5 ms·
Was chatting to my younger cousins the other day and they were surprisingly hostile against landlords. Not some types or some practices - all of it. Even relati
by Havoc 4y ago
Was chatting to my younger cousins the other day and they were surprisingly hostile against landlords. Not some types or some practices - all of it. Even relatives doing single buy to let.
Younger generation really isn’t on board with all this & only a matter of time before it shows in polls
- VettrianoE 4y agoWhat can we do about it ? We can - in maybe 10-15 years time with enough protest. But that is too late. If you are 28 yo and want to settle down what do you do - create a non profit to lobby against corporate landlords? That requires at least as much effort to do as keeping a regular job and maintaining your relationship. A young person without a solid family backing is already stretched too thin. And families is rapidly disintegrating across America leaving the young particularly vulnerable to the corporate landlord scheme.
- ihm 4y agoYou can join a tenants union to fight against your landlord. In the bay there’s TANC (https://baytanc.com https://baytanc.com) for example which I’m a member of.
- tjpnz 4y agoThat resentment is natural given that the people they're renting from often had their foot on the property ladder in their twenties. For millenials and younger that's the exception unless you've had help from your parents.
- prepend 4y agoHasn’t this been the case for many generations? Houses were way cheaper in 1980 and 1990 and 2000. I don’t think it’s particularly worse for millennials vs genx.
- ilyt 4y agoIt's becoming worse and worse over time
- TrackerFF 4y agoWhen I moved from home (almost 20 years ago) to study, I had to chose between living on campus - which came out to around $150 / month in only the rent, rent private for $200-$350, or purchase a smaller apartment. The apartment would cost around $50k-$100k, but back then the banks would give you a loan with as little as 5% down payment on the mortgage. A 20 year mortgage would cost around $200-$400 a month, depending on price of the apartment. Coming up with $2500-$5000 for a down payment was not that difficult, even for someone just finished in high-school. One could easily save that up over a summer or two. Fast forward 15 years, and the same apartments now goes for $250k-$350k. Rent is $1k minimum, and all the rooms on campus are either full and waitlisted, and you can only live there for 2 years anyway. Oh, and banks require a minimum of 15% for the down payment. And that's for the smallest, most basic "starter" units. The 2008-2009 crash killed all momentum, and building only reached the same pre-crash levels some 5-6 years later. This vacuum led to used housing exploding in price. I think the resentment comes from the fact that many young people are paying $1500 in monthly rent, while a mortgage for the same unit would come at $1000 / month. They go to the bank and apply for a loan, but the bank says "Sorry, you need to save up more for the down payment". Next year the same house is 5% more expensive, while the rent has also increased in the same manner - but salaries have not. Probably not a problem for us that are working in high-paying fields, but for regular people - especially young ones starting at the bottom - it probably seems like a race where the goalpost is being moved further and further away.
- was_a_dev 4y agoI don't know how young they are, but it's because renting absolutely sucks. It's an entire inconvenience for not having an inital capital for a mortgage deposit. I've rented many places, both with excellent and terrible landlords. And it makes little difference, when the laws offer so little protection to the renter. It wouldn't be half as bad if the inconvience was offset with the rent being the cheaper option. But that isn't going to be economically viable in such a captialistic society. Many more would complain if renting was a software product.
- scarface74 4y agoAs a former landlord even in the very red business friendly Georgia, there are plenty of protections for tenants that make it almost impossible to evict anyone in less than three months.
- was_a_dev 4y agoI agree there are a lot of protections for tenants. I do no think they're sufficient and go far enough. I say this as someone living in the UK.
- scarface74 4y agoHow much further should they go?
- was_a_dev 4y agoIn a lot of ways. They have in the UK with the latest Renter Reform Bill 2022. https://www.lettingaproperty.com/landlord/blog/renters-reform-bill-2022/ https://www.lettingaproperty.com/landlord/blog/renters-refor... I'd like to see some proposals on how much rent can be raised with respect to local rates. Some European cities have attempted this, but not without issues. And some enforcable time limits on how soon repairs can take - for example a broken boiler.
- 4y ago
- buro9 4y agoI see this amongst younger users (under 35) on the forums I run. They are very happy sharing a vitriolic dislike of everything that is a landlord society. This is very clearly against even a single buy-to-let landlord, but fully extends to all AirBnBs, their rental flats/homes (it is shocking how few seem to have a communal living space - their living room has been converted to a sleeping room to make the rent affordable), and it extends to the perception of what Netflix is and everything about SaaS business models. They do not hesitate to share ways in which they sabotage landlords in small ways daily. They gleefully share about coffee grinds down the sink in the AirBnB that has a septic tank, of using "bills included" rentals to run the heater... some of them in the cold snap before Christmas went into discount AirBnBs just to run the heating constantly, and of course there's rampant piracy. There is a very angry generation coming up. I'll note, I wouldn't have even thought the demographic of the sites I run would be considered left leaning or poverty, these are middle-class people who are angry at their hardship compared to what they perceive as they easy wealth and times of the preceding generations.
- ls15 4y ago"Apartment for rent (min. age 35)"
- Mezzie 4y agoNew fake ID market!
- javajosh 4y agoIt's almost like landlords are engaged in rent-seeking behavior.
- mbg721 4y agoDoes most housing "rent" qualify as "rent" for the purpose of the phrase? I thought it mostly didn't, because the idea was that a rent is a recurring payment exchanged for no additional value, but apartments, while hideously expensive, are still a you-get-what-you-pay-for thing.
- scarface74 4y agoThey are naive - period. Home ownership is severely overrated. It makes it harder to change jobs when you need to move.
- prepend 4y agoI think this is much easier now with remote work. Selling a house is hard. Owning has downsides. But the upsides almost always outweigh the downsides. If you plan on moving every year or something, then buying will be bad due to the transaction costs. But even if you move every 5 years, it’s possible that owning will be better in the long run.
- scarface74 4y agoThe people who are priced out of affordable homes aren’t predominantly those that can work remotely.
- prepend 4y agoI disagree as there are many $12-40/hour jobs in customer service that are remote and can get $100-200k houses in the middle of nowhere. I live in an area with lots of rural space within 2 hours drive. Remote work has been helpful for people who are “computer savvy” and deal with being in a remote call center.
- scarface74 4y agoYes and that still doesn’t help teachers, firemen, public service workers, factory workers, health care workers, and all of the other people who can’t work remotely. And there was just another post here within the last couple of days about how many of the remote customer service work jobs require unpaid training, inconsistent hours and are a race to the bottom.
- prepend 4y agoYou’re right. I was just pointing out how this risk is lower now than 10 years ago. It’s not completely eliminated. There are remote jobs of varying quality. But they are much more prevalent now, than 10 years ago.
- prepend 4y agoI had a similar conversation with some young relatives recently. Their argument was “My landlord bought the house 20 years ago and it’s paid off. So they should charge me less/nothing because their expenses are zero.” It was weirdly illogical to me as first, they thought the mortgage was the only expense and didn’t even know about taxes and insurance. And second, the idea of markets didn’t seem to matter and they thought they should get very low/free rent because they lived there. And they hadn’t thought about how people would be able to rent if this is how the world worked. I think maybe it’s because of virtualization where there’s not a clear cause and effect with digital goods so it all becomes very relative. Or something. But it made me not want to ever be a landlord as negotiating with people like that would be tough.
- defterGoose 4y ago| But it made me not want to ever be a landlord as negotiating with people like that would be tough. Well, well, if it isn't the consequences of my own opinions.
- BirdieNZ 4y agoWhat they've identified is that the amount of profit a landlord who owns a house outright can extract from their tenants "feels" too high. Even if they can't explain the reasons, intuitively they feel there is some kind of injustice occurring. There is, because land owners are monopolists that can extract economic rents (extra-high profits due to monopoly ownership) far beyond the ordinary rate of return in a fair and free market of capital goods. This is primarily because land (or more specifically, location) is a monopoly good, not a capital good that can be created if demand increases. The extreme end of this reality is feudalism, which most countries in the world decided against for one reason or another. Your young relatives are intuitively sensing that they feel like serfs in feudalism, and there's an increasing truth to that. Land value tax would solve this.
- prepend 4y agoIn my county, they have a “homestead exemption” that only applies to people to live in their home. I think this helps with the problem you’re describing. This allows the property tax rate to increase while impacting non-resident owners more than resident owners. Sadly though, this kind of tax just increases rent as it’s an additional cost to land owners.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoIt's just normal rage against capitalism in general. Land is just yet another thing that capitalists own. Just like factories, corporations. Just yet another facet of the "you'll own nothing and be happy" future.
- TrackerFF 4y agoWhen I was a student, the typical landlord where I lived was someone who owned an extra house, probably inherited or similar, had a basement apartment they did not use, and were reasonably priced. Then everyone and their mother decided that becoming a landlord is where the money is at, and started bidding each others up. This was sustainable because the city had a surge in people moving there. These days, most landlords here are just some random small companies charging exorbitant rents while trying to avoid costs and responsibilities at all cost. And as perverse as it sounds, these folks are often also involved in local politics, and will actively vote against things lie new development projects, changes in zoning regulations, etc.
- flutas 4y ago> These days, most landlords here are just some random small companies charging exorbitant rents while trying to avoid costs and responsibilities at all cost. Man that is the most accurate description I’ve seen in a while. My current apartment (powered by RealPage, just like my last 3 weeee) sent us all no less than 6 notifications during the cold last week about making sure we run water to not have the pipes freeze. A total of 4 buildings have burst pipes that included the fire sprinkler system, and they are now trying to blame the residents for not keeping their apartments warm, and also trying to say that “this is why you should have renters insurance because it’s not our fault.” I’m really hoping to get some popcorn and watch this shot show go down in lawsuits.
- fundad 4y agoAsk them how they feel about owners of any types of businesses.
- noahtallen 4y agoYeah, it makes sense when you consider what value landlords provide. A landlord may provide services like maintenance. But a renter pays not only for maintenance costs, but also mortgage costs. And the only benefit they get is the maintenance — not even any of the property value. Renters essentially finance the ongoing ownership of an asset without getting any of the value back. At the end of the day, the landlord typically doesn’t have to do much work (or can use rent to pay someone to do the work), but gets an entire house in value. Whereas a renter does a huge amount of work to handle the cost of rent, but gets nothing at the end of their stay. The only difference between a landlord and a renter is that the landlord has enough money for the initial downpayment in the first place. The renter is still covering all ongoing costs associated with ownership anyways, including mortgage and maintenance. (If they didn’t, renting out wouldn’t make financial sense.) A renter will easily pay $90k over 3 years, but will have nothing to show for it. Whereas the landlord gets 3 years of their mortgage paid off. The financial aspect of renting is very unfair to renters, and incentivizes perverse behavior. And JUST because renters don’t have the upfront capital for a down payment, or because all housing inventory has been snatched by landlords. Reiterating: renters CAN handle ongoing ownership costs, because they’re already the ones paying for the landlord’s ongoing ownership costs. In fact, that’s the only way that renting makes sense for the landlord in the first place. So the entire concept of renting is based on one class of people having capital and one class not.