9 ms·
> Amazon in October 2021 paid $123 million for the 29-acre property in Milpitas, California Talk about buying at the exact peak of the market. The cat is out
by paxys 4y ago
> Amazon in October 2021 paid $123 million for the 29-acre property in Milpitas, California
Talk about buying at the exact peak of the market.
The cat is out of the proverbial bag for all these large tech employers. Doesn't matter if you are Amazon or Google or whoever else. Once people got a taste of WFH life they were never going back to the hour plus commutes, weird social structures and power dynamics, noisy environment, lack of privacy.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI would like to be as optimistic as you are, but CEOs are clearly bent on returning to the old ways[1]( the gist of the article is:"it is not your decision to make"). [1]https://fortune.com/2023/01/20/work-from-home-remote-work-morgan-stanley-ceo-james-gorman-not-employee-choice/ https://fortune.com/2023/01/20/work-from-home-remote-work-mo...
- TillE 4y agoThe long-term financial benefits of remote work are likely to outweigh the emotional / speculative resistance from certain leaders.
- JohnFen 4y agoI'm not so sure. Companies don't really behave as "rational economic actors" anymore than people do.
- jensensbutton 4y agoAgree. I worry that many companies will maintain notional "support" for remote roles, but it will revert to a two tiered system where in-office workers have better career growth.
- Swizec 4y ago> "it is not your decision to make" Sure it is! Free market competition was made for exactly this sort of scenario. As long as some employers offer WFH, workers can make the choice. If we put a $$ figure on WFH and this makes salaries cheaper for employers that offer WFH, they may eventually win out the market. Saying "employees can't choose to WFH" may eventually be seen as silly of a decision as saying "we only buy inputs from countries with the highest import tariffs". Let the market decide. It's going to either way. Say I'm a company saving $50,000,000/year on office leases. That's a lot of room for higher salaries and nicer bonuses for my employees (including execs). And I still get to keep a huge chunk as extra profit. Long-term what sounds better to the board: A CEO who says "I saved us 50mil" or a CEO that says "I lost 30% of our workforce but we got them all back to the office! Btw I need another 50mil for the office"
- grapescheesee 4y agoMore so, I cut and saved 50,000,000. What salary increase allotments should go to increase in pay? I'll just say we saved n roles with the move.
- pklausler 4y ago"it is not your decision to make" I think that it is, actually.
- reaperducer 4y agoCEOs are clearly bent on returning to the old ways My company was like that. It started firing people who didn't return to work. Then someone noticed that there weren't enough people left in certain departments to get things done. Now the company is 90% remote, and selling some of its office buildings. The only people in the office are those who choose to be, and those whose jobs require them to be hands-on.
- ojbyrne 4y agoI think “As Return to Office Stalls” is a bit of wishful thinking. 18000 employees gone, probably more to go, trimming real estate is just another cost cutting measure.
- chrsig 4y agoI'd been reading this as returning to Office Stalls, comparing the open office to a barn. Or bathroom. Took me a moment to parse it properly that returning to the office is stalling.
- k__ 4y agoGood point on the weird social structures. I always found dating in the workplace kinda alarming, especially when people would date their subordinates.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat's a reason to ask for immediate relocation within the company to ensure your love interest isn't in your chain of command/review and vv. Many companies have pretty explicit rules around this. https://www.entrepreneur.com/growing-a-business/how-google-facebook-and-amazon-handle-office-romances/308983 https://www.entrepreneur.com/growing-a-business/how-google-f... Just a couple of things you might open the company (and yourself) up to (from the POV of the person in the supervisor role): - a sexual harassment lawsuit in case things end on a bad note - colleagues complaining (possibly rightfully so) about favoritism - inability to set policy because you yourself violate policy - a potentially very toxic situation in case the relationship ends and you have to continue to work together It doesn't really matter whether the person in the supervisor role is a male or a female, either way it looks bad and will likely lead to trouble. And for an encore: between founders the risks (but also some of the potential rewards) are even higher. I've seen a start-up that was doing fantastically well end up in shreds because the co-founders got romantically involved, got married, had kids and then divorced, the divorce pretty much killed the company.
- carlosjobim 4y agoThe rest of the world laughs at the American prudes and their extreme fear of letting romance and life itself come in the way of the profit interests of their 85 year old corporate lords. I don't mean to insult, but please look at your reasoning and think about if it is healthy? Is it appropriate for an adult to talk about "lead to trouble". Kids get in trouble, grown ups don't. Oh, it is so unprofessional to let the wonder of being alive ever interrupt the demands of efficiency and a steady stream of taxes to the IRS. Imagine the nerve of that co-founder who destroyed the startup for unprofessional things like having children! My accountant will make a very stern frown when I tell him. Please corporate working Americans if you read this: It is okay to have romance in the workplace! Life is too short. All the rest of the world does this and knows it is natural and healthy.
- jjtheblunt 4y agomostly agree, but for some work at a workplace was more coherent and peaceful than working from home
- wildrhythms 4y agoUnpaid commute... I know lots of folks in the Bay area spending hours per day commuting (and NOVA/DC area, if you live there you know). I'm not sure why it isn't considered stolen wages.
- sneak 4y agoStealing implies unilateral and without consent. People opt-in to jobs and the associated commutes completely voluntarily and consensually.
- itake 4y agoAlso, your commute time is your commute time. Your employer does not control how you go to your work nor what you do while traveling. Your employer also doesn't choose your housing.
- bcrosby95 4y ago> Also, your commute time is your commute time. Your employer does not control how you go to your work nor what you do while traveling. Not necessarily true. Some employers offer company buses to/from certain cities, with wifi, and they count that as working hours.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Some employers offer company buses to/from certain cities, with wifi, and they count that as working hours. Yes, effectively your company is choosing to send your worksite to (a place closer to) your home, so that you can start working sooner and stop working later.
- Teever 4y agoI bet that if employers were legally mandated to pay their workers for the time they commute that those employers would suddenly appreciate the importance of effective public transit and increased urban density.
- barbazoo 4y agoJust a couple of hours ago I was kicking off a build that would take about 20 minutes. It's a slow sprint so I went and put the laundry in the dryer and then had a quick coffee with my partner before going back to work just in time for the build to finish. It's heaven. This is the best work life balance I've ever had in my career and I love it. I can't think of anything right now that would get me back into an office in the city.
- Breza 4y agoI feel the exact same way, I run a data science team from my basement. At 4:30, I walk to my daughter's daycare and we play together in the time that I used to spend commuting. I never want to go back to an office.
- kylehotchkiss 4y agosounds like you need to run your build on a m2 max!
- ttul 4y agoHow about a $10K pay cut?
- lsaferite 4y agoYou could easily spend 10k on commuting. That's only about $40/day. Between fuel, maint, tolls, and maybe food, you can easily bust $40/day in the Bay Area. That's not even considering the _time_ spent commuting.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoAnd the morbidity/mortality risk. Driving is the most risky thing most Americans do.
- soiler 4y agoI already hated cars, but since I began WFH I've become really averse to driving unnecessarily. Getting killed by a car is one of the absolute stupidest ways to go. My dad smoked all his life and still made it past 60; my brain could hit pavement tonight if I run out of milk. And the worst part is that it wouldn't have to be my fault at all, and it wouldn't even require somebody to do something extraordinarily reckless. Driving too fast through my neighborhood is typical, because it happens to offer the shortest path from A to B for many people, and the road is wide thanks to bike lanes that I have never seen bikes in (because: cars drive too fast). I'll cut myself off here before this becomes an overly long screed.
- nostrademons 4y agoEdifice complex: http://www.ipglossary.com/glossary/edifice-complex/#.Y9hFf-wa6Lo http://www.ipglossary.com/glossary/edifice-complex/#.Y9hFf-w... As I was visiting the new space-age buildings at Meta, Google, and Apple in 2021 (and reading about Amazon's new HQ), I was thinking "Wow, all 4 are building new headquarters. I wonder if this means we're at the high point of Big Tech." Seems like that was prescient.
- notyourwork 4y ago> hour plus commutes Commuting is my biggest complaint with forcefully going back to office. If I have a bus or train that requires no brain power for me to get to office, I am more tolerable to it. Perhaps this will be a kick in the improve US public transportation for the masses? It is the only silver lining I can think of here.
- monksy 4y agoJust wait till you get a mayor who has decided to kill public transit. Trains/buses don't show up, they're packed with homeless using it as a bed and a toliet, and gangsters who smoke it up. On top of that they're not running the schedule, but "keeping the schedule intact". That's what's been happening in Chicago. (Thanks Lori "we're a car city" Lightfoot)
- reaperducer 4y agoI'm not sure you can blame Lightfoot for that. I've lived in Chicago on-and-off for 30 years -- never with a car -- and the CTA has always been like that. That's why some L cars have a "hobo corner," and why there's (was?) a homeless shelter at the O'Hare airport Blue Line station. The CTA may be smelly, but it beats getting shot at by thugs on the expressways.
- monksy 4y agoIt was never this bad. It's gotten worse over the last 2 years. https://www.wbez.org/stories/chicago-cta-riders-on-delays-safety-filth-smoking/00289237-4e60-4d9a-b355-8923fe433449 https://www.wbez.org/stories/chicago-cta-riders-on-delays-sa... Also, traffic has gotten a heck of a lot worse as well. Also the homeless have moved into the airport. [At the baggage areas,https://www.reddit.com/r/chicago/comments/zm4emb/homeless_people_at_ohare/ https://www.reddit.com/r/chicago/comments/zm4emb/homeless_pe... ]
- CuriousCosmic 4y agoThis is really the kicker. I would have no problem commuting 1+ hours into the city for work if I could actually make use of my time. I can't do anything while driving beyond listen to music. An audiobook is either going to get my full attention and I'll be distracted while driving or I'm going to miss 30-40% of the book trying to stay alert on the road. At that point I might as well just not listen to the audio book at all if I care about the contents. However if I could just take trains/buses into the city, provided they actually run regularly (i.e. they don't turn a 40 minute drive into 6 hours), I'd have 1-4 hours a day I could allocate to reading, listening to an audio book, watching TV, playing a game, working on personal projects, or continuing my education. Sure it might be a long commute but I could do the things that I'd otherwise barely have time for so it's not really lost time. Doubly so if I could actually do work on a company device while I commute (no surprise team meetings if you aren't actually on site yet meaning work would actually get done).
- MuffinFlavored 4y ago> Once people got a taste of WFH life they were never going back to the hour plus commutes, weird social structures and power dynamics, noisy environment, lack of privacy. Unless managers/directors/VPs/SVPs/C-suite executives get even more strict and companies around the country band together to not offer remote work closing any/all openings, forcing people back to work. 3 options: 1. get lucky enough to find a job that allows work from home 2. be unemployed 3. suck it up and work for a company that demands you work in the office unless you can find an alternative (aka a remote job) if you can't find a remote job, you're out of luck. whether this breaks down in reality (aka... what % of open jobs right now after all of these layoffs are in person vs hybrid vs full remote) is it a fairytale dream that there's a ton of remote jobs out there? especially with microsoft + google + apple + amazon being relatively against remote work.
- noddingham 4y agoNo, it isn't a fairy tale. I think because you're posting on HN you're only thinking about the popular stocks first. BLS says there's just shy of four million IT jobs out there. I'd say your chances are pretty good you can find one that doesn't have a shitty commute and/or allows remote/WFH options.
- phpisthebest 4y agoThe number of them fully remote has been dropping fast, at least based on what I see in my feed on various job sites like indeed, and linked in Hybrid seems to be more popular with 2 or 3 days of WFH Even the fully remote alot of them are requiring people to be with in 1-2 hour of a company office signalling that maybe they will be going hybrid as well
- ghotli 4y agoDon't worry about it, seriously. If you'd like to work remotely then do so. It took a little bit of work a decade back to find a great paying remote job. These days it's so much more simple even with some of the largest tech employers forcing people back into the office. I'd argue you don't want to work somewhere that "does remote since the pandemic". Apply at remote-only companies and if you're employable they'll find you a spot since they're dealing with brain drain too. Hot take, but I've done this remote engineer thing for a long time. Feels like we're in the golden age of remote work compared to my experiences a decade back. Find the position in the world wherein you both enjoy your work and how/where you do it. It's out there, guaranteed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- somethoughts 4y agoWhen I read the article it seems to be more about going from "Everything via Amazon Prime" to "Return to Physical Stores" versus going from "WFH" to "Return to Office"? "Amazon in October 2021 paid $123 million for the 29-acre property in Milpitas, California, part of a strategy to lock up real estate near big cities that could be used for new warehouses and facilitate future growth." Seems kind of crazy to buy an office complex and raze it for an Amazon warehouse/distribution center.
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoIf they can outsource your job to your home, they can outsource it to India.
- remote_phone 4y agoBoth me and my wife hate working from home. She is forced to but I elected to go into the office once it was available. The work life balance is better, sure, but my productivity plummeted and I was stuck doing nothing for hours every day waiting to hear back from coworkers. The stress involved especially during a recession is more than the benefit of no commute for me.
- ibejoeb 4y agoMaybe we'll collectively consider return to "office" again, as in a real office. Nobody wants to be in a bullpen, no matter how clever the PR is around open-plan. We all know it's just being too cheap to build walls.
- ClassyJacket 4y agoMaking people work in the office is cruelty for the sake of cruelty. I will not accept any job in future that makes me go into an office. There's no reason for it. It's power tripping.
- tinus_hn 4y agoOr it has nothing to do with the work-from-home dream and everything with the 18000 jobs they’re cutting.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- enos_feedler 4y agoI worked at the Googleplex pre pandemic. It was bustling. I quit during the pandemic but biked through it for fun. Ghost town. I still bike through and it’s still a ghost town. Office space went from being a problem to a burden.