24 ms·
First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal
- mensetmanusman 4y agoLNG will be a welcome capability for a country weaning itself from a violent authoritarian. This will not slow the green energy transition because hydrocarbons are still required for almost every technology in existence (including the ability to build PV panels).
- solarkraft 4y agoThe transition would be faster if we suddenly didn't have any more gas, but it would also be very chaotic. This looks like a decent middle ground with the gas being more expensive, increasing the incentive to stop using it while still being available to the people/business who haven't been able to do so yet.
- thworp 4y agoUsing a euphemism like "chaotic" for an event that would kill hundreds of millions (if it happens globally) and lead to a complete collapse of most social and economic structures is not exactly good form.
- gpvos 4y agoWe'll see how it works out when global warming has progressed further in a couple of years. That also has the potential to cause a lot of chaos.
- ajmurmann 4y agoI wonder how much production during that time would move to places like China where the energy comes from coal to a much larger degree which is so much worse.
- obblekk 4y ago9mo from the start of the Ukrainian war. For all the criticism modern governments get (often rightly) it’s incredible how fast Germany built these new terminals. And it does show we have just as much productive capacity in western societies today as we did 100 years ago. What’s missing is consensus that problems should actually be solved, not used to enrich yet another rentier class. I hope Germany learns from this and keeps away some of the barriers to growth they regulated into existence.
- kakwa_ 4y ago> it’s incredible how fast Germany built these new terminals. Except they weren't really "built" in 9 months. Höegh Esperanza (the floating terminal), was commissioned in 2018. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H%C3%B6egh_Esperanza https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H%C3%B6egh_Esperanza In reality, oversimplifying wildly, it took 9 months to negotiate the contract and "plug" this preexisting terminal into the German gas network. However, it's still impressive that our societies have tools like that available to handle unforeseen situations and crisis.
- bamboozled 4y agoWould be nice if they did the same thing with Nuclear and Renewables though wouldn't it? Some how they can "go to war" for gas, but when it comes to climate change it's, "meh"?
- Luc 4y agoFifty years of anti-nuclear movement has left its mark.
- tgv 4y agoIf the best retort the nuclear industry had was a Russian-Ukrainian war, then it's not so odd to see why.
- zmgsabst 4y agoActual retorts: - we don’t have the mineral supplies for other non-fossil options - nuclear has a better safety record, all in - nuclear doesn’t require we do business with cobalt slavers - nuclear can supply the base load - nuclear produces rare elements that help with advanced medicine But you can’t reason people out of a position they didn’t reason themselves into, and many people were raised in a green-washed death cult. Like most religious people, they uncritically repeat that faith and become angered if you point out the inconsistencies.
- AntiRemoteWork 4y ago[dead]
- H8crilA 4y agoGreat, now free the Leopards, Abrams and IFVs/APCs. This ain't gonna end unless Ukraine gets more armor to (re)form battalions. I really don't get the whole "don't anger Putin" vibe, during the Vietnam War the USSR would send pretty much anything they could against the American forces. Even aircraft together with crews, as aircraft weapon systems really really require trained personnel. And no WW3 happened.
- michael1999 4y agoVietnam is much farther from Washington than Kiev is from Moscow. We know exactly how the USA reacted when the USSR sent serious hardware to Cuba.
- user-extended 4y agoThe US wasn't bogged down in an active conflict with troops on the ground when that happened for months. We're past that point since a long time ago.
- blub 4y agoA strange moment, when the Pentagon shows more self-restraint than allegedly intelligent hackers.
- LargoLasskhyfv 4y agoMaybe. But that was just a reaction of the USSR to the USA stationing some serious kit in Italy and Turkey. Namely: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PGM-19_Jupiter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PGM-19_Jupiter to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Izmir_Air_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Izmir_Air_Station in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C4%B0zmir https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C4%B0zmir Now look at a map and compare the distance to the former territory of the Soviet Union and associates, and compare that with the distance of Cuba to the CONUS. Whining pinschers...
- actionfromafar 4y agoAnd Germany could also stop wooing the Chinese court. Why make the same mistake with a new country?
- brigandish 4y agoWho is selling the liquefied natural gas and where is it being transported from?
- bamboozled 4y agoThe article says it's from USA, and that it's likely from "fracking" which is really bad for the environment.
- MandieD 4y agoThe fracking was happening anyway for oil, and that the by-product natural gas is now worth selling on instead of just flaring off is a nice bonus. (In West Texas, at least; I don't know enough about the oil industry in the rest of the country to comment about it.)
- ilchalpenl 4y agoIs the buyer at fault or the seller?
- lostlogin 4y ago> Is the buyer at fault or the seller? It’s Putin’s, and a small group around him.
- loudmax 4y agoBad for the environment is relative. If the alternative to fracking is less energy consumption, then of course fracking is bad. But in the short run that means lowering the standard of living and politically that is a non-starter. If the alternative to fracking is wind+solar+nuclear, then yes fracking is probably worse. But it will take years, if not decades, to build up the green power generation capacity to replace fossil fuels. We're on our way and we should be doing more of this, but we're not there yet. In the current environment, Germany is reverting much of its energy generation from gas back to brown coal. This has far worse emissions than gas. As far as fracking goes, I'll happily accept a few earthquakes in the Dakotas over the ecological disaster that is coal. All of the choices here are bad. We still need to pick the least bad one.
- Normille 4y ago[flagged]
- greggarious 4y ago>Activists have protested the arrival of gas acquired through fracking. In Appalachia we can set our tap water on fire because activists protest so hard against one last generation of nuclear plants that could have bridged the gap until solar energy became cheap enough to be ubiquitous. These small but vocal groups were often funded by an odd mixture of dark money coming from former KGB operatives and fixers from the GOP who’d selectively boost useful policies to accomplish goals at odds with a happy, healthy populace.
- timdaub 4y agoIn the end, importing LNG for Germany is essentially crypto currency free market decentralization principles applied to geo politics. Clearly, and this has become obvious on the global stage, if you have two equally sovereign powers making a deal and having aligned incentives (e.g. to build physical gas pipelines that cost a lot of money and can be blown up), then the more resilient approach that features decentralized and permissionless market access is that of LNG. It's because LNG tankers are interoperable and they can technically come any moment from any new country. There's no direct platform-dependence on Russia for Germany anymore and with an extension of LNG ingestion capabilities, more diversity of supply will mean that gas now can't be leveraged as a power brokerage tool by a single country anymore.
- hbossy 4y agoExcept for the country that control seas.
- pphysch 4y agoIn unrelated news, "As investigators piece together clues, Russia has quietly taken steps to begin expensive repairs on the giant gas pipeline, complicating theories about who was behind September’s sabotage." [1] A farce of historical proportions. 1 - https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/26/world/europe/nordstream-pipeline-explosion-russia.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/26/world/europe/nordstream-p...
- keewee7 4y agoAs a European I'm glad the CIA/Poland/aliens blew up the pipelines that were funding the Russian invasion. Even the environmental effect was minor; the methane emission from the leaks had 1/5th of the GHG effect of my small country's, Denmark, annual GHG emission.
- pphysch 4y agoEurope continues to send more money than ever to Russia [1], whether by proxy or not. Industrial terrorism against Germany, by US/UK/etc., does not change that. What is does do is reinforce the European dependency on Washington, as evidenced by this post. 1 - https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/russia-s-oil-and-gas-export-revenues-from-the-european-union https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/russia-s-oil-...
- Zanfa 4y agoThis was true because of the all time high natural gas prices (€350/MWh) and high oil prices, both of which have now dropped to pre-war levels (~€70/MWh).
- pphysch 4y ago"Pre-war levels" is a disingenuous sleight-of-hand. Gas was at €15-20 in winter 20-21 before Zelensky declared his intent to assault Sevestapol, after which the price gradually quadrupled. All before Russia invaded.
- threadweaver34 4y agoAround a year ago, I was convinced Putin wouldn't invade Ukraine because the West would find new energy sources, starving Russia of key income, and Sweden and Finland would join NATO. Not only that, Russia is now confirmed to be the the junior partner in its relationship with China. In hindsight, I do buy into the argument that NATO grew too much to the east, and there would have been wisdom in creating an "DMZ" between NATO and Russia. The growth of NATO left Putin feeling trapped. It would have been better to slowly move Western resource sources to better sources and friendlier countries.
- StefanWestfal 4y agoI would argue that the Russian invasion proved the new NATO members right. At the end of the day Russia reserved itself the right to use brute force when it sees it's own interest threatened. For a lot of countries the only chance to defend themselves if attacked by Russia was and is to join NATO.
- Gravityloss 4y agoFinland and Estonia weren't planning for a new terminal but in February of course realized they needed one. The countries are connected by a new gas pipeline so share a common interest. They started a race to construct the ground facilities and acquire a floating terminal ship. Finland was farther along in the construction and it was decided to place the terminal there. It started supplying gas to the grid in in December. It's not famous German red tape so I guess doesn't make the news. https://lngprime.com/europe/finlands-first-fsru-begins-supplying-gas-to-grid/70014/ https://lngprime.com/europe/finlands-first-fsru-begins-suppl... Nowadays almost the whole of Europe is connected by international gas pipelines. Of course there are flow constraints, but it's hard to completely cut off any place. In theory one could send gas from Norway south through UK, Holland, Germany and Poland and then back up north through Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia all the way to Finland. Add the terminals dotting the map and it's a pretty resilient system. This is a nice resource. https://www.gie.eu/publications/maps/gie-lng-map/ https://www.gie.eu/publications/maps/gie-lng-map/
- de6u99er 4y agoSomeone could easily make the point that the Ukraine war was an opportunity for Biden to deliver on his promise to the US oil industry to make Europe buy US excess shale gas which was 3x more expensive than Russian gas.