11 ms·
TSMC starts volume production of 3nm chips
- yazaddaruvala 4y ago> 3nm technology would feature an estimated 60 percent gain in density of logic transistors and reduce power consumption by 30 percent to 35 percent at the same rate compared with 5nm technology I'm really looking forward to the new Gravitons and the M3 Pro/Max/Ultra MacBooks! and what they will be able to achieve.
- amelius 4y agoAnd Apple will take all the credit for TSMC's achievements, as usual.
- r00fus 4y agoYou do realize that TSMC is heavily bankrolled by Apple right?
- keepquestioning 4y agoWho has the details of this strategic relationship? Remember Apple's infamous $200 billion cash-pile during the peak iPhone era of 2010-2016? How much of it went to TSMC?
- AnonMO 4y agoThey are currently just under $50 billion and have bought back $130 billion+ in shares since 2018 I would most if not all of their reserves went into buybacks.
- discordance 4y agoAnd ASML will remain in the shadows
- congoe 4y agoSo will Zeiss
- lotsofpulp 4y agoASML has a market cap of $227B, and is 37th in rankings of market cap worldwide. Hardly in the shadows. TSMC is in 12th at $395B. For curiosity’s sake, Zeiss is #1,327 at $11B. Not bad though, P/E of 41, so market thinks it has quite a future. https://companiesmarketcap.com/carl-zeiss-meditec/earnings/ https://companiesmarketcap.com/carl-zeiss-meditec/earnings/
- roneythomas6 4y agoTo be fair Intel and Samsung are also ASML EUV customers.
- Night_Thastus 4y agoApple is one of TSMC's largest customers. Their presence in the market alone shifts how TSMC designs its processes and does business in general. I don't think TSMC gives a hoot about "who takes credit" considering how much $ they're getting out of this arrangement.
- wmf 4y agoApple chose to use N3, AMD chose to use N4, and Intel chose to use 7. I think it's fair to give Apple credit for making a tradeoff that leads to a better product.
- picture 4y agoSmaller transistors does indeed reduce dynamic power consumption as transistors can switch with less charge, however the leakage current (static power consumption) will rise, more than the already significant amounts. I'm not sure how much actual energy savings will come from this in an application like laptops. Also, increased density isn't a huge deal as, while it reduces the die size which reduces the cost, it also likely costs more than an already mature process. It can help with increasing the amount of logic gates in series before needing to be pipelined to the next clock cycle, but that's not that big of a deal either
- Symmetry 4y agoLeakage power will rise all else being equal, but there are plenty of things designers can do to counteract that for reasonable costs.
- baybal2 4y ago[dead]
- rowanG077 4y agoReducing logic density will still allow for lot's of more SRAM for a chip of the same size. Even if SRAM won't scale. More SRAM is almost always a cheat code for squeezing more performance out of a design.
- paulmd 4y agoLogic and SRAM are completely different things in this context. SRAM actually has had almost zero scaling since N7 while logic has more than doubled in density (2x theoretical / 1.5-1.6x real-world shrink at N5 relative to N7, for example, and then N3 gives about 30% real-world shrinks to logic, although that’s less than expected and the good shrinks are going to come from the later N3E node). As a result we will probably see the pendulum swing back from cache-heavy designs. Going ham on cache was an obviously advantageous strategy at 7nm, you can basically look at it as N7 having been two full node families ahead of the curve on sram density (Samsung is only catching up at 3nm/2nm). But since SRAM hasn’t scaled at all in the last 2 nodes it’s becoming comparatively more effective to spend your transistors on logic instead. You still want big caches of course (and cache can be easily stacked ala AMDs v-cache) but it’s more worthwhile to spend more heavily on logic than it was on 7nm.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago> what they will be able to achieve. Who? TSMC and Arm?
- whoIsYou 4y agoI just don't know what is left to achieve really. I have an M1 pro and I just don't really hit any bottlenecks in my workflow as is (unless I am building some obscenely large legacy codebase) It just seems to me that we are hitting a point of diminishing returns in terms of CPU performance because honestly, the speed of my laptop could triple and it would not noticeably affect my experience in any way. The main areas of improvement that I would actually notice are better battery life, and faster RAM and SSDs (faster networking as well)
- blovescoffee 4y agoBetter battery life is equivalent to more efficient power consumption (that the 3nm process improves on).
- mcbits 4y agoThis is more GPU than CPU, but I want to infer 3D models from my security cameras in real time so I can do some CSI "turn left and look behind it" shit. And use the overlapping textures for superresolution so I can shout "enhance!" and read the license plate reflected in the perp's eyeball. As for reading e-mails and so on, yeah, we've pretty much reached peak e-mail.
- barganzo 4y agoIf you can’t do that stuff right now with today’s CPUs, in sub-realtime, then throwing more/faster CPU at it won’t make it possible.
- mcbits 4y agoI haven't described anything that can't already be done (well, reading a license plate in an eyeball was mostly an exaggeration). It just can't be done affordably in real time on a home computer. And it's just the first few out of many examples to come to mind. I think people fall into the trap of conflating "this is what I do with my computer" with "this is what my computer is for." Obviously if computers are only for doing the things you can already do with them, then they won't benefit much from improvements.
- CSMastermind 4y agoI don't know much about chip fabrication but reading wikipedia I see this: > The term "3 nanometer" has no relation to any actual physical feature (such as gate length, metal pitch or gate pitch) of the transistors. ... a 3 nm node is expected to have a contacted gate pitch of 48 nanometers and a tightest metal pitch of 24 nanometers... "3 nm" is used primarily as a marketing term by individual microchip manufacturers ... there is no industry-wide agreement among different manufacturers about what numbers would define a 3 nm node So can someone who is more familiar with it help me understand what progress we're making in terms of the physical aspect of the chips? Is transistor density still increasing? Are we using different materials? At a physical level what's different about this generation of chips?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- atq2119 4y agoYes, transistor densities are increasing, interconnects are getting denser as well (that's what the "metal pitch" is about). There are also improvements in power consumption. I imagine there is more use of EUV and surely material compositions are getting tweaks as well. This is pretty much as it has been for the last couple of decades, though at a somewhat slower rate and with an increasing number of caveats. For example, the density of SRAM has recently been decreasing more slowly than the density of logic. What's particularly tricky are the economics: the cost per transistor isn't really going down much anymore.
- mk_stjames 4y agoLook at FinFET transistors; this is the style of MOSFET currently employed at the smallest scales that I know of; This is what started calling the feature size of the process node smaller and smaller past 24nm- at least for recent processes, the smallest parts of the "fin" were getting down in the 10-7nm range, and smaller.... but this isn't the size of the whole transistor, it needs multiple fins on either side to make the gate structure. So this was what happened when we end from talking about MOSFET feature size to the single-digit process node sizes that are essentially marketing terms now verses actual gate size. There are actual density increases do to the packing of these type of FinFETs vs. more traditional MOSFETS. Thus the efficiency gains that have been happening. Among other reasons. Or at least that is my understanding.
- xnx 4y agoIt's been a great run for the past few decades getting improved performance for "free" (i.e. through extremely advanced CPU engineering), and I'm glad they're still able to eek out another generation of hardware improvement. Curious how hitting limits/diminishing-returns in silicon will force innovation in architecture and software. Will be amazing to see the pendulum swing back toward software optimization. So much performance is being wasted or left on the table.
- kylehotchkiss 4y agothere was a HN post yesterday about replacing Redux with ChatGPT, so I would have to agree maybe we can all aspire to write slightly leaner software with the massive performance laptops tend to have these days!
- NovaVeles 4y agoThis is something I think in the next 5 years will become a major thing. Broadly speaking from an OS level, the folks that optimize their software the best will see big benefits. I have advocated (lightly so) to some Linux folks that we should start moving to where the situation will be by the end of the decade. Optimize now before we have too. The pessimist (AKA Stallman) in me is thinking that vendors like Apple and Microsoft are going to use things like their Security processors to force people to buy new hardware. Software optimizations can potentially keep older hardware going for a lot longer, but by having an arbitrary security chip requirement - folks can be forced to purchase new hardware every few years as older model support is dropped. We are already seeing this in Windows 11. While we will not have a year of the Linux desktop, the ability for the speed optimizations to be more open to all people could be a sizable win for the platform. Provided the ability to do this isn't locked down.
- visarga 4y agoMove compute closer to memory.
- zozbot234 4y agoYou mean moving memory closer to compute. And that's happening already in lots of places, even though it brings increased complexity due to having to account for NUMA.
- imiric 4y agoA few questions for those familiar with chip production: 1. How much smaller can we make the silicon process before we run into physical limitations? How many years do you think that gives us? 2. What are the most promising alternatives to silicon? Carbon nanotubes, photons? How many years are we realistically away from these being commercially viable?
- dotnet00 4y agoI think we're getting pretty close to Silicon's limits, optimistically maybe 2-3 more node shrinks. After that, I think Gallium Arsenide is the next most accessible material which should have room for a few more nodes. By then hopefully those more exotic technologies like carbon nanotube transistors will be a bit more viable. I'm not much of an expert though, just recalling what was covered in one of my lectures.
- NovaVeles 4y agoI am not so keen on photon transistors, at least not in the short term. I have seen them proposed for decades but progress has been slow at best. Maybe some folks will figure it out and we will make that leap but current progress is not looking great. As for Carbon nano tubes, I'm not too familiar with the applications of this for transistors but it does sound like something that can get us a little further down the road. All this arm chair speculation. All the people that work on these things would know far better than me. And I mean ALL the people! ;)
- dotnet00 4y agoI agree regarding photonic transistors, I have a hard time seeing how those would scale down to even current transistor sizes/densities. Especially given that they'd probably have to rely on much shorter wavelength light, which comes with its own issues. Carbon Nanotube transistors are fairly promising though, they're structured similarly to regular transistors but can have some neat properties like ballistic transport regimes (meaning zero resistance when enough current is going through), better heat dissipation and ability to handle much higher currents. IIRC they're also very tunable with the bandgap controlled by the shape of the tube. Main issue with CNT transistors is just that - as with most things involving CNTs - we need production methods that are significantly more consistent with the shape and quality of tube they produce. We'd need to be able to print billions of tubes per chip with almost the exact same shape to compete with traditional semiconductors.
- shmerl 4y agoDo AMD plan a 3nm refresh or they'll do it only for next generations of chips?
- Grazester 4y agoSomething tells me by the time this trickles down to AMD they will be on their next CPU iteration. Maybe some part of their Zen4 APU's maybe in 3nm.
- beebeepka 4y agoZen 5 is the most likely candidate. Early 2024?
- mdasen 4y agoAMD has said that 3nm will come with Zen 5c. The Zen 5 is set to launch in 2024 with the Zen 5c happening after that so most likely in 2025. Zen 4 just launched at 5nm after Apple had been using 5nm for 2 years. It looks like Apple will be the only 3nm customer in 2023. Apple is not only selling a lot of phones, but they also need a follow-up to the M1/M2 processors (and the M2 is a very marginal improvement). I don't want to sound like I'm knocking the M1 because it's truly amazing to have an M1 laptop, but Apple is shipping a 2-year-old processor in all its laptops. While the Mac might not use as many chips as their phone biz, the chips are larger which means using up more of TSMC's capacity. Again, it took AMD 2 years to get to 5nm after Apple launched their 5nm chips. AMD might get to 3nm faster than they got to 5nm, but I wouldn't count on it. Qualcomm is sticking with 4nm for their 2023 Snapdragons. Samsung's transistor density for their "3nm" 2GAE is basically equivalent to TSMC's 4nm (while TSMC's 3nm is nearly 50% higher). If the question is "should I wait for something that's just around the corner," I'd have to say no. AMD does have a Zen 4c on its roadmap at 4nm, but 4nm can be a bit misleading since we're talking about TSMC improving density by around 6% (and Samsung's 4nm trailing TSMC's 5nm). So I wouldn't wait for "4nm" either. There's always uncertainty around when new stuff will happen, but it'll likely be more than 2 years before AMD moves to 3nm. Remember: we aren't even at the point where anyone has launched a 3nm part that you can buy. Let's say that Apple introduces something in April for their Macs and then launches new iPhones in the fall at 3nm. That's going to be using up a lot of TSMC's capacity through 2023 and into 2024. Qualcomm will want their 2024 chips to be 3nm in Spring 2024. So maybe late 2024 or 2025 some 3nm capacity starts being available for AMD and they can launch 3nm Zen 5c then. Officially, this is what we have from AMD: Zen 4 - 5nm (2022) editorial note: this ended up being September 27, 2022 Zen 4 V-Cache 5nm (2023) Zen 4C - 4nm (2023) Zen 5 - 4nm (2024) Zen 5 V-Cache - 4nm (2024+) Zen 5C - 3nm - (2024+) Could we see Zen 5c in 2024? Maybe, but it seems like a stretch. TSMC's 3nm seems a tiny bit behind schedule and given that Zen 5c is targeting "2024+", it just doesn't seem likely. So, there won't be an update to 3nm for Zen 4 and even Zen 5 won't launch at 3nm.
- bilsbie 4y agoHow are we doing in the chip shortage btw?
- Tempest1981 4y agoFrom the WSJ: > Chip Inventories Swell as Consumers Buy Fewer Gadgets - Semiconductor companies slash production plans amid weak demand > https://www.wsj.com/articles/chip-inventories-swell-as-consumers-buy-fewer-gadgets-11672092605 https://www.wsj.com/articles/chip-inventories-swell-as-consu... Although elsewhere, I read there's still a shortage of chips for cars: > Automotive chip shortages to continue throughout 2023, industry says > https://arstechnica.com/cars/2022/12/automotive-chip-shortages-to-continue-throughout-2023-industry-says/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2022/12/automotive-chip-shortag...
- paulmd 4y agoYeah the distinction is leading vs trailing nodes. Automotive uses older nodes for cost and nobody is building any more of that. TSMC is trying to get them to move to 22nm nodes but so far that’s not what’s used, it’s 40nm and 65nm and 90nm and such. https://www.anandtech.com/show/17470/tsmc-to-customers-time-to-stop-using-older-nodes-move-to-28nm https://www.anandtech.com/show/17470/tsmc-to-customers-time-... Paradoxically there is actually some capacity available at the newer nodes now, because of big cancellations from major customers. But using them involves major design/validation costs and higher wafer costs etc, and the things that automotive and RF and power chips do doesn’t really scale.
- everyone 4y agoDo they make any 5nm chips other than apple silicon ones? What about the 3nm ones, will they all be apple? I would like to put one of those new chips in a normal pc.
- mdasen 4y agoYes, they make a lot of 5nm and 4nm parts for Qualcomm and others. For example, the Snapdragon 8+ Gen 1 is based on TSMC's 4nm (the regular 8 Gen 1 is based on Samsung's 4nm). AMD's Ryzen 7000 series (Zen 4) uses TSMC's 5nm. Apple tends to have the best margins and is willing to pay upfront for TSMC's capacity so they generally get it ahead of other customers. However, there are reports that Intel will be using TSMC's 3nm: https://www.windowscentral.com/intel-apple-tsmc-3nm-report https://www.windowscentral.com/intel-apple-tsmc-3nm-report. Intel has confirmed that it will be using TSMC's 3nm tech in its 2023 products, but hasn't said which products. Maybe we'll see Intel laptop chips at 3nm, maybe it'll be high-margin datacenter chips, maybe it'll be something for enthusiasts on the desktop, maybe it'll just be the GPU for chips made with Intel 4 (5nm): https://www.extremetech.com/computing/338679-intel-may-drop-tsmcs-3nm-tgpu-from-meteor-lake https://www.extremetech.com/computing/338679-intel-may-drop-....
- beautifulfreak 4y agoIntel canceled its order with TSMC. https://www.electronicsweekly.com/news/business/intel-cancels-n3-orders-tsmc-pares-back-n3-expansion-2022-08/ https://www.electronicsweekly.com/news/business/intel-cancel...
- mdasen 4y agoAwesome! Great to know Of course, the article goes on to say that TSMC is reducing N3 capacity with Apple being the only customer in 2023. I think it's just hard to get customers who want to pay what Apple is willing to pay.
- walnutclosefarm 4y agoThe mind boggles at what is being accomplished in semiconductor production at this scale. The smallest features in the (fin width, e.g.) in the 3nm process are roughly 5nm across. That's the diameter of a hemoglobin molecule. Or, to put it another way, it's about 40 silicon atoms. All this enables single chip processors with over 100 billion transistors, so, more transistors on laptop processor than neurons in your brain. Wholesale, that may run close to 1 ten millionth of a cent per transistor. All this, and yet the process for producing transistors in a planar layout on silicon (that is, an integrated circuit) was invented after I was born.
- bpye 4y ago> All this enables single chip processors with over 100 billion transistors, so, more transistors on laptop processor than neurons in your brain. I was sceptical, but this is true! The human brain supposedly has ~86 billion neurons [0]. [0] - Table 2 - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2776484/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2776484/
- mgsouth 4y agoTrue, but neurons are way more complicated than a transistor. Even a synapse is more complicated and powerful. Neurons are more like microcontrollers.
- stevenhuang 4y agoIt gets even more complicated when it is hypothesized neurons use spike timings to "compute". > A potentially more powerful way to construct symbols with spikes is to use spike timing, i.e., to consider exactly when spikes occur within the time window. The maximum number of symbols a neuron can construct with spike timing is limited only by the temporal resolution of the code. In formal terms, the information capacity of spike timing is much higher than the information capacity of spike count. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6665236/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6665236/
- walnutclosefarm 4y ago