4 ms·
So, the complaint is that they don't want to stick a fire door on the back of new buildings, since it would undermine some architectural design purity or someth
by hedora 4y ago
So, the complaint is that they don't want to stick a fire door on the back of new buildings, since it would undermine some architectural design purity or something?
- scrumper 4y agoThe thesis isn't particularly clear but what I think they want is a modification to Canadian building code so that structures up to a certain size don't need a second egress. They want that, I think, because that aspect of code makes it hard to design housing that sits in the middle of the scale between single family homes and high rises. That middle tier of housing seems like it could be important if you consider what NIMBY-ism and a shortage of housing is doing to some cities. I couldn't find out out _why_ a second fire exit makes it hard though. Maybe it's not the door, but the need for an extra stairwell? I'd hesitate to call it pretentious wank just because I don't understand it, so let's just say that the site was clearly not written for a lay audience.
- henrikschroder 4y agoYou have to go digging on that site a little bit to get to the why: "The building typology of five to six-storey apartment buildings usually involves a single shared central stair, accessed directly from the street with typically two to four dwelling units per floor. However, because the Ontario Building Code requires two means of egress, mid-rise buildings in Toronto are designed with two exit stairs connected by a common corridor. The result is that mid-rise construction only proves feasible on larger sites where around ten or more units can fit within a typical floor plan to achieve an efficient floor area ratio. Zeidler explains that “this appears to be a reasonable precaution for life safety. However, the life safety of this single stair type in Europe has been equal to, if not better than ours,” due to the fact that the single stair scheme is shared between fewer units. By changing the code requirement for two exit stairs, apartment buildings of midrise height could be designed around a single common stair. For instance, a point-access block, the dominant housing typology in dense urban contexts like Berlin, Paris, or Barcelona, is currently not permitted in Canada." https://secondegress.ca/A-Wicked-Problem https://secondegress.ca/A-Wicked-Problem
- mjmahone17 4y agoA big chunk of why is the % of floor area that is used for housing versus “support”. Basically a single stair layout gives you 90-95% floor efficiency, and a double stair is closer to 80-85%. People don’t rent common spaces like stairs, so you can bring the value of a building up by ~10% by allowing each apartment to have only a single exit staircase. Also if a lot is small (like 20ft wide or less), you have to compromise the design. For instance, instead of having full-floor units that get cross ventilation (windows at front and back), you may need to have duplex units that take up 40% of the front or back (so only get one side of the building).
- RegnisGnaw 4y agoIts the second stairwell.
- monknomo 4y agoRequiring two egresses usually means that the building will not have an apartment that spans the width of the building, instead there will be a central hallway to connect every apartment to two stairwells. That central hallway seems small, but it eats a fairly substantial percentage of the footprint space of the building. (elevators and trashrooms are also examples of things that eat a lot of footprint; limiting them for smaller buildings is beneficial for floorplan efficiency) And since people do not like bedrooms without windows, having apartments that don't span the width of a building limits possible floorplans, and drives the apartment design towards studios and 1 bedrooms. The buildings tend to become very wide in order to accommodate enough apartments to make them worthwhile to build, so they tend to use up a high percentage of the lot they are sited on, which reduces greenspace and other resident amennities.
- nradov 4y agoIn most areas, the building code explicitly requires a window in every bedroom. This serves as an additional emergency exit, either directly on the ground floor or with assistance from firefighters on higher storeys.
- bbojan 4y agoIronically, in Toronto, not every bedroom is required to have a window [1]. [1] BCC Ruling No. 14-03-1366: https://web.archive.org/web/20210422142050/http://www.mah.gov.on.ca/Page11347.aspx https://web.archive.org/web/20210422142050/http://www.mah.go...
- jaclaz 4y agoAnd this shows how internationally building codes can be very different. In Italy a room, any room for residential use, not only needs a window, but the window(s) surface must be at least 1/8 or in some cases 1/12 of the floor surface of that room, a windowless room can only be a bathroom (with a compulsory exhaust fan) or a closet/corridor/storage/utility room. But this comes not from fire related laws, but rather from minimal health requirements (natural light, ventilation).
- tlb 4y agoMost of the buildings on the page are multistory. A door on the ground floor isn't a big deal, but above that they require fire escape stairs, which are big and ugly and create a section with poor views out the windows.
- scotty79 4y agoAll examples seem to be about single stairs vs pair of stairs.
- RegnisGnaw 4y agoWhich is the key issue. The second set of stairs is needed for the second egress.
- jaclaz 4y agoNot really, they are saying that the requirement for a second egress in multi-apartment buildings (which is not only a second fire door, it is also a second stair, etc.) makes too costly/complex mid size buildings. The first image on this page exemplifies the issue: https://secondegress.ca/A-Wicked-Problem https://secondegress.ca/A-Wicked-Problem https://freight.cargo.site/t/original/i/9b6f13e0414b47f094ad5d69cbdae47abcf05c3c345c61d79d77670ea6d5be82/MissingMiddleDiagram_CityOfEdmonton.jpg https://freight.cargo.site/t/original/i/9b6f13e0414b47f094ad...
- twblalock 4y agoThat sounds fair on the surface, but we manage to build multi-egress buildings all the time in other countries, and if a single stairwell is the only egress a lot of people could die in a fire. Some of these mod-sized buildings are too tall to make jumping out of a window a realistic option. So I’m not really sympathetic to this argument. Unlike some building codes, this one is directly connected to a life and death issue and we have seen what happens in fires where people can’t get out.
- bombcar 4y agoYeah, it seems to me that we can actually work out the situations involved, and being on the sixth floor of a building with only one fire egress seems undesirable. Perhaps it can be compensated for with various "either two egresses OR each bedroom must be equipped to be fire proof for X minutes" or something, and bring back hook and ladder trucks (arguably which are not used as much because buildings now have multiple egresses when that tall).
- pessimizer 4y ago> each bedroom must be equipped to be fire proof for X minutes This is the kind of absurdly complex regulation that sounds simple, but is a lobbyist's dream. Two exits are easy to know when you've implemented, and easy for regulators to check if you've implemented. A "bedroom" being "fire proof" for X minutes will involve 900 pages of nonsense regulations from which lobbyists have carefully removed anything that will affect their bottom line. "Each bedroom must be equipped to be fire proof for X minutes" was the type of rule that caused the fire brigades to tell people in Grenfell to stay in their apartments, and even more importantly the type of rule that allowed contractors to claim compliance to was sufficient enough that they could use flammable, shit cladding that was illegal in Europe and the US, and install it incompetently (because if the units were "fireproof," who could care?)
- ripley12 4y agoThis is a snarky low-effort comment. Do better.