15 ms·
Who cares about returns over the next 150 years? Even half that is excessive. Someone investing at age 18 might care about the subsequent 50 years. It's goin
by gumby 4y ago
Who cares about returns over the next 150 years? Even half that is excessive. Someone investing at age 18 might care about the subsequent 50 years.
It's going to be a long time before some other country takes over the "reserve currency/investment market of last resort" position the US currently has. No other market is even close to providing the deep liquidity and rule of law the US market has over a wide variety of instruments.
Sure, someone will eventually take over that role, but there are no candidates today. And, to your point: it was clear by the late 19th century that the US dollar would displace Sterling, but it took another half a century for that to happen. On the scale of current human lifespan, you can assume it won't happen at all.
- ganonm 4y agoKeep in mind that the present value depends somewhat on the discounted future earnings, which by definition extends to the end of time. That being said, the associated time discounting heavily reduces the impact of earnings envisaged say 100 years from now (a 5% discount rate would mean ~13k USD in 100 years is worth about 100 USD now, and that's probably generous given historic market returns). So, the US doing extremely well 100 years from now vs. the US doing very badly 100 years from now could have a non-trivial impact on the perceived value of US assets. I suspect that the large uncertainty about what the world will look like in 100 years means there is just some sort of seldom changing value baked into assets to account for this, but it nonetheless exists, and could change if there was some huge geopolitical shift. And before you mention anyone on earth would be dead in 150 years, yes that's true, however you can always sell it to someone later on who will be alive in 150 years (or sell it to someone who can later sell it to someone etc. etc.).
- mint2 4y agoIs that actually how it works? Money has to go somewhere regardless of future. Whatever looks the least bad at present is in demand, regardless of what the returns are. Inflation was above tbill rates yet people bought because they don’t have better options. It’s like food. Food in 100 years does not help the need for food now.
- kqr 4y agoFood perishes faster han equity indices. If there was a futures market in foodstuffs that basically keep forever and is cheap to store (honey?) you would see that the expected price of that food in 100 years would have some effect on the current price.
- nonethewiser 4y agoIn theory maybe, but I'm not sure this is right. The further out you go the more worthless expectations on returns become. Who actually has high confidence in a price model projecting 100 years out? What organization has the conviction to execute on this 100 year plan instead of signals with real correlation for returns over 1, 5, 10, 20 years?
- itsoktocry 4y ago>Someone investing at age 18 might care about the subsequent 50 years Those 50 years are part of the next 150, and are no easier to forecast. Most market projections are for numbers ~7% annually, but periods worse than that would drastically alter investing plans, and hence social infrastructure planning.
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoThat is why https://www.firecalc.com/ https://www.firecalc.com/ exists. The idea is that you save enough that over all the possible starting years, you would end up with money instead of broke, for the length of time you think you'll be alive.
- kudokatz 4y agoIt's my understanding that firecalc uses only US data. Japan has "lost decades" of price-weighted, non-dividend returns that are flat since 1988 (Nikkei 225). Seems worth considering that some version of this has some future probability of happening in the US and hedging that. Another similar and popular US-data-only tool that is fun to play with is cFIREsim: https://www.cfiresim.com/ https://www.cfiresim.com/ (Edit: of course, US companies have non-US revenues - helps out a bit)
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoYes, that's a risk. If that happens, most of us simply won't ever retire. Yay capitalism?
- paganel 4y ago> Most market projections are for numbers ~7% annually, Too lazy to web search for an answer, but are those real returns? (i.e. inflation-adjusted).
- hammock 4y ago100-year bond spot rate: https://alfred.stlouisfed.org/series?seid=HQMCB100YR&utm_source=series_page&utm_medium=related_content&utm_term=related_resources&utm_campaign=alfred https://alfred.stlouisfed.org/series?seid=HQMCB100YR&utm_sou...
- kingkawn 4y agoYour assumptions presume that the pace of historical developments is the same as it was in the late 19th century, which seems clearly untrue. The rate that these things transform today may be breathtaking.
- MuffinFlavored 4y ago> Someone investing at age 18 might care about the subsequent 50 years. With a gradual decline in exposure to equities over time. https://www.google.com/search?q=what+asset+allocation+should+i+have+by+age https://www.google.com/search?q=what+asset+allocation+should...
- ideamotor 4y agoThis is terrible advice. It’s more complicated than this and depends on your situation (age, social security, pensions, tax deferred account timing) but generally you want less stocks when you enter retirement but gradually going back up in retirement.
- ambicapter 4y agoWhy going back up in retirement?
- ideamotor 4y agoI'll respond in more detail later but here is a paper that examines it: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2324930 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2324930: "Accordingly, as the results support, for those looking to maximize their level of sustainable retirement income, and/or to reduce the potential magnitude of any shortfalls in adverse scenarios, portfolios that start off in the vicinity of 20% to 40% in equities and rise to the level of 60% to 80% in equities generally perform better than static rebalanced portfolios or declining equity glidepaths. Though as the results also reveal, in particular scenarios where the equity risk premium is depressed, the optimal glidepath includes less equity, and in scenarios where the goal is to withdraw at a level that stresses the portfolio and its expected growth rate, higher overall levels of equity are necessary; with such high-risk goals, having a relatively high-risk portfolio, with the danger that entails, is still the optimal solution (and for clients who cannot tolerate that level of risk, the ideal solution is to choose not a less risky portfolio, but a less risky and aggressive goal). Nonetheless, for everyone else looking to maximize a sustainable income level, or determine the amount of assets to support a (reasonable) target income level, rising equity glidepaths appear to both maximize the likelihood of success and sustainable income and reduce the magnitude of shortfalls when they occur." There is a a lot of discussion of this here: https://www.bogleheads.org/index.php https://www.bogleheads.org/index.php. Also, this article: https://www.kitces.com/blog/should-equity-exposure-decrease-in-retirement-or-is-a-rising-equity-glidepath-actually-better/ https://www.kitces.com/blog/should-equity-exposure-decrease-....
- zie 4y ago> Someone investing at age 18 might care about the subsequent 50 years. I get what you are saying, but your math here is a bit off. 50+18 = 68. People generally can live longer than 68 years old, If we go out on longevity and assume people can live to 100 or 120, then it's more like 100 years. Your next thought is, but people will retire before/around 68, fair enough, but they stay invested generally the entire rest of their lives. So if the US dominance ends in the next 100 years, then today's teenagers might need to care about it. People in their 30's or 40's probably don't though. The next 150 years, you are right todays teenagers might not need to care, unless many/all of our aspirational longer living goals happen.
- purpleblue 4y agoNo, this is poor investment advice. The closer you get to retirement, the more your money should be in extremely short term, non-volatile investments like T-bills. You should not be invested in the stock market, because the risk is too high that you could lose a lot of your savings just before you really need it.
- zie 4y agoI never talked about asset allocation, you did, but going 100% equities to 0% equities is not reasonable either. Yes you probably want some bonds, but you still need some equities. The default answer is something around 20% to 60% equities in retirement.
- FooBarBizBazz 4y agoEverybody says this, but stocks and bonds go up and down together now. I guess it's less an issue if you're holding bonds to maturity and laddering, but that might just be psychological, not sure.
- zie 4y agoNot really, they are somewhat correlated, but they are not completely correlated. Duration has a lot to do with it as well. Look up Long Term Treasuries(TLT/EDV are funds that hold these) and compare that to US stocks like VTI. Bonds are like buying future cash-flow, stocks are about future growth. i.e. if you buy a bond that's paying you $25k/yr, then you will get that $25k/yr regardless of what happens to the NAV until maturity(and/or bankruptcy obviously).
- time_to_smile 4y agoOr we see a contraction in globalization in general in which all economies shrink. It's entirely reasonable that we could enter a period of long, slow decline across the board. Especially as we continue to push the limits of natural resources and global supply chains. For example suppose the US continues to move its push to return chip manufacturing to the US. This might mean both that US chip manufactures have a more healthy future than other more fragile tech companies and that they shrink in size. We could see a return of manufacturing to the US which leads to continued employment in US labor for while also meaning that labor force gets paid much less. We're already starting to see evidence of this happening. The concerning thing is that I'm not at all sure that our incredibly debt dependent global economy, which assumes future growth, can really handle a gradual contraction to a more sustainable economic structure. Either way, assuming up is the only way for the market to go is a very naive assumption, but one nobody is happy questioning.
- vl 4y ago>We could see a return of manufacturing to the US which leads to continued employment in US labor for while also meaning that labor force gets paid much less. Interesting! Why is it happening? Shouldn’t labor earn more in this scenario?
- bluGill 4y agoDepends. Manufacturing in the US implies high automation. For those who maintain the machines there is a lot of money, but there are far less jobs and in turn far less in total in labor. Though I suspect there is more need for such labor than people who can do the job. Hard to say, but there are a lot of things we haven't automated yet.
- verdverm 4y ago> a gradual contraction to a more sustainable economic structure Why do you assume that it requires a contraction to reach a sustainable economic structure? What prevents the economy from growing for the foreseeable future while also becoming more sustainable at the same time?
- dalbasal 4y agoWhy is "reserve currency" the central issue? Also, the US stock market, US Dollar and US economy/gdp aren't hard linked to one another these days. The companies listed can be selling to non US markets, employing internationally, founded internationally. They're just listing on the US stock market because well.. that's where the stock market is. The US could, in theory, become more or less popular a stock market regardless of its currency's popularity. Meanwhile, both the Euro and RMB have similar size markets backing their currency. Neither one is currently trying to displace the USD. I think the importance of owning the international currency is somewhat speculative.
- bobthepanda 4y agoYeah, China has already indicated that it would prefer the ability to implement sudden, nearly total capital controls rather than be annoyed with the day-to-day of a reserve currency.
- malandrew 4y agoStock markets are natural monopolies. Liquidity begets liquidity. What would cause companies to choose other exchanges and what stops the dominant exchanges from adapting to changes that threaten its liquidity advantage. Is there anything stopping the NYSE, Nasdaq or CME/CBOT from handling trades in another currency?
- gumby 4y ago> Is there anything stopping the NYSE, Nasdaq or CME/CBOT from handling trades in another currency? It would reduce liquidity. Equity prices would fluctuate not only on buy/sell basis but exchange rates. Sure, computers could figure all that out these days but what's the advantage? Overwhelmingly, equity buyers and sellers (not "traders") buy in their local currency because they use the money to live in a local economy. Companies list in other countries for access to those countries' buyers. What would be the point of Shell listing in Euro on the NYSE? They want to list in dollars. Nobody outside Nigeria lists on its exchange but local companies do because local people understand the companies and everything (both their operations and their stock) is in naira. So if you want to be an exchange in a different currency, just buy a local exchange. NASDAQ did try to buy the London Stock Exchange, though I think it fell through.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Spooky23 4y agoIt should give pause to people who think that the stock market is some sort of science. Macroeconomic conditions and policy influence this stuff.
- acchow 4y agoHow can anyone assume the next 30-50 years of the US economy will be anything like its rise to superpower over the last 150 years.
- refurb 4y agoSure, but how can anyone assume it won’t be? If you’ve been alive long enough you’ve realize the “end of US dominance” has been in headlines since the 60’s.
- roenxi 4y ago1. After what happened to Russia every planner in China has "the US government seizes our assets" as a plausible in the next 50 years. 2. It is implausible that the US will ever pay back its foreign debts in real terms. Anyone who lends to them will end up with less stuff in total. 3. We live in an age of computers and pervasive digital communication; things can happen a lot more quickly these days than in the 50s. 4. There is a consistent trend of dropping energy security in Western countries. This is no time to be forecasting assuming things will happen at a comfortable pace. People should have contingencies ready in case something unprecedented happens. It is tense out there.
- the_doctah 4y agoWhat kind of contingencies? Money in mattress?
- roenxi 4y agoI've got no particular clue. But if the plan is to assume things happen slowly over 50 years then that is a risky plan. If things play out like in the 1900s, we could see an entire world war play out over 5 years and that'd likely break the US dollar. Or some similar shock. We still don't really understand the impacts of the COVID pandemic and what that is doing in China. > Money in mattress? The response to every crisis the US has had for the last 3 decades is to print and borrow increasingly large amounts money. And they are probably the most responsible fiscal controller around at the moment. If you see that changing for some reason then sure, maybe money under the mattress could help. I don't expect that strategy to change myself, and the last thing I'd want under my mattress is money.
- bee_rider 4y agoWhat does investing with possible WW3 taken into account look like? Heavy on canned food, bullets, and remote real estate I guess? Assuming nuclear weapons don’t just magically vanish.
- nonethewiser 4y ago
- newyankee 4y agoMy understanding is that development in some modern areas is exponential. This is the reason why China grew so fast. So a case could be made for faster timelines. US may not slow considerably but it will stop leading and being the only one.