6 ms·
> [...] comment captured a common sentiment: “I’m not interested in my paid subscription subsidizing AI. I signed up to pay humans their worth for doing real wo
by echelon 4y ago
> [...] comment captured a common sentiment: “I’m not interested in my paid subscription subsidizing AI. I signed up to pay humans their worth for doing real work. I don’t want to give AI the eyeball hours or oxygen on a subscription platform.”
We let robots do so much already. The level of Luddite resurgence is through the roof.
I'd absolutely use AI to enhance my work. That doesn't make it any less meaningful.
- another_story 4y ago> I'd absolutely use AI to enhance my work. That doesn't make it any less meaningful. I would disagree with this when it comes to many creative works. Things like gallery showings are there as much to sell art as they are to sell the connection with the artist. There's a lot more that goes into the experience of a creative product than just the product itself.
- harvey9 4y agoPainters and sculptors have had assistants working with them long before AI came along, but you don't usually meet them at gallery showings either.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI remember an old segment of a news show (It may have been 60 Minutes, I used to watch that, a lot), in the 1980s, that featured a New York "artist." He was a fairly "cliché"-looking chap (Two-tone punk hairdo, whacky sunglasses, obnoxious dress, etc.), and he was quite smug that he didn't paint any of the work attributed to him. He hired minimum-wage people to do the work, and he spent all his time, schmoozing and going to parties, where he would evangelize it. Apparently, he did quite well. As an artist, myself[0], that had struggled to sell anything, I found it rather offensive. [0] https://littlegreenviper.com/art/Cavalier.png https://littlegreenviper.com/art/Cavalier.png
- ClikeX 4y agoPlenty of musicians have created music using randomised generators since forever. Using AI doesn't have to make the art less meaningful, it depends on what you do with said output. Plenty of "low effort" art gets valued at arguably ridiculous prices, purely due to the name of the artist. Is suspending buckets of paint on a pendulum to let physics do the work worth more than providing an AI with a prompt? In the end, the value of a piece of work is in the eye of the beholder.
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoAnd none of that music has been good
- ImPleadThe5th 4y agoRandomized generators are not the same as AI models built on the back of other artists who will never be paid for their contribution to the model.
- echelon 4y agoYou never paid the inventor of the English language you're using. Or the ideas in your head that are really just part of a prediction model that is a function of the inputs you surround yourself with. Every art student copies. Voraciously. Every engineer. Every musician. Babies and toddlers are learning machines. They soak in the world around them. For free.
- ImPleadThe5th 4y agoYes, but the English Language isn't sold back to me at a premium. Also, it wasn't developed by a private company, its evolved over time through the effort of many generations of people. Human learning is not the same thing as building a for-profit computer model. And making this comparison is part of my problem with the industry.
- epistemer 4y agoIt is the same stupid arguments from 50 years ago that the electric guitar is just noise. These people that are so offended by AI art and music I suspect are the type of people who would NEVER go to an art gallery anyway. They don't even know what you are referring to with buckets of paint. AI Art is just a topic to be pissed off about and generate sentences about online to them.
- gitfan86 4y agoIt is an emotional reaction. Logically these people know that Photoshop is very powerful without AI and they know that plenty of Artists need Photoshop to do their work, but they are not calling for a ban of Photoshop created art. They are calling for banning AI art because they are afraid
- lm28469 4y agoAh yes of course, we're scared, there are absolutely no moral or ethical questions to ask, no consequences on societies, employment, &c. to plan for We're just scared so we should shut up and accept whatever is coming as God's truth... the invisible hand and the magic of the market will make everything fall in perfect working order, as it always do, without any external interventions
- krageon 4y agoWith any new technology there is a lot of hand-wringing. Nobody says new tech cannot be criticised, but claiming it is by definition evil because it is new (which is essentially what is happening) is not useful. It's tedious to read and only has a positive impact on people that already agree with you. As such, it is not just tedious - it is also useless.
- gitfan86 4y agoHonestly, I was very scared too, when I saw it coming over a year ago. I see where it goes next, and there are enormous consequence for society and humanity in general, far beyond art generation being much easier than with photoshop. My advice is to try and live in the present and accept that the future is unknown, and accept that that was always the case, you could get hit by a bus any day regardless of what happens with the pending singularity.
- lancesells 4y ago> They are calling for banning AI art because they are afraid I'm not afraid for myself but I am for the future and the willingness to hand it off creation to these tools. Personally, this is another example of a few deep pockets monetizing and selling back another piece of humanity. All without asking or caring. Facebook monetized your family and relationships. Google monetized the knowledge of humankind. Right now people using a tool like Photoshop are varying degrees of craftsmen. You could take it away and give them a different tool and they'll be able to achieve something similar. You can take away a laptop from a writer and they'll still be able to write. Someone who illustrate in Procreate could lose their iPad and still achieve something with a pencil. Now a couple generations down the line the skills will start to be gone and the only creation will be made at $99.99 a month for your OpenAI suite. We've been on the road to idiocracy for awhile and it's just been sped up. I don't think it's a doomsday scenario but I do think it's a potentially uglier future.
- ergonaught 4y ago> We let robots do so much already. The level of Luddite resurgence is through the roof. The "This is just Luddites 2.0" sentiments are amusing in a sad way, because they seem to be expressed primarily by people who appear to be positioned well enough to readily understand why this is going to go horribly wrong.
- zmgsabst 4y agoThe Luddites were right: > Luddites objected primarily to the rising popularity of automated textile equipment, threatening the jobs and livelihoods of skilled workers as this technology allowed them to be replaced by cheaper and less skilled workers. The industrial revolution made life worse for generations in the early 1800s. We’re already seeing similar regressions — eg, app-driven-jobs and decreased customer service. And you should look up how the automation of labor turned out for horses.
- lm28469 4y agoYeah I just don't get how people miss this elephant in the room. Automation as it was sold to us since the 60s is a complete failure on the social aspect. Wages stagnate, we work as much if not more than 40 years ago, retirement age is going up, job security is dead, inequalities are growing, poverty is rising, virtually everywhere in the west. It's cool to automate factory jobs but if it's to push factory workers into amazon warehouses, uber, e-scooter juicers or food delivery jobs I don't see it as a net positive, capital owners sure generate more capital but that's the last thing I'd like to see increasing.
- soco 4y agoThe real issue is in your last phrase. It's not the automation itself which didn't deliver, but the fact that the general folk doesn't see much of the benefits. Yeah okay we got automated and have to retrain towards other jobs, but those new jobs look just as shitty as the previous ones.
- nprateem 4y agoExcept a more diverse range of products and services that are cheaper and higher quality.
- thedorkknight 4y agoNot food and housing. Getting a brand new AAA video game mostly generated by AI dirt cheap is awesome, but that's not going to matter much when you can barely afford rent and groceries