7 ms·
Added 49 volumes of Arkansas, Mississippi, and Tennessee law
- dredmorbius 4y agoThe Fediverse thread provides critical context to the archive itself, which is available here: <https://archive.org/details/govlaw?sort=-addeddate https://archive.org/details/govlaw?sort=-addeddate>
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://youtu.be/2tOJdGaMvVw https://youtu.be/2tOJdGaMvVw
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- akprasad 4y agoFor those who wouldn't click otherwise, a quick description: This is a video about `law.resource.org` and why they do the work they do. The most salient part of the video, for me, is the opening, where we hear from various citizens -- water inspectors, fire department chiefs, building inspectors -- who had to pay thousands or (at times) tens of thousands of dollars in order to get access to law codes that are directly relevant to their jobs.
- case 4y agoCarl is legend. I was fortunate enough to see his speech at Aaron Swartz’ funeral service at the Internet Archive, which I believe is online somewhere. He deserves your support! https://public.resource.org/about/donate.html https://public.resource.org/about/donate.html
- runlevel1 4y agoUntil just a few years ago, the state of Georgia was suing this person for freely publishing the state's official code of laws. Georgia had paid LexisNexis to annotate their laws and the annotated version became the authoritative copy. The state then asserted copyright over the annotations. In 2020, SCOTUS decided 5-4 that legal annotations that are created by legislatures are ineligible for copyright. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgia_v._Public.Resource.Org,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgia_v._Public.Resource.Org....
- joshuacc 4y agoIt’s interesting to note that this decision did not come down along typical ideological lines either. The majority was three conservatives and two liberals, while the minority was two conservatives and two liberals.
- tibbon 4y agoI want to be shocked that 4 SC Justices thought that those annotations were copyrightable. How is this not obviously public data? Legislatures are on our payroll and work for the people.
- imajoredinecon 4y agoIf you have an hour to kill, it could be worth taking a look at the dissents in order to see their reasoning. The justices (/their clerks) are very good writers and decisions and dissents are pretty easy for a layperson to follow.
- random314 4y agoMost people don't have an hour to kill, and frequently use common sense to judge egregious violations of this kind.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Most people don't have an hour to kill, and frequently use common sense to judge egregious violations Most people aren’t lawyers or justices. This is specialisation of labor. If it doesn’t matter enough to spend a fraction of the time reading an option that took orders of magnitude more time to produce, the lazy opinion is a hunch, nothing more.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- random314 4y ago
- AlbertCory 4y agoLegal note: the PTO's "PAIR" database continues terabytes of arguments about what claims are or are not allowable. I looked into loading this as text. Unfortunately, it's all images. You'd have to OCR it. Until fairly recently, most practitioners and the PTO worked on paper.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- winrid 4y agoI love this! They are suing the states, just so they can make law code publicly available. Saints.
- zhyder 4y agoThe legal code seems like ever increasing software code, except there's no incentive to refactor or delete whole swaths of it. How do we create such an incentive? Less is more here too, perhaps more so because the legal code affects everyone's ability to avoid doing anything illegal and to hold elected legislators accountable.
- cuteboy19 4y agoAndrew Yang's auto-sunset laws concept does not seem so monumentally stupid now
- LadyCailin 4y agoIt does. More things than not are better off to default to "an active law". Individual laws might benefit from auto-sunsets, but some of these already have sunsets, it's not a new concept. The general budget runs out, and relatively few things can continue to be paid out (including the national debt servicing!) automatically. But look at that shitshow every time the budget is getting close to expiring. I'm not sure having more of those shitshows every year is a good idea at all. Getting old and stupid laws off the books is indeed a noble cause, but not this way.
- esbranson 4y agoLegislatures are constantly attempting to refactor or delete whole swaths of it. That's why we have elections. Their incentive is the tax money they get to control.
- culi 4y agoI did a little side project where I tracked the partisan lean of each state over the years. I wanted to do a thing where I plot markers for every year where there was a major law passed that affected voting access in some way I was SHOCKED how difficult it is to access public law in the majority of states. And even more shocked about how little academic research and resources there are about this particular study. I found it difficult to find studies that compared laws in multiple states in general. I assume the reason for this is mostly to do with lack of quality databases and resources for this.
- nicbou 4y agoGermany has gesetze-im-internet.de. All federal laws are there, in plain, linkable HTML. I link to this website all the time. They even have English translations of some parts. The city of Berlin has their own version, although I find it unusable. It's slow, and hard to reliably link to.
- fweimer 4y agogesetze-im-internet.de is operated by juris GmbH. They used to claim exclusive rights for their custom-made consolidated versions, and I believe they still claim something like that for historic versions available through their commercial subscription. (It so happens that juris also runs gesetze.berlin.de.) These juris versions are often viewed as authoritative, despite being made by a private company outside of the legislative process. There's another completely non-official website called buzer.de, which handles this so much better. If you want to read the actual law as published, that's another commercial service (Bundesgesetzblatt, run by Bundesanzeiger Verlag), and there, the company claims protection rights as a database work. You are expected to buy a subscription if you want to print or search the PDF files they offer for viewing, or apparently for any kind of non-personal use. Unlike gesetze-im-internet.de and despite its commercial nature, Bundesgesetzblatt is an official federal publication.
- arlcode 4y agoGesetzte im Internet is published by the ministry of Justice According to https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/impressum.html https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/impressum.html is "just" providing the technical infrastructure(?). There is also dejure which is 100%. Am I missing something. The commercial Bundesgesetzblatt is a scandal indeed
- DantesKite 4y agoEven though there's only a few comments, I learned so much about state law and the way copyright is handled. And I must say, I'm deeply surprised. I would've never expected such a battle being waged in the background. It seems so backwards to put legislation behind a paywall. I'm also curious as to why so many southern states have been doing this. Is it a relic from something in the past? Or maybe it's just a coincidence.
- LadyCailin 4y agoIt surely stems from the racist past of the southern states. It's easy to keep "uppity" people (mostly black people, but also low class white people and other minorities) in check when you can arrest them and prevent them from exercising their rights because of laws they have no clue exist.
- miga 4y agoIt feels that discontinuance of electronic proceedings runs contrary to principle that law should be openly available and transparent. If not in the letter, then in the spirit. Why nobody raised this with SCOTUS?
- tmpburning 4y ago[flagged]