5 ms·
> It's not the onboarding, it's how the experience goes a month, or even a year, in. No -- as any product or marketing manager could tell you, it is the onboar
by crazygringo 4y ago
> It's not the onboarding, it's how the experience goes a month, or even a year, in.
No -- as any product or marketing manager could tell you, it is the onboarding.
Using any product is a "funnel" that starts when you open the website/app for the first time. Every piece of friction/confusion that results in lost users, well it results in lost users, period. And that's 100% the fault of the onboarding process. It's never the fault of users who won't stick it out for "a month" or "even a year" (!).
And journalists should be reporting on the experience of the average user. Sure, they should get the perspective and some quotes from die-hard fans as well, but you certainly can't expect a journalist to use a product for a year before writing an article about it that needs to be published tomorrow.
- patcon 4y ago> No -- as any product or marketing manager could tell you, it is the onboarding. Agreed. Onboarding is the main control of the boundary. The boundary (whether in a cell, in a community, in a company, in a fandom, etc) it controls what is "in" and "out", self and non-self. Onboarding is the cell membrane of community. If you fail to onboard effectively, you are a different creature :)
- shortformblog 4y agoThis is a product mindset that’s being applied to something that is not a product in a traditional sense. That’s kind of my point here. Mastodon represents a presentation of open protocols, and all of the work was put into making sure those protocols and the broader network provided a good experience. Additionally, social networks are not things you use just once or twice. I would argue that social media is defined by how it functions as a mature tool much more than the initial experiences. We have not had much in the way of social networks that seem to be designed for long-time users. We focus too much on new users in a space where people use these tools for years, decades even.
- dasil003 4y agoYes, the pursuit of scale at all costs is what has led traditional social media to become such a dumpster fire. Is Mastodon the answer? I’m not sure, but it’s a legitimately interesting experiment at the very least.
- crazygringo 4y agoOf course Mastodon is a product in a traditional sense. Are you going to argue qBittorrent isn't a product because it's a "presentation of open protocols"? Of course it's a product too. Mastodon is an app on the Apple and Play stores, with a back end that's federated. You don't get much more "product" than that. It's entirely possible to focus on a good onboarding experience for new users and a good long-term experience. It's not either/or, that's a false dichotomy. And the idea that we don't have experience of social networks "designed for long-time users" is ludicrous. Virtually every social network out there wants its users to stay for a long time. And with Facebook and Twitter, there are many users out there using them for over a decade. The idea that we "focus too much on new users" is just bizarre, when the reality is that Mastodon isn't focusing enough on that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- shortformblog 4y agoAnd why doesn't it focus on that? Because it's not a product in the traditional sense. It has completely different motives. I'm not going to argue this point until I'm blue in the face with you. Because at some point this kind of stuff is why open protocols always lose.
- clucas 4y agoThen it sounds like its motives aren't compatible with widespread adoption in the same way (e.g.) Twitter is.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> it's not a product in the traditional sense. It has completely different motives If the motives aren’t engaging and delivering value to users, I’m not sure it has value beyond being a curiosity. If those are the motives, then it is a product. Not realising that is the classic trucks-versus-trains mistake. (Railroads didn’t initially see trucks as competition, because they were railroads, and trucks were trucks, while in reality, they were all freight. The railroads went bankrupt and were restructured.)
- paulryanrogers 4y agoWhile true there is also the long-term survivability factor. And email began as super challenging to onboard before web mail. Today it's better, and not because federation was dropped. Rather email improved with better onramps to the network. Throwing out federation because of immature onboarding is like tossing the baby with the bathwater.
- dredmorbius 4y agoOnboarding is critical where competition is fierce and opportunities are limited, and where if you miss one chance you're unlikely to have another. Arguably, the onboarding process for Twitter, Facebook, and other social media platforms is not great, but people are given so many opportunities (and quite often: coercion) to join, that they did so. Google accomplished this for Google+ by hijacking its extant YouTube and Android registration-flow processes to create new G+ profiles. A platform with ~20m frequent users and perhaps 100--300m who'd ever participated in the platform ... boasted over 3 billion profiles. Because every person who registered a new Android device --- a necessary if not frictionless step in the chain of converting a $50 -- $1,000 brick to something remotely useful --- was captured by the network. (Many of those devices also had pre-installed, non-removeable Facebook and Twitter apps on them.) Critical mass, market power, and monopoly abuse also play critical roles here.
- ymolodtsov 4y agoOnboarding to Facebook is fantastic. They've invested billions in finding your friends and people you know and inviting you to befriend them on the app right away, solving the cold start problem which Twitter never managed to do.
- tbossanova 4y agoThe onboarding to driving a car is pretty tough, but people stick it out because the product has clear use once you get there.
- Karrot_Kream 4y agoDepends on the area you live in and the surrounding culture. People from big cities in Europe, Asia, and NYC in the US often avoid learning how to drive a car. It just stands out in the minds of most Americans and many Europeans because there's no reasonable alternative to driving to transport yourself anywhere. It's a great example of how even a crappy product experience wins when there's no competition in the market.
- medo-bear 4y agoi find it hilarious that you describe driving as a crappy product experience. sure it is challenging, but learning to drive is learning how to operate a significant piece of machinery with social responsibilty in return for greater freedom of mobility. ux factors play seccond fidle to this
- Gigachad 4y agoIt’s more that a huge amount of freedom has been taken from you so you jump through hoops to have some of it returned.
- vineyardmike 4y agoI’m an American and I grew up in the suburbs. I hate driving and I avoid it at all costs. I’ve considered giving up my license. it’s challenging, and I can drive competently, but it’s not rewarding at all. I find public transit much more free. Parking? Terrible. Monthly payments? Expensive. Drinking? No driving, but don’t leave your car anywhere unattended. Also, it’s not lost on me that automobiles are one of the leading causes of death in America. So eh fuck cars. I get the freedom associated with it, but it’s not the only way forward, we could create a different world. Likewise, mastadon has a mediocre onboarding experience and we can and should make it better. But it’s IMO such a natural product that it’ll get better.
- aeeifognionio 4y agoMaybe it makes good business sense, but it's no way to live. Living a good life takes work. It takes months to learn to drive. It takes years to learn to cook. It takes decades to learn to write. If you aren't confused, you aren't learning. Get used to confusion or get used to stagnation. Your choice.
- rdtwo 4y agoI have yet to be able to easily read a single link to a mastodon post. With twitter embedded links worked really well on most sites. How do you get reach without that?
- dpkirchner 4y agoDoes this link work? If not what do you see? https://infosec.exchange/@eric_capuano/109570476711349840 https://infosec.exchange/@eric_capuano/109570476711349840
- rdtwo 4y agoThis one actually loaded eventually, win
- TwoNineFive 4y agoYou've confused a sieve for a funnel. Mastodon isn't trying to funnel up every user possible to empower come capitalist aspiring overlord. It's trying to empower the users to filter out the garbage. You even called it a product, which it's not. The article above was talking about you. You can't even conceive that it's different.