8 ms·
I've heard arguments in the past of paying "acceptable" US wages to people in other countries would destabilize the other country more than it would help. I'm n
by dylan604 4y ago
I've heard arguments in the past of paying "acceptable" US wages to people in other countries would destabilize the other country more than it would help. I'm not an economist, so I don't know how valid those arguments are. I have always thought they were more scare tactics used in favor of being able to pay those low wages for as long as they could get away with it. I could see though how paying a small-ish number of people wages that dwarfs the larger number of people could cause a bit of turmoil.
to me, it goes back to the argument about remote workers should be paid less than the in office worker. or workers living in cheaper areas should be paid less than those living in expensive areas. to me, the salary should be paying for the work being done and that's it. if the same level of work is being done by both employees, it shouldn't matter if one is in Kenya and the other is in the US. the value of the work is what should be getting compensated. again though, i'm no economist.
- ogeiczvm 4y agoPhil Knight mentioned this in Shoe Dog. I don't remember the details but he was paid a visit by some officials and they told him he cannot pay factory workers more than they can pay their doctors.
- wkat4242 4y ago> I could see though how paying a small-ish number of people wages that dwarfs the larger number of people could cause a bit of turmoil. The same way that a CEO in our world is getting paid 100 times as much as a janitor?
- zenith14 4y agoI don't know about "destabilizing" per se, but whenever people try to set prices significantly above or below market, there tend to be consequences. If OpenAI paid $5/hr when people are more than willing to accept $1.5/hr, demand for those jobs would far outstrip supply, leading to intense competition for those positions. Situations like this often lead to corrupt practices where the bureaucrats/middlemen who find themselves in a position to determine who get these jobs end up capturing a significant portion of the profits, either directly or indirectly.
- practice9 4y ago> the salary should be paying for the work being done and that's it. I agree with you. The issue is quantifying the essential cost of work. As companies sometimes have no idea how & where they lose or earn money, they tend to rely on external factors to select a "justified" level of wages: average industry wages, location, local laws, whether you need to commute etc.
- NickC25 4y ago>I've heard arguments in the past of paying "acceptable" US wages to people in other countries would destabilize the other country more than it would help. Which honestly is a bullshit argument. The only destabilizing thing here is it would make the person in the higher-paying profession more valuable to society and more able to make economic impact where it might not normally. In this case, a rising tide does lift all boats...because you're giving more economic purchasing power to more people. Will this kill some businesses or disrupt the status quo? Yeah. Will it help more people than it hurts? Maybe, probably, who knows? But I personally see no problem with paying people relative to their output, no matter where in the world they are. Having been to Kenya myself and worked with Kenyan developers for several years, most of whom were quite talented, I see absolutely no problem with paying them their value relative to the work being done. I have no problem with high skilled Kenyans making much more than the local average because they have a skill that is in demand all around the world. >the salary should be paying for the work being done and that's it 100% agree. If a business derives $X profit from a laborer and agrees to pay a given % of $X to the laborer as compensation, it should not matter if the laborer is in a high cost or low cost of living area - the business still makes the same amount in profit, and shouldn't get to say "hey yeah we made $10mm off your application, but we're going to only pay you 5% of our profits as compensation because you live in Bangladesh and the cost of living is lower, so be happy with what we're giving you" when if you did the exact same labor and lived in, say, LA or NYC, they'd give you 10%. Just bullshit IMO.
- autodev1 4y agoBS? Based on what experience of yours? I spoke with a US Civil Engineer who worked in Honduras in the 1980's, clearing paths in forests for electrical transmission lines. He initially paid workers significantly higher than local wages-- US-level wages. The result: --> He was threatened with harm by bosses of local companies. Why? He took all their workers. The local companies couldn't compete-- they lost all their labor to his company which paid relatively (relative to Honduras) exorbitant wages. His US company literally destabilized the local labor economy. So, I wouldn't be so quick to jump to "that is BS", as in my opinion it exemplifies naivete & ignorance.
- 4y ago
- blagie 4y agoThe basic argument is a little bit different. There is a huge population in Kenya living, or in some places, failing to live for under $2/day. Most of these people are independent -- for example, street-side sellers in an urban slum, or living in a village far from Nairobi. The key question is how we improve lives of these people. It is difficult for me to overstate the impact a 5-fold improvement in income has on people's lives. I've seen initiatives which train people to do tasks like basic data entry, bricklaying, or otherwise, taking $2/day workers to be $10/day workers. Programs like these are typically a few months long. They don't train people to have the equivalent of even a middle school diploma, and they won't be competitive with even the least educated Western workers. Still, breaking generational poverty is a long process, and that basic increased stability is a first step. If we shut off employment paths following those programs by giving bad PR to anyone who employs people for $2/hour, we've doomed a key pathway for hundreds of millions of people to escape abject poverty. Gapminder shows four income levels: https://www.gapminder.org/fw/income-levels/ https://www.gapminder.org/fw/income-levels/ Westerners tend to group levels 1-3 together. However, the gap in quality-of-life from level 1 to level 2 is much greater than the rest of the stack. Level 1, life basically sucks. Hunger, lack of basic life-saving medicine, and early death. Levels 2-4, I've lived at (for at least a few months), and it's okay once you get used to it. It takes surprisingly little to bring people from 1 to 2, and these sorts of jobs are one way to do that. As a footnote: People often confuse financial stress with simply being poor, since in the US, those correlate almost completely. Financial stress sucks. Most people worldwide living at levels 2-3 don't have high levels of financial stress. A much more typical situation is a village, where no one has a lot of stuff, but people own the land and their homes. Financial stress sucks. I'd rather own a home at Level 3, with savings, a stable family, income, etc. than live paycheck-to-paycheck at Level 4.
- nerdathlete 4y agoThanks for sharing, the Gapminder level stratification (and Dollar Street photos) was very eye-opening and a humbling reminder of how privileged I am as a software engineer.
- blagie 4y ago
- fragmede 4y agoOpenAI is operating rationally as a corporation, and choosing labor, legally, in a cheaper country - if they were to pay US wages, why not hire American workers? The entire point is because it's cheaper. There's a different world where OpenAI chose to hire Americans for this job, but it's simply cheaper for them not to. The loss of American jobs is a whole other discussion, but it's the very economics of the situation that drove them to do that in the first place.
- bmitc 4y agoThat’s a very narrow minded view of economics though. Minimizing costs and wages is not the only optimization that matters.
- mensetmanusman 4y agotrue, But it generally has helped raise billions out of poverty.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ninjagoo 4y agothat were first thrust into poverty to start with by a different system of exploitation. I have to admire the beauty of this argument as it has occurred over time - let's exploit them using force and make them poor (enriching ourselves), then use the poverty to justify paying them less (enriching ourselves), using the argument that we are slowly lifting these billions out of poverty (enriching our souls).
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThat initial system of exploitation is what the US fought against in a revolution. Everyone was exploited at some time in history.
- spamizbad 4y ago> I've heard arguments in the past of paying "acceptable" US wages to people in other countries would destabilize the other country more than it would help. Interesting. If true, that sounds like a good argument for capping salaries. Would the US be a little less chaotic if we set a maximum wage?
- dylan604 4y agoBoy, that's a brave thing to suggest on a forum of people with aspirations of getting cushy jobs at FAANGs to get those uncapped wages. It appears it's going over as well as a lead balloon too.
- 6510 4y agocap income at say 300 m annually then gradually lower it. Get all those mentally ill people out of decision making. Make exceptions for truly mad skills. Around 50 m have some construction where further work is paid with a salary for life or until the company goes bankrupt.
- ninjagoo 4y agoAn astute observation. I had a good chuckle. Thank you!
- astrange 4y agoThat's why income taxes are progressive.
- ninjagoo 4y agoLovely! Have an upvote, such as it is!! It is rare to see such a complete demolition of an argument or the real-time validation of that demolition through the rules-for-thee-but-not-for-me reaction to it!!!
- pas 4y agocentral banks' main task is to keep economies from im- or exploding. if there's suddenly a big influx of money they have to raise interest rates to balance that out. development economics is not about the wages, it's more about market access. the problem is that many developed economies (looking at you USA) have protectionist tariffs which make it hard for developing ones to gain market share.
- ambicapter 4y agoWould you have a problem if a bunch of billionaires moved into your neighborhood? What do you think would happen to the prices around you? Why do you think people in, say, Lisbon, are so dismayed at the amount of "digital nomads" moving into their cities at the same time as their housing prices rise wayyy above their average wage? > to me, it goes back to the argument about remote workers should be paid less than the in office worker. Can you make a stronger link here? Because I'm not seeing the connection other than wages are involved.