5 ms·
There are some people that are so divergent from understanding and being able to perform or at least emulate normal social behaviour that they become harmful an
by Waterluvian 4y ago
There are some people that are so divergent from understanding and being able to perform or at least emulate normal social behaviour that they become harmful and problematic. I watched one, quite closely, develop through high school. I can still hear his smug “nah” any time you said something he didn’t agree with. Well, not “agree with” but “that he knew to be universally correct.”
Ultimately he ended up unemployable and bitter while his family tripled down on him being the victim because of an Asperger’s diagnosis. Moved to central Canada last time I heard.
I think what I learned from the experience is at some point you’ve got to compartmentalize harmful people from your groups and inevitably a growing number of segments of society, even if that feels wrong in some way. It’s more wrong to let them perpetually abuse people.
Edit: I’m not going to litigate this. If you don’t trust me or don’t want to accept that this person was truly abusive and harmful, or if you believe that victims should be made to tolerate abuse, I can’t help you.
- TheAceOfHearts 4y ago[flagged]
- Waterluvian 4y agoI don’t tolerate abusive people.
- throwaway2214 4y agoYou probably are considered abusive to someone, you might not even know it.
- Waterluvian 4y agoI have absolutely been abusive at times growing up and probably in my professional life. I’ve been put in my place many times. And I learn and grow from that. I was not a perfect teenager and I’m definitely not a perfect adult. I hope people wouldn’t tolerate it if I did it to them.
- serf 4y agobut I hope you understand that if no one did tolerate the abusive then our psych wards and hospitals would be about half as full, right? That isn't to say that half didn't need help -- it's that humans who need help can be abusive. So.. what do we do with them? Ignoring these people is about the same fate as 'compartmentalizing' them into a wood-chipper -- doomed.
- menzoic 4y agoThat doesn't mean you need to suffer. Reality is harsh. Cutting out toxicity is required.
- rahoulb 4y agoAgreed. My friend was stabbed by a schizophrenic who lived in the flat opposite and believed that my friend was stalking him. Ten years later and my friend still has virtually no feeling in his hand as the nerves did not grow back correctly and he had to give up being a professional musician. I know the guy didn't choose to be the way he was and I'm sure what was going through his mind was hell. But that doesn't mean that the rest of us should just live with the consequences of harmful actions.
- serf 4y ago>I know the guy didn't choose to be the way he was and I'm sure what was going through his mind was hell. But that doesn't mean that the rest of us should just live with the consequences of harmful actions. ok, but aside from a time-machine and time-cops, what do we do? We 'compartmentalize' the ill out of our lives -- they don't just disappear, they roam the streets and poorly interact with societies .. -OR- certain professionals sacrifice aspects of their lives in order to facilitate treatment and professional isolation for such individuals in an effort to keep them off the street and out of interactions with regular society. which one results in less violent crimes towards regular citizens? It should be obvious to anyone with their eyes open that someone has to interact with these people to provide rehabilitation and growing potential for people in need.
- rahoulb 4y ago> certain professionals sacrifice aspects of their lives in order to facilitate treatment and professional isolation for such individuals in an effort to keep them off the street and out of interactions with regular society. That was literally my dad’s job. In the UK in the 80s they implemented a policy called “care in the community” which was about ensuring that people with serious mental health issues were not institutionalised. For the most part this was a good thing but my dad actually made the decisions over the care and freedom they would receive. Eventually he quit because he felt too many dangerous people were being released - and in the end worked at Rampton, which is a prison hospital, looking after serial killers.
- _zzaw 4y agoSpeaking as someone who was stalked by a former acquaintance with mental illness: yeah, I realized the person didn't choose this, and I didn't judge them or wish harm on them. But they were also harassing friends and family members, and it got to the point where I had to send this person's photo/name/phone number to a number of people I cared about, and warn them to avoid any contact. I don't wish any harm on Bryan, but it sounds like the guy is a textbook stalker—unstable, obsessive, and potentially dangerous—so I absolutely understand why things have reached the point where others need to be warned about him.
- ezekiel68 4y ago> People often don't chose to be as they are. That's true but what does it have to do with the price of tea in China? The commenter raised a valid point that we may need to decide to compartmentalize for the sake of our own well being. This does not necessarily imply any measure of judgement against the other person.
- pwdisswordfish9 4y agoWhy are you blathering about tea?
- krastanov 4y agoIt is an idiom https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/the+price+of+tea+in+China https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/the+price+of+tea+in+Chi...
- henvic 4y agowow! The trolling escalated quickly! Are you trying to demonstrate his point?
- serf 4y agowhich point? the point that OP made that the negative should be cut from your life, or the greater point that if the entire world cuts the negative from their life then those people -- 'the negative' -- are doomed to roam the world and be negative towards the rest of the world ad nauseum?
- seanmcdirmid 4y ago> Asperger’s diagnosis This a real thing, mild forms are socially inhibiting, extreme forms can mean social skills are completely crippled. I feel sorry for these people (although I’m probably in the mild category), but I’m not sure what we could do to help without getting hurt ourselves? I just hope my kid is normal socially with a good sense of empathy.
- Waterluvian 4y agoIt’s truly heartbreaking. The guy was one of my closest friends because we had a ton of hobbies in common. I loved when he would target fixate on some problem and his basement would turn into a mad scientist workshop. I remember him as “the person who would see through a ridiculous idea.” But the abusive parts got worse and worse and became intolerable. I’m not sure what could have been done differently. Though as a teenager that was probably not my role to play.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoIt wouldn’t be reasonable for a teenager or even an adult to martyr themselves over that. I wouldn’t blame anyone really, though I guess we all have to overcome the cards we are dealt somehow?
- WhiteBlueSkies 4y ago[flagged]
- dang 4y agoHey please don't cross into personal attack in HN comments, even if another comment is wrong or you feel it is. I appreciate that you're fundamentally making a plea for empathy, but putdowns/attacks are definitely not the right tool for the job, and are against the site guidelines in any case: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Edit: looking through your comments, you've been breaking the site guidelines so badly that I've banned your account. Please don't create accounts to do that with. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.
- serf 4y ago>I think what I learned from the experience is at some point you’ve got to compartmentalize harmful people from your groups and inevitably a growing number of segments of society, even if that feels wrong in some way. It’s more wrong to let them perpetually abuse people. this strikes me as similar to the concept of being for life imprisonment over the spending of resources towards rehabilitation. To throw people to the wayside because YOU have determined them to be 'UN-fixable' IS wrong. It's useful for YOU to compartmentalize them out of your life because they represent a personal burden -- but this doesn't help them improve themselves or their conditions; it may not be your responsibility to help them improve -- but many of these people are hopeless without outsider intervention, they need help, not partitioning. If you can't help them then the next best thing is to make an effort to find them help, not to shut the door in their face. >It’s more wrong to let them perpetually abuse people what do you think happens when you make yourself lost contact with these people? Well, having been 'compartmentalized' earlier in life and never receiving any help or social training, they continue to perpetually abuse other people. Ironically the strategy of isolating them from oneself likely increases or prolongs their time 'out of step' with society -- all it does is protects YOU from the damage the person might do. All I can say is that i'm glad the entire world doesn't take your advice of 'compartmentalizing harmful people', otherwise this place would be a pretty brutal world to live in.
- Blackthorn 4y ago> what do you think happens when you make yourself lost contact with these people? Well, having been 'compartmentalized' earlier in life and never receiving any help or social training, they continue to perpetually abuse other people. It's really not his or her job to fix abusers.
- serf 4y ago>It's really not his or her job to fix abusers. most societies believe that each individual must contribute to some degree. It's being lost, but for most societies historically the mentally ill were the burden of the immediate family. Now we see the effects of the mental illness affecting society-at-large, it stands to reason that the entirety of the affected population is now somewhat responsible for making their own lives better by trying to assess and remediate the problems within their society. If I walked past litter on the ground in my home-town, I wouldn't say "Hey, not my job." and walk past it, I would pick it up for the betterment of my town. This isn't a foreign concept for most people.
- beaker52 4y agoFor some people, emulating “normal” social behaviour can be taxing on many levels and perhaps “normal” seems extremely odd to them. I’d sleep on the idea of ostracising people with social issues because it can hasten a downward spiral. In a lot of cases, people who don’t fit in are looking for love they don’t receive. Speaking from experience, if you can offer them that love in spite of challenging behaviour, you could be the key to them developing positive relationships that serve as models of how they can effectively fit in. If you can muster the energy, instead of pushing these people away, as hard as it may seem, try drawing them closer - it’s not an exaggeration to say that you might be saving someone’s life.
- tomjen3 4y ago>I think what I learned from the experience is at some point you’ve got to compartmentalize harmful people from your groups and inevitably a growing number of segments of society, even if that feels wrong in some way. It’s more wrong to let them perpetually abuse people. You need to ban abusive people at the first possible time (after you have established that they are abusive and not, e.g just ESL who learned from an old TV show/book). The more moderation a community has, the better the community will be. If somebody has Asbergers and can't adjust, ban them too. The why doesn't matter (unless it is easily correctable), the how does.
- aidenn0 4y agoWe had something like that go down between two of our children; we had to tell the one who got the worst of it "if the only way to feel safe is to never be in the same room as them again, that's okay" Forgiveness is one thing, but deliberately putting yourself in position to be victimized again is another.