13 ms·
I remember everyone had written Docker off for dead when they announced their updated pricing plans, but they really made perfect sense, and I am happy to see t
by paxys 4y ago
I remember everyone had written Docker off for dead when they announced their updated pricing plans, but they really made perfect sense, and I am happy to see the company recover. A large chunk of the tech world today relies on their products, but they were making next to nothing for it. It is definitely worth it for large companies to throw a few dollars their way considering the massive amount of value they are getting out of it. Whereas my company had no use for their earlier product offerings (private Docker Hub repos, Docker Swarm) we gladly paid money for Docker Desktop without even thinking about it.
- satvikpendem 4y agoIt just goes to show how what enterprise customers value and what individual developers value are two very different things.
- brianwawok 4y agoYes very much. It's a whole new world selling enterprise vs anyone else. Small business selling is much more like selling to consumers.
- jchw 4y agoThe problem I have with Docker is very simple; to individual users, they provide a service invaluable in a similar vein, though not of similar importance necessarily, to Wikipedia or Archive.org; Docker is literally a utility, which can enable tons of different interactions. The open source community is flooded with different ways to use Docker and take advantage of OCI images and whatnot. I just recently gave distrobox a spin, for example. I use Podman as my container engine, but the theory is the same, and most of the images are on Dockerhub. The problem here is simple; it only provides this immense value if it is effectively free without discrimination. But of course, it can't really just be free, or at least Dockerhub certainly can't be. On the other hand, it also provides immense value to enterprise and even smaller customers, too, clearly. And I don't think anybody ever strongly doubted that aspect, it just was more doubted whether you could make a business out of it. But lo and behold, Dockerhub was integrated enough into the ecosystem and without an a strong enough alternative that it didn't seem to matter. I assume Docker Desktop also factors into this somehow, but I don't know. I don't use it. Even on Windows and macOS, in the event I must use them to do dev work, I just use Podman Machine. Works well enough for me, and I don't care about a desktop UI (although apparently a couple do exist.) I am glad that at the end of the day, I haven't seen any super bad fallout from this. I'm still able to use Docker images on my NAS without paying a monthly subscription. Whatever their rate limit is, I'm not hitting it. I'm sure it's a super bad pain in the ass for certain parties though. Like I bet GitHub has a deal to keep Dockerhub unlimited in it's CI, but smaller providers that do CI like srht are probably screwed. That's a shame for the entire ecosystem.
- selfmodruntime 4y agoDocker Desktop is a godsend. I live most of my developing life in my terminal, but the ability to glance into what's going on in different services along with mounts, environment variables and logging is invaluable.
- jchw 4y agoI honestly can't relate very much. I can understand how it would help to be able to see the full breadth of what information there is to go along with containers, but A. I find Docker Desktop to be kind of annoying B. I actually feel like the CLI tool is well organized enough that it is not a problem to quickly grok what information I need using easy-to-remember commands. That said, Podman Desktop[1] does most of this stuff and it's free. Maybe it isn't as polished (Docker has definitely put a lot of engineering into the filesystem stuff on macOS for example) but to me it looks similarly nice to Docker Desktop. So if you are working as an individual and don't want to deal with licensing restrictions, there is a reasonable alternative at least. [1]: https://podman-desktop.io/ https://podman-desktop.io/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ilyt 4y agoCounter-point: most of the value is "a repository of images" and that's just hard sell to pay massive extra (over just "a local VM with some code running" or some of the cloud offerings) for a essentially S3-like file storage with slightly different API and some structure. Yeah tools and common container format is why it got popular but with amount of alternatives that's not monetizable either. Docker desktop is a smart move honestly, monetize stuff around the containers (managing, making sure its secure) that generally requires a lot of knowledge without it, so the pitch is not just "make the job easier" but "maybe allow company to skip hiring person(s) dedicated to running the whole house of cards"
- justsomehnguy 4y ago> The problem here is simple; it only provides this immense value if it is effectively free without discrimination. But of course, it can't really just be free, or at least Dockerhub certainly can't be. This is a self inflicted wound. They placed themselves there but never though about the costs of running a free service with PBs of traffic. > On the other hand, it also provides immense value to enterprise and even smaller customers, too, clearly And they should had taken money from enterprise from the day 1 for Hub services. Hindsight is 20/20, of course, but then I learned about Docker "eco-system" (especially things like Watchtower) the traffic costs was one of the first things what I though about.
- samcat116 4y agoTrue. People should see how much Salesforce licenses cost.
- warinukraine 4y agoWhat's Docker Desktop exactly?
- thefounder 4y agoThe thing that I have to install on MacOS so that I can run docker. Is there any other way(i.e no gui utility) ?
- brianwawok 4y agoLinux I just install some stuff from apt, so I assume you can brew install something to run it command line (no GUI)
- ahepp 4y agoDocker uses container functionality specific to the Linux kernel. So on Linux, you can install a relatively lightweight engine. But on MacOS or Windows, you need to install the entire "Docker Desktop" app, which secretly spins up a Linux VM in the background, and presents a (pretty poor) abstraction as if this is all running on the host machine.
- uberduper 4y agodocker-machine from brew sets up the linux vm using one of a few virtualization options. iirc I always used bhyve and never had to give it a second thought.
- kaashif 4y agoOn Windows, you don't really need to use Docker Desktop, I personally find it more convenient to run just plain old Docker in WSL. It's still a Linux VM, but you get more control over it. I never understood what the point of Docker Desktop was on Windows if WSL exists.
- CoolCold 4y ago
- FlyingSnake 4y agoI'm surprised by this as well, but maybe it was the HN bias that made that impression. My company received the memo from Docker to upgrade to paid version, and I helped many to move on to Podman. However there were teams for which getting a Docker Desktop license was easier than the Podman move. I am sure there are many more companies that can easily afford the convenience of Docker Desktop for a trivial fee.
- jbverschoor 4y agoWhat I don't understand is that devs that get paid 200k+ complain about getting any software license
- alfalfasprout 4y agoBad take. It's a tool needed for the business that the business is expected to pay for. The license belongs to the company not the employee.
- ghaff 4y agoIn principle, I agree with you. In practice, if there are cheap tools (or, more likely often less cheap services) to fulfill business requirements--and make things including things like traveling more pleasant--I'll often just pay out rather than dealing with approvals and requests which are often out of policy.
- mlcrypto 4y agoAnd it's against most company policy to install unapproved software and deliver it to customers
- jbverschoor 4y agoSure, but the same can be said for clothing for a real estate agent. Or keeping your personal licenses and credentials up to date.
- wiseowise 4y ago
- fullsend 4y agoGreat move by them to introduce a license requirement for 250+ seats but not waste resources enforcing it (as far as I can tell). Those who will pay, will pay. Those who won’t, will switch tools no matter how painful. They stayed relevant by keeping all their users, even those technically breaking the license, but also collected some cash.
- isthisthingon99 4y agoI have a product that has zero reduction in functionality if your license or trial runs out, just constantly nags you when you do useful things with it. Eventually, the workers at the company insist on the company buying it. Sometimes takes 6 months hah.
- Alir3z4 4y agoWinRAR?
- icelancer 4y agoAnd mIRC.
- smcl 4y agoSublime Text too
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoFor a while, I got around the nag by just never closing mIRC. :-D After almost 20 years of using it, though, I thought "You know...this guy deserves his $20" and paid for it.
- isthisthingon99 4y agoI still don't know how that dude makes money. People use my software multiple times a day, so the nag is quite annoying. I need WinRar once in a few months, maybe.
- runlevel1 4y agoThe reasonable price helps. We could have switched back to docker-machine. We even had a PR ready to do it on our workstation setup scripts. But given what they were asking for the value given, it didn't make sense to cheap out.
- that_guy_iain 4y agoEverytime there is a price hike everyone complains that said product is dead and open source competitor will replace it. Nearly always, the people complaining aren’t thinking about starting an open source project.
- oceanplexian 4y ago> A large chunk of the tech world today relies on their products, but they were making next to nothing for it. Yes, but only because they ran a massive marketing campaign, and then achieved market penetration as a result of years of developer cargo-culting. Containers have been around years before Docker, docker added a ton of bloat and a repository. So what? None of the predecessors (Jails, OpenVZ, etc.) needed tens of millions of dollars. Docker just capitalized on something that was open source and shamelessly monetized it. Great for them but not really worthy of admiration or anything to be remotely impressed by.
- JeremyNT 4y ago> Containers have been around years before Docker, docker added a ton of bloat and a repository. So what? None of the predecessors (Jails, OpenVZ, etc.) needed tens of millions of dollars. Docker just capitalized on something that was open source and shamelessly monetized it. Great for them but not really worthy of admiration or anything to be remotely impressed by. I think it's worth noting that the only thing they make much money off of now is their desktop application. They made it possible for clueless users to "run containers" on Windows and Mac OS (nevermind it's just a Linux VM...). Technical users had long been capable of doing similar themselves with Linux or BSD or Solaris or what have you, but that's not the important piece of what Docker brought to the table. (And yes, many developers are "clueless users" when it comes to this sort of thing)
- ngc248 4y ago>>> Containers have been around years before Docker, True, but docker made it easy peasy. They came up with the packaging format and other things in a neat little package. This was what made everyone take up docker when it came out.
- CoolCold 4y ago> Containers have been around years before Docker.. (Jails, OpenVZ, etc.) that's exactly what they failed to deal with - Ops people were already fine & happy all the way with _existing_ solutions (they even know the difference between OpenVZ and Jails). Who was/is struggling is the Joe The Average Frontend developer and Project Managers hearing "sysadmins still setting up our Jails". Or take from other angle - I'm on Windows, my colleague is on Mac, our grey beard devops guy is on Linux-Arch-Btw something - and we all can use the same Dockerfile and play around without not-giving-a-shit how it works under the hood and what kind of NAT/iptables/sysadmin-mumbo-jumbo is beneath. Total win!
- _skel 4y agoI suspect the initial negative take on the license change was correct, and this is the dying gasp of the company. It's just taking longer than expected to replace Docker Desktop. But I am seeing a lot of progress on Podman and Rancher and a few others, and some of the larger tech companies are also building in-house replacements. A lot of the people who had to scramble to find a replacement are not happy about it. In a year or two I think some of the companies that paid for licenses to avoid migrating are going to rethink their license costs, because the free alternatives will be just as good as Docker Desktop. Then we will see whether this revenue increase was sustainable or simply the transient result of holding customers hostage when they had no alternatives but to pay.
- roughly 4y agoWhat gets me about this is the math doesn't make any sense. Docker charges $10/developer/month. Those developers are paid $150k+/yr, fully loaded to the company (insurance, taxes, accounting, etc) is probably double that, but call it $250k/yr to be nice. You take 3 developers and have them spend a quarter on replacing Docker Desktop, that's nearly $200k in developer costs spent replacing a tool that's gonna cost your 250 person company $30k/year. Docker wants you to pay $10/mo to make your $20k/mo developer more effective, and companies in our industry would rather spend several months of developer time building an alternative that they'll have to support forever and teach every new individual coming into the company how to use. For a group that seems to pride itself on math and logic and whatever, I don't understand what the hell we're thinking most of the time.
- twblalock 4y agoIf you do the same math for a company with thousands, or tens of thousands, of developers, the answer looks different. Large companies already have dedicated teams for stuff that is a lot less critical than the container runtime. The companies that are too big to avoid paying, but too small to build a replacement, are the ones that are in a jam -- for now. But in a year or two, Podman or Rancher might might fully meet their needs. What should they do then? Continue to pay for Docker, or use a free and open source alternative that has feature parity?
- fxtentacle 4y agoI'm still wondering if this will be enough to pay back the 10x on $430 mio in funding that their investors expect... $135 mio in revenue is great, but they need 4.3 billion in profits.
- thih9 4y ago> A large chunk of the tech world today relies on their products, but they were making next to nothing for it. Isn’t this kind of monetization problem quite common for tech companies in general?