5 ms·
Some people would claim that this is a special case, and if large language models can save more lives statistically speaking than human doctors, then that's a w
by amelius 4y ago
Some people would claim that this is a special case, and if large language models can save more lives statistically speaking than human doctors, then that's a win.
- sinenomine 4y agoIt is hard to overestimate just how scarce even the median human doctor competency is, at the global scale. If large language models indeed can give billions access to mostly-reliable medical diagnosis ... it will be a huge humanitarian win. Honestly, I hoped that this company https://www.humandx.org/ https://www.humandx.org/ will make it real, but at same point they apparently pivoted to providing app-based quiz training to doctors. Maybe just taking an off the shelf instruct-tuned language model and tuning it on expert-curated corpus of doctor-patient dialogue is the right way of approaching this. Someone will do it, it's not even as costly as people imagine. Email me if interested.
- nradov 4y agoComputer aided diagnostic software has been around for decades. It isn't very useful in improving medical outcomes. Diagnosis isn't particularly hard in routine cases. The hard part is in gathering relevant data and entering it into a computer. Some parts of that data gathering can be automated to an extent, but in general it remains an unsolved problem. For example, large language models can't collect a useful patient history.
- sinenomine 4y agoI agree with the fundamental data/measurement bottleneck. Humans should likely concentrate our effort on scaling and democratizing this, physical, side of the equation. Still, given the apparent usefulness of basic unaided visual analysis https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK330/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK330/ I expect the upcoming multimodal language models to provide a tangible enhancement to diagnosis accuracy, if we allow them to see the photos of the patient.
- wwweston 4y agoThe most likely near-term way LLMs could help would be generating hypotheses about illness and treatment which would then be considered by a doctor who can understand when the LLM is mammalizing fish so to speak.
- treeman79 4y agoI’m on a number of support forums for illness. It is shocking how often doctors are flat wrong. Refuse to run tests, or ignore positive tests. Constantly see people post test results that are a clear positive and doctor says nothing is wrong. This is on top of some diagnosis can take months to multiple years. Of course it goes both ways. A number of conditions can often be managed by diet alone. Some People will go ballistic if you suggest they try this. Umm. You have 3 months until next appointment. Why not try healthy food in mean time?
- p1esk 4y agoIt is shocking how often doctors are flat wrong. I’m not going to dispute this statement, however it’s not clear how you can tell when it’s the case. The only way seems to consult multiple doctors and do a majority voting. Is that how you operate your illness support forum?
- treeman79 4y agoPeople post what symptoms are. What tests they have had, what doctors have said. People make suggestions on what conditions they should investigate. What tests should be run next. What kind sort of doctor they should see next. Something like Sjogrens, doctors tend to very out of date on testing criteria. So often a patient has every symptom. But doctor is highly dismissive of it. Or a test with a high false negative rate is negative. Doctor immediately stops testing. Even though better tests exist. Another example is when I see someone complaining about double vision. They need to go get a spinal tap to measure pressure. Not a lot of doctors realize that.
- p1esk 4y agoYou’re speaking as if you’re a doctor with better than average training and experience. Are you?
- bookofjoe 4y ago>Not a lot of doctors realize that. Retired neurosurgical anesthesiologist (38 years experience) here. It would never occur to me (or neurosurgeons I worked with) to order a spinal tap if a patient presented with double vision. Elevated cerebrospinal pressure — if present — could cause acute brain stem herniation and sudden death.
- mcguire 4y agoWho is going to accept liability when they're wrong?
- sinenomine 4y agoInvasive treatments should be signed off by a real person for the time being.
- RGamma 4y agoThe patient lol