9 ms·
Sherlock Holmes will finally escape copyright this weekend
- electrondood 4y agoYay! Now ST:TNG can do Sherlock Holmes episodes again!
- ddtaylor 4y agoThat's actually one of my favorite episodes. I really like all the ship in a bottle episodes.
- mahkeiro 4y agoIn the US. it's in public domain in Europe for the last 20 years.
- kmeisthax 4y agoUh... doesn't the EU have the same life+70 terms the US has? In fact, weren't they the reason that Disney was able to get their term extension in the US?
- arlcode 4y agoNow they do, but at the time of publishing they had different rules so those apply.
- input_sh 4y agoArthur Connan Doyle died in 1930, therefore life+70 is 2000. In general, yes, both use life+70, but different rules apply to works before that was settled.
- zerocrates 4y agoUS copyrights at the time these Holmes stories were published were good for 2 28-year terms, with a required renewal to get the second one. The Copyright Act of 1976 changed the term to "life of the author plus 50 years," but only for works created in 1978 or later. For works from before 1978 still in copyright under the old system, it extended the renewal term's length by 19 years for a new total of 75 years. The US thereafter had no works enter the public domain until 1998, with the oldest works that were still covered at the '76 Act's date of effectiveness (those from 1922) having finally expired 20 years later (copyrights always run through the end of the calendar year they expire in). Later that year, Congress tacked another 20 years onto all future and still-active existing copyrights with the Copyright Term Extension Act, so the public domain "paused" again until 2019, when works from 1923 entered the public domain. There have been no more extensions, so the following years have continued moving forward with successive years' works losing copyright protection. In 2023 the relevant year will be 1927. The final Holmes stories at issue here are from 1927, and so will be public-domain on January 1. It will be quite some time before anything under the "life of the author" regime in the US will fall into the public domain: authors who published works and then also died in 1978 would have the soonest expiration, in 2049.
- kmeisthax 4y agoGotcha. So America's attempt at reconciling the Berne Convention and pre-1973 law gave Arthur Conan Doyle extra copyright years that didn't apply in the EU or UK. Also, I wouldn't be surprised if the expiration pause triggered by the 1976 act winds up being longer and more intolerable than the Berne or EUCD/SBCTEA[0] pauses. There's a lot of 1978 artists still alive today, after all. And of course, if anyone ever figures out aging reversal and functional immortality, then we also get perpetual copyright. (Who the fuck thought life terms were a good idea?) [0] More derisively known as the Mickey Mouse Protection Act
- zerocrates 4y agoOh yeah, once we're into life of the author territory it becomes much more unpredictable when things will actually go out of copyright. And in 2049 and forward for many years, you'll have a mixture each year of older 95-year expirations and newer life+70 ones... it's a mess.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mlboss 4y agoTime to create some new adventures using chatgpt
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kmeisthax 4y agoI can finally retire the "Sherlock Holmes' emotions are still copyrighted" legal argument that I used to use for explaining the penumbra of the public domain.
- EGreg 4y agoTell us !!
- bena 4y agoEh. The Conan Doyle estate argues that the characterization of Holmes was materially different in some of the final stories. So any story that materially changes Holmes to be less of an ass was using that characterization. Netflix was about to take them to court over Enola Holmes, but all parties eventually settled and the suit was dropped. Likely the Conan Doyle estate realized their final copyrights were about to be up and it wasn't worth the legal battle they would likely lose because "having emotions" is incredibly vague.
- PicassoCTs 4y agoEmotions about the character of persons, that are deducted by the length of the nose and the span of the eyebrows? Seriously, reading the books with a detectives eyes, one can see all the nonsense they believed aeons ago..
- bena 4y agoI mean, Holmes can only really be as smart and capable as Arthur Conan Doyle was. Any blind-spots or nonsense Holmes engaged in was because Conan Doyle believed it. Which means Holmes believed in some really batshit ideas. But since the world of Holmes is defined by Conan Doyle, shit like phrenology was real in that world.
- PicassoCTs 4y agoOr that ridiculous quak-science with the monkey stem cells transfusion. The deduction stories were excellent, but some of the outlier-stories or the "nationalism" race characteristics are the insanity that gave us WW1 and WW2.
- chris_wot 4y agoAnyone wonder why Mickey Mouse is no longer the signature Disney character any more? I think we know why now. No more control over the character.
- dvngnt_ 4y agowho is the central mascot then
- cultofmetatron 4y agospiderman
- d-us-vb 4y agoI hope you're joking. Spider-man is owned entirely by Sony. It is only by a tenuous contract that Disney was able to get Spider-Man into the MCU.
- CharlesW 4y agoSony has film rights only, for as long as they produce a new Spider-Man movie every five years.
- citizenkeen 4y agoWow. No. Spider-Man is owned by Marvel, which is owned by Disney. Sony has an exclusive license to the film rights which they will eventually lose and cede back to Disney.
- toast0 4y ago> Sony has an exclusive license to the film rights which they will eventually lose and cede back to Disney. Not if they keep making a reboot and two sequels every few years (contract is one film every 5 years, AFAIK)
- MisterBastahrd 4y ago
- bilsbie 4y agoHow come the owners don’t just trademark these characters to get around the expired copyright? Wouldn’t that let them block all new material made with those characters? (Asking for a friend)
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoMy guess is that there is a window of time from creation of a mark during which it must be registered to be valid.
- alazsengul 4y agoThis is from an article on Mickey Mouse that was linked to in the original Sherlock Holmes article: Here is where it gets tricky: Disney also holds trademarks on its characters, including the “Steamboat Willie” version of Mickey Mouse, and trademarks never expire as long as companies keep submitting the proper paperwork. A copyright covers a specific creation (unauthorized copying), but trademarks are designed to protect against consumer confusion — to provide consumers assurance about the source and quality of a creation. Boiled down, any public domain use of the original Mickey cannot be perceived as coming from Disney, Ms. Ginsburg explained. Source: https://web.archive.org/web/20221227170631/https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/27/business/mickey-mouse-disney-public-domain.html https://web.archive.org/web/20221227170631/https://www.nytim...
- Sunspark 4y agoOut of curiosity, how clear does it need to be presented to the viewer that this is not a Disney production? Does it need to be written out at the beginning "The characters depicted here are entirely fictional and are not from the Disney corporation"? Or can it be at the end credits? Is it sufficient to expect that a viewer seeing the Warner Brothers animation and music at the beginning would know it's not Disney, or does it require more?
- IshKebab 4y agoAs far as I know you can't get out of it by saying "this definitely isn't a Disney product", no matter how clearly.
- AndrewStephens 4y agoFinally! I can start shopping around my spec script for “Sherlock Holmes : The Adventure of the Body in the Honey Jar” Winnie the Pooh crossover.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 4y agoThere was a Winnie the Pooh horror film recently: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winnie-the-Pooh:_Blood_and_Honey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winnie-the-Pooh:_Blood_and_Hon...
- kristopolous 4y agoThank goodness Honky Tonk Train Blues by Meade Lux Lewis will finally be public domain. But you'll have to wait another year for Pinetop's Boogie Woogie by Clarence Smith (who died before the 1929 stock market crash). In all seriousness, the first one is considered the first Rock n Roll song by some scholars. (you'll have to go archive.org to get the 1927 recording - youtube only has later ones - https://archive.org/details/78_honky-tonk-train-blues_meade-lux-lewis-lewis_gbia0385215a/%22HONKY+TONK+TRAIN+BLUES%22+-+MEADE+%22LUX%22+LEWIS.flac https://archive.org/details/78_honky-tonk-train-blues_meade-... )
- irrational 4y agoWhen Peter Pan escaped copyright, there was a flood of new Peter Pan books. I wonder if we will see the same thing with Sherlock Holmes.
- samwillis 4y agoThe copyright around Peter Pan is super interesting with an amendment in UK law to extend it to provide income to the very good cause of Great Ormond Street Hospital: https://www.gosh.org/about-us/peter-pan/copyright/ https://www.gosh.org/about-us/peter-pan/copyright/ > J M Barrie’s gift of the rights to Peter Pan has provided a significant source of income to Great Ormond Street Hospital > The copyright first expired in the UK (and the rest of Europe) in 1987, 50 years after Barrie’s death. > However, former Prime Minister Lord Callaghan successfully proposed an amendment to the Copyright Designs and Patents Act (CDPA) of 1988, giving Great Ormond Street Hospital the unique right to royalties from stage performances of Peter Pan (and any adaptation of the play) as well as from publications, audio books, ebooks,radio broadcasts and films of the story of Peter Pan, in perpetuity. I think this means that the adaptions you are referring to haven't been published in the UK. For those outside the UK and unaware GOSH if the most famous and most highly regarded children hospital in the UK. The NHS here get much criticism at times but the prevision for children is world class with a network of incredible children's hospitals. Having been in the situation where my child has been under the care of one of the children's hospitals, they are incredible.
- fredoralive 4y agoI'm not sure if GOSH can actually legally block derivative works, the relevant clauses are more about claiming a royalty, not a continuation of copyright, ie: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/part/VII/crossheading/provisions-for-the-benefit-of-the-hospital-for-sick-children https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/part/VII/crossh... "Provisions for the benefit of Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children. The provisions of Schedule 6 have effect for conferring on Children's Charity for the benefit of Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children a right to a royalty in respect of the public performance, commercial publication communication to the public of the play “Peter Pan” by Sir James Matthew Barrie, or of any adaptation of that work, notwithstanding that copyright in the work expired on 31st December 1987." GOSH can of course maintain a moral right as intended inheritor of the rights to approve disprove or derivative works, but as the copyright has expired I'm not sure if they have many legal rights. (Not a Lawyer, etc. etc.)
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- nestorD 4y agoThis might be a good time to note that a large number a Sherlock Holmes stories have been written with the autorisation of the estate since the death of Conan Doyle. Of those, I particularly like Neil Gaiman's The Case of Death and Honey.
- hipjiveguy 4y agoOne of my favorites as well - also, "Second Fiddle" :D
- oneoff786 4y agoMy buddy cop Sherlock and his overconfident cousin Elizabeth coming out soon!
- v9v 4y agoThe Arsene Lupin books have the famous detective "Herlock Sholmes" as one of Lupin's adversaries. AFAIK the original editions used the name Sherlock Holmes, but it was changed to avoid legal issues. I wonder which name reprints will use now.
- bardan 4y agoI didn't realise that about the Lupin books. Ironic that Monkey Punch's Lupin The Third comics had copyright issues of there own. (This is why in the original dub of Castle of Cagliostro, Lupin was called "Wolf")
- krapp 4y ago>The Arsene Lupin books have the famous detective "Herlock Sholmes" as one of Lupin's adversaries. This variation also appears in the Ace Attorney games[0]. [0]https://aceattorney.fandom.com/wiki/Herlock_Sholmes https://aceattorney.fandom.com/wiki/Herlock_Sholmes
- helloworld11 4y agoI'm curious, if Copyright stays valid for 70 years or so, how are these books only now entering the public sphere if the last of them was written nearly 100 years ago in 1927?
- lambertsimnel 4y agoIt might be to do with the remaining durations of some kinds of UK (and US) copyrights counting down from the death of the author. (I don't know whether those rules were in place during Conan Doyle's life, but his copyrights might have been retroactively extended.) See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries%27_copyright_lengths https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries%27_copyrig...
- leygo 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mwedwards 4y agoSo, the story concept of Metropolis will be out of copyright. However the distribution of digitally remastered copies of it can remain legally subject to similar licensing and drm protections that copyrighted/licensed works enjoy — but only insofar as the original media from which they are derived are still privately-owned physical property, in limited supply — right?
- lebaux 4y agoi escaped reality this week