7 ms·
Global warming has begun to make Norway warmer and wetter (2019)
- rich_sasha 4y agoWho would have thought pumping hydrocarbons from under the sea, mostly for burning, would cause an atmospheric warming effect. At least their sovereign wealth fund is now divesting from fossil fuel industries.
- 543g43g43 4y agoThat website is truly awful. Maybe it's personal, but I hate the "scroll to be shown a narrative" style of website design.
- krsrhe 4y ago[dead]
- nottorp 4y agoI gave up after like the 6th "page" with nothing on it.
- shswkna 4y agoI was about to post, how I love the website design. :-)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoLuckily most of NRK's articles don't do this, but I agree. I always skim through articles to find out if I actually care enough to read it. And when I do read the whole thing, I often have to jump up a few paragraphs. These articles completely break my reading flow to the point where I just give up.
- walnutclosefarm 4y agoThe NY Times does this kind of "presentation story" all over. I rarely read more than the first few captions, because I can't stand the continuous scroll format - it reduces the rate I can absorb the information in such articles by a factor of 4 or more, and increases the work required to get it (particular on the eyes, because reading text scrolling over pictures is hard eye work). I hate 'em. Give me text, charts and graphs, with pictures if they actually add something to the information in your story.
- M0r13n 4y agoI tend to agree. But I also think that the images in the background tend to engage me emotionally much more than plain text would be able to.
- LightG 4y agoYes, especially with this subject matter. Normally I hate, but in this case it works.
- marcusverus 4y agoI kind of liked them when they first started popping up. But after you've seen a handful of them, you realize that they're basically just powerpoint presentations.
- college_physics 4y agoI think its pretty good for its "genre" but its only natural that this mode of delivering information is not to everybody's taste.
- starkd 4y agoThat's because its propganda. The sleek feel is a diversion to lead your thoughts in a particular way. Not saying they are necessarily wrong, but that's all this is.
- raydiatian 4y ago[flagged]
- krona 4y agoI might be wrong but I don't think the site was made just for you.
- raydiatian 4y ago[flagged]
- EForEndeavour 4y agoIt sounds like you've given up hope of avoiding catastrophic consequences of climate change, and/or are worn out by years of hearing about it, to the point where you actively insult efforts to report on climate change developments ("shut the fuck up Norway"). Websites like this are created by and for people who would rather do something than nothing. Or who care to learn more about the problem rather than throw up their hands and be content with the totally unhelpful phrase "the planet is fucked."
- raydiatian 4y agoI learned a valuable lesson reading your comment and will rethink my perspective.
- dang 4y agoPlease don't break the site guidelines like this, regardless of how strongly you feel about an issue. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- cube2222 4y agoEven though it looks like a cool bag of facts, this really is just a bunch of correlations without good citations indicating any causal effect. Which is actually confirmed at the end: > We can't conclude that these isolated incidents are caused by climate changes. On the other hand, we can conclude that such incidents have already become more common. And that it will likely cost us several hundred billion NOK to arm ourselves against all this water. I'm worried that this kind of reporting only helps climate-change deniers. EDIT: Leaving the original comment in place, but it seems like there actually are citations behind the "Source" button which is present on many slides but doesn't work correctly for me on any browser that I've tried. Thanks to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34161145 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34161145 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34161168 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34161168 for pointing this out.
- truthwhisperer 4y ago[dead]
- willnonya 4y agoSo, attempting to be objective and realistic are harmful to the cause?
- cube2222 4y agoCorrelation is not causation. If you're indicating causation without any sensible proof, citation, or well-reasoned hypothesis, and just give a "scary" slideshow with "yeah, that might be climate change... or it might not, idk", then that will help people who are trying to show that "climate-change reporting is a bunch of BS" support their narrative. A lot of people will then, when they see a few such examples, assume that all climate-change reporting is like that.
- lukeschlather 4y agoIf you're bringing up the question of what causes global climate change in response to an article that is pretty narrowly focused on local climate change in Norway, a lot of people will assume that you know that global climate change is generally understood to be caused by human behavior, but are looking for ways to cast doubt on that fact without actually arguing the point.
- Roark66 4y ago[flagged]
- capitol_ 4y agoIt's not very strange that the Norwegian state sponsored news outlet picked Norway to make their case.
- astrolx 4y agoYou beat me to it :)
- astrolx 4y agoNRK is Norway public broadcaster, so it makes sense of their choice.
- Finnucane 4y agoThey’re Norwegians writing about Norway on a website based in Norway. So maybe they have an interest in what happens there?
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoIs there a version in Norwegian?
- tpmx 4y agoWhy doesn't it then mention the (growing) Norwegian oil extraction? And why is it in English?
- jansan 4y agoYes, there are changes taking place, but overall a country with very long and cold winters should be better off at the end with a little bit of warming.
- Simon_O_Rourke 4y agoMaybe I'm reading this wrong, but the way they're presenting these climate change effects I'm thinking this can only be a localized good thing for Norway.
- bentobean 4y agoI know what you mean. The “Oh no, our ground is more fertile” section caught my attention.
- LatteLazy 4y agoTheir ground will also start to disappear as sea levels rise. So there are up sides and down sides for them. Now consider the southern USA. They will also lose land as sea levels rise. And the same changes that make Norway more fertile and liveable make them less fertile and liveable. So the overall affect is: * Bad for everyone on average * Bad for most people because they picked the best places/ways to live (often costal ones) under the old model and invested in those and now will have to move/change all that I think we're about to see the current populous/rich areas realise they're fucked, and smaller colder places are the new them. How will the US feel when the corn belt moves north of the US-Canada border and it has to import food?
- tiahura 4y agoCan you direct me to a single photo showing an underwater pier due to sea levels rising?
- LatteLazy 4y agoThat's an oddly specific question given sea levels have "only" risen 15-25cm since 1900 and most piers are more than 25cm above previous sea levels (and less than 120 years old). You will soon get your wish soon though, we're raising sea levels by 3.7mm PER YEAR. And that rate is only going up. >Between 1901 and 2018, the globally averaged sea level rose by 15–25 cm (6–10 in), or 1–2 mm per year on average.[1] This rate is accelerating, with sea levels now rising by 3.7 mm per year. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise (I like their excellent graph / globe animation...)
- matsemann 4y agoI hope we (Norway) will stop opening new oil fields. Previous contract (Wisting) just got stopped, hope we keep that up.
- derriz 4y agoI also hope so. It’s not like the country can’t afford it. It’s hard not to view Norway and other big fossil fuel exporters as being analogous to cigarette companies. Everyone knows what you’re selling is poison but you get a pass because we’ve come accustomed to it. In an ideal world, carbon fuels would be taxed at source - ie those countries who do the extraction and profit from it would be liable for the associated externalities. Currently efforts target consumers rather than producers.
- matsemann 4y agoYeah, we like to believe we and our oil is so "clean". It's just that we export it for others to burn, and import products produced with pollution attributed to other's soil..
- SyzygistSix 4y agoDemand and genuine need is the issue, not production. Better that production is in Western democracies with high environmental standards than elsewhere. The issue is using those fossil fuels to reduce how much we will need them in the future and using them to transition to green energy. Cigarettes are a bad analogy. A necessary life-saving drug we all depend upon with bad side effects is more apt. Ramping up production of a better life-saving drug is the solution, not stopping production of the old one.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoUnfortunately it seems unlikely with the labour party being strongly dependent on support from unions that are disappointingly obsessed with keeping(and growing) oil industry jobs at any cost. And the conservatives want to do their hydrogen greenwashing nonsense of course. Then the 2 biggest parties after those are populist climate deniers(FRP) and populist luddites(SP).
- 4y ago
- subroutine 4y agoNot to dismiss the effects of climate change, but when we start blaming every environmental change we observe on climate change, I feel like we're bound to misdiagnose a bunch problems. That is a serious issue because reversing climate change is likely much more difficult and long-term (and perhaps conducive to forming defeatist attitudes) than identifying solutions to some number of unrelated environmental problems.
- louwrentius 4y agoThe solutions are already very clear, there is no difficulty or complexity here. It's just another example of the change that we observe all over the world, only this time documented in a beautiful web page. Oh and the solution is quite simple: we need to stop burning things. It really is that simple. This isn't about focussing on misdiagnosing problems, it's acknowledging that there is a problem in the first place and that we must make very significant sacrifices in our way of living. The real discussion is mostly about: do we want a controlled change in our way of living or do we want nature crash down upon us? It seems now that people don't want to change for the most part, just continue with business as usual and thus automatically choose the latter part.
- starkd 4y agoPeople also don't want to starve or freeze to death. Or be reduced to the level of 19th century poverty. It is a mark of just plain bad thinking to reduce any dissident opinion to that of a "denier".
- louwrentius 4y agoThis 'dissident opinion' was clearly a 'just asking questions' bad-faith attempt create confusion where there isn't one. Starving or freezing to death or being reduced to poverty is not a defacto outcome of climate change measures, but purely politics. The article doesn't even discuss specific policies or measures, so it's 100% bad faith.
- thesuitonym 4y ago
- olivermarks 4y agoReads like a sales brochure promoting eco apocalypse. The question is what are they selling?
- tpmx 4y agoThey are selling the image of a climate conscious large-scale oil exporter.
- nyolfen 4y agowhy is it in english lol
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoTax plans.
- polygamous_bat 4y agoReads like a cynical take written to throw doubt on empirical scientific facts. What are you selling?
- kleiba 4y agoSo... much... scrolling...
- M0r13n 4y agoEven if some of the problems shown in the article are not direct consequences of climate change, I am still sad that so much of the Norwegian nature is being destroyed. :-(
- thrdbndndn 4y agoEvery time I click "source" button, nothing happens and it jumps me to the very top of the page.
- hackandthink 4y agoNorway is a beautiful country. Great pictures.
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoSide note - For those that just have a hard time scrolling endlessly for the next sentence (e.g., handicap), in Firefox toggle the "Reader View" (F9) to remove all the spacing, and present the page in a readable format. I believe Chrome has a "Reader Mode" add-in. I do not know how to do it in Edge.
- concordDance 4y agoHonestly, in the medium term (e.g. 2100) climate change will be a net positive for Norway. Less cold deaths, more outdoors, more farming. The same is true of places like Canada. The problem is, most people actually live in places like India, Pakistan and Nigeria. And unlike Norway these places aren't going to get more habitable, nor do they have the slack to mitigate and adapt to the effects of climate change.
- frontman1988 4y agoSame is true for Russia, which is probably why they try to spread climate change denialism propaganda. And poor people in poor countries suffering will only create more labour to be exploited so that is also an advantage.
- NorwegianDude 4y agoLess cold related deaths? More habitable? More outdoors? Norway have a lower amount of excess deaths related to the winter than most others countries, even much warmer countries like e.g. Spain. Being outdoors isn't an issue. It's not that cold in Norway. It's Norway, not Antarctica...
- KyleBrandt 4y agoAre there title rules for HN that would apply here? "Something is happening to [Someplace]" is pretty much meaningless since it is always true.
- motohagiography 4y agoIs there a version of this that is readable that isn't a propaganda spectacle? Look at the narrative form and who it is trying to persuade. I thought climate change wasn't so much about meteorology as it was a general descriptor for a manufactured political climate, where one is either for the solutions or not, and therefore one can attribite literally anything to it. It is just a critical theory for dissolving reason and aligning people behind demagogues. Unemployment? Climate change. Social unrest? Climate change. Fertility rates? Climate change. Heart attacks? Climate change. It's intellectual chaff that only serves to center its ideologues. So long as you keep the reactionaries arguing about the weather they aren't going to offer meaningful resistance to the solutions being imposed on their countries and the co-ordinated demolition of national sovereignty to post-national governing bodies. It's a standard distraction theft. I'm a bigger environmental advocate than any of these climate people, because I advocate boundaries on cities, anti-sprawl, changing building codes to incorporate passive energy methods and legalizing off grid and passive energy homes, national tarrifs on goods made in slave labour conditions, building refineries in the countries where resources are extracted, reducing unmanaged migrations from south to north to car dependent economies where people need heat 8mos of the year, dissolving the supply management of domestic agricultural goods and replacing them with high tarrifs on agricultural imports, among other things, because the job of a government is to sustain the national interests of the people it serves. There are concrete economic and technology solutions to environmental harm. There are no solutions to "climate change" because it is about as intellectually rigorous as a yogic mantra. The only thing missing from that presentation was perhaps a Sarah MacLachlan soundtrack about how sad it was. Outside the bubble, this stuff is still very controversial. Propaganda is very persuasive, a lot of it is really inspiring and funny, and it's as soaring as a pop song, but just recognize when you are being played.
- Tryk 4y agoYou make a lot of claims and sprinkle some rhetoric but I notice you don't actually provide any sources for your claims. Nor does it appear as though your claims are falsifiable. >Is there a version of this that is readable that isn't a propaganda spectacle? > Outside the bubble, this stuff is still very controversial. Care to comment on why there Greenhouse gases are at their highest levels on 2 million years? Or why there is scientific consensus for human-caused climate change?
- londons_explore 4y agoNorway is both a very eco-conscious country, and one of the world's largest oil producers... The two don't cancel out - the CO2 produced from all that oil brought out of the North Sea is far more than the CO2 saved by having eco friendly well insulated homes, electric cars, and hydro dams. Norwegians are the large-scale drug dealers who give a couple of grand to an anti-drugs charity...
- vbezhenar 4y agoI don't believe in this global warming thing because winters around me as cold as they were in the past. But I hope that this is true because having warm climate is a good thing.
- ryan93 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Norway#Fossil_fuels https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Norway#Fossil_fuels
- ThinkBeat 4y agoI can confirm it has gotten warmer on average and we have a lot less snow in the south. Less certain in the arctic regions to the north. I look at photos from the 70s and the shift seems dramatic. But then the photos i am shown are of times with huge amounts of snow. It does not indicate an average. Many models I have read indicate that Norway will become drastically colder due to climate change if the Gulf stream changes. Some newer research indicates this wont happen,.
- jacooper 4y ago> And so, it is too late to prevent Norway or the world from changing. Because the changes are already in full swing. Exactly, so its time to adapt. The swage system can't handle extra rain? Time for an infrastructure upgrade. Getting too hot? Time to accept the new reality and remove stupid laws banning or taxing AC, the East has been living on ACs for ages, its OK. Support relocating homes in danger of landslides, and also support the new farms made possible from the warmer temperatures. > Nevertheless, things are not completely hopeless. According to a new report from the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), we can still halt the rate of global warming. > But to do so we must implement comprehensive changes to our society, according to the IPCC. We must change everything from our eating habits to how we build our cities. Because this ain't happening and Climate change isn't going to stop any time soon.
- yodsanklai 4y ago> the East has been living on ACs for ages, its OK. It's not OK considering this makes climate change worse, that we're trying to move out of fossil fuel, and that energy is also going to be an issue (regardless of climate change).
- jacooper 4y agoNot doing this will affect people, so be it really. Excess heat deaths in Europe are caused by the lack of ACs.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoConsidering AC runs on electricity and solar generally works best when AC is needed most, it's a problem with a solution.
- brutusborn 4y agoI agree that adaptation needs to be discussed. Ignoring it is delusional. However saying change isn’t happening isn’t fair. Many countries have built new energy infrastructure and investment in coal has become unattractive. It might not be enough to make climate activists happy, but we are definitely spending a lot of resources on this problem. Emissions targets are incentivising governments to reopen or reconsider nuclear. I don’t think carbon neutral by the end of the century is an unreasonable prediction.
- calltrak 4y ago[dead]
- college_physics 4y agoImagine some documentary director filming five minutes leading into a car crash that ends up killing the passengers in the front seats and leaving the rest severely disabled. Afterwards she screens the film for us, but for unexplainable reasons she plays it at 1/1000 the normal speed. We are supposed to figure out what is happening. We are somewhere midway the film. Everything looks so earily calm. The driver seems confident on the steering wheel. The passengers are absorbed in their own pursuits. Rain drops hit the windshield. One by one, every few minutes.
- bilsbie 4y agoHow can we be sure it’s from global warming? Aren’t we calling it climate change now?
- TacticalCoder 4y ago> Aren’t we calling it climate change now? Overall temperatures are warming but it's hard to call it "global warming" when there are tens of dead in the US due to a winter so harsh it's going to break records and when it's believed that the entirety of Europe may become much colder should the gulf stream stop (which some believe would be a consequence of warming). In the grand scheme of things planet earth ain't dodging another ice age. So there's that too. If you want to rally more people to the cause I think it'd be wise to call it "man induced climate change" or something like that. Not just "global warming". "Global warming" is unlikely to gain much traction when people are literally freezing to death in advanced economies.
- cujaneway 4y agoInteresting read, I was in Skjåk this August and the entire landscape is covered in pine. My mother in law who's 65 tells me how none of the trees existed around Grotli and the Skjåk region when she was younger, incredible to see how much the landscape has changed in a single lifetime.
- BLanen 4y agoThe "positive effects" for some farmers must be offset by higher variance and less predictability due to climate change, surely?
- kodyo 4y agoIs this a net good or net bad for Norway?