9 ms·
The Galaga no-fire-cheat mystery (2012)
- cvccvroomvroom 4y agoGrowing up, neighbors were an arcade dealer. Played quite a bit of the original Space Invaders, Donkey Kong, and Asteroids at their house.
- deeg 4y agoIt seems crazy that no one knows if it was on purpose and who did it. Everything nowadays is logged in minute detail in git that it would take little time to figure it out. I'm also surprised that the code hasn't been saved somewhere.
- IncRnd 4y agoA log doesn't clarify whether a bug is intentional or unintentional. See the Apple goto fail security bug. [1] It's not known whether that bug was intentional or a bad programming mistake. [1] https://blog.codecentric.de/curly-braces https://blog.codecentric.de/curly-braces
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- csa 4y agoI loved that cheat! Easy way to get the high score when visiting an arcade. It was also fairly to see if the locals knew the cheat — the high scores would be unusually high. Then the challenge was just to get on the board, especially if one player had all of the high score slots.
- nmg 4y agoThis game was so perfect. One thing I miss about this era was the cacophony of various games as you walked into the arcade. All those machines blaring their sinusoidal siren songs at once. The audio design of Galaga was extraordinary and a huge part of its charm in my opinion, but to truly experience it, you really need to be standing at the machine, fully bathed in it, with a backing chorus of all the other machines chirping and crooning their tunes.
- beebeepka 4y agoI also miss having a crowd looking at what you do. Some would cheer, others would try and get you killed. Practically grew up at the arcades.
- zxcvbn4038 4y agoIf your in the US there are a surprising number of arcades around that are loaded with the classic games. Just Google and you’ll find them. If you are willing to travel then probably the best two are https://www.gallopingghostarcade.com/ https://www.gallopingghostarcade.com/ (Illinois), https://www.classicarcademuseum.org/ https://www.classicarcademuseum.org/ (New Hampshire). There is very little parking at Galloping Ghost, suggest you take Lyft to get there. Plan to spend the day for either. If your into pinball then https://roanokepinball.org/ https://roanokepinball.org/ (Virginia) Limited paid parking, take Lyft to get there. You can play everything in 4-6 hours. All three are free-play, pay per head for admission, ok to leave and come back same day.
- johnnymorgan 4y agoYeah but do they have the sketchy banger guy in acid wash jeans selling hash?? Like I want the fully experience :) Loved arcades back in the day
- ourmandave 4y agoMy arcade back in the '80s was in the mall (which has long since died) and only a few stores down from the Marines recruiter, so they were always popping in.
- anotheruser13 4y agoThere's also the National Videogame Museum in Frisco, TX.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoThere are at least 3 of these in my city and unfortunately all of them kinda suck for one reason or another. Two of them are basically just noisy f'ing bars with a lot of arcade machines you have to pay for and the third, which operates as per your description, has a lot of slightly-broken cabs and uses emulation for several of them. But what's worse is that when you don't have to pay for it, it turns out most arcade games really suck.
- FatActor 4y agoI don't see how that could have been accidentally discovered. It is so esoteric and time consuming, that even if someone owned an arcade and could set the machine to free play, what kind of thought process from historical hacks prior to 1982 would have inspired that kind of a search space? Much like easter eggs in early Microsoft Office products from ca. 1990, I can't imagine. Like maybe trying to run down a shot counter might have been on the agenda, but those two specific aliens just cinch it for me. Now, as to whether it is a bug or not. Looking at the forensics of the original ROM at the provided URL[0], the fix is nontrivial. It looks like a bug, IMHO. But if it is a bug, who stumbled upon it? I would think that if the author put that in there to get the high score all the time, it certainly is obfuscated enough, but he would run the risk of being discovered. Perhaps the cheat is obfuscated in order to sneak it through code review and not be fired by Namco? What really supports the bug theory is that the flight pattern of the far left bees has to be altered to account for their location on the screen. This REALLY feels like a bug, because when I'm trying to alter a corner case in code, I can rarely see the second-order consequences without code coverage/fuzzing. This is a total code smell IMHO. But again, how would someone even exploit this flaw without the ROM. Which leads me back to the intentional cheat by the programmer. I'm legit ambivalent about this. But if I was pushed, I'd have to say it was an intentional cheat slipped into the code, because programmers were just too good back then. TEAM CHEAT FTW. [0] https://www.computerarcheology.com/Arcade/Galaga/ https://www.computerarcheology.com/Arcade/Galaga/
- hgsgm 4y agoI would be quite surprised to learn that arcade games written in assembler had "code review".
- CoastalCoder 4y agoOr Jira tickets. Sigh...
- saberdancer 4y agoIt's quite different incentive when you play for free - why waste your time dodging shots when you can fight but if you were playing in an arcade, some players might try and prolong the experience and enjoy the challenge of evading shots.
- ipsin 4y agoDoes anyone know more about the Galaga programmer, Tetsu Ogawa? I haven't seen any interviews, or even an idea about whether he might be alive or dead.
- hgsgm 4y agoAfter Galaga, he got a job at Toyota in 1984 and worked his way up to CEO.
- atdrummond 4y agoIf one searches for “Toyota CEO Galaga” on Google, this reply is now the top result. I wonder what fake information will be birthed out of this high pagerank.
- lupire 4y agoNow atdrummond's reply is. It will fade as recency effect wears off.
- unwind 4y agoHere [1] is an article about the 30th anniversary of the game (from two years ago), very detailed and interesting but unfortunately it doesn't say anything about his later career. :( [1]: https://shmuplations.com/galaga https://shmuplations.com/galaga
- moring 4y ago> Considering that this cheat is very obscure, it is unlikely something that was discovered by chance. > However, if the cheat was widely known shortly after the game’s release, then it is very very likely that it was a planned cheat by someone at Namco The article even mentions that a developer might have seen the bug through code analysis, but then reverts to "random chance or intention". Neither is completely impossible, but intentionally planting a backdoor by building what is close to a buffer overflow, without causing the game to crash? That's highly unlikely, IMHO. I'm not even yet convinced of the "highscore theory". My best guess: The developer spotted the bug while proofreading the code, found it to be non-fatal but a bug nonetheless, and then a decision was made (by devs or management) to leave it in there because it's hard to trigger and non-fatal and the deadline was close. The highscore thing may have come as an afterthought, assuming it is even true.
- croes 4y agoThe high score theory is quite unlikely, considering that arcade games are quite public. So anyone watching the player would wonder why he doesn't shoot the last two enemies but just dodges them for 10 minutes.
- pigsty 4y agoBut an adult wouldn’t stand and watch his screen for 10 minutes either and put the pieces together. A kid might. They might also think he’s dumb and just goofing off. Kids also might find it themselves because they’ll do weird stuff in games, imagining situations in the game world, like sparing a character and giving them a chance at redemption or something. A lot of speedrunning tricks are found by kids with a lot of time to just goof off and do seemingly pointless stuff in games.
- croes 4y agoI think it was a design flaw that a programmer used as cheat but it wasn't put there as a cheat in the first place.
- ajsnigrutin 4y ago
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- pronoiac 4y agoHere's the Joystik issue (and page) on the Internet Archive: https://archive.org/details/joystik_magazine-1983-10/page/n40/mode/1up https://archive.org/details/joystik_magazine-1983-10/page/n4...
- phkahler 4y agoWhat if someone sucked at the game, got down to 2 bees, and just avoided getting shot? Then on a pass when they didn't shoot, they got them! I heard it as something like: don't kill them until they run out of shots, and then nothing will shoot at you. BTW: Space Invaders => Galaxian => Galaga always seemed like a natural evolution to me.
- wiz21c 4y agoTrivia: Galaga appears in the arcade scene at the beginning of the Wargames movie :-)
- jonathanzufi 4y agoJoystik Magazine was an epic publication. I remember visiting the local newsagent (Australia) every week to see if a copy had arrived and the feeling of glee seeing a new cover. The screenshots, layouts, fonts - all so unique at the time. Pretty sure I still have them lying around in storage somewhere and they’re probably also available on eBay - somehow a PDF just doesn’t do it justice.
- a13o 4y agoAs a former gamedev, I think the author lacks imagination for the monotony, depravity, and sheer volume of player effort. The most likely discoverer is some kids, more interested with wasting time than getting high scores, seeing who can survive the longest on a single quarter. Or maybe they wanted to troll others and hog a machine as long as possible. I suppose it could be a bug found during development/QA, deemed not worth fixing, and then leaked by those with knowledge showing off, followed by viral spread. But just typing this out it sounds more complicated than kids being kids. I would bet money that it is not a clever developer sneaking a cheat or Easter egg into the game.
- mftb 4y agoThis. I was 12 when this game came out and bottom-line any time you could stretch out your game on a coin-op, there was incentive to do so. Really the only competing incentive was to get a free man, so you could also increase your score, but if you were down to your last couple of quarters then this or something like the pattern where you leave the last little rocks in Asteroids while fighting ships, was something to do.
- djaychela 4y agoThe only flaw I can find in this is that I would have expected the person finding this out to have left just one enemy on screen, not two. They're much not dangerous in pairs, in my experience on Galaga...
- jghn 4y agoThis reminds me that one of the tricks I used to use to identify which difficulty jumper the game was set to was to leave exactly 1 mothership on the first board. If it would try to capture your fighter after a few sweeps through, you knew it was on the easy jumper setting.
- jasoneckert 4y agoI love when my old blog posts show up on HN :-) I've gotten hundreds of emails since that post in 2012 with people who knew about the cheat in 1982, citing specific events that could not have been misconstrued. Of course, I haven't revised the blog post to add all of them, but the one that I probably should have added was one person who noted that their mall got their first arcade the month before Christmas in 1982 and he visited it several times a week. Just after Christmas, they imported a Galaga game - and the same day they got it, the owner of the arcade told the patrons about the cheat as a sales feature (even made up a hand drawn sign of how it worked). Perhaps it was clever marketing on the part of Midway and Namco.
- lupire 4y agoThe fad must have passed quickly and the trick been lost in the pre-Internet era. By 1990-2000, I don't think players knew about it anymore, and Galaga was far less popular.
- bigbacaloa 4y agoIn 1990 I had a classmate who would bore the hell out of us by demo strating his ability to get ridiculously high scores in galaga. He surely was using the cheat. He was the sort who wouldn't say that he was cheating.
- canucker2016 4y agoI think I learned of the trick from the magazine blurb mentioned in TFA. If you didn't happen to read that specific page in that specific magazine in the few days it was on the newsstand, you would've had to find out via word of mouth/watching someone do the trick in person. Most arcades didn't have the space to keep games around forever. Games that didn't bring in the quarters got replaced by newer, shinier, flashier games. By the mid-80s, you'd be lucky to find one Galaga machine in most arcades. So if an older friend mentioned the trick or you happened to read that specific issue of Joystik magazine in the library, you'd have a hard time even finding a Galaga machine to try the trick. By the late 80s, ever more expensive arcade games lost their novelty and home entertainment (game consoles/rentable VHS movies) got good enough so overcoming the inertia of staying in the comfort of your home/sofa was too great. The convenience stores/random stores got rid of their one or two standup arcade machines, then the smaller arcades closed down.
- easton 4y agoAnother Galaga mystery, what’s the origin of the “midway fast shoot hack” version, where the fire speed is twice as fast? My Dad loves Galaga, but grew up with that version and gets annoyed with the normal, slower version (mostly because after you’re used to the fast one it feels like the button is just dropping half your inputs on the slow one). As far as I know, the game is otherwise unchanged apart from the fire speed.
- brutuscat 4y agoAnd this is the magazine the article mentions at the bottom update part: https://archive.org/details/joystik_magazine-1983-10/page/n39/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/joystik_magazine-1983-10/page/n3... > UPDATE: Jon (I won’t give you his last name) sent me an email after visiting my post. In it he sent me a link to an October 1983 special edition issue of Joystik Magazine that covers winning strategies for common arcade games of the time. In the TRICKS OF THE TRADE section near the end of the magazine, they cover the Galaga No Fire Cheat beautifully! Page 61, Disarm The Bugs.
- PaulHoule 4y agoYou'd think with modern code analysis a good look at the binary would give some insight into what is going on.
- corysama 4y agoOof! That's a blast from the past. I learned about this 40 years ago from my favorite book as a kid "How to Win at Video Games - from the editors of Consumer Guide(R)" https://archive.org/details/book_how_to_win_at_video_games_complete_strategies/page/n61/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/book_how_to_win_at_video_games_c...
- terran57 4y agoThis brings back a lot of memories. My part time job in high school during the early 80s had me working as video arcade attendant on evenings and weekends. Unfortunately, for the arcae manager, he had not properly done the research into traffic flows and how to actually make an arcade fun to visit - So, much to his chagrin, the patronage to this arcade was pretty low. However, this was great for me, as I had the keys to the games and could load up free credits on them to my heart's content before or after hours. We had Defender, Pac-man, Centipede, Galaga, and 8-10 others which, because traffic was so low, the manager encouraged that I play so people might be enticed to come in. Eventually, I noticed that one of the few regulars, a kid around 12 years old, had the ability to play of Galaga just to the point he would roll the high-score counter on a single quarter. Then he'd move over to Pac-Man and do the same. Curious, I asked him to show me how he did it in exchange for free credits on the other machines. He demonstrated that there was a pattern on Galaga that, if you followed precisely, would allow you to cruise through each level. The first key step, of course, would be get your ship captured so that you could free it and double your firepower. He also demonstrated that there was also a pattern on PacMan, and again, if you followed the pattern precisely, it would also allow you to cruise through each level, while maximizing points. Over the course of a few days, I committed the patterns to memory. Then, with this new-found skill, I was able to go to other arcades around town and obtain the high score. (At that point in my life it was the absolute best feeling to see every line High Scores Screen filled with my initials). Shortly afterwards, the arcade where I worked closed (I can tell you it was a sad day for me when the truck came to pick up all the games as I was hoping to buy one on the cheap). I then found a new job, which involved a lot of physical activity, which caused me to lose a bunch of weight, which suddenly made girls show an interest in me, which then made video games much less attractive to me... and so, I forgot the pattern. (geez, I sound like an old man - I guess soon I'll be yelling at kids to get off my lawn ...)
- Forgeties79 4y agoI remember discovering that if you let the demo screen progress to where your ship is captured, you can then control the new ship! You basically got 20-30s of free Galaga haha. The catch was the demo still tried to run, so it would yank you around some while you tried to play.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoThat one was fun but sometimes would crash the machine and it'd have to be power cycled to go back into service. The bug is still in the Galaga/Ms. Pac Man combo cabinet but it actually does reboot on its own instead of locking up the machine. Think that's also true for the 20-in-1 cabinet one of my friends owns.
- Forgeties79 4y agoTIL!
- ohyoutravel 4y agoNostalgia! Others have covered it, but I really miss how various cheats or special items seemed to be word of mouth rather than a YouTube video with 5 million views. Usually the word of mouth was pretty vague too, which created more mystery. “There’s a way to do X I’ve seen it” with few further details. I remember this floating around about Mike Tyson’s Punch Out ways to beat specific fighters easily, and another for Final Fantasy 2 (US) about a special rare drop item on the moon.
- jtode 4y agoBoy do I wish someone had told me at the time...