10 ms·
Speaking as a Japanese-American, I personally think the biggest problem with Japanese programmers comes down to the Japanese being too crafty and elitist. What
by Dalewyn 4y ago
Speaking as a Japanese-American, I personally think the biggest problem with Japanese programmers comes down to the Japanese being too crafty and elitist.
What do I mean by this? Basically: If you're a wizard at peeling the skin off an apple with your knife you never need an apple peeler; consequently, you never get a good peeler industry going. Meanwhile, Americans manufacture the best apple peelers because they can't skin an apple with a knife to save their own lives.
Likewise, Japan doesn't /need/ or /want/ the conveniences and luxuries afforded by genuinely good programming. Japanese can and will get by with the hard(er) way and won't care.
Tools exist to address an inconvenience. Good tools exist to make a convenient inconvenience even more convenient. And good toolmakers exist to enable such better conveniences. None of this can exist if there aren't inconveniences in the first place.
This also extends to the hardware side of things, too. Take flash memory, for example. Flash memory was invented in Japan by Toshiba, but nobody cared because Japan was too good. Meanwhile, Intel and the west seized upon the invention and made bank.[1] We all know where Toshiba is now.
This I feel is why Japanese programmers continue to be utterly inept (most still can't produce unicode programs), and why the wider industry in Japan continues to be irrelevant on the world stage from a programming perspective. There is no Japanese equivalent to Microsoft or Google or Amazon because Japan's too good for that.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fujio_Masuoka https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fujio_Masuoka
- mostertoaster 4y agoI enjoyed reading this. Thank you. Specifically how you beautifully put “Japan is too good for that”, in a way that both compliments and criticizes at the same time.
- Insanity 4y agoThat is a really interesting perspective, thank you for sharing! The idea of Japanese people honing a skill/job to perfection is definitely a stereotype where I am from. Perhaps it might be a justified stereotype which ties into this. Definitely the apple peeler example rings true.
- Der_Einzige 4y agoIt is justified. That's why Toyota/Lexus is superior to all other brands in terms of fit and finish, and quality. I can literally see the difference in stitching quality between Lexus and any other brand vehicles. Even poor Porsche gets brutally mogged by the LC500.
- jfk13 4y ago> Japanese programmers continue to be utterly inept That's quite a sweeping statement! Plenty of Japanese programers I know are extremely competent.
- Dalewyn 4y agoI feel that based off my experiences using and interacting with Japanese software. Very frequently, they exhibit exotic bugs and quirks that make me sincerely question the aptitude of the programmers involved. Maybe the programmers in question are smart as in book smart, but they clearly don't know how to reflect that in practice. Also, it truly is ridiculous that so many Japanese programs still can't unicode.
- ihatepython 4y ago> Also, it truly is ridiculous that so many Japanese programs still can't unicode. Can't, or won't? In truth, Unicode is a completely braindead standard
- forkerenok 4y agoI think starting with a certain complexity a polished product is more of an execution issue than it is of quality of programming. In my experience, many programmers that are book smart can contribute to great working software, but can also produce crap when left to their own devices ("who cares about UX, look at this slick 3NF data model I fleshed out") or managed incompetently ("We fixed all the bugs that were in our bug tracker, therefore the software must be complete").
- justsomehnguy 4y agoThat's quite a sweeping statement! But plenty of Japanese programers you know who are extremely competent != all Japanese programmers are extremely competent. Only a Sith deals in absolutes.
- PurpleRamen 4y agoOne can be competent and still suck. The thing with software is that it's quite easy to reach mastery in some very specific domain, while lacking any competence in other important areas.
- 082349872349872 4y agoIf it's any comfort: Switzerland invented* the quartz watch. But swiss watchmakers were too good for that. * at least according to how swiss tell this story. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quartz_clock#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quartz_clock#History differs substantially. (but does mention Longines ca. 1966, which may have been how the story I heard arose? In any case, these days Longines has long since been bought by Swatch...)
- namaria 4y agoKodak invented digital photography. History is full of examples where people and companies couldn't see or capture the huge value of their inventions.
- midoridensha 4y agoXerox's PARC has to be the biggest example of a company not capturing the value of its inventions.
- PsycheOS 4y agoAbsentee leadership with no understanding or care to monetize it - including the pricing on the first Xerox Computers. Also many deca billion dollar spinouts from Xerox Parc: 1. SGI / silcon graphisc based on Jim Clarke's work on 3D chips. 2. 3Com / ethernet based on Bob Metcalfe's work. 3. Adobe based on John Warnock and Charles Geschke on vector graphics and printing. etc.
- djmips 4y agoApple could be almost considered a direct influence from Xerox Parc. SGI then went on to spinout Nvidia and ArtX(bought by ATI/AMD) amongst others.
- unity1001 4y ago> Absentee leadership with no understanding or care to monetize it Its not that. Its that pushing digital photography and other stuff and monetizing them would kill their existing business. However you look at it, its a risk.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ihatepython 4y ago> This I feel is why Japanese programmers continue to be utterly inept Ahh. This explains why Perl is so much better than Ruby. Makes sense now.
- bakuninsbart 4y agoWas that sarcasm or genuine preference? Either way I'd love to know what drives your opinion in Python vs. Perl!
- ihatepython 4y agoWell, not exactly sarcasm but a snarky way to say that Ruby was written by a Japanese programmer, so he can't be completely incompetent. Perl is my preference of the three (Perl, Python, Ruby). I agree with 'There Is More Than One Way To Do It', and disagree with 'There Is Only One Way To Do It'. And Perl has the best support for regular expressions. Ruby is OK, but I learned Perl first, so it feels more natural.
- willbudd 4y ago> And Perl has the best support for regular expressions. To me this sounds a bit like driving to a supermarket three towns away because it has the best selection of coffee filters... :)
- melagonster 4y agowhen perl5 released, this actually is a good idea. but world changed.
- ihatepython 4y agoWell to be honest, I have driven more than an hour to go to my favorite Italian deli and get my favorite sub sandwich, so it fits my personality
- satvikpendem 4y agoWhy do you hate Python? And what is your opinion on Nim, Crystal, Rust etc?
- IYasha 4y agoI'd also note the hereditary love for trade/manufacturing secrets which transformed into adoption of extremely proprietary licensing. Developers prior to ~2015 hardly ever considered publishing their code or even format specs. This secrecy has deep roots and it really annoys and pisses me off. I'm not narrowing down on corporate software - even hobbyists who write "dating games" would never publish code even if it's something ridiculously simple. I can hardly remember an example of FOSS from Japan except for CrystalDiskInfo. But I can tell for sure, when you were using japanese software from before 2010s you could FEEL it, the proprietaniness, the secrecy, the know-howness, the one-of-a-kind-ness, handmad(e)ness :) I still remember trying that "dark internet" sharing program... SO secret and proprietary, so much security by obscurity - it made be laugh, cry and facepalm.
- skissane 4y ago> I can hardly remember an example of FOSS from Japan except for CrystalDiskInfo. The programming language Ruby has to be the most famous Japanese open source software of them all
- Cerium 4y agoOf course that is because Matz is nice.
- xrd 4y agoIt's never really occurred to me before, but Matz is Mormon, right? I wonder if that informed his decisions differently than if he were heavily influenced by Buddhist or Shintoist thinking, as the larger population does. It would be fascinating to see if there is any correlation between alternative religions and approaches to software in Japan. Feels like there is a heavy influence of Buddhist thought (mindfulness) on the silicon valley community. Perhaps people that come from minority spiritual communities have to "think different?"
- wil421 4y agoAre you saying Buddhist thinking helps SV or hurts Japan? Or both?
- powerapple 4y agoThat's my story with the dish washer: I find it is a lot easier just wash dish as soon as it is used, it does not take more than a few seconds for a plate, and my dishwasher are only used as a place to dry plates. I had thought about the same concept you mentioned here when comparing eastern and western culture, and I thought it might come from diet, but I didn't backup with any research.
- midoridensha 4y agoDishwashers make sense if you have a lot of dishes, and make a practice of filling the dishwasher before washing. For a single person, this can take many days. The total amount of water and time ends up being less by using the dishwasher. However, if you have a small number of dishes so that you can't afford to wait 3-7 days between washings, and need to clean them daily, the dishwasher makes no sense.
- rippercushions 4y agoAre people really leaving dirty dishes in the dishwasher for a week? That sounds like it would smell terrible and anything left on the earlier plates would be dry as cement by then.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoI think most people usually get almost all of the food off the dishes before putting them in the washer. If your dish is covered in dried yogurt & avocado slime - a lot of time the dish washer won't even get it off.
- bmacho 4y ago> anything left on the earlier plates would be dry as cement by then. Water makes it soft again in a minute. Postponing dishwashing is not worse than doing it right after eating.
- alternatetwo 4y agoI'm not sure what you leave on your dishes, but generally it's just a few crumbs, maybe a bit of butter, if it's obviously too much for the dishwasher - oatmeal does get as hard as cement for example - you need to rinse it off first anyway.
- sampo 4y ago> Americans manufacture the best apple peelers My favourite apple peeler is the Jonas peeler from Sweden. https://www.kitchenkapers.com/products/linden-original-jonas-peeler https://www.kitchenkapers.com/products/linden-original-jonas...
- wil421 4y agoHa! It’s been a while since I’ve seen that type of peeler. Makes sense that it was popular in the 50/60s my grandparents had one. I recently bought a peeler that I don’t like and I’ll try the Jonas one.
- galangalalgol 4y agoWhy peel apples? I do cut it in half and take out the core, but that is mostly to be sure there is no Griswald.
- dsr_ 4y agoIf you are cooking with apples as an ingredient, the skin will often be a textural problem. If you're eating a fresh apple, it generally isn't an issue.
- Narishma 4y agoTouching apple skin with my teeth gives me the same sensation as fingernails on a chalkboard. I don't have this issue with other fruits, just apples for some reason.
- wil421 4y agoI have young kids under 3 who will point out the smallest speck of peels and reject the Apple slice.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoI'm allergic to the skin.
- 4y ago
- Semaphor 4y agoOne of my favorite pieces of software, EmEditor, is made by a company that was started [0] 1995 in Japan. Though maybe it’s telling that they’ve been headquartered in the USA since 2001 ;) [0]: https://www.emeditor.com/about/about-emurasoft/greeting/ https://www.emeditor.com/about/about-emurasoft/greeting/
- a_c 4y agoSo true. Perfect did indeed become an enemy of good. And good stuff end up being better than perfect. Two related examples I can think of: - China skipped credit card to use mobile payment directly as credit card is already perfect for the western world. - Apple didn't iterate over blackberry, the then perfect phone. On the other hand, do we count games as software? Japan still produce lots of great game AFAICT, no?
- Dalewyn 4y agoWe have to remember that it's the writing, the graphics, the music in Japanese video games that make them great, not necessarily their programming. They are amazing works of art, but unimpressive technical demonstrations.
- Jensson 4y agoThe movement code in mario games is better than anything in the west though. But you could call that type of code "art" as well, it isn't really a software engineering feat. Maybe you could say that Japan has great software artists, but they aren't that great at software engineering.
- yurishimo 4y agoCan you expound upon this? I've not heard this talking point before. I do know Nintendo has a history of pushing the technical limits of their own hardware, but I'd be interested to read more about some specifics.
- djmips 4y agoWhen you only care about how something looks and plays but care nothing about how it happens under the hood you can end up with some really ugly code. I am not claiming this doesn't happen in the west either but in general when I got a glimpse of Japanese game code it was 'ugly' compared to western even if it technically was great (fun, performant etc)
- bitL 4y agoThe same holds for Germany. Beside the "no pain no gain" attitude, the pursuit of "perfection" leads to weird outcomes. For example, the music band Kraftwerk dissolved because half of the members wanted to make sounds that looked "perfect" on an oscilloscope and not how good they sounded.
- steve1977 4y agoI guess there's a reason why Japan is often called the Germany of Asia.
- pmarreck 4y agoDo you have any information about the Kraftwerk claim? (I'm also a firstborn American German so this is personally culturally interesting)
- alfalfasprout 4y agoThey played a live show recently here in the US and it was super fun!
- HPsquared 4y agoIn other words, craftsmanship is valued over profitability.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoA respectable focus, but not one that survives in a complex and ruthless market
- presentation 4y agoBut Japanese companies produce tons of borderline useless convenience gadgets?
- manojlds 4y agoSounds a lot like Jugaad in India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jugaad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jugaad