6 ms·
Caroline Ellison Plea Hearing Transcript (12/19/2022) [pdf]
- JCM9 4y agoA lot of checks and balances in there to make sure the defendant knows what they’re doing and can’t claim later they want to change their mind. The government’s strategy on these sort of cases is to take out the little people with deals, get them to flip on the big boss, and then throw the book at the boss. They seem to be following that playbook here.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- akiselev 4y ago> THE COURT: And I say that because no one here knows for sure what your sentence will be -- your lawyers don't, the government doesn't, I don't -- because that's not going to be determined until a later date, after I get a presentence report from the probation department, I calculate the guidelines, I get submissions from you, the government and the probation department. > But even if your sentence is different from what you had hoped for or expected, you won't be allowed to withdraw your plea on that basis. IANAL but this makes it look like the case is so strong against her that she's just throwing herself at the mercy of the courts. All the cooperation buys her is brownie points with the judge, who might decide to make an example out of her anyway. They didn't even really have to flip her, she just walked in the front door.
- cm2187 4y agoBut if judges keept fucking people who enter those pleas to get a lighter sentence, that would defeat the purpose of those plea deals, and people would take their chance at trial, so I'd assume there is an incentive for the court to play ball.
- twelve40 4y agoWhat possible chance does she have at trial? To claim that she was zombified alive by her evil boyfriend? Because the rest of it seems pretty 2+2: there were X billion dollars, now thanks to these two CEOs and their friends, there is none. So it appears as if she flipped not out of goodness of her heart, or a fierce desire to restore justice, but because it's the only sane thing to do to save one's ass.
- wl 4y agoThat’s a standard admonishment given to the accused when they are accepting a plea deal. The only thing the prosecution can offer is a recommendation to the sentencing judge. Usually the judges agree, but they don’t always.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> That’s a standard admonishment given to the accused when they are accepting a plea deal. In the federal system. Like the bail situation, one of the reasons this violates people’s expectation is the federal system does not work the same as most state systems.
- whoiscroberts 4y agoIt’s also important that they don’t agree on a sentence too early because they might find out she played a larger role than they assume at this point.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> important that they don’t agree on a sentence too early The point is the prosecutor can’t agree to a deal. They can agree to recommend this or that. But a judge ultimately sentenced.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> It’s also important that they don’t agree on a sentence too early because they might find out she played a larger role than they assume at this point. There is no such thing as a sentencing agreement in the US federal system. At most, the defense and prosecution, when it gets to that point, could agree on recommendations, but the judge would still be free to disagree.
- jojobas 4y agoHer decision-making is possibly as affected by drugs as SBF's. They were a self-confessed stimulant mob.
- draw_down 4y agoHmm. I guess I don’t usually think of people in CEO positions as small fries. It’s not clear to me that ~100% of the blame for all this falls on the one guy.
- jiggawatts 4y agoThe relevant bit is her testimony, during which she throws SBF under the bus and drives back and forth to make sure he's going down with her: THE COURT: Now, tell me in your own words what you did that makes you believe that you are guilty of these crimes. THE DEFENDANT: From approximately March 2018 through November 2022, I worked at Alameda Research, a cryptocurrency trading firm principally owned by Sam Bankman-Fried. At Alameda Research, I first worked as a cryptocurrency trader and was later appointed by Mr. Bankman-Fried as the co-CEO and eventually CEO of Alameda Research Ltd., the subsidiary that housed the firm's main trading and market making operations. In those roles, I reported to Mr. Bankman-Fried. From 2019 through 2022, I was aware that Alameda was provided access to a borrowing facility on FTX.com, the cryptocurrency exchange run by Mr. Bankman-Fried. I understood that FTX executives had implemented special settings on Alameda's FTX.com account that permitted Alameda to maintain negative balances in various fiat currencies and crypto currencies. In practical terms, this arrangement permitted Alameda access to an unlimited line of credit without being required to post collateral, without having to pay interest on negative balances and without being subject to margin calls or FTX.com's liquidation protocols. I understood that if Alameda's FTX accounts had significant negative balances in any particular currency, it meant that Alameda was borrowing funds that FTX's customers had deposited onto the exchange. While I was co-CEO and then CEO, I understood that Alameda had made numerous large illiquid venture investments and had lent money to Mr. Bankman-Fried and other FTX executives. I also understood that Alameda had financed these investments with short-term and open-term loans worth several billion dollars from external lenders in the cryptocurrency industry. When many of those loans were recalled by Alameda's lenders in and around June 2022, I agreed with others to borrow several billion dollars from FTX to repay those loans. I understood that FTX would need to use customer funds to finance its loans to Alameda. I also understood that many FTX customers invested in crypto derivatives and that most FTX customers did not expect that FTX would lend out their digital asset holdings and fiat currency deposits to Alameda in this fashion. From in and around July 2022 through at least October 2022, I agreed with Mr. Bankman-Fried and others to provide materially misleading financial statements to Alameda's lenders. In furtherance of this agreement, for example, we prepared certain quarterly balance sheets that concealed the extent of Alameda's borrowing and the billions of dollars in loans that Alameda had made to FTX executives and to related parties. I also understood that FTX had not disclosed to FTX's equity investors that Alameda could borrow a potentially unlimited amount from FTX, thereby putting customer assets at risk. I agreed with Mr. Bankman-Fried and others not to publicly disclose the true nature of the relationship between Alameda and FTX, including Alameda's credit arrangement. I also understood that Mr. Bankman-Fried and others funded certain investments in amounts more than $10,000 with customer funds that FTX had lent to Alameda. The investments were done in the name of Alameda instead of FTX in order to conceal the source and nature of those funds. I am truly sorry for what I did. I knew that it was wrong. And I want to apologize for my actions to the affected customers of FTX, lenders to Alameda and investors in FTX. Since FTX and Alameda collapsed in November 2022, I have worked hard to assist with the recovery of assets for the benefit of customers and to cooperate with the government's investigation. I am here today to accept responsibility for my actions by pleading guilty.
- Diesel555 4y agoThe actual statement portion after all the understandings > THE DEFENDANT: From approximately March 2018 through November 2022, I worked at Alameda Research, a cryptocurrency trading firm principally owned by Sam Bankman-Fried. At Alameda Research, I first worked as a cryptocurrency trade and was later appointed by Mr. Bankman-Fried as the co-CEO and eventually CEO of Alameda Research Ltd., the subsidiary that housed the firm's main trading and market making operations. In those roles, I reported to Mr. Bankman-Fried. From 2019 through 2022, I was aware that Alameda was provided access to a borrowing facility on FTX.com, the cryptocurrency exchange run by Mr. Bankman-Fried. I understood that FTX executives had implemented special settings on Alameda's FTX.com account that permitted Alameda to maintain negative balances in various fiat currencies and crypto currencies. In practical terms, this arrangement permitted Alameda access to an unlimited line of credit without being required to post collateral, without having to pay interest on negative balances and without being subject to margin calls or FTX.com's liquidation protocols. I understood that if Alameda's FTX accounts had significant negative balances in any particular currency, it meant that Alameda was borrowing funds that FTX's customers had deposited onto the exchange. While I was co-CEO and then CEO, I understood that Alameda had made numerous large illiquid venture investments and had lent money to Mr. Bankman-Fried and other FTX executives. I also understood that Alameda had financed these investments with short-term and open-term loans worth several billion dollars from external lenders in the cryptocurrency industry. When many of those loans were recalled by lenders in and around June 2022, I agreed with others to borrow several billion dollars from FTX to repay those loans. I understood that FTX would need to use customer funds to finance its loans to Alameda. I also understood that many FTX customers invested in crypto derivatives and that most FTX customers did not expect that FTX would lend out their digital asset holdings and fiat currency deposits to Alameda in this fashion. From in and around July 2022 through at least October 2022, I agreed with Mr. Bankman-Fried and others to provide materially misleading financial statements to Alameda's lenders. In furtherance of this agreement, for example, we prepared certain quarterly balance sheets that concealed the extent of Alameda's borrowing and the billions of dollars in loans that Alameda had made to FTX executives and to related parties. I also understood that FTX had not disclosed to FTX's equity investors that Alameda could borrow a potentially unlimited amount from FTX, thereby putting customer assets at risk. I agreed with Mr. Bankman-Fried and others not to publicly disclose the true nature of the relationship between Alameda and FTX, including Alameda's credit arrangement. I also understood that Mr. Bankman-Fried and others funded certain investments in amounts more than $10,000 with customer funds that FTX had lent to Alameda. The investments were done in the name of Alameda instead of FTX in order to conceal the source and nature of those funds. I am truly sorry for what I did. I knew that it was wrong. And I want to apologize for my actions to the affected customers of FTX, lenders to Alameda and investors in FTX. Since FTX and Alameda collapsed in November 2022, I have worked hard to assist with the recovery of assets for the benefit of customers and to cooperate with the government's investigation. I am here today to accept responsibility for my actions by pleading guilty.
- berkle4455 4y agoTL;DR: Yes x55
- courtPedant 4y agoI count 59 yes’s from Caro and 3 yups.
- nostoploss 4y agoHow many counts of stop loss?
- kerblang 4y ago> So the maximum sentences for Counts One, Two, Three and Four are all the same, so I'm going to read them together, okay, at once. So with respect to your liberty, the maximum term of imprisonment for each of the four counts, One through Four, is 20 years in prison. > With respect to your liberty on Counts Five and Six, the maximum term of imprisonment for each count is five years > And then lastly, on Count Seven, that has a maximum term of imprisonment of 20 years Whoa
- mhneu 4y agoThe maximum total is not the realistic maximum that she would get if tried. Criminal offense category, concurrent sentences, and criminal history all need to be taken into account.
- mhneu 4y agoBefore judge Ronnie Abrams, an Obama judge.
- greenyoda 4y agoJudge Abrams is no longer involved in the case. She recused herself due to a potential conflict of interest: https://www.businessinsider.com/ftx-collapse-sbf-judge-stepped-down-alameda-wang-ellison-abrams-2022-12 https://www.businessinsider.com/ftx-collapse-sbf-judge-stepp... "...the case was reassigned to Lewis A. Kaplan, a senior judge at the court, legal filings show." Kaplan was appointed by Bill Clinton in 1994: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lewis_A._Kaplan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lewis_A._Kaplan
- mhneu 4y agoYes. Abrams presided over the plea on Dec 19. Now Kaplan has the case. Abrams' husband works at Davis Polk, but Davis Polk (firm w/ ~1000 attorneys) has represented FTX in the past. It's pretty typical for these sorts of conflicts to arise, and in this case it's probably best to remove any sniff of a perceived conflict by Abrams stepping aside. Nothing here is going to be controversial -- though our federal courts are currently going through serious turmoil due to events of last few years, albeit not really SDNY and the 2nd Circuit is mostly normal too.
- plugger 4y agowhy would this matter in the slightest?
- draw_down 4y ago[dead]
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoIt's worth reading. Pretty vanilla fraud. Take funds from entity X, lend them to entity Y, lend them to Mr BF. Don't tell anyone it's being done, including and especially all the people putting money into entity X. Make up some nice fake balance sheets to hide it.
- anonu 4y agoI think it's not really worth reading. No new information. Other than her saying yup and yes to almost every question, we also know she had a beer last night at 8pm.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoIt's information to me (and it will be to a lot of people i suspect). I never saw what happened reported anywhere so succinctly. There was a lot of speculation reported.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AlexanderTheGr8 4y ago> So even if you did nothing or said nothing at trial, you could not be convicted unless a jury of 12 people agreed unanimously that you are guilty They need to unanimously agree? So, one bad/corrupt juror could render anyone not guilty? I thought it would be majority or 3/4 majority (as they do for some bills in parliament). Unanimous seems pretty risky.
- papa-whisky 4y ago> So, one bad/corrupt juror could render anyone not guilty? No, they need to unanimously agree on either guilty or not guilty. A hung jury would result in a retrial.
- Lazare 4y ago"It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer." That comes from Blackstone (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio), and has been a bedrock principle of justice in English, English inspired justice systems, including the US. Historically unanimous juries were required in criminal trials through the English speaking world, and that's still true in the US, Canada, and NZ at least. For a period of time criminal trials at a state level could have majority verdicts in Louisiana and Oregon, but a recent Supreme Court case (Ramos v. Louisiana) declared this unconstituional, and federal cases (as here) always required unanimous verdicts. Somewhat oddly the UK has allowed majority verdicts in some criminal trials since 1967 (although I believe they're generally rare and somewhat controvesial), as does Australia. But they're very much the outliers. > Unanimous seems pretty risky. Generally speaking, allowing a pure majority has been seen as the risky option, given the stakes. (Much the same logic applies to the standard of proof required, which is "beyond reasonable doubt", otherwise phrased as there being no plausible reason to believe the accused might not be guilty. Obviously it would be much easier to achieve a guilty verdict if the standard was "preponderance of the evidence", but the goal of the system is justice, not guilty verdicts.) Some history here: https://corkerbinning.com/jury-unanimity-uk-us-verdict/ https://corkerbinning.com/jury-unanimity-uk-us-verdict/
- DaveExeter 4y ago>They need to unanimously agree? Hmm. How can I explain this. Human beings are social animals and go along with the crowd. There are not 12 independent decision makers on a jury. Most jurors are followers, and will be persuaded by another member of the jury. We decide what to think based upon what others think. >So, one bad/corrupt juror could render anyone not guilty? No, that's called a hung jury. Gov't can try again.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- DonsDiscountGas 4y agoCan somebody explain to me what their endgame plan was? They stole what, $10B? Did they think that would just blow over or something? Follow-up question: Let's say that 6-12 months ago Alameda went bust, and FTX didn't steal all their customers funds to bail them out. Presumably Alameda fails. Maybe FTX fails too depending on their state, but they return all their customers funds first. Is that possible? I dunno if any crypto-related company has ever shut down cleanly so I don't know how it would work. It seems like it would be a better option though, they'd have dented reputations from a failed hedge fund/business but y'know, not any fraud.
- Cipater 4y agoStarted out making investments/bets with loan money thinking they would make it back with profit since they're oh so smart. Bets fail, they pour more money into it on hail Mary shots, they lose that too. Lenders want their money back so they use customer funds to pay them back because they have access to it and loans have to be paid back. Meanwhile they've also been enriching themselves personally, living large in the Bahamas and what not. Boils down to 2 things. 1. They were unscrupulous from day 1 and implemented a system with no restrictions or checks on their ability to move money around. In addition, they were comfortable with straight up lying to customers and lenders about the 2. They believed their own hype.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bigtones 4y agoTLDR - Calorine Ellison is pleading guilty to 4 counts: * conspiracy to commit wire fraud on customers * conspiracy to commit wire fraud on lenders * conspiracy to commit securities fraud * conspiracy to commit money laundering She is waiving the right to appeal, must be a witness for the prosecution, and she is agreeing that the maximum sentence recommendation imposed on her is 20 years in jail and a $250k fine.