5 ms·
Common Lisp: 2022 in review
- Wintergreen88 4y agoFantastic article. Thanks very much
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- medo-bear 4y agosuch a powerful language and such an amazing small comunity. learning lisp is not only fun but it can broaden and deepen your understanding of computing far more than what you get from syntax-soup languages. plus with common lisp you can build industrial strength applications with unrivaled interactive development
- Insanity 4y agoI use CL for hobby projects and do love it. The main difficulty with “industrial strength lisp” is finding places in the industry that want to do so. :/
- galdor 4y agoTalking about Common Lisp in the places I worked for in the past has always be met with mockery and disdain. But then again, I have seen this kind of reaction for every non-mainstream language, so it is not really surprising. I'm currently getting back to CL, hoping to do much more with it for 2023. Being able to develop incrementally in SLIME has been a joy. Hopefully I will manage to find the right project idea to apply CL to.
- smcn 4y agoI was /that guy/ at my last place and I agree that it's not well received. Though once I was writing some lisp to fix a problem we were having and I had a developer beside me and he was blown away by what was happening. I think that the interactivity is something which must be experienced to be fully appreciated. I use it at my current start up and could not imagine using another language. I've become too used to this kind of workflow.
- galdor 4y agoI just realised you were working on Feetr! I learned you guys were using Common Lisp on Twitter. Small world really. What implementations are you using, and how are you running it in production, if it is not a secret? Any performance issue with the GC at large scale?
- smcn 4y agoTiny world! CCL is used locally for two reasons 1) error messages are better and 2) it ensures that we're writing portable code. SBCL is used in production because it's much faster and it's constantly being updated, so we get cool things for free. I have been eyeing lispworks but I don't know that it offers much benefit right now. We do plan on mobile apps at some point and that's a conversation we'll have with them. Production itself is pretty much just a live image, not much different than what you'd have when you're developing. We use slynk to be able to connect to it and play with the data. Can see that here [0]. GC hasn't caused an issue yet. I imagine we will run into issues latter half of this year when we roll out alerts but those are challenges which can be overcome. That might even be a lispworks thing honestly. 0: https://i.imgur.com/8ACxOXG.png https://i.imgur.com/8ACxOXG.png
- galdor 4y agoThanks for the info. I'm also using both SBCL and CCL, both to stay portable and because it sometimes help finding issues detected by one and not the other. If you end up blogging about CL (and tech in general) at Feetr, know that there will be at least one interested reader :)
- smcn 4y agoThat honestly means the world to me, thank you so much!
- freilanzer 4y agoI would read that blog as well. I can't use CL at work but I'm always interested.
- medo-bear 4y ago> The main difficulty with “industrial strength lisp” is finding places in the industry that want to do so i think its important to not give people unrealistic expectations and this is why i said "you can build ..." instead of "you will find plenty of job opportunities". although, mind you, i don't think that jobs-to-size-of-community ratio is frightening
- noloblo 4y agoWe need cl industrial strength lisp
- louis771 4y agoAmazing work by the author of the Common Lisp Cookbook. I've hesitated to get into CL for months, but seeing about all the activity going on, I'm in for 2023.
- dgan 4y agoDisclaimer: not a big Lisp user. Interesting how Lisp code is NOT littered with " if something != null, ...", unlike your average Java project (or even python, but it's less visible), and just works. My understanding is that busines-as-usual handling of nil (empty lists) implicitely confers to Lisp code monadic style which help to avoid tedious checks
- fredrikholm 4y agoIt's littered, just hidden. Eg: if, if-let, when, when-let, unless etc. This makes it appear that the data is passed down in a monadic style, but it often isn't; *nil* is not an actionable value.
- crapaud23 4y agoThis is the way Clojure works too. Nil is treated as an identity/neutral element. This goes beyond lists: in contrast to Common Lisp who equates nil to the empty list, Clojure maintains a distinction and you're supposed to handle nils by correctly implementing functions. This is as easy as using clojure's core functions, they all have been tailored to handle nil as the neutral element. As a consequence, in Clojure, nil's neutrality extends to other datastructures, for instance (hash)maps. (assoc nil :some :value) => {:some :value}.
- dgan 4y agoI like the idea, but JVM is a show stopper for me :/
- smcl 4y agoMay I ask why? I've no dog in this fight (I don't work with Java) but I've seen plenty of people against Java the language who were very happy to use Scala or Clojure. I haven't encountered anyone who has specifically said they were against the JVM, so I'm interested whether it's something technical (maybe you do more real-time or work with resource-constrained systems) or if it's something more personal. There are no bad answers, I'm not looking for an argument just genuinely curious :)
- hmcamp 4y agoOn a slightly different tangent, is anyone using Prolog in production?
- lars-b2018 4y agoThis is a great synopsis of the state of things..thanks for posting. Having all this information on one page really helped me grok all the action this year. It really highlights that there is a lot of activity in this space, which is great to see, because CL continues to be my secret weapon! ;)
- rosebay 4y ago[dead]
- tmtvl 4y agoACL2 gets mentioned in passing, but it may be worth noting that version 8.5 was released this year, with several new features and bug fixes: https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/moore/acl2/v8-5/combined-manual/index.html?topic=ACL2____NOTE-8-5 https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/moore/acl2/v8-5/combined-man...
- medo-bear 4y agoMaxima should also deserve a mention I think
- vindarel 4y agoexcellent point, thanks. It's added. I mostly prepared the post with the reddit history, that means someone missed the opportunity to inform the broader Lisp community there. For Maxima, what could be added?
- tmtvl 4y agoMaxima 5.46 came out (https://sourceforge.net/p/maxima/code/ci/master/tree/changelogs/ChangeLog-5.46.md https://sourceforge.net/p/maxima/code/ci/master/tree/changel...) in April. It also had a number of bugfixes and some new features, personally I am fond of getting rid of the python dependency for building the documentation, but I suppose preventing gensyms from leaking and fixing limit going into an infinite loop may be considered more important by some.
- vindarel 4y agoThanks, added.
- matrix12 4y agoGreat overview! "Anything Common, is of little value." -Nietzsche
- mark_l_watson 4y agoThis will take a while to read through! I have been using Common Lisp since 1982, love the language, but I have been drifting over to Python more in the last 8 years because of support for deep learning. That said, I think CL is the best research language.
- vindarel 4y agothen you'll be pleased to read that @digikar is advancing on fast Python FFI, or to discover numerical and scientific libraries. > This will take a while to read through! but much less than to write or to google, so lay back and enjoy each line ;)
- kaveh808 4y agoVery flattered to see kons-9 mentioned. It is wonderful to be back developing in CL after so many years. I hope 2023 will see a community of users grow around the system. I would love to see what uses people put it to. That, after all, is why I started to project, combining my two favorite software things: Common Lisp and 3D graphics.
- tmm84 4y agoI likewise want to thank you for the great YouTube videos that you produced. Watching someone interact and do things in CL helps me to understand it better as someone who plays in Scheme/Racket on the weekends.
- agumonkey 4y agoFun to see schafmeister lab is still on CLASP. Thanks for the review, I stopped scanning the CL world but often at work I miss this crowd.