5 ms·
For longevity, muscle strength may be as important as aerobic exercise
- surfsvammel 4y agoMy anecdotal experience is that whenever old people fall and break something, then it all start going downhill, health wise, very quickly. I’ve always thought it’s because they don’t have very much muscle to begin with, that braking a leg or something, forces you to be still so much that you loose whatever muscle you do have left. That in turn has other negative effects; socially from not going out of your house, maybe even cardiovascularly, mentally, etc. That’s how it’s been for my grandmother, and for my wife’s grandparents. Purely anecdotal.
- HNDen21 4y agoExercising strengthens the bones in addition to building muscle. DEXA scans will show this... when a person starts squatting for example, bone density goes up as well
- Temporary_31337 4y agoit's not just bones - it's also the tendons, ligaments, heck even the skin
- HNDen21 4y agoright
- SoftTalker 4y agoAll true but it's not without risk. I'm in my 50s, lifting weights for about 3 years now, slow steady increases in weight and am much stronger than I was in 2019. Recently while bench pressing I felt something "pop" in my shoulder and now can't do any pressing movement at all without significant pain. Diagnosed and tried to rehab it as a tendon strain with no improvement. Getting an MRI soon to see what's going on. At my age I don't really feel "old" mentally or physically, so hitting my body's physical limits in the gym is both difficult to accept and discouraging, as I had been making decent progress up until then. I can still squat and deadlift and do many other accessories but I am paying much more attention to what my joints and ligaments are telling me.
- layer8 4y agoYeah, one is always limited by the weakest link in the chain, unfortunately.
- saiya-jin 4y agoThe problem is (and it increases with age) - muscles are not your limiting factor long term, connective tissues are. They can be damaged by long term fatigue, or sudden burst of too much strain. Pushing weights continuously, in higher age, will eventually lead to injury, even if muscles would easily go even further, they are much better at repairing/building up quickly compared to ie tendons or ligaments. Even for young, there is general advice to put 1 week out of ie 10/12 of complete rest, or probably active rest. It is for all those little fractures and sprains in connective tissue to heal a bit. With age, this should be more frequent and/or longer and as usually everything is very individual.
- mister_mister 4y agoI would advice to lose the barbell and focus on dumbbells and machines. Try training more like bodybuilders instead of power lifters. Using the full range of motion, and being able to rotate while performing the movement will decrease the tension on your joints and ligaments.
- jwiz 4y agoWhen I did a DEXA scan a while back my density was literally off the chart (higher score than the highest one written). I strength train for about 8-10 hours a week.
- jackschultz 4y ago> Running, swimming, playing soccer and other aerobic exercise do a lot for the cardiovascular system — our heart and blood vessels — but they don’t do much for overall muscle mass or strength. Preface: like most people here, I'm not a doctor or physiological specialist. I am decently active, and what I've found from the papers and science that gets brought up, and from my own self experimentation, is that the majority of our aerobic exercise isn't aerobic. In order for your body to use the aerobic energy system, we need a much higher base to raise our lactic thresholds to levels where we can use that system for things like running, swimming, or playing soccer. Instead, our bodies use the glycemic anaerobic systems by default because we don't have that aerobic base. In order to change this over the winter, I've been doing workouts at much, much lower intensities to try to build up my aerobic ability. For example, this morning I did an hour long walk on a treadmill with slight incline while keeping my heart rate at a consistent 100 bpm. This is a much, much lower level than might even be considered a heart rate for the workout. But I could feel my body doing work the whole time. Other workout is on an indoor bike where I also find a pace where I'm giving effort, but super low intensity to build up my base. Again, n=1 and I'm not an expert, but my true guess, which is one that I'm working on myself, is that very few people have a good aerobic base to where very little of our exercise is truly aerobic.
- Temporary_31337 4y agoYeah, the science around endurance sports (cycling, nordic skiing, rowing, running etc) has got this covered in quite the detail and does recommend that majority (80%) of your training should be aerobic - i.e. below first lactate threshold. That said, especially as you're unfit early on, doing above aerobic exercices is absolutely fine to increase toe aerobic capacity.
- jackschultz 4y agoWhat I'm saying is that for the majority of people, even those who are considered "fit", don't default to aerobic system of energy when doing endurance sports because they don't have a solid enough base. They think because they're going for a 30 minute run it _must_ be aerobic, but if tested, they'd find it wasn't. To know if this is true or not would require testing and numbers and defining what's considered "fit", rather than commenting on HN. That said, I truly have relatively high confidence in that the active population these days very much relies on the glycolytic energy system rather than oxidative, anaerobic rather than aerobic.
- Temporary_31337 4y agoThis is music to my ears, as I've started re-emphasizing gym workouts over my cycling workouts. It's already widely known that aging and inactivity tend to reduce muscle mass (muscle atrophy) and longer aerobic/endurace exercices such as cycling or running will improve your stamina and will lower your body fat, but will not increase your muscle mass by much. I've gone this rabbit hole of doing bicycle training and very long bike rides and lost a lot of weight/fat without even needing to change my diet much, but I have not gained muscle. This year I am improving on that by mixing in some gym session early on in the season (and hopefully keeping some gym work later in the season too)
- DeltaCoast 4y agoFor the past few months I've been doing cycling,10-15 minutes, on a stationary bike right before lifting for about 30-45 minutes. And then trying to squeeze a longer bike ride 30 minutes at the end of the week. I find cycling beforehand makes the overall workout more intense.
- rocket_surgeron 4y agoI'm not a human bodyologist. I'm a barely functional human being who feels as though he is faking his way though being an adult. What I can say is that two years ago in my early 40s I had a L5-S1 spinal fusion after decades of pain, tremendous weight gain, and crippling depression. My surgeon really only said two things after I woke up from the surgery. He loomed over me in what my post-anesthetic stupor remembers as a pose resembling the nun scene in Blues Brothers and said "if you want to recover, waaaaaaaalk" and then the next day when I was a little more cognizant he said "lift weights". When I asked him what else, he said "DO YOGA". Doctor surgeon looming over my bed: https://i.imgur.com/jlMRimz.jpg https://i.imgur.com/jlMRimz.jpg Every day I walk at least 1 mile, which takes 20 minutes. Three days per week I lift weights under the direction of a trainer specifically educated to deal with people with fused backs and I'm extremely close to "graduating" from her on to "normal people weightlifting". The other four days I do yoga, a mix of ashtanga or yin depending on how I'm feeling the day after the strength training. It has completely, radically, transformed my physique, mental health, and life in general. Walking and yoga cost $0.00, weightlifting costs me a lot but can be very inexpensive, and it is all more than worth it.
- avgcorrection 4y agoSounds like a well-balanced routine. Good luck onwards. :)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jobs_throwaway 4y ago> people who hit the cardio and the weights realized an approximately 40 percent reduced risk of all-cause mortality and 50 percent reduced risk of cardiovascular disease mortality it makes sense, but damn is that figure staggering. 40% reduced risk of all-cause mortality?!
- radu_floricica 4y agoI am a firm believer that the first 15 minutes of daily light exercise are not for fitness, they're simply for basic health. You can and should definitely do more, but if you don't even do that you go down.
- sonthonax 4y agoI’ve always thought there’s something misguided about the legions of “want to get fit” types who self flagellate with long runs. Running is terrible exercise. Terrible because it’s extremely hard on the body unless you’re on the lower end of the BMI scale. If you do any sport with a high mobility requirement, you can feel how tight a single run makes you. The killer in old age is immobility, of your knees and hips. Running really doesn’t help. Now before people point me to some article debunking how running isn’t in fact bad for your knees, that’s not what I’m saying. Efficient running is all about maximising power through a very small range of motion. Runners by and large have terrible hip mobility for athletes.
- johnrob 4y agoThis is not a scientific argument, but if you build up conditioning safely, i think running should be excellent for you - especially if sprinting is involved. My take is that it’s a natural movement that evolution has prepared you for. Just my 2 cents.
- inciampati 4y agoAgreed. Natural movements of all types are critical. Just running long slow distances on hard surfaces can be rough on the body. Running is addictive and costless aside from your time. That's maybe why the legions (myself included) use it as their primary exercise.
- ren_engineer 4y ago>This is not a scientific argument, but if you build up conditioning safely, i think running should be excellent for you the problem is that running/jogging is usually the first thing people turn to for "getting in shape" and these people are often significantly overweight. Starting off with a high impact exercise is a recipe for disaster. Put on a 50-100lb weight vest and try running around and feel the impact on your joints and back, not ideal
- SoftTalker 4y agoIf you are 50lbs "overweight" your body has built the strength to carry that weight. Look at any champion powerlifter or "strongman" champion, they all look overweight. It's not all fat, it's the muscle to move that weight around as well. So it's not really the same as a normal-weight person putting on a weight vest. But long term overweight is hard on your joints, no disupting that.
- dukeofdoom 4y agopresumably this already is a kind of a fitness test. anyone able to walk 10 miles per day is already fitter than most boomer Americans, even 5 miles, is not likely to die
- LorenPechtel 4y agoYup, but there's also the reverse factor that those who are approaching death rarely are capable of walking that far. I strongly suspect that most measurements of factors related to longevity are actually measures of health. That being said, I think both strength and cardiovascular fitness matter. If nothing else, strength matters in terms of being able to save yourself from a stumble.
- ren_engineer 4y agofeels like a correlation/causation thing once again. If you are in good enough health to lift weights at an older age by definition you are healthier because you aren't suffering from a debilitating illness. People who are dedicated enough to lift weights are also probably following a much better diet than the average person regardless it's good to see strength training getting some love instead of the cult of cardio. People associating fitness/working out with misery on a treadmill is why so few people workout
- Temporary_31337 4y agoit almost doesn't matter if the chicken or egg was first - if you're in the cohort that is exercising beyond cardio sports, your odds of being healthy/alive at any particular age actually go up with age.
- ding_dang 4y agoComrade, if you lift weights you must stretch. And everybody must lift weights.
- skybrian 4y agoWhy not resistance bands?
- helph67 4y ago"Tryptophan is among the nine amino acids our body can't make and we must consume in foods like turkey and soybeans so we can perform essentials like making protein. The researchers also think the fuel sends signals to cells, ones that aging stem cells apparently don't get." https://scienmag.com/major-research-initiative-explores-how-our-bones-and-muscles-age-new-ways-to-block-their-decline/ https://scienmag.com/major-research-initiative-explores-how-...
- michaelg7x 4y agoI listened to a FoundMyFitness [0, transcript] podcast [1, audio] on this subject and was struck by the simple anecdote of how when ageing we will eventually need to hurry out of the way of some approaching car — and struggle to do so, and thereafter perhaps stop going out, reinforcing our decline. Interesting episode. [0] https://www.foundmyfitness.com/episodes/stuart-phillips https://www.foundmyfitness.com/episodes/stuart-phillips [1] https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9wb2RjYXN0LmZvdW5kbXlmaXRuZXNzLmNvbS9yc3MueG1s/episode/ZTBmNjViM2YtODVmZC00ZThkLWI5ODMtNzEwMjZlZmFlYTBm?ep=14 https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9wb2RjYXN0LmZvdW5...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]