8 ms·
Why did the flywheel hybrid system never catch on for road cars? (2021)
- easybake 4y ago> Flywheel motors have often been compared to capacitors, capable of quickly storing and releasing energy. Proponents cite weight, cost, and environmental advantages over traditional chemical-battery hybrids. --- See also: https://hackaday.com/2021/05/30/bicycle-flywheel-stores-a-bit-of-energy-not-much/ https://hackaday.com/2021/05/30/bicycle-flywheel-stores-a-bi... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual-mass_flywheel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual-mass_flywheel
- selectodude 4y agoPeople generally do a shit job maintaining their car where the worst case scenario is generally that it just doesn't start. Having a fifteen pound weight spinning at 30,000 RPM being maintained as well as your average vehicle sounds utterly terrifying.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoImagine what would happen in a crash Obviously there’s energy from batteries or gasoline or whatever in regular cars
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoBut this would equip every car with a detached semi tire (or possible more)'s worth of kinetic energy to go flying.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- frankus 4y agoIndeed. Kinetic energy in the form of a flywheel has both the advantage and the drawback that it’s relatively easy to release all of the energy in a fraction of a second. Of course you can do the same with chemical energy, but we have good intuition around things that will detonate. With everyday substances, both a stick of butter and an SUV traveling at 100 mph contain about a kilowatt-hour of energy, but the latter would generally be more destructive if something goes wrong.
- nerdponx 4y agoIf anything, it's astounding just how much energy is in food like butter, and in such a stable configuration. Alternatively, it's humbling how bad and inefficient we are at manipulating the physical materials in our environment, because we can't so much as replicate a stick of butter without making it noisy and dangerous.
- zmgsabst 4y agoWhat do you mean? A butter stick sized piece of C4 is similarly stable but contains more stored energy.
- rdl 4y agoI thought it was "via a cow", which is noisy and dangerous.
- dtgriscom 4y agoDoes the C4 have more energy, or just the ability to release it (a whole lot) more rapidly?
- HarryHirsch 4y agoThe latter. High explosives come with the oxidant built-in, and the reaction propagates faster than the speed of sound.
- causi 4y agoYou are completely wrong. 1 gram of C4 contains 1.59 kilocalories of energy. 1 gram of butter contains 7 kilocalories of energy.
- saalweachter 4y agoIt looks like C4 is 60% denser than butter, but that isn't enough to save the original claim on size, versus weight.
- TylerE 4y ago15 pounds? Not gonna store much energy. Many cars already have several pound turbo impellers spinning at 50k+ rpm. (And remember force will be proportional to rpm^2)
- bagels 4y agoI don't think there are many turbo impellers that heavy, are there? The ones I've disassembled we're not very heavy from what I can recall.
- dtgriscom 4y agoThe energy also depends on the diameter; presumably the flywheel would be larger than a turbo rotor.
- dredmorbius 4y agoTurbos are small and lightweight. The goal is for them to respond quickly to changes in requested power, with minimal lag (already a problem). So small and light, with effective (air) pumping power. If your turboimpeller is doubling as kinetic energy storage, you're doing it wrong.
- winrid 4y agoI think parent comment's point is that they already have a dangerous spinning object. Not that I think this is a good counter argument...
- mrguyorama 4y agoIt's not accurate. Turbo impellers should not be heavy enough to store significant energy, except maybe in large diesel engines, and are also naturally housed in a large, often cast iron, housing that will easily contain any shrapnel.
- dredmorbius 4y agoTurbos also run periodically and reasonably infrequently, at least for street vehicles. They're invoked generally under high-acceleration or load, not when cruising at constant speed. A flywheel would typically be spinning not only far more often but at great speed and load.
- userbinator 4y agoA bearing failure is probably the most common failure mode, would probably result in an unignorable insanely loud noise, and render the unit inoperable once they actually seize.
- WalterBright 4y agoI wouldn't bet on it. Never stand radially from a high performance engine.
- WalterBright 4y agoI replaced the cast aluminum bell housing on my dodge with a forged steel one, probably about 9x stronger. I've seen pictures of flywheels sawing through the body of the car. I like my feet.
- HarryHirsch 4y agoAll biologists are shown photos of exploded ultracentrifuges. It makes them care for centrifuge rotors, the consequences when limits are exceeded are spectacular.
- dncornholio 4y agoThey are already inside almost all cars though. This is just one with magnets.
- lathiat 4y agoRelevant video from Veritasium today on kinetic energy: https://youtu.be/J_n1FZaKzF8 https://youtu.be/J_n1FZaKzF8 Also this is a problem enough at <10,000 RPM with just normal metal flywheels and clutches that many drag racing and Motorsport rules require extra “scatter shields” to protect both drivers and spectators from them exploding or exiting from the normal bell housing.
- fathyb 4y agoAs of today the characteristics of flywheels are definitely better for racing and not very useful to consumers. But I believe that they will find a usage if we find a way to miniaturize them enough. Regenerative braking converts mechanical energy to electrical energy to send into a battery. This energy is then extracted, reconverted into mechanical energy, and then transmitted to the wheels. A compact and efficient flywheel should remove the energy conversion and could improve the efficiency of EVs. We'll obviously hit a density limit at one point, but we're currently far off. Williams proved it works, but because F1 cars have to use an ICE in a tight package, they had to pick between batteries or flywheels. We should hopefully start seeing EV race cars implement this soon.
- greenthrow 4y agoFlywheels have a ton of drawbacks compared to batteries for normal passenger cars. Not least of which is that it won't just spin indefinitely and passenger cars constantly park and sit for hours and hours.
- fathyb 4y agoI think you misunderstood me: I meant flywheels could be used for temporary storage (regen breaking), as a complement to permanent storage (battery), because it is more efficient for regen and handles energy bursts better.
- aidenn0 4y agoHow do they compare to EDLCs (Supercapacitors)?
- fathyb 4y agoFlywheels should be more efficient. With the current tech for mechanical <=> electrical conversion, a super-capacitor with 100% efficiency would be as efficient as a flywheel with ~65% efficiency for regen braking. The flywheels by GKN are ~98% efficient. The downside is size and weight, which makes me believe miniaturization is the key.
- NHQ 4y agoFlywheels only make sense on a massive scale. We should put one in space.
- midoridensha 4y agoOr in (or near) a power plant to store utility-scale power from renewables.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThis is done, as an alternative to "spinning reserve" with renewables-loaded grid supplies. The benefits are mixed. Amongst other problems, the Earth's own rotation actually puts a lot of stress on the rotational axis. free-floating flywheels aren't generally highly practical, so compensations (I believe magnetic bearings are common) are used. The apparently obvious storage mechanism ... turns out to be rather difficult to operationalise.
- elcritch 4y agoCouldn't the gyros just be oriented so the axis align with earths rotation? At the equator thats easy, just mount it vertically. In the contiguous US I'd guess a what 50deg angle? It'd be fun in a scifi movie to see large disc shaped buildings sticking half way out at an angle all over.
- BenjiWiebe 4y agoI believe you'd actually need the axis of rotation to be the same. So a horizontal flywheel, mounted on either pole.
- elcritch 4y agoAt the equator a gyroscope on its side would have the same orientation for its axis of rotation as the earths. Think of holding a gyroscope on a merry go round.
- 4y ago
- aidenn0 4y agoTL;DR batteries got better faster.
- dredmorbius 4y agoBatteries also serve typical passenger-vehicle energy demands better than flywheels, with far less complexity and risk.
- erik_seaberg 4y agoDoesn’t a flywheel resist changes in direction like a gyroscope?
- pfdietz 4y agoLess of a problem if the axis of the flywheel is vertical.
- ragebol 4y agoThen steering becomes more difficult.
- pfdietz 4y agoWhy would that happen? Rotation of the vehicle around an axis parallel to the axis of the flywheel will cause no gyroscopic effects.
- toxik 4y agoTo better understand the intuition here, imagine you spin a really heavy bike wheel on an axle held horizontally between your hands. It would be easy to spin the axle, which is the equivalent of turning the car here. To be clear I’m agreeing with you.
- userbinator 4y agoYes, although I'm not sure how much that effect would be noticeable in the systems discussed.
- omginternets 4y agoI imagine they’re placed parallel to the ground, which would have the additional benefit of reducing body roll during turns.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoHa ha, could cause you to nose down (or up) though. Rotational physics is weird.
- _whiteCaps_ 4y agoCaterpillar makes a flywheel UPS: https://h-cpc.cat.com/cmms/v2?&f=subfamily&it=group&cid=402&lid=en&sc=US&gid=18492969&nc=1 https://h-cpc.cat.com/cmms/v2?&f=subfamily&it=group&cid=402&... I was talking to one of their engineers a long time ago, so the details may be fuzzy, but I think they're able to start supplying power in a single 60hz cycle. The idea is that the flywheels cover the start time of your diesel generators.
- SoftTalker 4y agoYeah big data centers use these.
- Gud 4y agoAlso hospitals.
- _whiteCaps_ 4y agoYeah, that was the use case they told me about - makes sense, you don't want to lose power in the middle of heart surgery.
- amelius 4y agoWhy is it so hard to find the maximum stored energy on that webpage?
- Maxburn 4y agoYes, we used these in data centers. They were not considered a battery replacement though, what they did was for areas of the world that take frequent and quick power loss events they allow the UPS system to ride through a small power loss without hitting the batteries (prolonging life) or generators (saving wear/fuel). The flywheel only lasts a couple minutes under full load. Any power loss longer than that transfers to battery and triggers a generator run to prepare to take the load long term. In that case why have batteries at all? Because generators and transfer switches aren't perfect. On typical data centers the batteries are sized for a fifteen minute full load capacity. That's fifteen minutes where the on site people can potentially fix something. That's one reason, the other is with flywheel you must start the genset earlier so it can take power before the flywheel dies, leading to more wear and fuel usage. Starting motors creates a lot of wear, drastically increase that and your gensets don't last long at all. Why not have a lot more batteries than fifteen minutes? The batteries are sized for the computer load only, not the full facility HVAC load. In general in a server room that's at capacity you have fifteen minutes run time without HVAC before you start shutting servers down on high temperature. So as you can see flywheels are an expensive addition that only make sense in certain isolated areas with bad power.
- ramyarjahani 4y ago[dead]
- js2 4y agoLane Motor Museum in Nashville, TN has the 1967 Gyro-X in their collection, a 2-wheeled vehicle with a gyroscope for balance. https://www.lanemotormuseum.org/collection/cars/item/gyro-x-1967 https://www.lanemotormuseum.org/collection/cars/item/gyro-x-... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tqGB1zOICfg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tqGB1zOICfg
- tguvot 4y agoI believe hybrid Volvo XC90 starting with 2020 has it https://thebrakereport.com/volvo-using-kers-on-production-cars-in-2020/ https://thebrakereport.com/volvo-using-kers-on-production-ca...
- byhemechi 4y agothat's just electrical regen braking
- tguvot 4y agothey always had regen braking. this is different: " Volvo’s KERS setup is based around a carbon fibre flywheel that spins at up to 60,000 rpm. Braking spins the flywheel up, and accelerating takes advantage of its momentum by supplying drive to the rear wheels."
- perryizgr8 4y agoWhy would they make the flywheel out of carbon fiber? Isn't carbon fiber supposed to be very lightweight? In a flywheel you would want a massive wheel.
- tguvot 4y agomy guess that it's easier to spin-up during braking and it's less weight to carry during driving. I guess they went through a bunch of materials before they figure out price/performance/efficiency sweet point. Flywheel even enclosed in vacuum to minimize friction...
- Gordonjcp 4y agoIt's immensely heavy and expensive, and not very effective. Edit: okay, that's probably going to need a little more explanation. You've got a car travelling (frictionlessly in a vacuum, as per all good physics experiments) with a flywheel that can be connected to the driveshaft with a clutch. When you engage the flywheel it disengages the driveshaft from the engine. Your car is travelling at 50mph, so it has some amount of energy that you can calculate from its mass. The flywheel is at rest. When you engage the flywheel clutch, the car will slow down and the flywheel will speed up until both have (neglecting losses, remember) an equal amount of energy, and the car will be doing 25mph. Bring the car to a stop, with the clutch disengaged again. The car has no energy but the flywheel is still spinning. Now engage the clutch to move off. The car will accelerate to 12.5MPH, because it gets half the energy in the flywheel and once they have an equal amount no more energy can be transferred. You can get around this with clever gearboxes, a bit, and if you're building a multimillion pound racing car that's definitely the way forward.
- archi42 4y agoThe flywheel in the article is not mechanically, but electrically coupled. So while what you describe sounds about right, this is not an issue here.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoSo you've got a heavy and complex motor-generator in the drivetrain, a heavy and complex motor-generator in the flywheel, and a lot of heavy and complicated power electronics to join the two?
- archi42 4y agoI'm not advocating for anything here and not in it for a discussion - it's just that your criticism gave the impression you might have missed part of the article.
- Sniffnoy 4y agoHuh, the flywheels discussed here are charged/discharged electrically. I would have assumed that part of the point of a flywheel would have been to make it mechanical rather than electrical! Is electrical more efficient? Or just easier to build?
- pifm_guy 4y agoTo slow down a car while speeding up a flywheel requires an infinitely variable gearbox. Ie. When you first start deceleration and the flywheel is stationary, you'd ideally have infinity:1 ratio. When the car is pretty much stopped, and the flywheel going fast, you'd use 1: infinity. And in between you'd use every other ratio. Such gearboxes aren't really a thing (at least not without massive caveats). The best you can do is fixed gear ratios and a clutch, or a CVT and a clutch to handle the ends of the range. Both are mechanically complex and not very efficient (a typical shift under load with a clutch wastes half the energy into heat in the clutch material). Compare to electric, where a 'gearbox' consists of software/inductors/capacitors/switches, and you can effectively have an infinite ratio (software) gearbox.
- programmer_dude 4y agoI think it is more efficient if you need power conversion i.e. gear shifting.
- saalweachter 4y agoI think it works better with having a spinning mass in a low friction environment you want to couple and uncouple with at high speeds.
- winReInstall 4y agohttps://www.jalopyjournal.com/forum/threads/clutch-flywheel-explosions-lets-hear-some-stories.185297/ https://www.jalopyjournal.com/forum/threads/clutch-flywheel-... A flywheeel is basically a bomb in all but name.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoNo way!? A spinning offset mass rotating at tends of thousands of RPMs is dangerous to have in your average consumer car? Who could have thought?
- canadianfella 4y ago[dead]
- hansel_der 4y agoturbochargers are rather popular thou
- XorNot 4y agoTurbochargers are pretty light weight by comparison. The energy they store is minimal - they're just there to shunt more air into the engine, not provide 20kW on demand.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoTurbocharger fans/impellers are not offset weights though but perfectly balanced and they are also lightweight. A flywheel on the other hand is intentionally unbalanced, an offset weight, kind of like a clock pendulum spinning really fast, making it incredibly dangerous when something does go wrong. It basically becomes a centrifugal slingshot.
- detaro 4y agoNo, flywheels for this kind of energy storage are not "intentionally unbalanced", rather the opposite. Where did you get that idea?!
- helsinkiandrew 4y ago> Porsche viewed flywheel storage as more durable than lithium-ion batteries in the extreme power charge/discharge cycles of racing A few years ago supercaps were predicted to be in every car for storing shorterm energy from breaking, since then Tesla sold Maxwell Technology [1]. Have any car makers deployed a different technology than Lithium? 1: https://passive-components.eu/tesla-sells-maxwell-technology-supercapacitors-to-ucap-power/ https://passive-components.eu/tesla-sells-maxwell-technology...
- jmgao 4y agoMazda has regenerative braking that goes to a supercap, but AFAIK it's only sporadically available in the U.S. because the American fuel economy testing standards don't benefit much from it.