8 ms·
France's largest semiconductor company got nationalized in plain sight (2022)
- sofixa 4y agoSlightly aside from the main topic, but I thought ST Micro was France's biggest semiconductor company but they're apparently technically considered Dutch now (same as Stellantis, the ownership structure of Fiat, Peugeot, Citroën, Chrysler, Opel; Airbus and plenty of others). As for the effective nationalisation, yeah, France has a protectionist mindset when it comes to critical industries (e.g. energy generation, shipbuilding, semiconductors) as pretty much any non- ideologically blindly governed by free trade/capitalist absolutism country. Even the US which is as close to that as i can think of does blatant protectionism.
- csdvrx 4y ago> France has a protectionist mindset when it comes to critical industries (e.g. energy generation, shipbuilding, semiconductors) Between the power cuts due to the planned lack of maintenance of their nuclear reactions, and the loss of various contracts and shipyards, I'd have though they'd have learned the lesson. But now, it now time for the ritual sacrifice of this last critical industry > blatant protectionism. Which should be illegal.
- bobkazamakis 4y agoLmao? If Putin offered every man woman and child 1 million for their gun, you'd still be calling it a free market.
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoI genuinely can’t make sense of this comment or how it connects to GP’s, whether you agree or disagree with GP’s statement or not.
- elcomet 4y agoThere have been no power cuts in France
- Georgelemental 4y agoPretty much every advanced economy has used protectionist policies to develop at some point in their history. And all of them have also used free trade policies. There is no sacred dogma here, every trade arrangement has tradeoffs and every situation is unique.
- olalonde 4y agoSounds like the "argument from middle ground" fallacy. Another perspective is that advanced economies have advanced in spite of the occasional misguided protectionist policy. Economics is not a hard science but the empirical evidence in favor of protectionism is very lacking.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- marmetio 4y agoAnti-protectionism doesn't really apply when an adversarial country with no interest in a free market tries to seize a critical industry.
- Georgelemental 4y agoA hypothetical example: you are the Supreme Leader of Slevobistan, and you want to make your domestic widget industry as strong as possible. Your rival nation Flerovia has a well-developed industry making low cost, high quality widgets with economies of scale. Case A: Slevobistan is starting from scratch, has no domestic widget production whatsoever. In this case, if you fully open your market up to Flerovia, you will never get any on-shore widget industry! Startup domestic producers will be out-competed by the experienced Flerovian widget empires. Protectionist policies will make it harder for you to get cheap high-quality widgets in the short term, but they are necessary to build up your widget industry in the long term. Case B: Slevobistan already has an advanced widget industry, and you want to preserve it. In this case, protectionist policies, by insulating your industry from competition, could allow it to fall behind and decline. Free trade will ensure continued competition, pushing your widget industry to innovate and improve. As for empirical evidence, the historical record shows many examples of countries using protectionism to get ahead. For example USA (Civil War was in part over protectionism vs free trade, protectionist Northern industry won), Asian tigers, China…
- ur-whale 4y ago> Which should be illegal. It's a sovereign nation (still, in spite of the EU's efforts to the contrary). Therefore legal / illegal is whatever the f*k they decide.
- xwolfi 4y agoIm a French citizen and I'm inclined to agree we shouldn't be too protectionist, at all level of society: we should not protect jobs when a company is failing, we should not protect companies when a foreign one is gaining market shares, we should not nationalize something the Chinese are ready to subsidize. We are not going to be treated in any special way by the adversaries of China, and there are ways for us to benefit from a more relaxed relationship with them, at the detriment of the US: it makes the US care more about us, it makes China think less about screwing us, it makes us infiltrate both deeper. I think, as a small country, our best bet is to look entirely harmless while selling to every sides. End of the day nobody really wants to take us over because we're impossible to govern for a profit, so even if we fuck it up and China gains control of something we would have wanted for ourselves, we can just take it back after the fact and ask "so what, you want to invade us to deal with the people we cant even manage ourselves?". Honestly the best strategy for Taiwan too: be as insufferable and costly as possible so that even a successful take over just dump cost on the taker to convince them instead to keep a status quo where they just speak loudly waving their arms in patriotic excitement.
- ajsnigrutin 4y ago> at the detriment of the US Somehow people around here in the balkans have been getting the feeling that pretty much every thing every EU country did in the last year, has been favorable to US and detrimental to european citizens... Be it Scholz, Macron, ursula, etc. Whatever move they do, people of europe lose, and US gains something.
- Baeocystin 4y agoWhy? Can you give examples? Honest question, not arguing. I live in California, and don't have much contact with the zeitgeist of the Balkans/Europe in general.
- it_citizen 4y agoThis is a very strange take. 1) There was no power cut back in France 2) It is largely admitted that the power sector in France was way better off before Europe got involved and forced to privatized some activities. Some go even further: Henri Proglio (former CEO of EDF) recently said during a senate commission that Germans were really hell bent on crippling EDF, and succeeded.
- Georgelemental 4y agoFrance was getting along just fine with publicly-owned EDF, but then the EU came along and decided we needed to privatize. Except that we can't actually expose consumers to volatile market prices, so the result is a Frankenstein abomination that gets all the downsides of the private sector with none of the upsides. Kind of like US healthcare
- nhchris 4y ago> but then the EU came along and decided we needed to privatize There'd be a lot less anti-EU sentiment if there was a bright line against meddling with what should be internal affairs of sovereign states, instead of growing like a cancer until everything is under its purview, and national governments are just for show.
- sofixa 4y ago> There'd be a lot less anti-EU sentiment if there was a bright line against meddling with what should be internal affairs of sovereign states GDPR, DMA and DSA, the Covid recovery funds, Schengen, Erasmsus. Just those massive things off the top of my head compensate the EU's normalisation across Europe in certain markets, which has had it's successes (in the making) like separating rail operations from infrastructure thus allowing competition, and non successes like the common European energy market which has plenty of good ideas on paper, but when faced with a massive energy crisis due to extreme external factors is terrible.
- actionfromafar 4y ago
- Kuinox 4y ago> Between the power cuts due to the planned lack of maintenance of their nuclear reactions, and the loss of various contracts and shipyards, I'd have though they'd have learned the lesson I suggest you to read more diverse news sources.
- frozencell 4y ago> France has a protectionist mindset Why did they sell Alstom then?
- ohgodplsno 4y agoMacron was the prime factor in that sale, and who it ended up benefiting remains to be seen. There is an open inquiry for corruption, embezzlement of public money and concealment. Protectionism is a foreign word to this man. Also, GE bought a whole company for insane amounts of money, much more than it was worth, and EDF re-bought GE Steam Power later for basically nothing, and that was really all that mattered for nuclear reactors.
- orwin 4y agoReally interesting. Just a point : being nationalized by Cuba or the USSR in 2022 probably have better outcomes than being under the cusp of any Atos VP. The company will survive by bloodsucking on French and European contracts they do not deserve (but they will manage to respond to the exact hidden specs), then will sell the contract to crosoft or any of their daddies for play money. Sorry for the serious people working there. I might be wrong, but I've worked with Atos for 5 years, they are the worst. But their VP have friends in high places.
- frozencell 4y agoDo you have some arguments along with your testimony?
- orwin 4y agoWe had to buy a Bull (https://atos.net/fr/solutions/data-analytics-business-computing/x86-bullion-serveurs https://atos.net/fr/solutions/data-analytics-business-comput...) and participate in their "Bullion Partner" program to get the right to be involved in h2020 projects. Our company CEO was very clear that this was just a cash grab from them, asked by France "ministère du numérique" (also, we ended up managing the Bullion software ourselves because their engineers couldn't follow RedHat documentation for more than 10 minutes, while still having to pay the support contract).
- tianlong 4y agoInteresting! I thought that was the modus operandi of every consulting company (respond to the exact hidden specs from insiders).
- olivierduval 4y agoThe move is not unusuable, considering that China is more and more an aggressive competitor to Europe (and France) and has different values than Europe. Doesn't it make sense to lower the risk for all your strategic industries to depend on external and not dependable actors ? What is really fascinating is HOW the move was done: it was not nationalized in the common sense (the state buying all the shares, using some "strategic actor" argument to force the nationalization) but France took operational control and locked the company. Quite a smart move actually...
- walterbell 4y ago> France took operational control and locked the company Imagine applying this level of analysis to other companies, states and nonstate actors..
- daevout 4y agoIndeed if we did apply that level of analysis to other companies, we might not have emded up depending on a one man dictatoship flush with concentration camps, ongoing genocide and war preparations for essentials like PPE and antibiotics.. imagine that.
- walterbell 4y ago2011, https://www.cfr.org/blog/henry-kissingers-china https://www.cfr.org/blog/henry-kissingers-china > Mr. Kissinger should have mentioned that he left statesmanship with China for business with China. Nowhere does he discuss Kissinger Associates, the highly successful consulting firm he founded almost three decades ago, which does a thriving business providing entrée to Chinese officials and business leaders for foreign companies. Indeed, Mr. Kissinger has spent more time negotiating business than negotiating policy.
- rnk 4y agoChina has done a good job of hiring us leaders when they "retire to become rich consultants". You see the same thing in Germany of course with their old pm and Russia. This is how the despots curry favor and get the elites to go against what's good for the country. I don't know about recent Kissinger impacts, but you see it in germany getting too dependent on russian gas.
- pr337h4m 4y agoThere's no real evidence of the French state nationalizing Soitec. >Last is Team France. With the exception of Francoise Chombar, they are all French Nationals. I put Francoise Chombar on Team France because she shares a board with Eric Meurice at Umicore, so I assume she’s on his team. How exactly are these directors "Team France?" There's no reason to believe that they are agents of the French government just because they're French nationals. >All of the board actions in conjunction means that this was likely premeditated by the controlling shareholders - the state of France - to further control Soitec. Bpifrance and CEA are state-owned, but the free float is 61%, not to mention BlackRock's 8% stake. There doesn't seem to be anything stopping the shareholders who make up the free float from voting out the board or accepting a tender offer.
- CyanBird 4y agoThis piece is a puff piece written from the Anglosphere to drive panic and ensure that their broad narratives like the general anti-china narrative succeed in driving wedges on broad issues relating to French and paneuropean national security
- walterbell 4y agoIs this a typical board action? The board granted itself extensive power through a list of resolutions added to the typical bylaws of the company at the so-called “extraordinary shareholders general meeting”. It’s rare to see an extraordinary resolution, so it’s outright mind-boggling to see 35 resolutions. This is one of the broadest power grabs I’ve ever seen. Is this a common restriction on shareholders? When NSIG (National Silicon Industry Group aka China) bought the 14.5% stake in Soitec, they agreed to a standstill agreement on the shares ... Should NSIG Sunrise S.à.r.l acquire shares in the Company before the expiration of the Shareholders’ Agreement at the close of the Shareholders’ General Meeting called to approve the financial statements for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2021, it would lose its rights relating to the Company’s governance > There doesn't seem to be anything stopping the shareholders who make up the free float from voting out the board or accepting a tender offer. What are some good examples of uncoordinated free-float shareholders influencing corporate governance? HN ranking history of this thread: https://hnrankings.info/34539669/ https://hnrankings.info/34539669/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Lazare 4y agoOn the one hand, what's being alleged doesn't actually sound...particularly bad? I don't see any obvious ethical concerns, and if it's against French law then that should be litigated in court, not on a blog post. But on the other hand, the evidence presented to support these allegations seems awfully weak. For example, to make the claims work the author flags a list of people as being on "Team France" merely because they are French nationals, or in one case, merely because they happen to be on another board with someone who is a French national? Weird, messy fights for control of public companies happens all the time; this doesn't even sound particularly interesting, even if the wildest claims being made are true. Not sure if the author is just extremely naive, know there's nothing going on here but is trying to manufacture a controvery, or is just bad at writing and left out some key information. Whatever the case, I'm just left confused why I'm meant to care. (Also, I'm more familiar with US finance. Maybe this really is unusual in France? Because poison pill provisions and standstill agreements and such are routine in the US. As are boards with power over things like, eg, issuing more shares.)
- walterbell 4y ago> I'm just left confused why I'm meant to care. Semiconductor supply chains have been of recent interest due to unpredictable supply shortages, sanctions, export controls, diversification of electronics manufacturing from China to SE Asia, and billions of national investment in duplication of Asian fabs on US, EU and Japanese soil. Those who care about semiconductor supply chains include those whose businesses depend on availability and integrity of computers, automobiles, aircraft, cellular networks, mobile phones, satellites and other communication systems.
- DrBazza 4y agoSemiconductor companies are of national strategic interest. Some countries have been slower than others to realise this. Politics moves at a glacial speed when it comes to technology.
- roenxi 4y agoThis is political mechanics, it is interesting for the same reason kernel-code deep dives are interesting. Europe has consistently failed to get a toehold in the high tech industry, which is quite stupefying considering the technical and social advantages of the Europeans. There are questions to ask - eg, we know what happens to the Elon Musk equivalent in China (Jack Ma, disappeared for a bit and moves to Japan for the healthy fresh air). What would happen to him in Europe? This article is a glimpse of why all the serious tech players end up being Asian and American. PS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gong_Shou_Dao https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gong_Shou_Dao - I can see the spirit of Elon in this article, truly I can.
- fnordian_slip 4y ago>I put Francoise Chombar on Team France because she shares a board with Eric Meurice at Umicore, so I assume she’s on his team. Sorry if I fail to see the bigger picture here, but I do not find that kind of guilt by association particularly compelling. Some of the other evidence seemed a bit shaky, too, but this does somewhat discredit the author in my eyes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- unity1001 4y ago"Nationalized in plain sight" -> Wow that's so horrible!! How can they nationalize a company, and even do it in 'plain sight'!!! ... If you are an American, that is... Because in the rest of the world, neither publicly owned companies nor nationalization is a 'bad thing'...
- comte7092 4y agoSo let me get this straight, the largest shareholder made a bunch of board moves in order to advance its own interests? Why is this being written about like it’s a scandal? If this were some Wall Street hedge fund this would be treated like some bold power move.