7 ms·
Kind of related to this is the concept of "Brunswick Stew." Look it up if you want a more accurate description, but as I recall, the idea from Colonial times i
by Waterluvian 4y ago
Kind of related to this is the concept of "Brunswick Stew." Look it up if you want a more accurate description, but as I recall, the idea from Colonial times in America is that there'd be a tavern/inn with a fire, constantly running, and a big cauldron of stew always topped off and ready for weary travelers. The idea is that they never "finished" a batch. They just perpetually added leftovers and foods that were at risk of spoiling.
It's like a Soup of Theseus... it's always the same stew, but it so gradually evolves, the flavour changes, the ingredients change, but there it is.
The concept feels incredibly cozy to me, both in practical and conceptual terms.
- krisroadruck 4y agoalso known as hunters pot / stew. Essentially the same thing as thing as the broth, but in stew form: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perpetual_stew https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perpetual_stew I've actually done this myself in a crock pot for up to a few weeks at a time. The order you add stuff makes a difference. You don't want to toss in fish or anything with real strong flavors too early in your run or it funks things up for a few days. Much as the concept is fun, soup/stew every day gets weary pretty fast. Fun for short bursts in the winter though.
- TuringNYC 4y agoPerhaps i'm geeking this out too much, but I guess it depends on ingress-vs-egress and drawdown....but...doesn't including nearly spoiling food risk the whole stew going bad in a few days? Or do the constant simmer prevent that?
- Waterluvian 4y agoI don't know. I'm not sure the historians fully know. This concept might even be apocryphal to an extent. What I have learned is that the concept evolved (like so much cooking does) from what I described into a "it's actually now a recipe that people prepare once." Something else I learned is that back in the day, people had different expectations for food quality. We would regularly eat rancid meat (many BBQ sauces were specifically built to hide/safen up rancid meat). And maybe while the concept was "it's always going", there were practical things we like to exclude from oral/written tradition, such as "well... actually we purge it once a week otherwise it goes completely bad." Who knows!
- inetknght 4y ago> well... actually we purge it once a week otherwise it goes completely bad I know that when I cook stews I often end up with a lot of food bits stuck and eventually burned at the bottom and sides of the pot. I can imagine keeping it going by pouring the stew contents to another pot so that I could clean the first pot though. Without doing that... those stuck & burned bits will certainly add "flavor" to the stew.
- yourapostasy 4y ago> ...those stuck & burned bits will certainly add "flavor" to the stew. Cooking fuel from wood was expensive to procure, so if I were making such a stew I'd cook it low and slow to conserve precious wood, so maybe they "cooked" over coals back then. If I were to do this today, I'd top off with lots of water before bedtime so there won't be burnt bits in the morning. Maybe try to seal the lid edge with dough that can be used as bread in the morning to sop up the stew (might need to do 2-3 batches of such bread to make the supply of it last through the day). I'd also likely use a rocket stove, a pot heat exchanger [1], and hot water pipes on the inside and outside of the rocket stove exhaust port to extract out as much working heat as possible. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q1j1RI3D7Zk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q1j1RI3D7Zk
- dekhn 4y agoThis stuff is known as "fond" and it's commonly used to make flavorful liquids (stock/broth).
- vram22 4y agoWonder if the word fondue is related to fond. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fondue https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fondue I first read about fondue in Asterix in Switzerland (IIRC). Good fon(due)! #PunIntended
- boomerango 4y agoThere is fond (which can also burn) and then there is charred debris. The former adds umami, the latter tastes like cigar ash.
- SatvikBeri 4y agoAlmost all dangerous bacteria develops in temperatures between 40 and 140 degrees, so as long as you keep the stew hot enough it's likely to be fine: https://www.fsis.usda.gov/food-safety/safe-food-handling-and-preparation/food-safety-basics/danger-zone-40f-140f https://www.fsis.usda.gov/food-safety/safe-food-handling-and...
- malfist 4y agoTo add to this, the ones that survive outside that range are typically anaerobic and can't survive being exposed to air, so that makes it even less likely to be a vector for food poisoning
- GenerocUsername 4y ago2 ways bacteria/fungi hurt people: excreting toxins or by colonizing us. The 140 degree rule basically stops all colonizers since anything that lives in those temps probably isn't planning to infect us. But some extremophile that takes hold in the hot soup could still excrete toxins that build up over time
- kadoban 4y agoI'm not sure there's anything in the intersection of: "grows in boiling water" , "exists outside of the deep sea or other exotic places" , "hurts humans" and "is at _all_ common". If there is, it has to be a really short list.
- zarzavat 4y agoFood goes bad when either there are microbes growing in it (you get sick from infection), or there have been microbes growing and those microbes have left behind toxins (you get poisoned). Nothing can remain alive in a boiling pot of stew, the few things that can survive have very specialized habitats. So the only things you have to worry about are non-living poisons: toxins and prions. Since these by definition cannot reproduce, it’s only a problem if the food was spoiled before it went in the stew. The chance of encountering a toxin goes to 100% as more and more food is added, but it will be dilute, no different to consuming food just before it goes bad.
- pazimzadeh 4y agoSpores will survive boiling, that's why autoclaves (pressure cookers) are used in medical research https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autoclave https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autoclave. But spores are in a state of dormancy, so if you never stop boiling the broth, then spores never grow into anything. The most dangerous thing would probably be to boil the broth in stops in starts
- mgc_mgc 4y agoDepending on the circumstances, boiling in stops and starts may not be too bad: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyndallization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyndallization
- pazimzadeh 4y agoThat is amazing! So basically you trick the bacteria into exiting their spore/dormant phase before you hit them again with another boil. It seems risky because if you ever let the spores divide at all then you introduce further variation and a selection process into the mix, which could be disastrous. But that reminds me of the "shock and kill" strategy used to get HIV out of its latent state before killing the virions: https://clinicalinfo.hiv.gov/en/glossary/shock-and-kill-strategy https://clinicalinfo.hiv.gov/en/glossary/shock-and-kill-stra... And I guess this effect is also why chemotherapy drugs work best on fast-growing tumors.
- 4y ago
- jacquesm 4y agoBefore refrigeration people were a lot less picky about what was considered spoiled food. One of my grandmothers would never look at the dates, but just trusted her eyes, nose and tongue as to whether something was fit for consumption or not, regardless of how much it was past the 'best before' date.
- bitdivision 4y agoBest before not bad after
- ben_w 4y agoThe labels include "best before", "sell by", and "use by", and they don't mean the same thing.
- TuringNYC 4y agoThis is a great listen/read: https://www.npr.org/2022/07/28/1114335397/expiration-dates-lead-to-lots-of-food-waste-though-these-dates-vary-widely-by-st https://www.npr.org/2022/07/28/1114335397/expiration-dates-l... NPR Expiration dates lead to lots of food waste, though these dates vary widely by state July 28, 20225:14 PM ET Heard on All Things Considered
- abyssin 4y agoBack in my dumpster diving days, I discovered how useful the sense of smell can be. Surprisingly, using it to detect bad food also changed the way I enjoyed good food. It became very pleasurable to eat fresh food!
- HarryHirsch 4y agoIt works most of the time, but not always, traditions around food are important. Rice is particularly insidious, rice grains carry Bacillus cereus spores that germinate after cooking. The trouble is that that particular bug grows at fridge temperatures and generates a heat-stable exotoxin. Any prepared rice older than 24 hours has the potential to give you really roaring diarrhea, even if it doesn't taste off.
- sklargh 4y agoCame here to make a Ship-of-Theseus dad joke, beaten throughly to the punch.
- idiotsecant 4y agoI think the coziness of this recipe might be tempered somewhat by the fun food-borne illnesses that would have to spring up doing this.
- unixhero 4y agoI think if it is brought to a boil every hour it should be safe-ish
- twelve40 4y agohow do they manage to avoid that in the article? they list at least three different restaurants that serve these long-running soups, surely they don't poison their customers?
- x13 4y agoThe article mentions keeping it at or above 200 degrees.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoAs others have said throughout these comments, as long as you keep the temperature high constantly, it won't be an issue. Bacteria won't survive in simmering water, so time alone will not cause it to go bad. The toxins that bacteria produce can survive, which means tainted ingredients being added might spoil it, but as always, the poison is in the dose. With a large enough pot, a couple pieces of spoiled food likely won't cause illness.
- pontifier 4y agoInteresting idea. Really fast food because it's so slow.
- bitwize 4y agoMy dad would tell me of roadside chili houses in the southwestern USA (Texas, California, etc.) that always had a pot of chili going that they would ladle out to hungry travelers. The meat in the chili supposedly varied according to what was available: usually beef, pork, or roadkill.
- blahedo 4y agoHuh. I am a relatively recent (11 years) transplant to Virginia and had never heard of Brunswick Stew until I moved here, where lots of people make it (it's "traditional") but I have always found it to be thin, bland, and insipid, so I'll take the minimum amount to be polite at an event but otherwise avoid it. But of course they're all making it fresh from a recipe. I wonder if the reason I'm finding it bland is that the true traditional version includes a range of flavours from all the previous leftovers? That seems very plausible to me.
- mbg721 4y agoTraditionally, the first step is making stock from a bowling-ball.
- shagmin 4y agoMy wife hates it because growing up in North Carolina she associated it with hunters throwing in bits of meat from whatever their most recent kill was - rabbit, squirrel, maybe venison. Never know what you're eating.
- ch4s3 4y agoIt is just bland. I grew in southern Virginia and it was a fixture of wintertime and often sold by churches and fire departments. At best, it’s tomatoey and doesn’t have too many lima beans, but is always a bit gluey and the meat just sort of turns into little string of muscle fiber. Honestly it makes me a little queasy just thinking about it. Most of the time it seems to have been cooled for 2-3 days prior to sale, for what that’s worth.
- sasattack 4y ago[flagged]
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoI haven't had it personally, but one of my SO's tried a famous "perpetual stew" when in France and we talked about it at one point. Her description kinda matched what I'd expect from braises that I've let go to long: you end up with bland mush. I think there's a reason very few restaurants serve this style of dish, and it's not because of health codes. We live in an era of insane abundance compared to the medeivil and colonial eras. A lot of historic dishes from those times just don't stand up to the expectations of a modern pallet.
- notfromhere 4y agoIt's a romantic notion but if you simmer anything for too long it'll just be generic food water at some point
- 2muchcoffeeman 4y agoIt’s just old timey MSG.
- gfaure 4y agoHow does this make any sense? The longer you simmer something, the more concentrated the remaining material becomes.
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoVolatile flavor compounds boil off as well.
- notfromhere 4y agoThe flavor breaks down and so does the food. For example: boil potatoes for too long and more water gets into it. It'll kill the flavor and texture, so that the food tastes watery and the texture becomes soup-ey and wet.
- jrochkind1 4y ago> I think there's a reason very few restaurants serve this style of dish It is in fact quite common in some parts of China, as the OP mentions. But it's just a stock, used in other dishes, not a dish of it's own. > more specifically in the cuisines of Canton and Fujian, where there’s a rich tradition of making lou mei, or master stock, which is used to braise and poach meats. I had read about this before, I recall an article about maybe a US restaurant where the chef had brought the lou mei over from China, and the sous chefs who were tasked with keeping it going. I can't seem to track down the article now. But my understanding is that in fact very many restuarants in China do this, it's standard.
- scandox 4y agoWe had a salad like that for a while but I think it was in danger of becoming a serious health risk after a week or so.
- taneq 4y agoYeah, you can only do it with hot foods that are effectively being constantly sterilised.
- doublepg23 4y agoI just had my first cup of Brunswick Stew the other day. Extremely delicious and was as cozy as you said.
- madaxe_again 4y agoI worked, as a teenager, in a Michelin starred hotel in the U.K. - they had, in the kitchen, an enormous stockpot, as tall as a man, which must have held 500 litres or more of stock, perpetually simmering. There was a stepladder to get up to chuck stuff (bones, vegetable scraps, you name it) in, and it had a tap at the bottom to fill smaller cauldrons from. It was explained to me that it had been going since the 50’s. Not quite ancient, but pretty elderly. Long shift on a cold winter night, nothing beat a mug or two of that stock.
- paxys 4y agoNot quite the same as Ship of Theseus because the soup will never be fully replaced. The will always be some bits of the original – no matter how small – hanging around forever.
- gattilorenz 4y agothe dilution level is presumably not the same, so I’m nitpicking, but technically it could be like with omeopathy [1], where the initial substance can be so diluted it is guaranteed that there is no trace of it at the molecular level in the final preparation. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence_and_efficacy_of_homeopathy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence_and_efficacy_of_hom...
- pishpash 4y agoSounds disgusting and unhealthy. May as well drink stomach acid. There is something about freshness of food not just sterility.
- rgrieselhuber 4y agoCozy is the perfect word and I find myself noting often that the things I naturally find to be cozy are related somehow to finding small portals of comfort in order to make surviving in a harsh world a little easier, developed by people over the millennia.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoYou can do this with whisky. When you have less than a couple of inches left, dump the remains into a decanter. Repeat with every bottle you buy. Occasionally drink some. Never let it empty. It becomes your own personal blend, always changing. Lots of fun.