10 ms·
Perhaps. Just try to remember that yours is not the first generation to pursue these goals.
by timr 18y ago
Perhaps. Just try to remember that yours is not the first generation to pursue these goals.
- davidw 18y agoI think there used to be a different balance between various things. You could expect to find a 'good company', dedicate a lot of your live to it, and be more or less reciprocated. These days, it's "every man for himself". In Europe, they have, in some places, attempted to legislate this relationship, which I don't agree with, but sometimes I feel there may be something we are missing out on in terms of long term, loyal employer/employee relationships. I'm not sure I'd want that myself, having pretty much grown up with the hopping around + brutal layoffs style common in tech, but still... it makes you think.
- run4yourlives 18y agoI think that's exactly it. It's just taken a couple of generations to adapt to this new reality. My parents (well, my mom at least, my dad was an entrepreneur) would never quit their jobs. This was something that was unheard of. Xer's would be happy with whatever job came their way. Now, the millenials are fully understanding that their jobs are about as secure as their car parked in the bad part of town. Honestly, corporations have changed how they treat their employees, and so the employees are adapting.
- davidw 18y agoRight... it's a problem with solutions at different equilibriums (I'm not sure of the exact way to phrase that), and I'm not sure that what we are moving towards is necessarily the best for all people/jobs/companies: sure, there's more flexibility and responsiveness, but as an employee, I have figured out at this point that I don't really have any more loyalty to an employer than they are likely to have for me, and perhaps we both lose out because of it in some ways, at least for certain combinations of people/jobs/companies.
- run4yourlives 18y agoI'm not sure that what we are moving towards is necessarily the best for all people/jobs/companies: That I think is the key. Everyone figures that it'll be great when we're all sitting around in our pj's "working", but will it? We're talking about a change to the fundamental nature of our society. There will be winners and losers, but that's a very different world from the one we know.
- tom_rath 18y agoIt's not that Gen-Xers were happy with whatever job came our way, it's that we had rent to pay and food to buy (and had no desire to live with Mom and Dad). Once the economy got better (and our businesses succeeded), we got picky too. You might have what it takes to walk the walk, but don't jump to conclusions before you've trod the path of a truly awful economy.
- run4yourlives 18y agoI'm gen X. I'm actually in my third "career". Trust me, I didn't do security after leaving the army because I liked it. You're 100% correct though, I have no problem limiting my tolerance for bad situations these days.
- LogicHoleFlaw 18y agoWell, it certainly looks like we'll have the opportunity.
- davidw 18y agoI was born in 1975, so I've been around the block... if not many times, a few, at least. My point was that once upon a time, companies and their employees were likelier to stick together through good times and bad. These days the equation has changed: companies are liable to dump you when quarterly profits aren't good, and you're likely to dump a company at the first whiff of something better. That's better in some ways, but I think we've also given up something that may be harder to quantify. For instance, if you're a happy worker and not worried about the next quarter, you can also invest in the company long term, rather than strictly looking out for your own interests, and vice versa, even if there's a bad quarter. Said companies also had time to invest in things like creating Unix, and lots of other R&D that wasn't immediately registered as profitable. I don't know that I'd be happy like that, and I think that the cream of the crop in today's world oughtn't look to other people's companies as a place to make their mark; still, I think it's something that bears thinking about. Perhaps the pendulum will swing back at some point in the future.
- yters 18y ago
- dangoldin 18y agoYou should take a look at the book 'Supercapitalism" by Robert Reich - it may give you a new perspective on how business has evolved over the past 30 years. One of the major themes is that the focus went from people as citizens and unto people as consumers. Thus the reason for corporations changing their behavior. It's as much the consumer's fault as the corporations'.
- gaius 18y agoThat's the thing with a corporation. It can only sell what people want to buy. It's like when people complain about Starbucks taking over the high street, well, Starbucks can't exist where people don't want its products and services, same as any corporation. I have a pet theory that this is why some people have this visceral hatred of corporations: they're a mirror to the people, and people don't like what they see.
- kaens 18y agoWhile it is true that a corporation can only sell what people want to buy, a lot of large corporate entities have spend a lot of time and money researching how to influence what people want to buy. To a really ridiculous degree. Furthermore, a lot of large corporate entities have no problem doing things that the vast majority of people would consider immoral (at the very least) to reduce their costs, or increase the likelihood of someone purchasing more of their product(s). People who hate corporations for being corporations generally aren't really thinking about what they don't like about said corps, and also rarely take the time to consider how the corporations actions would be justifiable (in a human sense, not necessarily just in the profit-motive sense) to the people running them. I think that what people tend to rail against is corporations like Monsanto. Sure, they can only sell what 'people' want to buy - but they also have no problem with showing utter disregard for human life or the environment, furthermore what they sell is not marketed at individuals - they end up being only able to sell what other corporations want to buy (who in turn don't know or don't care about said disregard for human life or the environment), and have enough money to buy their way out of most legal trouble.
- dangoldin 18y ago
- mattmaroon 18y agoNo, but ours is the first to do so en masse and be widely pilloried for them, at least in this country.
- timr 18y agoHm. I don't know...when people say things like that, it tends to reflect feelings of persecution more accurately than fact. As recently as the late 1960s, American youth were idealizing personal freedom, quality of life and independence, and "adults" were criticizing them for it (probably in the WSJ). San Francisco is practically a monument to the era...
- fallentimes 18y agoThe people you refer to in the 1960's didn't actually _do anything_ they just talked about doing something (there's a great South Park episode about this). Matt and many others are doing what he talks about.
- astine 18y agoOh, but they did in the 30s.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- DaniFong 18y agoOne could call it so far the closest thing to a true Marxist revolution. Workers in control of the means of production.
- Tamerlin 18y agoMost of the Gen-Y's that I've worked with have been pretty intelligent, but very arrogant and largely useless, because they hide their inexperience behind their arrogance and claim they're doing things a "new way" even when it's considerably worse than the "old" way.
- Prrometheus 18y ago>Just try to remember that yours is not the first generation to pursue these goals. Ours is the first generation with the technology to enable it.
- timr 18y agoI'm pretty sure that our parents had new technology, too. More to the point, I'll bet that when they were 23, they were bragging about how their new technology was going to allow them to change the world. It's almost a cliche, really. Granted, our didn't have computers or the internet; technology has marched onward. But regardless of whether we're discussing the modem or the mimeograph, the story of the young usurping the old with 'modern' technology is a classic.
- Prrometheus 18y agoNot all technology is created equal. The ability to communicate, coordinate, and compute has reduced the optimum size of the firm in many industries. What is more important, it has reduced the minimum size of a successful firm. Steam power and heavy industry, by contrast, had the opposite effect.
- j2d2 18y agoUltimately, you both can be right. It's about where you stand relative to everyone else. If the younger folks are enabling themselves via tech faster than the older, it should be possible to position yourself better. I think it's more a testament to the improvements we've made in technology how easy it is for kids to become BIG deals quickly with good ideas.
- 13ren 18y agoA young man sets out to seek his fortune... Yes, it's the beginning of a fairly tale, a standard mythological motif - by which I don't mean it is fictional or trivial, but that it is universal. BTW: Matt does acknowledge that the next generation will do the same to his (at the end). He's right about greater productivity - but if everyone is more productive, then the competitive bar simply resets at a higher level. It's an endless trudge, if the finish line recedes as you approach... There's a sophisticated argument that with a smaller firm-size, you have more CEO's. The problem with competitive success remains that not everyone can be a winner - it's a zero-sum game by definition. But everyone can have a family. Everyone can have the satisfaction of improvement and mastery. Everyone can enjoy the thrill of risking a lesser thing for a greater thing. Everyone can take pride in effort and sacrifice for a worthy goal. And ultimately, these things are immensely more satisfying than vacationing for months in Europe. Talkin bout my generation