5 ms·
What China - a superpower with a very confrontational and combative attitude - can get away with in its own back yard might be quite different from what modest
by bell-cot 4y ago
What China - a superpower with a very confrontational and combative attitude - can get away with in its own back yard might be quite different from what modest little Norway can or would try to do in the Greenland Sea.
Also, talk to a few volcanologists and marine engineers about trying to build airfields on the tops of barely-above water active volcanoes. (Vs. China is building on shallow, solid, inactive atolls.)
- klyrs 4y ago> Also, talk to a few volcanologists and marine engineers about trying to build airfields on the tops of barely-above water active volcanoes. Discount plane parking/moorage/incineration?
- toast0 4y agoMoorage with built-in incineration solves the problem of what to do with the boats when the owners disappear.
- zardo 4y agoAnd Norway has plenty of EEZ, China is short on it.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoI think we need to understand that China is not "confrontational and combative" in a negative way. Think of it more like the kid who's been bullied for years and years and when puberty hits is finally able to stand his ground. That's China, and they're not the only ones who have been bullied over the last centuries and who may be able to stand their ground soon.
- karatinversion 4y agoDisagree. The Spratly island shenanigans, in particular, are squarely aimed at Malaysia, Taiwan, the Philippines and Vietnam, which in your analogy are the smaller, younger victims of the bullies.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoChina has been claiming the South China Sea since before the PRC, hence why the claims by the ROC/Taiwan are same: the PRC took over the ROC's claims. Of course this is not the 'correct' narrative to say that... Every country has been acting the same. Look at what the US control and ask why that is. The difference is that China has been on the receiving end of the stick over the last centuries while the US (for instance) has been on the giving end. There is no right and wrong, just being weak or being strong.
- rnk 4y agoTrying to excuse your bullying behavior by pointing at someone else's behavior isn't actually justifying your own.
- sklargh 4y ago"Since you know as well as we do the right, as the world goes, is only in question between equal power, while the strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must" https://www.nku.edu/~weirk/ir/melian.html https://www.nku.edu/~weirk/ir/melian.html
- mytailorisrich 4y agoWell, exactly. Some of the replies I get are childish and ridiculous. The US control land almost up to the Chinese coast bit China is the bully for finally being able to assert a few claims in the South China Sea... how far can hypocrisy go As for the neighbours' input, we'll ask Mexico, Cuba, and South America...
- remarkEon 4y ago> The US control land almost up to the Chinese coast Curious, what land is this?
- nonethewiser 4y ago
- BurningFrog 4y agoThose kids often are the worst bullies!
- drblastoff 4y agoYou’re conveniently ignoring a couple thousand years where China bullied its neighbors relentlessly.
- nonethewiser 4y agoAnd, you know, the present. Should I really care more about China being bullied 70 years ago than China bullying right now?
- Dylan16807 4y agoThe nine dash line is not at all standing their ground.
- mlindner 4y agoChina has not been "bullied for years". They have a imagined chip on their shoulders and a persecution complex. It reminds me a lot of how Russia describes it's invasion of Ukraine. The messaging to the public is in terms of "Russia has always been attacked" and how "the invasion is actually defensive in nature because NATO has always been planning on attacking Russia" (note: NATO is a defensive alliance and never even had plans for invading Russia). What you're hearing is not truth, but is instead the internal propaganda that is used to defend against criticism of the national government by creating an external opponent for the populace to focus on. It's a time honored tradition of dictatorships the world over.
- bloppe 4y agoOpium wars, Japanese occupation, US Chinese exclusion act, etc. China was bullied. The extant generation of Chinese has not directly experienced most of it, but it's not just a chip on the shoulder. I think claiming the whole south china sea is ridiculous because there's no principle behind it. A coastal EEZ is a principle, but if China can claim the south china sea why can't Vietnam? I also struggle to formulate a strong argument against claiming and developing an uninhabited reef. China is by no means the only country participating in the spratly islands land grab, and to my knowledge no country has ever shied away from claiming uninhabited land. International Maritime law was not formulated to deal with this situation. I think China's neighbors will more likely than not be able to maintain their reasonable Maritime rights. If not, I think China will find wanton domination to be more trouble than it's worth.
- mlindner 4y agoJapan occupied many countries during WW2, it's only the CCP that still cares to the extent that they do about it. In fact in many of the countries that Japan occupied there is now strong pro-Japan sentiment, but not China. The US Chinese exclusion act can not be termed "bullying of China" as it was explicitly about internal US politics rather than international politics. If that is termed bullying of a country then any anti-immigration law throughout history would be bullying of some country or another.
- 4y ago