7 ms·
Caltech to launch space solar power technology demo into orbit
- WalterBright 4y agoIn January 2023, the Caltech Space Solar Power Project (SSPP) is poised to launch into orbit a prototype, dubbed the Space Solar Power Demonstrator (SSPD), which will test several key components of an ambitious plan to harvest solar power in space and beam the energy back to Earth.
- wrycoder 4y agoIt launched successfully. I’ll point out that a space-based solar array with a microwave power downlink was on the front cover of IEEE Spectrum around 1971. The article ran the numbers and pointed out the technical challenges. So, this idea is not new, but it hasn’t gained enough support over the last fifty years to get a project off the ground.
- xxr 4y agoI first learned about the idea from SimCity 2000[0]. Not saying it was the impetus here, but I wonder what amount of the continuing interest in orbital power is due to SC2k. (I suspect my experience is not unique here on HN, but I wonder about the "general" public.) [0]https://simcity.fandom.com/wiki/Microwave_Power_Plant https://simcity.fandom.com/wiki/Microwave_Power_Plant
- LarryMullins 4y agoSeems plausible, for millennials at least. SimCity 2000 was one of those games that seemed to be in every public school computer lab in the late 90s and early 00s. Tons of people played it, more than just the usual audience for management/business sims.
- DennisP 4y agoModern designs are a lot different than those monolithic '70s designs. Now it's a bunch of mass-produced small parts self-assembled in orbit, with a phased-array transmitter. Manufacturing's way cheaper that way, once you start scaling a bit. (See NASA's SPS-ALPHA project or the book The Case for Space Solar Power.) The other big change is the prospect of $50/kg to LEO with Starship. Falcon Heavy's advertised price is already down to $600/kg.
- tzs 4y agoIt's been an idea in science fiction even longer. E.g., the 1941 short story "Reason" by Isaac Asimov was set in an orbiting power station with a microwave downlink [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reason_(short_story) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reason_(short_story)
- waltbosz 4y agoI was wondering if anyone would mention "Reason". The power station is just the setting for the story, the plot is about a humorous argument between the two humans running the station and a robot who they are training to take over their jobs. I wonder where Asimov got his idea for the technology. Did he just make it up? Or was inspired by existing technology of the 1940s.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI wasn't a huge believer in this project when I was at Caltech, but I'm glad they stuck to it and are getting something off the ground. It's an interesting tradeoff of RF losses vs losses to solar power non-ideality. The theory looks great, but I do wonder if the theory can be met in practice.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf it works in Earth orbit, it will also work in lunar orbit where it can solve the most expensive barrier to a moon base - power. So, although it may be too expensive for Earth power, it can be very practical for moon power.
- dghughes 4y agoWouldn't solar panels on the moon be easier? No atmosphere and on always being blasted with sunshine.
- josh11b 4y agoThere is no place on the moon that isn't in shadow 14 days at a time. https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2022/07/03/powering-the-lunar-base-version-2/ https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2022/07/03/powering-the-l...
- amelius 4y agoNear the poles?
- Fordec 4y agoOnly works if your bases are at the poles. Which for some missions works, but it's a limitation if your project needs to be anywhere else.
- Nomentatus 4y ago
- IshKebab 4y agoAh I was wondering how something like this could go ahead when it's pretty obviously a terrible idea to engineers. > SSPP got its start in 2011 after philanthropist Donald Bren, chairman of Irvine Company and a lifetime member of the Caltech Board of Trustees, learned about the potential for space-based solar energy manufacturing in an article in the magazine Popular Science. Intrigued by the potential for space solar power, Bren approached Caltech's then-president Jean-Lou Chameau to discuss the creation of a space-based solar power research project. In 2013, Bren and his wife, Brigitte Bren, a Caltech trustee, agreed to make the donation to fund the project. The first of the donations to Caltech (which will eventually exceed $100 million in support for the project and endowed professorships) was made that year through the Donald Bren Foundation, and the research began. "Ok nobody tell him it's a bad idea and we get like 50 PhDs and 5 professors!"
- p1esk 4y agoYou forgot to explain why this is "pretty obviously a terrible idea".
- thisisbrians 4y agoSome ideas about what makes it challenging: - A satellite will have to transmit power through the entire atmosphere from space, which will have substantial losses even in perfect conditions - A satellite constellation in orbit would need many ground stations to transmit power to from space - Weather will get in the way of transmission to the ground, just like it does with ordinary solar - The cost of getting a PV array into orbit is very expensive relative to the amount of power it can generate and transmit
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> satellite will have to transmit power through the entire atmosphere from space, which will have substantial losses even in perfect conditions Balancing this is at least a half an order of magnitude difference in collection efficiency. > Weather will get in the way of transmission to the ground, just like it does with ordinary solar True. But there are extraterrestrial atmospheres where water vapor and ozone aren’t a problem. (I’ve only seen this proposed with microwave.) > cost of getting a PV array into orbit is very expensive relative to the amount of power it can generate and transmit This is the killer. That said, this is a long-term research endeavour. If we contemplate such an array around the Moon or on Mars, or in a world with in-space resource extraction and manufacturing, the economics shift.
- c-smile 4y agoProblem is not in harvesting the energy but in delivering it. The only reasonable option is to beam highly energetic beam back to Earth. Do we want us to be browned by l/masers from the orbit?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> only reasonable option is to beam highly energetic beam back to Earth This is how we should do it. But we can’t. Fortunately, the sat-to-sat laser folks are working on that kit. In the meantime, these proposals tend to focus on microwaves. In any case, to the degree this one day has an economic case around Earth, it’s in powering low-orbit satellites. Not punching through the atmosphere. That said, I don’t have any obvious near-term high-power use cases for a LEO constellation.
- c-smile 4y ago> to focus on microwaves Ah, it will be masers then ... and so together with masks we will wear saucepans ... We do not need additional energy to be delivered to the Earth from outside, we are warming it already. Instead we need to harvest energy that is heating up Earth surface already.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> do not need additional energy to be delivered to the Earth from outside, we are warming it already Waste heat isn't our problem. > we need to harvest energy that is heating up Earth surface already If we're being artistic that's what an in-orbit solar panel, which at least part of the time blocks photons from reaching the Earth, does.
- throwaway4aday 4y agoWhy have I been seeing this egregiously wrong idea everywhere lately? Delivering power in the form of microwaves to the Earth is not going to cause any warming. Even if we were to purposefully beam it straight into the ocean and heat the water we just aren't capable of delivering enough wattage to make a serious difference. The reason global warming is a concern is because of the greenhouse effect of CO2 trapping the Suns heat which is an energy input that we can't even come close to approximating.
- notum 4y agoCloud cover doesn't affect microwaves?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Cloud cover doesn't affect microwaves? It does. (Ozone and water absorb microwaves. This is how your microwave oven works.)
- Nomentatus 4y agoMicrowaves are highly tuned to the particular frequency that causes water molecules to resonate. But this is just one microwave frequency. You don't have to use that one. https://www.gi.alaska.edu/news/using-microwaves-see-through-clouds https://www.gi.alaska.edu/news/using-microwaves-see-through-...
- notum 4y agoTo expand on my semi-sarcasm with a proper question: so there's a microwave frequency that is completely unaffected by atmospherics? In which water, ozone, the rest of the gas mixure and particulates are mostly transparent? What frequency spectrum is that? And for bonus points: can this project fry commercial planes?
- Nomentatus 4y agoFirst sentence: not what was said. But note that microwave towers have been in use for mission-critical long-range all-weather point-to-point communication on earth for many, many decades. My late father helped design some of them. What would the minimum power loss be for thick cloud/hurricane? Dunno.
- notum 4y agoAs synonymous comms and power delivery may look, they are a different ball game. This also seems to be the last nail in the coffin for terrestrial radio astronomy, now that you mention it.
- cratermoon 4y agoSee also https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/03/space-based-solar-power/ https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/03/space-based-solar-power/
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoDoes anyone have a recent list of power-constrained activities on satellites in LEO? That is, something you'd like to be able to do but can't because putting albatrosses of panels on low-orbiting birds makes them go down fast?
- LarryMullins 4y agoThe classic example is RORSAT, Radar Ocean Reconnaissance. The Soviet Union built a bunch with nuclear reactors because they needed a lot of power but were also to be in LEO so large solar panels would limit their lifespan. But I don't think powering a satellite from the ground makes much sense; you'd need ground stations around the world.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> RORSAT, Radar Ocean Reconnaissance Radar was the only thing that came to my mind, too. (Didn't know about the project, though. Thanks!) Problem is earth observation, as a market, sucks. With low-latency optical imaging en route, I'm not sure what premium radar would command. > don't think powering a satellite from the ground makes much sense Microwave power transmission through atmosphere is terrible, and we're nowhere close with laser. The idea would be large arrays in a high orbit beaming to lower-orbit birds. That's the only proximate case where space-based solar power makes sense: space to space. The only place where having the panels where you need power doesn't make sense is in the atmosphere. I just can't think of anything you'd want to do there that requires that much power.
- LarryMullins 4y ago> Problem is earth observation, as a market, sucks. With low-latency optical imaging en route, I'm not sure what premium radar would command. One advantage of radar is that sometimes you can see through things that aren't transparent to visible light. I don't know if it's true, but I've heard that modern SAR sats can see through petroleum storage tanks and some warehouse roofs, so they can collect data which may be valuable to traders. These modern sort of radar satellites are apparently fine with solar power, but maybe they'd be even better with more power.
- cmdialog 4y agoWhen is someone going to launch something to clean up all the tech demos and space junk?
- waihtis 4y agowhen a big publicity incident caused by space junk happens
- Grim-444 4y agoI'm pretty sure there's already FCC rules requiring deorbit of satellites within a certain number of years of their mission completion. [Edit] https://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-adopts-new-5-year-rule-deorbiting-satellites https://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-adopts-new-5-year-rule-deor...
- throwaway4aday 4y agoIt's in LEO, the atmosphere will bring it down.
- pythonguython 4y agoYep. Part of launching is making a deorbit plan (if possible). That satellite will come down, and they already know when that will happen.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoI'm super ignorant on physics and whatnot; but wouldn't it make more sense to use airships covered with solar panels at 5k-6k meter altitude? Thin solar is now a thing, and I'm quite sure that there would be a viable way to engineer an airship in such a way. One could even use graphene aerogel instead of helium or hydrogen as the lighter-than-air filler. Is this a really dumb idea? Any of you with a more relevant background could tell me where this could be so wrong?
- dahfizz 4y agoIs graphene aerogel lighter than air? I thought it _was_ mostly air, which is why its so light.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoAbout 7 times lighter than air, AFAIK.
- SapporoChris 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org//wiki/Aerographene https://en.wikipedia.org//wiki/Aerographene It is approximately 7.5 times less dense than air. Note that the cited density does not include the weight of the air incorporated in the structure: it does not float in air.
- idiotsecant 4y agoSeems like some of the bad parts of terrestrial solar (fighting atmospheric conditions, wind loading, etc) without the good parts of orbital solar (once you're in orbit, staying there is relatively easy and you have very little in the way of mechanical stresses for your solar array, so you can make it really huge). I might not be thinking about it hard enough.
- LarryMullins 4y ago> 5k-6k meter altitude That's not high enough to put you above bad weather (airliners fly higher, and they divert around storms.) Bad weather is bad news for airships and historically destroyed about as many as hydrogen fires. You'd need to bring your airships down into hangers when the weather got bad. Also, wouldn't the graphene aerogel be filled with air and be heavier than air? Aerogel doesn't just float away. Unless you mean for these to be vacuum airships, but those seem very far fetched.
- tee_0 4y agoI walked the campus at cal tech a few days ago. It feels like a real college. Other colleges could be mistaken for luxury resorts or spas. They feel like a gimmick. But at cal everything looks normal. It looks like a place where people actually come to work and learn. It has a monastic quality in comparison. A place where people are truly preoccupied with the truth. It’s the first university I’ve been to that felt like that. Besides maybe Stanford.
- laidoffamazon 4y agoMy state school was like that. It's just buildings. Most schools are like that!
- mabbo 4y agoThe oldest part of the University of Edinburgh, called "The Old College" would, I think, excite you as much as it did me. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_College,_University_of_Edinburgh https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_College,_University_of_E... Street view from the courtyard: https://maps.app.goo.gl/f2o6V8JFpPtMW5R47 https://maps.app.goo.gl/f2o6V8JFpPtMW5R47 It's an incredible and beautiful 200+ year old building that's been continually used for teaching since it was built. On the one end of time, it's construction was halted because the Napoleonic wars cost too much. On the other, I had lectures about machine learning in it. The rest of the university is more modern, but that place always felt like the soul of the Uni to me.
- KerrAvon 4y agoI have stayed at many luxury resorts, and they don’t resemble any university or college I’ve toured or attended. Possibly you just find the Pasadena-area architecture particularly inviting?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jmyeet 4y agoI encourage you to watch The Future of Solar Power [1]. I am firmly of the belief that solar power is humanity's future of energy production. Yes, beaming power to Earth is viable and could be economical. This pretty much solves the problem in variable power generation. I've seen estimates that a space-based power collector could generate about 6-8x what that same collector could on Earth (due to atmosphere, weather and day/night) so even with some power loss from beaming power to Earth, it's viable. But there's an even better fguture for this. The first is as the power source for space habitats. You literally just put them on the outside hull. These are incredibly efficient in creating living area per unit mass and ultimately would become a Dyson Swarm. I consider this inevitable. The second is you can do better than beaming power with orbital rings [2]. In short, you put a loop of conducting cables in orbit, run a current through them and float things on top with the magnetic field. The beauty of this is those things elevated on the ring are fixed to points on Earth. This means you don't need to speed up to Mach 30 to reach orbital speeds. If you have an orbital ring, you can run cables down from space directly to the ground. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W-TISSvR0L4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W-TISSvR0L4 [2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LMbI6sk-62E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LMbI6sk-62E
- nickpinkston 4y agoI was more hoping for the arcology building from SimCity, not the space solar plant, but pretty cool.
- elihu 4y agoWhat's the best case wireless energy transfer efficiency that anyone is expecting with current technology, or with technology that reasonably assumed to be attainable in the near future?
- DennisP 4y agoAccording to The Case for Space Solar Power, 40% overall efficiency with the technology at the time it was written (about a decade ago), with a theoretical maximum of 60%. This was with microwaves from a phased array transmitter and a reference signal from the ground target, and the satellite in geostationary.
- iamleppert 4y agoWhat a great way to heat a column of air. At the end of it, what are we talking about, 90% loss?
- politician 4y agoWe already use microwave links at ground level successfully.
- iamleppert 4y agoThere’s a big difference to receiving a signal than to receiving energy with any kind of reasonable efficiency.
- politician 4y agoI'm sure you know this, but receiving a signal is the same thing as receiving energy. Take a random plot of land, build a grid of telephone poles, stretch conductive wire cables between the poles, and you've built an orbital power receiving station where the ground is still available for critters and plants. Make the plot wider to spread the energy over a larger area to make it safer for birds passing overhead, or narrower to punch out the atmosphere to improve the loss rate. There is a difference, and it's tunable.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoThis article prompted me to research: antimatter capture from the solar wind: http://www.niac.usra.edu/files/studies/final_report/1107Jackson.pdf http://www.niac.usra.edu/files/studies/final_report/1107Jack... Not sure what the yields are, but the paper suggests that a capture array would be about 5 tons. Might be worth a try when Starship matures. Antimatter is pretty valuable. I think SpaceX should look into this, antimatter harvesting could be lucrative.