8 ms·
> If you can qualify for a mortgage, you have a big leg up on people who rent. This is not always true. Often, the price of real estate outpaces rent. I.e. ren
by WalterBright 4y ago
> If you can qualify for a mortgage, you have a big leg up on people who rent.
This is not always true. Often, the price of real estate outpaces rent. I.e. renting is cheaper than buying.
As a renter, you're not paying property tax, insurance, repairs, maintenance, and maybe utilities.
As a renter, you have no risk. Remember 2008 when housing prices tanked?
Making money off your house often depends on how good a negotiator you are.
Most people neglect to consider transaction costs. For example, you have to pay your real estate agent 6% of the sale price of the house. The house also may sit vacant for many months waiting for a deal, this is all dead weight cost.
The first few years of your mortgage, you aren't gaining much of any equity. It's nearly all interest payments.
A renter can walk away any time. This is why renting is better if you're going to stay less than 5 years.
- Scoundreller 4y ago> This is why renting is better if you're going to stay less than 5 years. Sometimes the opposite if you have rent control. Mine can only pass on property tax increases and capital improvements. As monthly strata fees, interest and repairs go up, they can’t pass any on to me. At this rate, I’ll never move out!
- FlingPoo 4y agoI'm in the same boat as you. I live in Southern Ontario (Canada) in a small town (10-14 thousand people). I have a 1000sq/ft apartment, 2 bedrooms, central air/heating . Moved in 15 years ago, rent was $726/month (Canadian dollars obviously). It's rent controlled. 15 years later, I'm now paying $868/month. Just 15 units/apartments here, VERY quiet building. On top of rent, I pay my own hydro, which is about $100/month, water supply is included in rent. I write software for a living, and over the last 15 years I've saved (invested) enough money to buy any house in town for cash. But I don't see the need, I'm single, no kids, and I work from home (second bedroom is my office). I'm 56 now, and am on track to retire in 7-8 years, with low 7 figures saved. The more I save, the more cheap/stingy I become with my money. While I could easily buy a new vehicle for cash, I prefer to keep my (rusted in places) 2010 F-150, I keep it maintained mechanically, and it is still purring along.... except for the rusted rocker panels that is. :) There is VERY rarely any units in my building for rent, all 15 units/apartments are rented by long-term tenants. The only way the landlord/owner can raise the rent is when a tenant moves out. About 5 years ago, the couple across the hall moved out, landlord renovated their apartment, and rented it for $1,800/month (same apartment as mine, just a mirror image). I don't know anything about the US of A, if there is rent control there or not, but it's almost universal in Canada for "purpose built" commercial rental buildings. Private rental units, like privately owned condos and houses, they can raise the rent as much as they want AFAIK.
- Scoundreller 4y agoIt’s all over the place in US, and even Canada. Private condos/houses are mostly still rent controlled in Ontario too.
- Panzer04 4y agoAnd this is why rent control is bad for society - very beneficial for those who have it, prevents anyone else from finding cheap land nearby (because the remaining non-controlled housing is in higher demand :/)
- AYBABTME 4y agoThat's why you'll end up in a slum where repairs are minimal. (at least if you're in a large metropolitan)
- cammikebrown 4y agoAlso, nobody bragging about their mortgage mentions their down payment. I’d never be able to afford 20% down anywhere on the west coast.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoMost of the US is not the west coast, and an FHA mortgage only requires 3-5% down and a credit score of someone with a pulse. That mortgage principal and interest is fixed for the life of the loan. Rent always goes up. Real estate builds wealth because it’s one of the most accessible ways to acquire an asset that historically beats inflation with easily accessible leverage. You can even rent it out after only a year of occupancy (although one can only have one FHA mortgage outstanding at a time). There is always risk with any asset, but you have to live somewhere; might as well borrow to capture the upside if you’re going to stick around for a bit. If you’re renting, hopefully you’re still allocating cashflow to investments to offset the real estate exposure you’re not getting through ownership.
- mikem170 4y ago> an FHA mortgage only requires 3-5% down and a credit score of someone with a pulse Those kinds of loans are a huge government subsisdy, contributing quite a bit to the unaffordability of housing. So many mortgages today are backed by the government. These came about in the 1930s with the New Deal. Without government guarantees it would not make sense for banks to take on the risk of underwriting fixed rate low interest 30 year loans. Many other countries, like Canada and the UK for example, have mortgages that must be rolled over to new interest rates every 5 years. Would you wanted to underwrite a 30 year loan for 500k a couple years ago at 3%, knowing that rate could only go higher? It's not fair. These government loan guarantees skew the price of housing, negatively impacting people who need a roof over their head and don't have the money to compete with investors who can bid up the aritificially limited supply of housing to make passive income collecting rents.
- toomuchtodo 4y ago(Disclosure: I fully support all reasonable measures to make housing more affordable) On the contrary, government backed mortgages provide an opportunity for buyers to become homeowners competing against institutional investors and cash buyers. They are a subsidy, but that’s not a bad thing if desired policy is to encourage home ownership. I would very much like to see your data that these mortgages are what cause unaffordable housing, versus lack of supply, institutional investors buying up residential real estate, restrictive zoning, and most recently, a real estate asset bubble due to Federal Reserve zero interest rate monetary policy (which caused real estate prices to skyrocket when money is cheap). > Would you wanted to underwrite a 30 year loan for 500k a couple years ago at 3%, knowing that rate could only go higher? Tangentially, the bond market seems to be a peace with 30 year mortgage terms, probably because the life of a 30 year fixed term mortgage is typically under a decade (while being amortized over said 30 years).
- pigsty 4y ago> As a renter, you have no risk. Remember 2008 when housing prices tanked? As a renter, you have the risk of your rent shooting up year after year as has happened these past few years basically globally. Housing prices tanking are mostly an issue if you’re planning to sell your house, or you’re one of those people who buy with the intention of reselling. If you bought something in your affordable range and prices drop in half afterwards, well, that sucks, but you’re paying what you expected to pay and missing out on a discount you didn’t anticipate.
- smileysteve 4y agoA poor renter often can not walk away any time as easily as a home owner. First and Last months rent is often a deposit, and when you don't have credit is a minimum, 30, 60, even 90 days notice (and the naive or people who can't take a phone call, research laws, or just don't have time) will sometimes pay more. In effect, poor, don't have credit, then lost deposits + new deposits could be worth more than a down payment. Oh, and those with credit might have gotten down payment assistance (with forgiving), or a low% downpayment - and their worst loss is that downpayment and 7 years of bad credit; plus it takes a lot longer to evict a delinquent mortgage than a delinquent renter.
- WalterBright 4y ago> A poor renter often can not walk away any time as easily as a home owner. Consider how much it costs to have your house sit empty for a year looking for a buyer. There's nothing "easy" about it.
- HWR_14 4y agoI'm not sure of any time I've heard of a house sitting empty for a year. Even in 2009. Until a few months ago, you had houses selling in hours/days, and even now it seems like they still move quickly.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhat can I say. I have. The market goes up and down, and in down markets houses can sit for a long time. The last house I had was in a development with several homes in it for sale for over a year.
- unshavedyak 4y ago> This is not always true. Often, the price of real estate outpaces rent. I.e. renting is cheaper than buying. > As a renter, you're not paying property tax, insurance, repairs, maintenance, and maybe utilities. You are though, are you not? Ie the only thing that changes between renting and owning is who is maybe economies of scale. For sake of discussion, lets say you rent from someone who owns a spare house. You are paying everything you just mentioned, on average, as the renter. If you don't, then the owner is losing money - and that's not likely. Now with a larger business owning your home/apartment/etc, i imagine there is room for economies of scale. They don't have to pay to have a plumber come out, they might already have one on staff or retainer. etc. Perhaps they get better deals on land taxes and whatnot too? But lets not forget - you're paying for everything your landlord is, plus profit. Always. The only way it works out cheaper for you is if they are more efficient at it.
- rileymat2 4y ago> The only way it works out cheaper for you is if they are more efficient at it. One easy way would be the difference in credit scores leading to lower payments for the landlord.
- willis936 4y agoThere is a widening gap between "perfect credit score" and "able to afford a down payment on a mortgage".
- ravel-bar-foo 4y agoThere is a small seeming exception in regions where housing prices are rising rapidly: if the owner is willing to forgo increasing rent at the rate of housing price increases (which is pretty common among smalltime landlords), then renting can appear to be cheaper than the present-day mortgage for an equivalent property. Of course, in that market as a renter you lose out on appreciation of the house, so renting is only better if you can get bottom-market rates near the top of the market.
- dnissley 4y ago
- gaganyaan 4y agoAs a renter, you're paying at least 1/N of things like utilities and maintenance, where N is the number of renters for that property, right? In the case of N=1, where someone is renting a single family home, you must be paying at least as much as if you owned the home, since presumably the landlord wants to make some profit on top of all the expenses being passed to you.
- rdtwo 4y agoYour simplified model leads you to the wrong conclusion. You need a better model to understand the nuisances
- judge2020 4y ago> Making money off your house often depends on how good a negotiator you are. Good luck negotiating with the bank's appraiser. During the 2021 housing craze you might've been able to get 5-digits over closing, but from what I've heard, it was still rare to have a buyer with another $20k to throw your way. Nowadays, you're completely at the mercy of the market and how much the homes around yours are being sold for, relative to your home's square footage and whatnot.
- WalterBright 4y agoYou're not negotiating with the appraiser. You're negotiating with the buyer or seller. > you're completely at the mercy of the market I hear all the time people saying they cannot negotiate. They can. You can. I can. There are many books on it if you need an introduction to it.
- judge2020 4y agoHave you ever bought or sold a home? Unless the buyer is buying in cash, or at least has large cash reserves to give to you at closing, they can only afford up to whatever the bank approves them for, and lenders don't hand out $400k loans for properties valued at $350k just because "the seller made a hard bargain and the buyer agreed". If they did, they'd be upside down the second after closing because a foreclosure means the lender/bank can only sell the house for $350k less than what the buyer owes (and they don't tend to stake their foreclosure sales on whether or not they find another oblivious buyer willing to pay way over market for a house that they could go across the street and get for much cheaper).
- WalterBright 4y ago> Have you ever bought or sold a home? Yes, I have. Several times. You can always negotiate. You're leaving money on the table if you don't invest some time learning how to do it.
- judge2020 4y ago
- EdwardDiego 4y agoIt really depends. On your jurisdiction. On your market. In my country, renting carries a strong risk of instability. As our rental laws were written in the 60s, when it was something you only did while at university. After the Christchurch earthquake, I ended up moving house 3 times in 2 years. Why? Because the landlord wanted or needed the house back. The first one, the farm the cottage was on was sold, and the new owner wanted it for worker accommodation. The second one, the owner's house was red-zoned[0], and he needed somewhere to live. The third one, the owners had bought it for their retirement, and were renting it out until then. Not that I knew that up front. But, 10 months in, they decided to retire. So how much cheaper was it to rent, considering the costs involved with moving, the cost of cleaning rentals you're leaving, the time you spend finding a new rental, and the letting fee that every property manager used to charge until recent legislation? And I haven't even mentioned the cost that such instability imposes on you and your family. My oldest son has lived in about 11 different houses. Renting! > A renter can walk away any time In my country, that wasn't true on a fixed term tenancy, you were liable for rent for the entire term. TL;DR - it depends. Oh, and fun fact, my mortgage repayments + taxes + insurance + maintenance are significantly cheaper than the rents I'd been paying for significantly worse houses. Which makes sense, when the "Mum and Dad" investors are using your rent + tax breaks to cover the ongoing costs until they can sell for sweet tax-free capital gains, of course you're paying more. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Residential_red_zone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Residential_red_zone
- 1270018080 4y agoRenters pay for mortgage, property tax, insurance, repairs, maintenance, and utilities. Along with a bonus middle man fee to the landlord.
- Quarrelsome 4y ago> This is not always true. Its usually true in urban areas especially given the somewhat global housing shortage that seems to plague most of the big cities around the world right now. Definitely true in mine, renting is way more expensive here and now rates have risen and landlords have sold up its spiking even more due to lack of supply.
- Archelaos 4y agoThere are further aspects that speaks against home ownership: a) The money one puts into a house is an investment whose future value depends on the increase or decrease in the value of the property. If a person puts most of her or his money into this investment, this means per se a high risk, because the person's investments are not well-diversified. b) People run the risk of overspending early in their life, because many of them want to build or buy a house for life, which means building something larger than they would rent at that age, thus generally spending more money on housing (via interest rates). c) When people have no heirs or their heirs are already well provided for, it makes little sense to own a more or less mortgage-free house when they die. The money could have been spent during their lifetime. These aspects speak, of course, not absolutely against home ownership. Point (a) cannot easily be avoided, when the property's value is high compared to one's savings and income. But it also means a commitment to saving, which can be a good thing. Point (b) can be mitigated by starting with a small property, selling it later and then buying or building a larger property. Point (c) can be mitigated by a mortgage on the house, if this is possible, or by another financial instrument where the house is (partially) sold but one retains a right to live there until death. -- All in all, however, the danger of overspending is real.
- jaclaz 4y ago>Point (c) can be mitigated by a mortgage on the house, if this is possible, or by another financial instrument where the house is (partially) sold but one retains a right to live there until death. In Italy (but probably in many EU countries) there is a way to sell what is called "bare property" (in Italian "nuda proprietà"), while keeping use of the house (in Italian "usufrutto"). The cost of a "nuda proprietà" is of course much lower than the full one, and basically the buyer is betting on the time the seller will still live, whilst the seller is using the sale income to live those remaining years. It is not particularly common, sometimes the buyer (of course not really poor people) use this form to buy a house for their sons as a form of investment for when they grow up.
- TacoSteemers 4y ago> The first few years of your mortgage, you aren't gaining much of any equity. It's nearly all interest payments. It might not have to be that way. Where I live we have the linear mortgage. Every month I pay a constant amount back on the principal, and a variable amount of interest on the remaining principal. At the end of the mortgage (30 years here) it is all paid off. With this type of mortgage we pay the lowest overall amount of interest. Because the monthly payment goes down each month, the first payment is the highest. As a result some people choose to get a different type of mortgage instead, even though the linear type costs the least in the end.