6 ms·
Will we know alien life when we see it?
- nyfresh 4y agoHot take, no explanations: - Planets are sentient - Alien Robots outlive Aliens - Photon life makes more sense - Carbon based life is fragile
- keithwhor 4y agoAs a hot take I’m not incentivized to respond seriously, but I will say that Carbon-based life as we know it on Earth is seriously antifragile. We’ve found life in the most inhospitable places we can imagine and the kicker is it’s all self-replicating and self-healing. Yes, we’re meat sacks that pop when poked — that’s a very conserved trait of life on Earth — but for the most part, especially with a holistic view like at a species level, we’re ridiculously hardy.
- rendall 4y ago> the most inhospitable places we can imagine That "we can imagine" is doing a lot of the work, there. We humans are pretty limited in experience, operating parameters and yes, imagination. On but one dimension, consider the range of all possible temperatures and how narrow the band in which the lifeforms of which we have knowledge can survive. Consider the same along all other dimensions like radiation, gravity, pressure, particulate density, magnetic field intensity, perhaps others we have not even discovered yet. Carbon life that we know about is "robust" only considering the relatively narrow ranges on our own planet.
- keithwhor 4y agoThe range of all possible temperatures is theoretically infinite. Life as we know it — without protection — can survive at everything from 0K to 386K (113C). As humans we have harnessed temperatures in the 100s of millions of degrees (fusion) safely and can build machines that reliably extend our operating parameters far beyond their normal bounds. It’s easy to be dismissive, but the reality is that life as we know it is pretty freaking incredible.
- enkid 4y agoI don't know, a center of a star seems pretty inhospitable, and we haven't found life there yet.
- lowbloodsugar 4y agoAre we getting a lot of telemetry from our “center of sun” probe?
- oblak 4y agoenkid's people have had a remote outpost near the center for some time now. They have not reported finding any life so far there but can we really trust them after the Saturn 3 disaster?
- buran77 4y ago> We’ve found life in the most inhospitable places we can imagine ...on Earth. Take away something as simple as the magnetic field of the planet and suddenly resilient life narrows down to a couple of bacteria, Archaea, or Tardigrades [0] which still die with enough exposure. Anything above 120 degrees C will also cook our goose and every other form of life, again short of a few Archaea [1] which still die a few degrees later. And then there's the most basic of all: water without which some life doesn't die but doesn't exactly "live" either. A handful of spores, spore-like forms, or completely dried forms of bacteria for example can go for eons without water but they're not functioning. And the higher level and complex the organism (thus possibly easier to recognize as life), the higher the chances one of the "subsystems" is more fragile and its failure kills the organism. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioresistance#Radioresistance_comparison https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioresistance#Radioresistanc... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strain_121 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strain_121
- rhn_mk1 4y agoI don't think life can be evaluated as a snapshot in a moment of time. Life is a process, and it affects a population. I think even the most conservative definitions may agree on that. Antifragility plays well with this definition: it doesn't describe the state, but the potential and the ability to change. Taking into account the huge populations, and the fact that only a couple individuals must survive hardship in order for life to prevail, I can see the antifragility.
- lowbloodsugar 4y ago5 mass extinctions. Arguably heading for another one (us and everything else).
- Enginerrrd 4y agoWhat do you think is occurring that is likely to end our species?
- Enginerrrd 4y agoFor those who down-voted, this was a genuine question, and I'd really like to know.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rhn_mk1 4y ago5 mass extinctions and it's still going. Seems quite hardy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- DesiLurker 4y agoI actually agree with 'QM/EM based life'. My current thinking goes as following.. - Intelligent life develops superfast AI - - then develops even more advanced quantum version of it. - Life slowly starts augmenting its meatspace with advanced replicable machinery - Eventually everything starts becoming very predictable so it start absorbing the advanced AI in our minds, which slowly becomes our essence (assuming consciousness is 'computable' ie.. not some penrose-esq orchestrated reduction) - It then builds a hypercomputer operating at very close to max efficiency and start harvesting all matter/stars to sustain it & migrates to it. there is another path where just like light currently exists as an EM wave packet we discover other stable forms and migrate to that. of course this does not means the pervious iterations of life do not continue to exist, just that they become increasingly irrelevant.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tylershuster 4y agoIf you accept the existence of angels and demons, you already do.
- madspindel 4y agoAliens from heaven. Actually a valid theory that angels are just friendly aliens and demons are the bad ones. If they can visit earth they probably have godlike technology.
- wincy 4y agoI think there was an episode of the Outer Limits like this where some scientist made contact via wormhole with aliens and they looked suspiciously like demons with the horns and everything. The aliens of course said “we have a bad rep but we’re actually good guys!”, then proceeded to do something like drain the oceans or boil them for terraforming or something apocalyptic after convincing the scientist to let them teleport through.
- nobody9999 4y agocf. Childhood's End[0] by Arthur C. Clarke. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Childhood%27s_End https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Childhood%27s_End
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- someweirdperson 4y agoDo they fulfill our current definition of life?
- tylershuster 4y agoIs there consensus on that?
- jl6 4y agoRemember when most of the known exoplanets were hot Jupiter-like worlds, so it looked for a moment that perhaps those were the dominant type of planet, but then it became clear that this type of planet was commonly detected just because they were the only type of planet our techniques were capable of detecting? Same, but for life. We’re probably only going to find the kind of life that has the characteristics and behaviors that we currently recognize as life, and is in a place we think of pointing our telescopes at, and our telescopes are a fine enough sieve to see.
- polishdude20 4y agoAt some point, if you stretch the definition of life too far, what's the point? Like, what's the point of saying a rock is alive? We've got them everywhere, we know they exist everywhere but we can't really do anything with that info. Knowing something is alive gives us a basis for interacting with it. Saying we found life on Mars isn't important because we found life there. It's important because it challenges or confirms our expectations about so many other things. It's kind of like shooting hoops. The hoop stays in the same place and we try and throw the ball into it from different angles. Each angle we can throw it in from teaches us something new. If you took that hoop and just decided that you get a point by moving the hoop to the ball instead, what does that actually help us with? Another way of saying it. If everyone is a superhero, then nobody is.
- t8sr 4y agoWe don't even really have an agreed-upon definition of life, so the question is basically non-sensical. Alive are the things we say are alive, which is mostly stuff like us: some type of metabolism, growth, response to stimuli. By that definition we would certainly recognize it, at least up close. If we're willing to expand the definition of life, e.g. to accept some type of self-aware computer as alive, then we'd have to tweak the definition, such as it is, and then we're no longer talking about "life" as we think of the word today. I guess people often wonder about other biochemistries. As far as I know, from a semester of undergrad astrobiology, we don't currently consider those very likely. Silicate chemistries were speculated for decades, but the chemical dynamics just don't tend to work out. The other main idea was ammonia as solvent, but that'd be hardly exotic, and the current thinking is that biochemistry would be entirely too slow at the temperatures where ammonia is liquid. The wilder ideas, like high energy chemistries on the surface of neutron stars only ever appear in science fiction. (Excepting the odd paper from the seventies, but that was a strange time.) Maybe people will accuse me of a lack of imagination, but I think it's telling that these threads are almost always mainly the home of comments shouting the word "quantum" like it means something, or getting their information from Mass Effect. I do think it's an interesting question whether we'd be able to recognize other types of intelligence, but I am pretty sure we'd be able to recognize other types of life. (By the way, the article seems to be mostly about whether we'd recognize alien life seen through a telescope, but that hasn't deterred speculation about other kinds of life in the thread.) Source: I actually studied this in college, for a bit.
- yamasanama 4y ago> We don't even really have an agreed-upon definition of life, so the question is basically non-sensical. ... > I am pretty sure we'd be able to recognize other types of life. ... > Source: I actually studied this in college, for a bit. So, let me summarize. You find the question non-sensical, then you are sure you know the answer, and finally you appeal to authority (your own) to elevate your opinion over those of us mere common-sense mortals. Sorry, I'd have liked to give more weight to your angle, but you kinda made that hard.
- t8sr 4y ago
- Hani1337 4y agoI firmly believe that life on Earth was triggered by spores meeting water and developing mycelium networks breaking down minerals into nutrients and slowly taking advantage of photosynthesis to develop more complex life forms. Spores can easily resist the vacuum of space, and pass any form of great filter. They do help create enzymes and uptake nutrients, they do help break down minerals, they do communicate with entire ecosystems, and so much more we barely understand. This would mean that fungi are of alien origin.
- yamasanama 4y agoIs your belief based on any kind of evidence in which case I'd love to hear your best arguments, or is it a religios belief (like in Jesus) in which case there is not much to discuss?
- darkerside 4y agoHypothesis is a key step in the scientific method
- yamasanama 4y agoSure. But stating a belief without any reason why this would be true, or more precisely, why this hypothesis would be preferable over the currently accepted hypothesis which does have supporting evidence, is just not very convincing.
- darkerside 4y agoI'm just pointing out that you presented a false dichotomy. Just because it isn't proven science does not make it a religious belief.
- polishdude20 4y agoCheck out some stuff written by Nick Lane. He's got a very well thought out theory of how life started.
- 4y ago
- nathias 4y agoI think artificialness is always distinguishable by other sapient creatures, we might miss some of the less complex ones.
- dieselgate 4y agoThis was a good write up as it contained criteria and points for "defining life", it was nice to have a refresher on the meaning of "entropic" life as well. I've often thought if complex extraterrestrial beings were discovered they may not "look" much different than anything found on earth, since the spectrum is so vast on this planet (bacteria, plants, mammals, cephalopods, etc.) - considering the universal confines of physics and locomotion. Isn't there something special about crab/spider anatomy as well and it being very "evolutionarily stable" or something? Cannot recall any papers or information on specifics here at the moment. Meanwhile, I always laugh watching old Twilight Zone episodes and how they have regular humans playing aliens - they don't even bother to differentiate them as a species (likely because of available technology) but think this can work well in a way. edit word
- dcminter 4y ago> Isn't there something special about crab/spider anatomy as well ... Carcinization? https://xkcd.com/2314/ https://xkcd.com/2314/
- leplen 4y agoThere's a lot of convergent evolution towards the crab body plan, a phenomenon known as Carcinisation. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carcinisation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carcinisation)
- fbdab103 4y agoWho is to say that is a universal phenomenon? May have something to do with our level of gravity, life cycle of the blastocyst, metabolic requirements from respiration, other fauna competition, etc. Which is not to say there is a better alternative on the table, but I would hesitate to say that we should expect crabs on other planets. Edit: Kicking myself over the missed opportunity to say "space crabs" or a Zoidberg reference
- delecti 4y agoThe fact that there are a large number of crab-like land and water dwelling organisms, and in a range of sizes and regions, suggests there's a pretty big range of environments that crabs thrive in. That's still far from universal, but it's also not very limited either.
- pcdoodle 4y agoWe're just thinking with our meat over here...
- mrlonglong 4y ago> Cell phones don’t randomly fluctuate out of a vacuum,” quips Walker. But Boltzmann brains do.
- boltzmann_brain 4y ago[dead]
- doctor_eval 4y agoSure, but only in the same way that Schrödinger’s cat is both alive and dead. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boltzmann_brain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boltzmann_brain
- moloch-hai 4y agoFor every Boltzmann brain that doesn't know it is one, an infinite number do know, and are horrified. Another infinite number of them are not. Yet, there are an equal number of all three.
- aredox 4y agoDisappointed to see there is no mention of Lem's Solaris, whose devoted large paragraphs to this very question. For a very enlightening, very poetic short story from a little known author, I would encourage sci-fi fans to search for "La porcelaine de l'univers" from Bruno Vizerie.
- yarg 4y agoI'm starting to think that given enough time and space any context in which self replicating structures can occur will give rise to some form of life (as a statistical inevitability). (I've probably been reading too much sci-fi.) Alien life does not need to be restricted to matter as we know it; if space itself can give rise to self replicating structures, then it too could be alive. Beyond that, life could occur in any medium and at any scale (in either space or time). Even regarding terrestrial life, how long did it take for us to notice microbes (as something other than a curse from god)? There could even be macroscopic lifeforms moving so quickly that we are unable to see them. So the answer, as far as I can tell, is really that it depends on the kind of life we're referring too. And if it's too far outside the human context of understanding or perception, then the answer is no.
- alienalp 4y agoBy looking at what happened in earth judging it is a normal likelihood for a cell to form within billion year and evolve to us within 4 billion years, is nuts. Scientists thinks this way because they have no idea about what statistical possibility of this to happen in such time. What happened and happening in Earth even if not a miracle to one then it is result of a luck statistically impossible to find anywhere in cosmos. It is worth to mention that all living beings in earth are descendants of same cell. Even in earth there is no sign of multiple different cell formation which shows how lucky we were.
- Retric 4y agoYou’re confusing the odds of a specific lottery ticket hitting the jackpot with any ticket winning. Someone will win fairly regularly. So yea, the odds of life evolving to something genetically compatible with humanity when we did might be tiny, but we aren’t the only possible form of intelligent multicellular tool using life and it could have happened +/- a few billion years. Given earth starting 5 billion years ago the odds of some intelligent civilization eventually showing up might actually be fairly high, we just don’t have enough data to know.
- 4y ago
- m3kw9 4y agoThis looks like a question looking for a problem. If we don’t we won’t know, but when we do it answers this question with a yes.
- doctor_eval 4y agoI’m surprised there isn’t more discussion of life as a kind of information processing. This would put life on a spectrum from viruses (very little or arguably no intrinsic information processing) to humans, which can process even abstract information. But it would also include the kind of life we might potentially find in Jupiter’s clouds, or in the layers of the sun. Discussing life in terms of Darwinian evolution or chemical complexity seems to miss the point. I’d be happy to consider an AI or a cloud “alive”, even if (like a virus) it requires help to replicate.
- xwolfi 4y agoBut we are... the product of code, read by machines, processing input to produce decisions. How are not information processors ? Do you think computers are not a natural extension of us ? There is absolutely discussion of life as information processing, for instance Stanislas Dehaene is super interesting but I ve heard conferences in biochemistry explaining why all amino acid would work to code information, but the 4 DNA uses have chemical properties that help persist and clone it better and the like.
- doctor_eval 4y agoSorry, I meant that the article doesn’t talk about life as information processing. Perhaps I should have said, “I’m surprised there wasn’t”. Although I got about ¾ of the way through it so maybe I missed it. But at the time of posting, nothing in these threads either.
- dhosek 4y agoWhen I got my teaching credential, I had to take a biology class because I hadn’t taken any biology as an undergrad (I also had to take government and P.E. as well for the same reason—having aced the AP American History exam 17 years earlier in high school spared me from having to take an American History class). One of the things that sticks with me still is the somewhat inevitability about the formation of cell membranes given the characteristics of the atoms that compose the molecules that compose the membrane. I was left thinking that life like as we know it on earth might, in fact, be very much a likely outcome of any planet of suitable size, location and composition.
- moloch-hai 4y agoNowhere in nature (that we know of) does any organism make a membrane from scratch. All membranes are extended from an existing membrane, and then pinched off. Possibly, all life and all its existing membranes were extended from a primordial membrane. Arguably, DNA, RNA, and the proteinome are just the universal membrane's way of making more membrane more efficiently.
- moloch-hai 4y agoNot only would we likely not recognize it, we are probably staring at one or more forms of life right now that we are failing to recognize. Likewise, sentience in them or even in the familiar form.
- 0xy 4y agoAfter riding the subway in many major cities around the world, I'm convinced there are alien lifeforms on Earth.
- laughingman2 4y agoOne interesting research group tackling this question is ex-computer engineer, currently biologist Prof. Micahel Levine's group. They built xenobots (biological robots) from frog cells which are not evolutionarily programmed to do tasks which they accomplished. Their research in part deals with emergence of agency at multi-cellular level. And they want to get at the fundamental signatures of what makes some collection of agents into a new single agent at an higher level. Checkout, https://youtu.be/XheAMrS8Q1c https://youtu.be/XheAMrS8Q1c And a new research paper (inhavent had the time to read yet) on this question of how coherent higher order agents emerge from underlying sub-agents. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02688/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.0268...
- qwerty456127 4y agoLife is overrated. What we consider life are just mechanisms that are complex enough to feel mysterious, also grow and develop fast enough for us to notice. I don't think looking for life makes much sense. Looking for intelligence (anything you can communicate with to reach meaningful results, insects are also intelligent, pocket calculators also are and that would be cool if they had emerged without the humans building them) and consciousness (no good definition existing to the date) is what is interesting.