regular tv" and "This needs to work reliably in really crappy situations". The font also looks like the subtitles that some local teletex stations used to use. I wonder how much of that broadcast is teletex/subtitle aligned to work well. If it had some smooth jazz with helvetica playing in the background I wouldn't take it seriously. That EAS font (to me a foreigner) screams "This isn't daytime television".
- sokoloff 4y agoAmusing that that alert for Washington DC has an “effective until” time in mm/dd/yy format and in Pacific Standard Time (3 hours behind DC’s Eastern Standard Time).
- duxup 4y agoHoly smokes yeah that sounds just like the EAS tones. We can't be desensitizing folks to legitimate emergency announcements. Fine them to high heaven.
- scotty79 4y agoWhen was the last legitimate emergency of this kind? I'm not from USA.
- dave78 4y agoOur governor (ab)used the EAS system to announce COVID lockdowns. The false Hawaii missile warning comes to mind too. Somewhat interesting is that I don't think they were used on 9/11.
- throwanem 4y agoI don't know of anything in the relevant regulation that would prohibit a statewide EAS activation for a public health emergency.
- scotty79 4y agoOther comments links to video of when it was first introduced and tested. It's from November 2011
- dave78 4y agoNo, EAS was rolled out in 1997, and it replaced the very similar EBS which was from the 60s. 2011 is just the first time they actually attempted a nationwide alert, which was always a capability but had never been used to that point.
- palmscenter 4y agoWireless Emergency Alerts use the same tones, but didn’t exist on 9/11. EAS did exist, but the alerts are supposed to include the protective action to be taken. What protective action would you have recommended the public take? And since broadcast news widely covered the attacks, what contribution would an EAS alert make?
- palmscenter 4y ago“The FCC document references the 18 Fox owned stations and says nothing about the 200+ affiliate stations.” Im fact the FCC mentions the affiliates several times. One example: “Therefore, we find FOX responsible for broadcasting the Promotional Segment containing the EAS Tones on 18 of its owned-and-operated broadcast stations, transmitting the Promotional Segment to 190 of its network-affiliated television broadcast stations, and causing the transmission of the Promotional Segment on Fox Sports Radio and the Fox Sports on XM channel.” > Are those stations culpable if they also broadcast Fox produced content that was in violation of EAS rules? Station licensees are responsible for the content they broadcast. In this case at least the FCC went after the content source, which is itself also a licensee.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- not2b 4y agoFor a company of Fox's size this is a small fine.
- anigbrowl 4y agoIt'd be interesting to contrast post-broadcast website engagement with other ad campaigns for similar events; perhaps the payoff exceeded the cost, though obviously it's not the sort of stunt they can repeat without putting their broadcast licenses at risk.
- mikeiz404 4y agoFor context: It’s ~0.01% ($.5M/$4.4B) of the company’s revenue for that year. (I’m not weighing in one way or the other here) > That may be difficult, however, since the FCC says in its proposal that the company had $4.44 billion of revenue in 2021. Edit: Wow, looks like I really messed up the math. It has been updated. Thanks for the comments pointing that out/asking about it.
- munk-a 4y agoCan you clarify if that's Fox Sports, this particular Fox branch or the Fox Corporation as a whole?
- mikeiz404 4y agoI believe it’s revenue for Fox in general. The number is pulled from the article but I messed up the original calculation.
- munk-a 4y agoAh no worries - I thought that Fox had a revenue in the billions last year so I was really surprised to hear they had a profit sitting around five million.
- morisy 4y agoIs that profit for the sports division only? Briefly looking just found the overall profit: 2021 Profit: $ 2,150,000,000 Proposed Fine: $ 504,000 Fine / Profit * 100: 0.023% [Profit Source](https://www.google.com/finance/quote/FOX:NASDAQ?sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiGzI3kyfD8AhWGjYkEHSKhDS4Q3ecFegQICRAg https://www.google.com/finance/quote/FOX:NASDAQ?sa=X&ved=2ah...)
- metadat 4y agoLightly discussed earlier today as well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34577793 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34577793 (3 comments)
- SSchick 4y agoTangentially: I honestly wish the same was for radio stations and any emergency/siren sound that are commonly heard in traffic, it makes me absolutely paranoid. No responsible radio station should use these sounds or broadcast music containing them.
- bee_rider 4y agoAlso break noises. Nowadays I guess the vast majority of AM/FM radio listening takes place in cars, so it would be nice to tailor the laws to that.
- btown 4y agoOr noises meant to mimic the vibration of a phone! If there's anything likely to cause people to simultaneously take their eyes off the road, it's that!
- anigbrowl 4y agoThe original headline was 'Fox Sports Admits It Used Fake EAS Tones On Radio As Well As TV' but it seems like people inside the broadcast industry have been following this case for a while, and it didn't convey the context of the admission coming as part of an enforcement action. I felt the first line provided a better summary of the issue for a casual reader.
- cmurf 4y ago$500K per transmitter seems more reasonable as a deterrent. $500K total seems more like a royalty payment.
- dave78 4y agoMaybe I'm not as cynical as most here, but I find it hard to believe that any American company would willfully violate this law because it "only" cost $500k. Even for a company the size of Apple (as an example of the wealthiest company I can easily think of), I would think $500k is still a pretty big expense and not one anyone would take lightly.
- eftychis 4y agoI think FCC needs to make it something like 150% of expected profit + $50 million and above. Then maybe it will make a dent or sense. Plus, getting the DoJ involved. tl;dr: if executives/board members don't go to jail for things there is always a right price for a company to break the rules.
- LanceH 4y agoYou say this without knowing the actual regulations, obligations, and posted penalties, of course.
- eftychis 4y agoMy comment (clearly to the average person) implies what needs to be done to work as an effective deterrent, viewed in a black box setting. You can see the description of the facts from FCC's point of view here [https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-23-4A1.pdf https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-23-4A1.pdf] -- as linked in the article -- describing the social damage Fox inflicted. FCC makes clear that this is what is prescribed and that given the profits of Fox it has no impact in the company's operation. Thus, there is no reason to reduce it. If you feel otherwise perhaps you have a more positive view of how companies make decisions in the U.S. which is great. P.S. And for readers' convenience here is the forfeiture framework FCC uses here: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/47/503 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/47/503 It is inadequate from my vantage point. P.S.2. It is common secret, and a running joke here -- check other hackernews posts -- that FCC has no teeth. Regulations need to change.
- froglets 4y agoIs there any reason they couldn’t keep the ad online or in a podcast?
- MBCook 4y agoUnless that was a part of some plea agreement (“we won’t go for $1.5 million if you admit and promise…”). The FCC has no jurisdiction over those.
- trimbo 4y agoOut of curiosity, can movies and shows use them? Do they censor it out if the movie is ever shown on broadcast TV? Naturally the example that came up when I searched is The Purge: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ns8t4Y9G4wU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ns8t4Y9G4wU
- kube-system 4y agoThey’d have to censor it. Or it would programmatically activate the emergency systems that it controls.
- MBCook 4y agoThe Wikipedia page for the EAS notes that CBS had to pay a fine for using it in an episode of The Big Bang Theory.
- throwanem 4y agoThat isn't a valid SAME header. It's incorrectly encoded and the pitch is too low. Both errors are likely intentional, specifically to avoid inadvertent broadcast interruptions. I still wouldn't expect a broadcaster to take a chance on it, but I would be surprised if it actually triggered an EAS receiver.
- noodlesUK 4y agoI feel like this is generally far too small of a fine for something this serious. A deliberate use of an emergency signal to further an advertising campaign, especially an emergency signal that is literally designed to hijack neighbouring radio stations (though I’m not reading that this happened in this case) seems like a pretty egregious thing, and should result in a fine big enough to be noticeable on the balance sheets. I agree with some of the other commentators here that we should go further and ban things like car horns and brake squeals etc in radio programming (where a large number of listeners are driving and noises like that could result in fatal collisions). I feel like a 500k fine would be justifiable for a car horn or similar, not a “prepare for a serious threat to life” emergency signal that is meant to sound very distinctive. If I went to a public building and played a plausible sounding fake fire alarm over a megaphone I would almost certainly be arrested. They did this but to potentially millions of people.
- ericmay 4y agoYea I agree. Something like $504,000 per second might be better.
- costco 4y agoI'd rather a $500,000 fine that actually gets collected than the ridiculous approach we take to spam calls where we fine people [9 figures](https://commsrisk.com/more-enormous-fines-proposed-for-robocallers-who-never-paid-their-previous-fines/ https://commsrisk.com/more-enormous-fines-proposed-for-roboc...) and make no attempt to collect it. TCPA's $1500/call sounds great but in actuality no one has have ever paid anything close to that and the spammers don't have anywhere near the amount of money to do that.
- ericmay 4y agoSure, really we just need law enforcement to do its job here. I'm not sure why they don't. I've had a lot of issues with spam calls that began only when my mom became terminally ill and I was assisting her. They'd call "this is senior aide helper" (among others) and would call "verified" from the carrier with local numbers. I can't imagine how many Americans who are dealing with trouble in their lives are being scammed here. The FCC should fine the telecom companies $1,500/reported spam call. That would stop this over night. I don't know who is paying who to prevent us from stopping this, but it sure as fucking hell looks to me like people in our government don't give a damn about citizens.
- samstave 4y agoYet again we all ask the same: WHERE do the fines go? How audit? Recall Pfizer was fined $2+ BILLION for stuff they did a few years ago (not talking about the TRILLIONS in fraud recently revealed) But WHERE SPECIFICALLY do the 'fines' wind up? Also, if we are facing a gov't shutdown because we ran out of money in our budget, then how the F were we able to supply Ukraine (the most corrupt, according to some) with 100B++ in 'aide' Where the hell is accountability in ANY of our agencies... and if not accountability, transparency?
- kube-system 4y agoMost federal fines go to the treasury unless there are laws stating otherwise, and then Congress decides what to do with it. There are many thousands of pages of documentation on treasury.gov if you are interested in learning more. In the end, Congress must authorize all spending.
- astrange 4y agoThe government cannot run out of money, it owns a money printer. And there isn't a shutdown, you're thinking of the debt ceiling, which is basically the government refusing to pay its credit card bills even though it's perfectly capable of it.
- charcircuit 4y agoThis violates free speech. I'm glad the internet allows for more freedom of speech than radio and tv
- throwanem 4y agoCompliance with EAS regulations is a condition of broadcast licensure. This isn't a free speech issue under law; it's a violation of a term in a contract freely entered upon by a broadcast network with the US government, and fines are one of the possible penalties enumerated for such violations.
- charcircuit 4y agoIs there a way to broadcast on the radio or tv without getting into such contract that limits what you can broadcast? If you can only talk if you are prohibited from saying something don't you see how that violates free speech?
- brewdad 4y agoPirate radio is a thing but there’s a reason it’s illegal.
- throwanem 4y agoYou would about as reasonably argue that laws prohibiting espionage violate free speech, because one should be able to say what one likes to an agent of a hostile foreign power with no need to fear any consequence. This absurdly absolutist conception of free speech bears no resemblance however remote to anything ever actually codified in US law, and I don't see what you mean to achieve by advancing it other than to give the impression of being entirely unserious.
- charcircuit 4y ago>You would about as reasonably argue that laws prohibiting espionage violate free speech Yes. >This absurdly absolutist conception of free speech bears no resemblance however remote to anything ever actually codified in US law It's not absurd. It's quite a simple ideal of being able to freely express things. Whatever US law is doesn't change my ideals of existing in a society which is not bound by a govemment on what they can and can not express. >I don't see what you mean to achieve by advancing it other than to give the impression of being entirely unserious. This could be said about any compromise of free speech. Many groups desire to take away people freedoms of speech and they start by taking away things people think would be absurd to want to express.
- Overtonwindow 4y agoHas anyone else turned off the emergency alerts on their phone? The first time I got an amber alert I was sitting in my living room and it was for something that happened 40 miles away, so I turned off all of the emergency alerts. I went for Christmas to visit my parents and an emergency alert went off and they're like we can't stop it, they go off all the time, and so I took their phones and turned off the emergency alerts. Am I out of the norm or have other people experienced this, have also turned off the alerts?
- IIsi50MHz 4y agoMy devices let me separately disable Amber alerts without disabling all alerts. For a few years, I kept them all on, but after umpteen alerts that I had miniscule chance of helping with[1], I disabled Amber alerts. [1] Too far out of area, or working from home without a view of any traffic, too sick. Or sometimes excessively vague descriptions of suspect vehicle.