3 ms·
Calling the situation a collapse is a bit alarmist. However, the cold realities of demographics make continued service level declines inevitable. Demand is acce
by nradov 4y ago
Calling the situation a collapse is a bit alarmist. However, the cold realities of demographics make continued service level declines inevitable. Demand is accelerating because populations are sicker on average, due to both aging and chronic diseases caused by overeating and sedentary lifestyles. We can't really afford to spend higher percentages of GDP on healthcare and there don't appear to be any revolutionary productivity improvements on the horizon, so unfortunately those who lack the means to pay out of pocket for high-quality care can expect to wait in longer queues.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bryanlarsen 4y agoAs Keynes said, "Anything we can do, we can afford". We can afford to spend more on health care, we just choose not to because we'd rather spend on something else.
- rossdavidh 4y agoIn the U.S., at least, our spending as a % of GDP is at an all-time high.
- nradov 4y agoWhile technically correct, that saying is meaningless in the real world. Healthcare spending increases are only affordable as long as the rest of the economy is growing. At some level, healthcare spending would act as a drag on the rest of the economy. But even within theoretical affordability limits there are tighter limits imposed by political reality. Voters are already strapped by inflation in the cost of daily living. They're going to balk at paying more in taxes or insurance premiums just to maintain healthcare service levels. We might be able to reach a political consensus for a moderate tax increase on high-income people but that would only delay the worst effects by a few years and won't resolve the root problem. In the meantime there are marginal gains to be made in software to improve productivity. That won't solve the problem either, but it will slow down the decline so that's what I'll continue working on.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoI don't know, old people are the most reliable voters and medicare is a pretty sacred cow. It's very tough to pass a tax increase in the US, but if anything can do it, saving Medicare might be it. Also, it'll be a lot easier politically to let the Trump tax cuts expire than to explicitly raise taxes even though both are basically the same thing.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThe point of Keynes' saying is that capacity is what matters. If you have enough beds, nurses and doctors you can find a way to pay for it. If you don't have enough beds, nurses and doctors you are screwed and throwing more money at the problem can have more impact on the price you pay than the capacity you are able to buy.
- joe_the_user 4y agoThings vary by country. Here in the US, health care spending (measure $ per GDP) has been nearly twice the level of many other advanced nations while health care been subpar and continues to decline compared to other nations. The reasons the US spends much and does so badly for its citizens are very complex in overall but one simplification that I think makes the inefficiency obvious is this; we have a full state sponsored system - medicare and etc as well as a full private health care system and they each cost money.
- defrost 4y agoI lived and worked in a number of countries, I'm Australian by birth and retirement. I once read a detailed an convincing argument that the US system had too many layers between sources of health care money (taxes + payments in private insurance) and end point (delivery of health care) with no incentive or structures to keep the middle ground lean and mean. ie. Way too many people and groups prifiting richly from the pipeline flow of healthcare money with too many lobbyists motivated to keep that status quo. It's not that the US has dual systems, more that they don't compete on outcomes but that the private system is motivated to increase profit and hamstring the public system.
- maxerickson 4y agoThere's not really a public system (outside the military and IHS). The government acts as a payor into the private system (in many cases, driving a hard bargain where you want any of their money you have to take their prices for everything).
- refurb 4y agoEvery time this comes up I share a link to the McKinsey study from 10 years ago. You can google it. It’s worth a read, it’s an insightful analysis. They basically adjust spending by GDP, then compare the US to other OCED nations, then split spending across a dozen categories of healthcare spending. The biggest cost driver? Out-patient procedures. It’s not just that it costs more (it does), but volume is way higher than other countries and one of the biggest drivers of the higher spending seen in the US. For in-hospital care, the US is marginally higher. Drug spending is higher, but it’s 50% more for 10% of spending, so marginal. It’s lower in durable equipment spend. And much higher in R&D spend, though the impact isn’t huge. Americans get a lot more out-patient procedures than other countries. That’s the biggest cost driver of US healthcare. Is it cost effective? Not sure that’s been answered yet.