10 ms·
Inequality, interest rates, aging, and the role of central banks (2021)
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI'm not entirely certain what the conclusion of the essay is, ultimately. It argues that central banks have been reducing the "neutral" rate over time, and lowered interest rates indicate an economy that needs to induce demand. it argues that an aging population demands less. It also argues that income inequality contributes to reduced demand. These are things I understand. But it just ends in arguing that choices can be made about income inequality and "Let's get to work". What is the work, precisely? [Asking genuinely. I'm not a wealthy person who can buy a politician or give poison money to an academic institution to teach my philosophy. I don't know what the essay wants from me.]
- losteric 4y agoThis piece seems to be focused on explaining the state-of-the-world, with a clear theme of needing wealth redistribution in my uniform. I like that they didn't propose policies, as that brings in personal opinions.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoOkay, but this whole essay is just a well-argued, well research personal opinion. That's kind of what an essay is. I'd like to know what I'm supposed to do with it.
- di4na 4y agoBasically it tells economists and anyone that think they can have an impact to present ways to change this inequality stuff.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> But it just ends in arguing that choices can be made about income inequality and “Let’s get to work”. What is the work, precisely? The clear implication is “policies that address inequality.” (Unfortunately, the only example the article gives is the wartime mobilization [0] that corresponded with the end of the Great Depression, which implies that the solution is to mobilize and launch a massive global conventional war, which seems both impractical and likely to have undesirable direct and indirect effects that would outweigh any salutary effects on the domestic distribution of income and wealth.) [0] And unfortunately fails to point to a variety of anti-inequality domestic economic policies that were adopted within the US under the political cover of the war, which would–though definitely controversial–be a much more interesting discussion point than “wartime mobilization”.
- gemstones 4y agoI have no idea how to accomplish this in our current political structures, but the way cultures have historically solved this is through periodic debt forgiveness. (Every 7 years in the Torah, Babylon did it at the discretion of the king, etc.)
- vineyardmike 4y agoOr through large inflation that devalues existing debt
- Rury 4y agoDebt forgiveness can help reduce inequality, but so can holding people to their debt obligations. And either can also increase inequality. It entirely depends on the circumstances surrounding the debt.
- dragonwriter 4y agoIt is true that many historical cultures have had a traditiom of periodic or irregular debt forgiveness. I think it is far less clear that the effect of such traditions was to constrain inequalities of wealth or income, or even that, lacking the ability for a narrow elite to organize extractive systems at the scale possible in the modern world, historical societies even had anything meaningfully comparable to modern problems in that domain to address.
- imtringued 4y agoThere wasn't much economic growth at the time so paying interest was pretty much a literal debt trap. Forgiving debts definitively helped with poverty back then.
- lukas099 4y ago> anti-inequality domestic economic policies that were adopted within the US under the political cover of the war Care to speak a little more about those? My impression was that FDR's focus shifted drastically away from New Deal policy-making upon the US's entry into the combat.
- 5822130027 4y ago[dead]
- throwawayghh 4y ago[flagged]
- Lanz 4y agoIf you want to see the economy contract and output plummet, play more redistribution games.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoIf you want to see modern serfdom and an eventual peasant's revolt, don't.
- tomr75 4y agothat's what populism/trump/borris is
- nerdponx 4y agoTrumpism is definitely not a peasant's revolt, but it's marketed as one.
- SSJPython 4y agoEven if it's not a peasants' revolt by definition, the peasants' (rural population, working class, non-intelligentsia) support him. So it is a de facto peasants' revolt.
- MuffinFlavored 4y agoworking class == non-intelligent?
- SSJPython 4y agoworking class == non-intelligentsia Meaning not part of the intellectual elite, the sector of society that provides ideological guidance and justification for the system and its rulers.
- 4y ago
- dang 4y agoDiscussed at the time: Inequality, Interest Rates, Aging, and the Role of Central Banks - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28379178 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28379178 - Sept 2021 (182 comments)
- WalterBright 4y ago> The ultra-rich therefore spend relatively small shares of their income on goods and services that directly provide jobs and incomes to others, instead accumulating stocks, bonds, art, trophy real estate, and other assets. Investing in stocks does provide jobs and income to others. When you buy stocks, the money goes to finance the business. When you buy art, the money goes to the artist. And so on. Consider if an artists creates a painting, and sells it to a rich dude for $100,000. Who is harmed by this? I don't understand all the "inequality is bad" axioms that people seem to accept uncritically.
- 0xEFF 4y agoMost assets, both stocks and fine art, are bought and sold between relatively rich people not from the person or company who originally issued the asset. Consider a house, the builder sells it once, but it gets bought and sold on average every 7 years subsequently.
- WalterBright 4y agoLet's say Richie Rich buys a painting from Willy Wealthy for $100,000. Now Willy has an extra $100,000. What's he going to do with it? There's an entire industry of artists making art to sell to the Richie Riches and Willy Wealthies of the world, and this has been going on since antiquity. Why do you think all that medieval Italian art was created? It was rich Italians patronizing the artists. The same with real estate. In the meantime, while someone owns a house, they gotta pay others for insurance, repairs, maintenance, taxes, etc. Even buying the house will cost you 6% going to the starving real estate agent. Owning a house is very expensive, not counting the purchase price.
- nerdponx 4y agoThe money does flow back into the economy, but it's extremely diluted in that the surplus obtained by any individual "downstream" of great wealth is small. Meanwhile, the people spending all that money are the same people setting things up to ensure that surplus flows back to... themselves. So the wealthy people spend money, the people who manufacture their stuff and provide their services get as little surplus as possible without inciting them to riot, and the remainder goes right back to some other wealthy person, and then the process repeats. There's no guarantee that surplus/welfare/utility flows along with the money, and it should be obvious to any observer that it definitely does not in practice. The tired old argument that wealth accumulation doesn't really exist because the money all eventually goes "back into the economy" has always been an insulting hand-wave that is neither a principled model nor in agreement with basic facts about the economy.
- WalterBright 4y agoUnder free market banking, interest rates (aka the price of money) are set by Supply & Demand. Central banks like to think they are not subject to S&D, which is why they make bad decisions about interest rates.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> free market banking, interest rates (aka the price of money) are set by Supply & Demand This doesn’t make sense in any money system. For commodity money, the supply is set by mining. For fiat, by a Treasury.
- WalterBright 4y agoThis was how things worked in the US before 1914 (establishment of the Fed). See "Monetary History of the United States" by Milton Friedman.
- missedthecue 4y agoThe interest rate would be set by how many people want to borrow money (buy) and how many people want to lend (sell). The convergence point would be the price of money aka interest rate. How does it not make sense?
- chii 4y agoThe poster is alluding to the fact that an authority such as the Feds have the inclination to change this convergence point (for whatever reason). Therefore, this breaks the assumption that the money market is free.
- SSJPython 4y agoBecause it is not realistic. In every nation that has ever existed, the supplier of money has always been a monopolist. And this is precisely because the supplier has requested taxes to be paid in that currency that they supply. If you have multiple suppliers of money, then you literally destroy the entire basis of the state. The whole thing comes crashing down. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chartalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chartalism
- logicchains 4y agoFun fact: the Cantillon effect, whereby the first recipients of newly created money (banks and financial institutions) gain at the expense of the later recipients due to being able to spend it first before it causes much inflation, can by itself produce a highly unequal distribution of wealth. So even if everything else in society was perfect, the current central banking system would still lead to an uneven distribution of wealth. This would be remedied if newly created money was credited directly to people's accounts rather than given to banks to lend out.
- valenterry 4y agoRight. Or, banks should bid for receiving newly created money (i.e. bidding for giving out new credits).
- jandrewrogers 4y agoThe Cantillon effect is a desirable result in theory because it can greatly increases the viscosity of the resultant inflation. This gives the economy time to adapt to the change in prices. Depositing newly created money directly into people’s accounts has the same base problem as the current situation — it is misallocated with respect to the need for expanding currency supply — but has the added problem that inflating the currency this way has very low viscosity, which is undesirable. Very liquid inflation is correlated with poor outcomes historically. Any practical allocation of new currency is going to be a misallocation, including a helicopter drop. The challenge governments have is inflating currency in a way such that it takes as long as possible to be fully reflected in the economy so that it is minimally disruptive. This turns out to be very tricky, precisely because it is virtually guaranteed to be a misallocation.
- logicchains 4y ago>The Cantillon effect is a desirable result in theory because it can greatly increases the viscosity of the resultant inflation Whether it's desirable in theory depends on what the end goal is. If the end goal is less wealth inequality, a less efficient but more fair system might be more desirable than a more efficient one that systematically transfers wealth from currency holders to financial institutions.
- raven105x 4y agoIt is very rare for someone to have a sound argument from first principles as to why inequality is worse than equality for society as a whole. The majority don't get past "well, it's wrong because people kept saying so since I was young, duh!" to consider the pros and cons of inequality as opposed to equality (either as abstract ideals, or actualized realities) for society as whole.
- greysphere 4y agoHere's a simple model: people have a desirable quality that exists in some people and doesn't in others. This quality is randomly distributed among all people. To express the quality, a person must have access to some amount (K) of resources. How do we maximize the expression of this quality? We maximize the number of people with K or more resources. Assuming some power-lawish distribution of resources what coefficient of that curve accomplishes this? The answer is the flattest one, assuming the total amount of resources exceeds K*population. This model is communicated at large in various forms, "meritocracy", "you can do anything if you put your mind to it", "inalienable rights of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness", "every life is sacred" and so on. It's such a common model, it seems unsurprising that many people balk at a need for explanation. It's like asking 'explain from first principles why 2+2=4'.
- bbwwnn 4y agoIf the amount of resources is below Kpopulation - e.g. K/2population, wouldn’t that model suggest allocation K to half the population and 0 to the other half? If it is significantly above - e.g. 2Kpopulation, what’s the issue with giving everyone K and e.g. one person all the remaining resources?
- Al-Khwarizmi 4y agoThat there is not one K, but many, and we don't even know their exact values.
- bbwwnn 4y ago
- BenFranklin100 4y agoI’m very interested in this topic and familiar with the background material, but the author’s prose is so poor I can’t make heads or tail of this article.