14 ms·
Long Covid: major findings, mechanisms and recommendations
- crims0n 4y agoInteresting that they classify loss of smell as a neurological symptom. I had Covid last January and my sense of smell has never been the same. I used to be able to walk into a room, flair my nostrils, and pick up everything from the couch, carpet, and curtains… to the subtle cool drafts from the windows and fireplace. Now everything has completely dulled out, and I only occasionally pick up those old scents in passing - functioning as a cruel reminder of what I lost.
- jklm 4y agoThat's fascinating - even as a kid my sense of smell has been near-nonexistent. Whenever I've read descriptions of powerful smells in books, I've always written them off as overly flowery language. Reminds me a little generally of how some have an inner voice when they read and others don't.
- jotato 4y agoHow is your taste? I lost it completely (not just a little or muted, but 100% gone) for about 5 weeks. It started to come back, but 18 months later things still don't taste right. Nothing is flavorful or stands out as delicious.
- crims0n 4y agoSorry to hear that… I hope it continues to recover for you. Mine is okay for the most part I think, I have never had a complex palate though so the taste of food is something I haven’t historically valued outside of “this is edible, and this isn’t”.
- Daub 4y agoEntirely anecdotal, but I had a freind who had been a smoker for fifty years. On giving up he was delighted to smell tomatoes for the first time since his boyhood. Before that point, I had never before considered tomatoes as even having a smell.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoThere are certain things I have no problem smelling and tasting. And other things I just can't smell or taste. The result is that I have a whole entirely new set of sensitivities that I didn't have before. I cannot stand the fragrances in detergents and air fresheners. I used to keep the Fresh Linen scent Febreze fresheners around the house. It doesn't smell like Fresh Linen anymore... it just smells sickeningly sweet like dunking your head into a container of liquid detergent. I can't eat oranges anymore and have basically retired from giving recommendations on cigars because I'm just... broken... in that respect anymore.
- raybb 4y agoHave you looked into smell training? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smell_training https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smell_training
- squidsoup 4y agoSmell training, using an assortment of strong smelling essential oils, appeared to help me recover my sense of smell after my first covid infection.
- jasonhansel 4y agoI was confused by this, but I think they mean "neurological" as in "relating to the nervous system," specifically to the olfactory sensory neurons that detect smells.
- anon84873628 4y agoAt first you were probably thinking of the meaning of "psychological". Part of the confusion probably comes from words like "neurosis" or "neurotic" which in fact fall under the discipline of psychiatry.
- ergonaught 4y agoThis has basically nailed the stuff my wife developed “out of nowhere” toward the end of 2021. Wow. I wonder how one convinces doctors to take that seriously? It’s been a real nightmare.
- soderfoo 4y agoA coworker mentioned her partner was struggling with long covid. The wait time for a long covid specialist was long, and the eventual appointment yielded little. Seeking a referral for the specific underlying symptom and abstaining from mentioning long covid finally resulted in better care it seems.
- mistrial9 4y agoin the USA if you are near a research hospital or can get to one.. a person signing up for a support group might find themselves heading to eligibility for participating in a formal medical study.
- cfeduke 4y agoMy wife started to have many of the symptoms of long COVID starting around September of this year. No official diagnosis from her many doctors and specialists, just a constant barrage of co-pays and test after test after test. Some of her doctors say for certain it is not long COVID but they also say they do not know what it is... so... uh huh. Just have to keep on testing, and do the same test multiple times.
- hilbertseries 4y agoThere isn’t really a diagnostic test for long covid. There’s been some interesting research and anecdotes around microclots and oxygen flow. https://xdrx.substack.com/p/how-i-recovered-from-long-covid-using https://xdrx.substack.com/p/how-i-recovered-from-long-covid-...
- soderfoo 4y agoUnease and woe are the two feelings I'm left with after my quick layman reading of the article. Think I am most concerned with the reproductive implications, which seem under researched. Coupled with the unrelated decline in sperm count the past decade... I'm hoping my ruminations are just me catastrophizing. Can anyone more medically and scientifically literate provide some context to temper my doom and gloom?
- Alex3917 4y ago> Can anyone more medically and scientifically literate provide some context to temper my doom and gloom? Most of these issues stem back to endothelium damage. And the good news is that, in addition to taking all the vaccines you're eligible to get, there are a bunch of other things you can do to strengthen and protect your endothelium, e.g. doing HIIT and taking ACE inhibitors. The one risk we (afaik) don't really know how to mitigate is the risk of developing an autoimmune disorder, but this can happen after any viral illness and isn't necessarily a COVID-specific risk. And in terms of reducing the risk of neurological issues, Palmitoylethanolamide seems to a least be much safer than NSAIDs, albeit expensive and still somewhat experimental.
- alchemist1e9 4y agoExcept for me and many others long covid symptoms got worse after vaccination. Additionally new research is uncovering serious and significant risks for the vaccine with fairly marginal protection benefits.
- dontknowwhyihn 4y ago[flagged]
- toofy 4y ago> but you’re still not allowed to say that. you literally just said it.
- roenxi 4y agoAs always, it is difficult to assess this sort of thing without a reference to the flu. As far as I can tell, in daily life we are continuously encountering people with various chronic problems and systemically under-calling the impact of them. It is a total coincidence if a body is functioning at full capacity. If COVID increases the hazard ratios there isn't much I can do. As far as I can tell, everyone is going to get COVID. There is no avoiding that. It would be interesting to know how much worse it is than a typical flu though, just for academic interest.
- squidsoup 4y agoSignificantly worse than the flu - multi systemic organ damage. The narrative that covid is like the flu, is both wildly inaccurate as this paper explains, and also dangerous, leading to a more cavalier attitude towards covid prevention.
- godelski 4y agoMaybe I'm being generous to the parent, but I also would like a comparison to the flu. Not because I don't believe covid is significantly worse (when I got it, it was way worse than the flu), but because I don't have a medical background and it is difficult to contextualize the actual risks here without some baseline where I have a decent intuition already built around. But where I disagree with the parent is the need for this paper to specify those distinctions as I'm not the target audience. I can read data and understand it, but any good data scientist knows that you need real expertise in a domain to contextualize that data. It would be naive to think that my understanding of data directly translates to a strong understanding of this work. I'm not the domain expert.
- moistly 4y agoBut have you actually had the flu? I ask, because most people say “oh, I had the flu” when in actuality they just had a common cold. The flu, the real flu, knocks you on the ass so hard that you actively start considering that death is a possibility and that heading over to the hospital would be a good idea. I’ve had the flu perhaps twice. Once as a child, once in my early 50s. The latter completely recalibrated my understanding of illness.
- d_sem 4y agoFascinating read. I'm glad to see these findings get serious attention by researchers. It was really frustrating getting dismissed by my local physician when sharing symptoms like sugar sensitivity, fatigue, and focus issues. It was like being perpetually tipsy for months. It was a big shock as a knowledge worker to have to relearn how focus. I hope they further study vaccines as well. In my anecdotal case my long covid symptoms resumed, along with additional symptoms like body bruising / bone pain for several weeks. There may be classes of healthy adults that react differently than expected and we can learn how to improve from the evidence.
- cf141q5325 4y ago>In my anecdotal case my long covid symptoms resumed, along with additional symptoms like body bruising / bone pain for several weeks. The term used in Germany for "long-covid like symptoms after vaccination" is "post-vac syndrome". Having seen something similar in English yet.
- nerdponx 4y agoMeanwhile long Covid sounds more or less like the chronic health problems I've had since ~2014 (which nearly ruined my life). In my case it seems to be autoimmune, so maybe that's part of what's happening with long Covid as well. There are various protocols (mostly dietary) that attempt to help, under names like "Autoimmune Paleo". It all seems under-studied. Maybe now that millions of people are having the same symptoms, there might be some movement on it. That or GSK will come up with a drug that doesn't really help and has a lot of side effects but the medical community will declare the problem solved and move on.
- thewizardofaus 4y agoCovid fatigue is no joke. As an Elite Athlete I'm training 20-30 hours a week. I got covid last year (triple vaxed) and it wiped me out for a good 6 months. It took me 3 weeks to be able to walk longer than a minute without needing to lay down for the rest of the day and sleep. I have dealt with fatigue problems for 6 months and only just now, do I feel like I'm getting "back to normal". The most frustrating thing is alot of people are dismissive of the symptoms and generally say, "Oh yeah, I get tired too" but fail to understand the severity of it as they haven't experienced it. I have a fairly good understanding of my body and the associated symptoms of overtraining/fatigue in a heavy training cycle but covid fatigue was soemthing completely different.
- ribs 4y agoFrom my experience, this stuff isn’t limited to COVID-19, and I don’t mean that to minimize your experience with it. I just want to note that I had the flu in 2013; my temperature got up to 104F, and I was sub-par for about that same amount of time; it was about 6 months before I felt back to 100%.
- journey_16162 4y agoAre you back to training? Or do you still need to be careful? Could you share some tips about pacing / not triggerring PEMs?
- djtango 4y agoOuch that's a really serious and painful setback to your training! Sorry to hear about your struggles. Are you back to normal now? Any lingering issues eg cardio/breathing
- _kulang 4y agoSimilar experience — and interestingly it can be seen in my resting heart rate over time and VO2 inference on my watch. The acute fatigue was quite bad (and is what people seem to talk about) but the milder lingering fatigue reduced my running and lifting performance across the board and left me tired in the late afternoon rather than the evening. It’s not life altering per se, but it impacted my routines and productivity noticeably. Thankfully after 5 months I seem to have kicked it fully, and am ripe for another infection. Needless to say I got the bivalent booster before the holidays
- EMM_386 4y agoI was diangosed with syncope on standing shortly after getting Covid (the first time). I'd never experienced anything like this before in my life, but suddenly the world would fade to black if I stood up too soon from a reclined position. I also experienced intense brain fog. I actually scheduled a doctors appointment specifically for "brain fog" at the time and they were confused as to what I was explaining. All I could say is that it felt like I was thinking through "mud" and lost my ability to focus. I wasn't even thinking of Covid when I booked that appointment, but looking back it makes sense. This has gotten better with time, but I have no doubt that Covid had something to do with this. The timing was just far too coincidental. The fact that it has strong binding affinity to ACE-2, which can cause cardiovascular issues, only lends credence to this theory.
- DoreenMichele 4y ago[flagged]
- nerdponx 4y agoIt would be nice if the medical profession actually had some kind of handle on brain fog. It can be debilitating.
- seydor 4y agoMaybe you just lost weight during covid?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- javierluraschi 4y agoI was an early adopter of long COVID before it could be properly diagnosed, if I could ask for something, it would be to spread awareness for those who are still suffering. The hardest part was, by far, feeling like I was making it all up, I felt a tremendous relief when I got diagnosed. For me, it lasted almost a year, but I can say that I was lucky to fully recover. There is a bit more info from my personal experience in this post: https://www.geekwire.com/2021/veteran-software-engineer-launches-ai-startup-hal9-battling-long-covid-pandemic-concerns/ https://www.geekwire.com/2021/veteran-software-engineer-laun...
- Animats 4y agoThis is really bad. Important points: * About 10% of people getting COVID get some form of long COVID. * There's long term damage. At least years. Maybe permanent in some cases. * You can get COVID more than once.[1] Somewhere above 6-10% of infections are re-infections, and that number increases over time. Immunity seems to last 3-18 months. What is this going to look like in 5 years? 30% - 40% of the population disabled? [1] https://www.everydayhealth.com/coronavirus/what-if-you-get-covid-19-more-than-once/ https://www.everydayhealth.com/coronavirus/what-if-you-get-c...
- throw_nbvc1234 4y agoYou're missing the variable of how severe the long covid symptoms are. If it's 10% long covid and 10% of those are serious it's only 1% of total covid cases. Unless you're using a loose definition of "disabled".
- l3uwin 4y agoThat's still millions of people
- PaulKeeble 4y agoAccording to the ONS data 75% are impacted on day to day basis by their Long Covid and 25% are severely impacted. This likely maps to Mild, Moderate and Severe from ME/CFS definitions roughly. Its a lot of people disabled and an awful lot very severely disabled.
- dehrmann 4y ago> 30% - 40% of the population disabled? That assumes likelihood of getting long covid doesn't drop after successive infections.
- ggm 4y agoThe nature paper says for a cohort, it may rise. And, it seems like related CF viruses (Epstein-barr) may reactivate. Having a lot of covid spike protein in your body is not good for you.
- ck2 4y agoEric Topol (one of the authors) is another "must read" like Derek Lowe https://erictopol.substack.com/archive https://erictopol.substack.com/archive
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- Erik816 4y agoLong Covid is extremely similar to ME/CFS, but affecting far more people. On the plus side for those of us living with ME/CFS, we can now explain to people "it's basically Long Covid." On the downside, this can be an extremely debilitating illness that lasts indefinitely. I am on year 14 and while I have seen improvement, I am still partially disabled. My condolences to everyone dealing with Long Covid, which includes both the actual disease and the social consequences. It is already exhausting, but even more so when you need to convince people it's real, struggle to deal with skeptical or poorly informed doctors, and politely deal with the continuous unprompted medical advice from well-meaning friends, family, and internet strangers.
- jordansmithnz 4y agoI’ve been dealing with long COVID since March last year. There’s some interesting learnings I’ve had along the way: - I was almost perfectly healthy and in my early 30’s. Long COVID isn’t that rare and can happen to anyone, even with a mild case of COVID. - After first getting COVID, I didn’t rest much. There’s research showing this increases chances of getting long COVID. If you test positive… rest and fully recover. Don’t make the same mistake I did. - Quite a few people I’ve met seem to have the opinion it’s all neurological. The linked study has plenty of proof it’s not, but people seem to like putting things they don’t understand in a nice bucket. - If you’re reasonably healthy, don’t take it for granted. Health won’t always last. Thankfully, I’m doing much better the last few months. I think I’ll be 90% back to normal within a year. Not everyone is so lucky though, so it’s encouraging to see so much research being put forward.
- nnspired 4y ago[dead]
- tern 4y agoIf you have long COVID, look into https://retrainingthebrain.com/ https://retrainingthebrain.com/
- nikolay 4y agoCOVID-19 is no joke. I know people want to move on with their lives, but people should stick to N95/KN-95/KF-94/FFP2/FFP3 masks for the time being unless we want to create a massive health care crisis and ruin the global economy as the if people get reinfected every few months, this would be imminent!
- wkat4242 4y agoWhere I live people do get reinfected every few months because masks are gone, and this is not a major problem. Most of the long COVID cases stem from the first and second waves here.
- nikolay 4y agoWe are talking long-term harm - it's too early to say people are just fine.
- nradov 4y agoYou should probably hide under your bed wearing a triple mask. Just in case.
- nikolay 4y agoHe who laughs last, laughs best. Keep laughing!
- dieselgate 4y agoJust got home and on the drive saw a billboard that said “he who laughs last didn’t get the joke” Keep laughing regardless!
- nikolay 4y agoCOVID-19 is no joke.
- 4y ago
- ETH_start 4y agoThis is a very poor analysis. Its assertion that "long COVID is an often debilitating illness that occurs in at least 10% of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) infections" is based on a study that neither accounts for misattribution of symptoms to COVID, nor the psychosocial effects of a COVID infection, e.g. the anxiety related to getting COVID, the isolation required of those who contract COVID, etc. The best evidence available suggests most cases of "long COVID" are misattribution: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/2785832 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullar...
- dsjoerg 4y agoCertainly misattribution explains _some_ amount of what people think is "Long Covid". It's very hard to say how much, because "Long Covid" itself lacks a proper definition. However, that study is not the best evidence available. I agree that the original study could be improved, but the Jama Network paper doesn't account for the fact that many people test negative for Covid antibodies after a true infection (as explained in the original study). We can't start talking about the true prevalence of Long Covid until we have a sensible definition.
- wesapien 4y agoI got Covid in November and I was fully jabbed but no boost. As soon as I felt something different, I performed nasal rinsing and added Iodine to it. I did this for the first 5 days twice a day. This was the crucial thing for me. I felt fine after the 4th day but still tested positive. I tested negative on the 10th day and I ended my self quarantine. Before that, I was already taking Zinc, Vitamin D3, Vitamin C for years. I feel normal and I'm very glad that whatever I did before and during infection seemed to have help me recover fast.
- tasuki 4y agoHow do you know that what you did helped you recover fast? As a data point, I also had Covid and also recovered fast, without any of these.
- wesapien 4y agoI can't really know for sure because I've only gotten COVID once. Even with that in mind, they are low risk. It's not the first time I've tried nasal irrigation. It's given me relief every time I had performed it during the times I had a cold or even just a stuffy/runny nose. This goes way back to when I was a child. The supplements I take have a lot of data points as far as their benefits. If you Google these things individually: nasal irrigation, vitamin c/d and zinc and add filter "before:2020", you will see all the pre-COVID data points. I'm not just jumping into some fringe left COVID hipster trend.
- karim79 4y agoI tested positive in mid-February 2022. I had been double vaxxed with the second one administered on Christmas Eve of 2021. The symptoms started with swollen red feet (which I somehow dismissed) followed by really strange vivid dreams that night. The following day I woke up in the morning and was unusually tired, and so took a nap on the couch and silenced my phone for a while. I was feeling relatively normal post-nap. Later in the evening before sleep time I took my dog for a walk. It was -2C outside and the air felt warm as it hit my face, and as I was walking the stairs back up into my flat (on the third floor) my legs felt abnormally weak, and at that stage I took a test, which was a solid positive. That same night I contracted a high fever and informed all my co-workers. I don't recall having had a virus where I would literally spend minutes/hours self-negotiating to get a glass of water, or go to the toilet, and for the first four-five days I had no appetite whatsoever. I was in and out of sleep for that period and fully devoid of energy for about ten days. I tested negative on the ninth days. For the next three weeks, I had almost no energy, little ability to concentrate - overall it took about a month to get back on my feet and about two months to feel "normal" again. Overall, I think there's something to long covid, but I'm no doctor.
- yratsor 4y agoMy experience is that after two doses of Pfizer I had unexpected positive side effects, such as increased performance (e.g. I can do a lot more push-ups) and my allergy symptoms (runny nose) have significantly decreased. Do you know any research on unexpected positive side effects?
- seydor 4y agoThere are simple changes that don't affect people's lives but can promote protection to those that want to be protected. Longer winter school breaks (instead of summer) could somehow mitigate the flu/cold/covid season. Remote work helps, as does the normalization of wearing masks (and perhaps stop politicizing it)
- thenerdhead 4y agoThis is very comprehensive and highlights the major challenges with something so novel. I hope more doctors read up on these challenges. I’ve been lucky to have doctors advocate for me recently now that more research is coming out. Especially around diagnosis, markers, and treatments. Many are just self diagnosing given many cannot find any underlying cause. While I’m one of the unlucky ones who gets long Covid with each infection, many are throwing darts at what helps manage their day to day symptoms. The good news in my case is each long covid bout is shorter than the previous. Here’s my story: https://jondouglas.dev/long-covid/ https://jondouglas.dev/long-covid/
- npunt 4y agoThanks for your story Jon, found it helpful.
- thenerdhead 4y agoThanks for reading!
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoI really hope they find something for the tinnitus that is COVID related. It's insane. I'm on friggin' hearing aids for it. 34y/o, always taken good care of my ears. And then I got infected 4 months before I could get a vaccine. It's just not fair.