8 ms·
Monkey stone tools shed doubts on the human origin of archeological sites
- vbezhenar 4y agoIf those were monkey tools, why monkeys didn't evolve since then?
- zach_miller 4y agoThey did.
- BobbyJo 4y agoA common misunderstanding of evolution is that it means a population of X becomes a population of Y. In actuality, it means a population of X becomes a population of X AND Y. If X and Y aren't competing for the same resources (speciation commonly happens to take advantage of a different set of resources), then there is no reason they can't coexist indefinitely.
- Beltalowda 4y agoI blame Pokémon for this erroneous view of evolution. Your Charmander has evolved in to a Charizard!
- dieselgate 4y agoThis made me laugh but also made me think about what does and does not evolve. Sharks and the coelacanth fish are often mentioned as modern animals that “have never needed to evolve”. Guess it’s just based by comparing current physiology/structure to what fossil records can be found. Of course “everything evolves” but that depends on a frame or reference in time
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y ago> everything evolves Not necessarily, some things go extinct. Or, evolves in to what? Perhaps we can be certain that every changes. Maybe that's cyclical too.
- moloch-hai 4y agoSharks and coelacanths have evolved exactly as much as humans. The difference is that they have kept a more-or-less constant body plan, and evolved details less easy to see. The monkeys have also evolved exactly as much as we have. Again, it is less easy to see the evolved differences from their ancestors, because their bodies are so superbly adapted to their way of life and so have not changed much.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoSurely this is wrong if we're talking about genetic drift which has no reason to be linear with time ?
- wizzwizz4 4y agoIt's also wrong if you're considering the number of generations available for evolutionary selection pressure. But it's less wrong than what it's rebutting, so I'm happy to say it's rhetorically correct. (It'd need to be a bit more precise to be pedagogically correct, à la lies to children, in my book, because it is still misleading.)
- moloch-hai 4y agoAcknowledging, generation time is a legitimate counter.
- svnt 4y agoThis is not true. They have not evolved/derived as much for a number of reasons including differing mutation rates, minimal environment change, selection against adaptation, etc. It is not visible vs invisible changes that progress at some fixed proportion to reproductive rate; that is a gross oversimplification and conceptually inaccurate. See e.g. Sewell Wright’s fitness landscapes.
- benj111 4y agoIsn't 'need' the wrong word. They just haven't happen to produce an advantageous mutation ..... That changes their form enough to cross some arbitrary line where we would define 'evolving'
- alar44 4y ago[flagged]
- tejtm 4y agoIn case you are seeking an answer, consider that birds instinctively build nests but (most) don't put roofs on them although the process would be a logical continuation of what they can already do. Because what they have is good enough. Without selective pressure, evolution just dithers around what already works. There will be reasons they got to where they are, that they remain just indicates those reasons have not gone away.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoI'm not so certain that it's logical, considering how birds would tend to be away from the nest during the warm days in search for food, and back incubating the eggs during the cold of night, while a roof over a freestanding nest would require much more investment of materials and effort (especially for a species without hands !) ? And of course a lot of species of bird achieves this by nesting in (vertical) holes.
- hutzlibu 4y agoAlso the nest needs to be hidden and a roof would be much harder to spot. So building a roof, that does not draw attention and can resist strong winds would indeed be much harder. Also usually there is some sort of roof and protection by overlapping branches and their leaves.
- gus_massa 4y agoImagine a penguin looking at a albatross and saying: "If they are eating fish like us since many million of years, why didn't albatross evolve since then?" I choose albatross because the birds more related to penguins are albatross or something similar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Procellariiformes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Procellariiformes I'm not sure what happened when the ancestors of penguins split from the ancestors of albatross, but let me guess: <guess> They lived in different areas. In one areas there were less fishes per area and they had to continue flying to catch enough fishes. In the other are there were more fishes, but they lived in deeper water, so they have to enhance the diving abilities. <)guess> Perhaps my guess is bad, or very bad, but I hope you can imagine that the same birds living in different areas may have different food source and different fishing strategies, so in each are the birds that were better for that strategy outnumbered the other birds, and after 60-80 millions year they look very different. Both evolved. albatross look quite birdy like the ancient ancestor, penguins look weird.
- hzay 4y agoGreat explanation, one thing missing is extinction events. Small extinction events in a matter of decades (for birds) drastically influence characteristics that are favored or disfavored - like a drought, or too much rain, or invasion by another species or whatever. Apparently[1] the characteristics that help animals eat in threatening times are the ones that drive evolution. [1] The Beak of Finch book
- jmclnx 4y ago> I'm not sure what happened when the ancestors of penguins split from the ancestors of albatross My guess, similar to yours will added a reason :) Flying consumes a lot of energy. My guess is some albatrosses found a place where there was a lot of food, very safe and then hardly ever needed to fly. Thus the move to penguins.
- deafpolygon 4y agoWithout an extinction event, they can stick around for as long as possible. Both evolved. It's like how we had neanderthals, denisovans and homo sapiens and homo heidelbergensis all on this planet at one point.
- syspec 4y agoBecoming more intelligent isn't necessarily the final outcome of evolution.
- Juliate 4y agoUpvoting because the question, while looking dumb, is very legitimate, if only for some of the answers it calls for. And that’s what makes good questions.
- tgv 4y agoTwo easy options: lack of a sufficiently complex language to transfer ideas and social organization. If a species doesn't get over those hurdles, evolution happily takes another path. And about intelligence: we may not be (or have been) that much more intelligent than certain other apes, but we can learn from other humans from thousands of years ago thousands of miles away. That makes a difference.
- lll-o-lll 4y agoCool! I was unaware there were non-human primates that made and used stone tools. Sucks for the archaeologists of course, but I get the impression that theirs is a profession where you must constantly revise in light of new evidence. Now, if it turns out that ancient DNA is all bunk, I’ll be very sad indeed. Understanding the origins of the human primates is so interesting, but maybe we will never have enough good data to be confident of much. There are limits to what we can figure out, but that’s never stopped anyone from telling a good story!
- mc32 4y agoBut looks like this, as of now anyway, only applies to new world species and thus sites in the South American continent and not Africa or Asia.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoIt's been known for awhile that modern humans aren't the only tool users. Neanderthals and other archaic humans are straightforward examples, but western chimpanzees also do it pretty frequently. Even outside the apes, macaques are known to use stone tools for foraging and sexual gratification.
- ceejayoz 4y agoLots outside primates, too. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tool_use_by_animals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tool_use_by_animals Birds, dolphin, octopuses, otters...
- mc32 4y agoSure and I guess Neanderthal tools would have produced similar tool shapes to those produced by historical humans. What this paper is saying is that S.Am. primates may be responsible for primitive tools previously associated/attributed with/to humans (due to how they look/characteristics) in some South American sites but this aspect casts some doubt on the origin of those sites and thus affects chronological occupation of the continent by people.
- 4y ago
- wslh 4y agoAn article talking about this: "Monkeys Trash Theory of People in Americas Tens of Thousands of Years Ago" https://www.haaretz.com/archaeology/2023-01-05/ty-article/monkeys-trash-theory-of-people-in-americas-tens-of-thousands-of-years-ago/00000185-81eb-df9e-a3bf-87ef3d130000 https://www.haaretz.com/archaeology/2023-01-05/ty-article/mo...
- Noumenon72 4y agoI'm kind of suspicious that neither the abstract nor the article shows a picture of anything resembling a stone tool. Perhaps the field has been defining random rocks with hammer marks as "stone tools" for excitement, and showing a picture would have made people say "well a monkey could have done THAT" all along?
- svnt 4y agoThis is exactly what has happened in many cases.
- moloch-hai 4y agoOf course none of this means there were no humans in South America 30kya. It only means this particular site might not be good evidence for such presence. If no other sites show unambiguous evidence of human presence, we might need to account for that. There is a site near Los Angeles, excavated by Richard Leakey, that has been rejected as indicating early human presence because there was too much stone-tool evidence, and because "everybody knows" there were no people there 200kya. Now that we have the unambiguous Cerutti Mastodon site from 130kya, it might need to be re-evaluated. Generally the null hypothesis is that people went anywhere they could go whenever they could, no matter how inconvenient that is for anybody's chronology narrative.
- mkl 4y agoThe Cerutti mastodon site seems pretty far from unambiguous: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cerutti_Mastodon_site#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cerutti_Mastodon_site#Criticis...
- moloch-hai 4y agoWikipedia is the last place to consult for current scholarship. Pages are typically "curated" by retired professors with an ax to grind, who carefully scrub anything that contradicts their grad-school thesis. The criticisms that have been thoroughly debunked keep surfacing again. Most egregiously, BS about construction machinery. The only legitimate criticism I have seen is that they didn't find flakes from stone blade maintenance, or a hearth. Of course, that work could have happened 50 feet away, or 500, and not been found. There is way more than enough evidence without.
- Beltalowda 4y ago> Now that we have the unambiguous Cerutti Mastodon site from 130kya, it might need to be re-evaluated. I don't think you can describe that as "unambiguous"; there is plenty of criticism. The other site you're referring to is the Calico site, which was excavated by Louis Leakey, Richard Leaky's father. It wasn't just that there were "too many" of them, it was also that the presence could be explained by natural phenomenon. Does this prove it wasn't human-made? No. But given everything else we know, it's unlikely. > Generally the null hypothesis is that people went anywhere they could go whenever they could, no matter how inconvenient that is for anybody's chronology narrative. That's not really how that works. The first evidence of modern humans is in Africa about 300,000 years ago. The first evidence of humans anywhere outside of Africa is about 200,000 years ago, in the middle-east. East-Asia about 80,000 years ago; Australia: 65,000 years ago. 130,000 or 200,000 years ago just doesn't fit in with ... anything. Perhaps pre-modern humans arrived in the Americas much earlier; but AFAIK there is no evidence of that either, or considered very plausible.
- rkagerer 4y agoAre there photos?
- rkagerer 4y agoI initially misread this as being about a monkey with a toolsheld.
- aksss 4y ago“Shed doubts”??? Since when is that a turn of phrase? You “cast” doubt (like a shadow), and “shed” light.
- skupig 4y agoIf you can shed light on something, why can't you shed a couple doubts on it too?
- slowmovintarget 4y agoBecause that would be ridding yourself of doubt, not gaining new doubts.
- benj111 4y agoIf you "shed light" are you not casting light or exposing to light the subject? So in this context you would gaining new doubt. I always assumed this came from shod as in a horse shod with shoes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jfk13 4y agoFor some discussion, see https://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=3828 https://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=3828
- Wolfenstein98k 4y ago"Monkey stone tools shed..." For a second I read it that way and thought "Bloody hell they've got toolsheds now?"
- mumblemumble 4y agoI only skimmed the article, but I just wanted to point out that the provided HN title differs significantly from the actual paper title, in a way that is potentially misleading. The stone tools use in question is not the flintknapping that we usually think of. It is, in essence, just picking up a rock and using it as a hammer to bash things. Nor is this paper purported to reset the timeline on early human anthropology. The archaeological sites in question are a specific set of sites in Brazil where evidence of that kind of tool use had been interpreted by some to be evidence of early human presence in the Americas. As the article itself points out, though, that has been a subject of debate for decades. The earliest citation for the monkey hypothesis for the origin of these sites that I noticed the article mentioning is from 25 years ago.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 4y agoWe used to think that humans were the only animals to use tools, but this was disproven long ago: otters use rocks to break open shellfish, birds use tools to create their nests, etc. Then, we thought that humans were the only animals to fashion tools, not merely pick up objects from their environment. This was also disproven. Primates sharpen sticks to hunt, bend twigs to get ants out of trees, etc. Today, we believe humans' unique relationship to tools is recursive: we're the only animal ever observed to use a tool to make a tool. It's this capacity for self-referential thought that sets us apart from the rest of the creatures on earth. There's tremendous intelligence in the animal kingdom: Octopuses and crows can solve complex problems, dogs can manipulate humans, dolphins can transmit visual imagines to one another through sound. But self-referential thought is why a human built this website and other animals could not.
- bl0rg 4y agoThere’s always something that sets us apart, isn’t there? Something that makes “us” better than “them”. Or so we tell ourselves as we continue to rape the planet and kill our cohabitants. The mind can be quite resourceful when faced with cognitive dissonance.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 4y agoI attended a talk in college by a guy who had measured a bunch of cultural attitudes toward animals, nature, the environment, etc. from different cultures all around the world, then ranked them from most empathetic to least empathetic. He found the #1 contributing factor to be whether or not that human population coexists with monkeys. Monkeys are the link that connect us to the animal world. Looking at the face of a creature that is similar to your own is tremendously powerful. I think it's natural to wonder about our place in the world, but you're right: we shouldn't think of ourselves as distinct from it.