8 ms·
Why would prisons ban my book? Absurdities rule the system (2022)
- throwawaysleep 4y ago> Many prison systems ban reading materials because of their formats: No hardbacks! No pop-ups! The kinds of people in prison would use them as weapons, to huff the binding glue, or would hollow out the cover and shove drugs in it.
- megabless123 4y agoThe kinds of people _outside_ of prison would use them as weapons, to huff the binding glue, or would hollow out the cover and shove drugs in it too.
- imwillofficial 4y agoNo, you obviously have no idea how having the worst people in society with nothing but time, magnifies the weaponization of literally everything possible. I say this as a convict. You’d be amazed at the creative ways people will warp things from their intended purpose. Prison Break has nothing on real life.
- megabless123 4y agoSo? people inside of prison being extra-creative does not make the people outside of prison less-creative.
- HideousKojima 4y agoPeople outside don't need such creativity because they have access to superior implements. No need to file the end of a toothbrush into a shiv when you can just use a knife or gun.
- imwillofficial 4y ago“Necessity is the mother of invention”
- isk517 4y agoHonestly, I want to live in your reality where criminals outside of prison rely solely on hard-cover books as weapons and a means of getting high instead of literally all of the things available to the general public that are better at being weapons and a means of getting high.
- jmyeet 4y agoThe source of drugs in prisons is primarily the people who work there [1]: > Prison staff are often responsible as well: During the pandemic, even though visitation from family and friends was suspended, attorney visits were restricted, and teachers, tutors, and volunteers stayed home, drugs got into many prisons anyway. As The Marshall Project reported, the number of incarcerated people disciplined or charged for drugs actually increased during the pandemic in Texas prisons. Prisoners highly value books and other reading material. They are generally looked after. Many prisons limit the number of personal items so reading materials are passed to other prisoners (who themselves may not have the funds or outside family to purchase them). Banning books isn't a safety issue. It's another means of squeezing more profit from the incarcerated. [1]: https://www.themarshallproject.org/2021/07/15/inside-the-nation-s-overdose-crisis-in-prisons-and-jails https://www.themarshallproject.org/2021/07/15/inside-the-nat...
- HideousKojima 4y agoFWIW when I worked for a local government doing IT and software dev I had to go into the local prison a couple dozen times to set up some equipment. There were zero metal detectors, searches, etc. for me when I entered, and I could have easily smuggled in just about anything. In fact I had a credit card shaped knife that I made sure to remove from my wallet everytime I went in, but there would have been nothing to stop me otherwise.
- notch656c 4y agoThere was likely no searches because the prison officials tacitly are involved with the smuggling and need to not search anyone to make it look like a uniform policy rather than an exceptional policy for the smugglers. Had you actually brought materials to the prisoners, whoever was doing the actual smuggling would have found out through the grapevine and you would have been promptly arrested. My humble conjecture.
- duxup 4y agoI think most understand some of the physical reasoning. The absurdity is the discrepancy and random outcome.
- jollyllama 4y agoYes, there are legitimate concerns with specifics of the materials in this context.
- tyingq 4y agoThere's also the movement towards doing away with paper books altogether and charging prisoners, by the minute, to rent e-books. https://americanlibrariesmagazine.org/blogs/the-scoop/prisoners-pay-to-read-prison-tablets/ https://americanlibrariesmagazine.org/blogs/the-scoop/prison... https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2020/jan/13/us-states-move-to-stop-prisons-charging-inmates-for-reading-and-video-calls https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2020/jan/13/u...
- ceejayoz 4y ago> In December, the West Virginia Division of Corrections and Rehabilitation launched a pay-per-minute ebook policy, which charges inmates five cents (4p) per minute of reading. The fee equates to roughly an hour of prison labour. "Rehabilitation", indeed.
- leetrout 4y agoIt is all a giant scam and the general public including me is complicit
- Ekaros 4y agoI wonder when that monetization model comes to other devices outside. Just imagine how much companies could make if it costed money to use your smartphone, tablet or computer...
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoI mean, we used to pay per minute to use our cell phone. I think it's proven that it's harder to sell to a (literally) non-captive audience.
- hansvm 4y agoWait, that's over-priced even for the general public. That's around $25 to read an average Harry Potter book -- even nice sets of books 1-7 go for less than $175 new, where you get to keep the bloody book. You can buy the whole ebook series for Kindle outright in the $60-$80 range.
- SamoyedFurFluff 4y ago> While Texas prisoners can read Hitler’s manifesto, the state banned pioneering Black journalist Ida B. Wells’ book “On Lynchings” because its examination of racist vigilante mobs used “racial slurs.” Similarly, Louisiana bans texts by Black prison abolitionists, including George Jackson’s “Blood in My Eye” and Mariame Kaba’s “We Do This ‘Til We Free Us,” for being “racially inflammatory.” But it allows “Mein Kampf,” as well as every single book mentioned in the Southern Poverty Law Center’s round-up of racist literature. Certainly very bizarre
- jen20 4y ago> Certainly very bizarre Or just SOP for those familiar with Texas governance.
- DangitBobby 4y agoI wonder who recommends these bans and who carries them out. Guards? The state? Are they only banning books once someone tries to bring them in? That could explain why some of the books you'd expect to see on the list are missing.
- therealcamino 4y agoThe article goes into the inconsistencies of the process, which vary widely from state to state.
- DangitBobby 4y agoYes, though not in enough detail to determine whether certain books have been omitted from bans because e.g. racism is not a concern or if prisoners have not tried to bring them in.
- sonotathrowaway 4y agoOnly if you don’t know the history of the American legal system - e.g., created to capture runaway slaves, then to provide a legal system to protect slavery. Allowing convicts to understand the history of the practice would be anathema to its goals.
- rgrieselhuber 4y agoIf I were applying to YC again I would be tempted to pitch a private / non-profit prison. I abhor the idea of private prisons but it seems like the only way in our modern society to build a prototype of one that actually treats incarcerated people like human beings.
- jmyeet 4y agoI understand this desire but charity alone cannot (let alone the profit motive that would seep into any venture-backed effort) cannot solve a systemic problem. The roots of the modern US prison system go back to slavery economics [1]. The Lousianna State Penitentiary (known as "Angola") is quite literally a cotton-picking plantation. Poverty and the desire for forced (ie cheap) labor are the driving forces here. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4kI2h3iotA&t=3s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4kI2h3iotA&t=3s
- rgrieselhuber 4y agoAgreed. As well as a heavy fascist / anti-human bent toward the torturing of consciousness.
- kingkawn 4y agogood ol US o A
- Retric 4y agoA non profit prison should in theory be able to out compete for profit prisons because they don’t need to bake profits into their bids. They could then use that surplus to have more humane conditions. However that argument applies to other industries, but charities haven’t taken over the world because the profit motive is surprisingly effective at motivating both people and organizations.
- Tostino 4y agoYou are entirely ignoring the revenue generating portion of slave labor in this analysis.
- imwillofficial 4y agoWhat I find absurd is the author takes the stance that banning books is wrong, but not so subtly hints that so called “racist” books should be banned. I find this contradictory.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoIMO the author's point is that banning books is wrong, and even if it isn't, it makes no sense that his book is banned while Mein Kampf isn't.
- DangitBobby 4y agoOr put more charitably, their stance is if you _must_ ban books for the safety of prisoners, racist ones are a good candidate, but having not banned racist books indicates it's not about safety.
- imwillofficial 4y agoI could see that logic.
- mindslight 4y agoBy my superficial understanding, the main social organization in most prisons is gangs based around racial lines (eg Aryan Brotherhood) so anything that can raise the temperature is a poor idea.
- kingkawn 4y ago[flagged]
- czx4f4bd 4y ago> so called “racist” books Setting aside questions about the morality of banning books, why is "racist" in scare quotes here? The only two books I saw the author explicitly note as being unbanned were Mein Kampf and the Turner Diaries. Are you suggesting that these works are falsely maligned and not truly racist?
- yikesonbikes 4y ago[dead]
- teekert 4y agoSo, you're addicted, maybe not even because of your own fault (shitty childhood, opioids from a physician?) and your country takes you out of college instead of helping you!? You take someone from a situation that may make their situation better into a stonecold environment that produces unproducitive citicens at best and criminals at worst!? And he didn't even harm anybody else. What a system.
- sonotathrowaway 4y agoYou have to realize the American legal system is optimized to (1) provide employment for the legal system, (2) provide slave labor for states and corporations, and (3) exploit the families of prisoners for profit.
- jahnu 4y agoPerhaps also, (n) assuage the fears of a certain class of voters through populist policies that have less to do with effectiveness than they do with fear and retribution.
- sonotathrowaway 4y agoThat rhetoric furthers economic benefits though. Prisons are mostly located in rural areas, where they provide job centers to otherwise poor people. The legal system is chiefly concerned with moving people out of urban centers into rural areas, where their incarceration is paid for through state tax revenue, redistributing the money from urban to rural areas. This is the reason why prison lobbies are the strongest political opponents of drug decriminalization or legalization - reducing prison occupancy reduces profits per prisoner.
- x86_64Ubuntu 4y agoI've also heard that the prison population, while sometimes non-voting, goes to the electoral advantage of these rural areas.
- MBCook 4y agoKansas bans the 3rd edition of O’Rielly’s Python Cookbook for… “Describes procedures for construction of weapons, ammunition, bombs, incendiary devices” Interesting.
- londons_explore 4y agoThere is another book with "cookbook" in the title which is banned in a lot of countries and matches that description...
- mnd999 4y agoSo pythonistas are anarchists now.
- HorkHunter 4y agoalways have been, down with type tyranny
- fein 4y agoPython still forces indents for code structure. The true anarchy language would probably be PHP.
- throwaway019254 4y agoOf course, there's a section on distributing packages and making a stopwatch timer.
- null0ranje 4y agoMy code certainly blows up all the time.
- yikesonbikes 4y ago[dead]
- quacked 4y agoAnyone that is serious about engineering societal problems out of existence should take up prison reform as one of their highest priorities. People who compulsively break the social contract need to be separated from people who don't, but the present way of doing it is basically just an extended duration of torture where they're placed at the mercy of much worse criminals and corrupt guards, and really prevented from doing anything useful besides forced labor for little or no pay.
- jahnu 4y agoI apologise in advance for a lack of reference (was probably Popehat) but the most bizarre if not scary thing I read about the public’s attitude to prisoners and justice was that if you asked them “Should prisoners be allowed to read books?” or ask them “Should prisoners be required to read books?”. You’ll get very different results. Basically any question asked of the public will broadly favour the one that sounds like a punishment :( Edit: as per the reply below, it’s entirely possible I misremembered this. I asked Popehat and he said it sounds familiar but he doesn’t recall.
- richbell 4y agoThere was a post yesterday about Arizona prisons inducing labour (birth) in inmates against their consent. Plenty of comments saying things like "they're wards of the state so consent isn't needed". https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34235888 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34235888 Edit: fixed a typo and clarified that it's labour (i.e., giving birth) and not physical labour.
- lp0_on_fire 4y agoWithout commenting on the morality those comments are correct. In the United States those who are incarcerated can be compelled to labor, per the 13th amendment.
- jMyles 4y agoYou might even say that's the whole purpose, historically and economically, of prisons in the first place.
- derefr 4y agoUnder this view, presumably historical nations that made most of their money from trade, and didn't rely much on local production (the Netherlands, say; or Portugal; or Hong Kong under British rule), would see little-to-no local economic benefit from a marginal slave laborer — and so just wouldn't bother to establish any prisons / penal colonies. And also, likely would find it hard to sell these criminals on to other countries, given their known criminality / disobedient attitude. Is this accurate? If so, then what did such countries generally do with their criminals? Exile them?
- manholio 4y agoI hate that the immediate reference against which a book ban should be compared is Mein Kampf. The effect will not be to ease those bans, but to ban Mein Kampf too, and that sets an incredibly low standard to book bans - it's a very dull book. In my university we were able to read and critique Mein Kampf and trace Hitler's intellectual claims into the broader climate of his era. He's a negligible figure in the history of ideas but a good case study for their power. This is more and more risky to do in higher education, as it prompts lynching by a woke mob. Ironically, the hordes requesting banning Mein Kampf are espousing many of its authors convictions.
- troupe 4y agoI assumed that Mein Kampf was commonly read in high school at schools with a strong great books program. Is that not the case in the US?
- metabagel 4y agoWhy would anyone choose Mein Kampf for a Great Books program? It’s not a significant intellectual or creative work of literature.
- metabagel 4y agoIt may be dull, but it’s also anti-Semitic. “Ironically, the hordes requesting banning Mein Kampf are espousing many of its authors convictions.” This strikes me as being complete nonsense. Anyway, citation needed.
- manholio 4y ago> It may be dull, but it’s also anti-Semitic. Yes, so? That's relevant because antisemitism is wrong? Really, in a thread about banning books you bring up wrong ideas? > This strikes me as being complete nonsense. Anyway, citation needed. I could give you a citation, but you banned the source material, remember. That's double plus ironic because Hitler's work is absolutely full with vitriolic ramblings about how the Jewish media is spreading wrong ideas poisonous for the soul of the nation. "The bigger the lie, the most likely it is to be belived", he laments, and explicitly calls for the suppression of such speech. He would get to enact those ideas in a few short years. Antifascist activists who are looking at book bans as a weapon for their fight should probably take a good hard look in the mirror; they might see some disturbing semblance.
- light_hue_1 4y agoWhy is there a cover photo of a black man? To make us think that this has to do with the population that is most affected by prisons? When in reality these are the experiences of an extremely privileged white woman! (rich parents, attended a private school, etc.)
- RajT88 4y agoPerhaps to get commenters to show their bias and inattention to detail. For example: people suggesting the conviction may have been due to a violent crime.
- troupe 4y agoThe author seems to find it inexplicable that"Mein Kampf" would be allowed if any other book is banned. "Mein Kampf" is a fairly common read for high school and college classes that focus on original source material. Not to say that there aren't weird things that are banned in different places, but "Mein Kampf" doesn't appear to make the argument he is trying to make.
- yamtaddle 4y agoI think the author finds it weird they ban civil-rights-promoting books for being "racially incendiary" but allow Mein Kampf. It's kinda like banning Titanic for the nude painting scene, but allowing Behind the Green Door. Like, sure, I guess it's kind of a classic, from a certain point of view, but... really? That gets through but Titanic doesn't?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- metabagel 4y agoIt does, because although there is scholarly interest in Mein Kampf, it’s also anti-Semitic. It would be reasonable for prisons to make the determination that the latter trumps the former.
- uwagar 4y agoiowa bans arduino for dummies.
- jetrink 4y agoMy girlfriend volunteered with a program that supplies books to children and teenagers in juvenile prisons. As you might expect, those facilities tended to take a very paternalistic attitude. In general, young adult literature dealing with drugs, crime and gangs was not permitted. In other words, inmates were not allowed to read books reflecting their own life experiences. Often it was single administrator in charge of banning books and that person would operate without any formal policy. It was difficult to appeal individual bans, because that administrator usually also had the power to ban the program from the prison entirely and didn't respond well to people questioning their decisions.
- timwaagh 4y agoI wonder why prisons would ban books written by 'black prison abolitionists' How could a book arguing that prisons are nonsense and criminals should be free possibly be considered inflammatory in a prison where criminals are not free but want to be? I don't doubt that the American justice system is perverse but this is not the reason. Sure mein Kampf could use a ban but that's all.
- userabchn 4y agoI think the problem with prisons (both privately and publicly run) is that they have a monopoly over the lives of the prisoners, and, as we know, absolute power corrupts absolutely. I propose that prisoners be allowed to select which rehabilitation provider they are assigned to. The rehabilitation provider must pay fines if the person reoffends after they have been released.
- esbranson 4y agoEbooks came up here, but only extended as far as 2020, so here is a more recent discussion from early 2022. It has 40 views on YT after nine months so I can tell how much y’all care. :lol: Cost of Reading in Prisons: Book Censorship and E-Reader Tablets In Carceral Institutions https://pen.org/event/the-cost-of-reading-in-prisons-book-censorship-and-e-reader-tablets-in-carceral-institutions/ https://pen.org/event/the-cost-of-reading-in-prisons-book-ce...