13 ms·
Why fusion will never happen (2012)
- xkcd1963 4y agoWell yes but we don't know what other synergetic technologies will enable making fission profitable in the future. Very few people predicted smartphones to hit the market in 2010, drones in 2020 etc.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- TreeRingCounter 4y agoThe article seems to blame "the bankers" for not investing in nuclear fusion, while completely ignoring the fact that most of the cost of new nuclear construction is from regulatory changes that happened in the last 50 years.
- LastTrain 4y agoThose exist for a reason, care to say why they aren’t necessary before dismissing them outright? Surely you agree some amount of regulation is necessary?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gamegoblin 4y agoAny set of nuclear regulations that aren't just a copy of France's nuclear regulations are probably too restrictive. France gets 3/4 of their electricity from nuclear without any major incidents. (Obviously this is overly simplistic, there is a set of natural disasters that France isn't subject to that other countries are, so France is just a starting point. But every addition should be justified by answer the question "What about our circumstances makes us different from France here?")
- Gwypaas 4y agoHalf of France's nuclear fleet is offline due to maintenance issues. They've gone from an electricity exporter to importer when it is most needed. Have a look at Flamanville 3 and try to sell another 50 of those to the public. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flamanville_Nuclear_Power_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flamanville_Nuclear_Power_Plan...
- gamegoblin 4y agoAnd yet... no major safety events and still generating a significant amount of electricity. Obviously, as you point out, it could be better. But I'll take France, issues and all, over coal plants every day of the week. I expect France will get their act together. Re: net importer, their amount of import is basically a rounding error, on the order of 0.1% of their energy usage. They are energy neutral.
- Gwypaas 4y agoThe great thing is that the alternative is not coal plants anymore, it is renewables. https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-levelized-cost-of-storage-and-levelized-cost-of-hydrogen/ https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-...
- acidburnNSA 4y agoLCOE is unrelated to systems costs of large decarbonized grid because it leaves out the costs of long-term backup, increased transmission, overcapacity needed to fill the night batteries, and more.
- wolfram74 4y agoYou've made two arguments here, all are necessary and some are necessary. There's a record of anti-nuclear sentiment being stoked by fossil fuel industry[0] [0]https://www.forbes.com/sites/kensilverstein/2016/07/13/are-fossil-fuel-interests-bankrolling-the-anti-nuclear-energy-movement/?sh=35d5b1a67453 https://www.forbes.com/sites/kensilverstein/2016/07/13/are-f...
- nosianu 4y agoThe "key point" according to the article itself is: > Now here’s the key point I’m trying to make: it’s not that fusion is expensive, it’s that everything else is cheaper.
- Gwypaas 4y agoTMI, Fukushima and Chernobyl are acceptable events which we should simply deal with every 10th year when they happen?
- theironhammer 4y ago
- mjhay 4y agoThose events killed orders of magnitude less people than coal plants do every year, from normal operation. Fukushima, in particular, only had one death attributable to radiation. Fission is the only operational technology that can replace fossil fuels for base load. Grid storage for solar and wind is just so under-developed and difficult to scale. We have to stop emitting CO2 ASAP, we can't wait for tech that may or may not work. Ruling out fission because of these demonstrably small risks is wildly irrational, when the alternative is total global social and ecological collapse. Humans tend to judge unfamiliar but small risks as being much larger - think of how there are annual panics about razor blades/fentanyl/whatever in Halloween candy, but not the cars that kill over 70 children each Halloween on average. This same tendency is exactly why there is so much irrational fear around nuclear.
- Gwypaas 4y agoThe great thing is that coal is not the alternative anymore, renewables are. https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-levelized-cost-of-storage-and-levelized-cost-of-hydrogen/ https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-... Base load on the producer side is an outdated term. It simply came into existence because the most inflexible plants used to be the cheapest, that is not the case anymore. You can talk about base demand, but that can be fulfilled using any source. Or as Wikipedia puts it: > The base load (also baseload) is the minimum level of demand on an electrical grid over a span of time, for example, one week. This demand can be met by unvarying power plants, dispatchable generation, or by a collection of smaller intermittent energy sources, depending on which approach has the best mix of cost, availability and reliability in any particular market. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_load https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_load > This same tendency is exactly why there is so much irrational fear around nuclear. Or because you still have to measure the radioactivity of wild game and mushrooms in northern Sweden and Bavaria. > Although game is considered a delicacy in Bavaria, large amounts of meat are disposed of. Because many wild boars are still contaminated with radioactivity - even 35 years after the Chernobyl reactor accident. https://www.tellerreport.com/news/2021-04-26-35-years-after-chernobyl--inedible-game-meat-in-bavaria.ByNr9KuEPd.html https://www.tellerreport.com/news/2021-04-26-35-years-after-...
- prewett 4y agoHis point is that even if the reactor is free, it’s not competitive because of everything required to convert the heat to electricity makes it more expensive. That part has nothing to do with regulation.
- jseliger 4y agoVideo regarding Helion that sama just posted: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bDXXWQxK38 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bDXXWQxK38. Note that Helion says it can get D + D to work, which eliminates much of the OP's concern about tritium. The company is also hiring: https://blog.samaltman.com/helion-needs-you https://blog.samaltman.com/helion-needs-you I do not personally have the ability or knowledge to independently evaluate claims, but the history of "it will never work" for something that does not outright violate the laws of physics as we understand them is notable too.
- tedd4u 4y agoYesterday's discussion on that video (form Real Engineering) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34029426 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34029426
- pitaj 4y agoI'm really surprised this didn't get more engagement given the massive engagement with pretty much any other fusion story here.
- tedd4u 4y agoAgreed! AFAIK much of that video was news.
- pfdietz 4y agoMore comments on Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/fusion/comments/zo9831/the_real_engineering_channel_at_helion_showing/ https://www.reddit.com/r/fusion/comments/zo9831/the_real_eng...
- mycall 4y agoI wonder if future iterations of this use more than two chambers for ever more power, perhaps eventually converging into a sphere shape for the reactor (many years from now).
- PartiallyTyped 4y ago
- eloff 4y agoI didn’t read the article, but you could also write one about why you should never say never or why pessimists tend to be wrong in the long arc of history. My dad is fond of talking about how his Astronomy professor said we’ll never be able to detect planets outside our solar system, and proceeded to prove it through optics calculations. That didn’t age well. We’ll get to fusion too. It might take a ridiculously long time to be economically competitive, or it might not. But it will happen.
- Mistletoe 4y agoFusion is happening right now for free. Our whole planet is in the chamber we call the solar system and receives 1370 watts per square meter. About 173,000 terawatts received continuously. I often wonder if we need a fusion chamber on earth and if it is possible for it to exist as an energy generating device without it being a sun or a bomb.
- SubiculumCode 4y agothe earth receives the tiniest fraction of the sun's output. Space-based solar panels would have an almost unlimited amount of energy at their disposal...but how to get ithat energy down the well without James Bonds-ish laser beams?
- eloff 4y agoSpace based solar is dumb. Let’s be generous and say you can get 2x output by having 24/7 sunlight, and that somehow we can beam it down efficiently enough that it’s a wash with gains from not having clouds or atmosphere in the way. Then the cost must be less than 2x for it to make sense over ground based solar. That’s just not realistic. Now when we have mining and manufacturing in space, and can use the energy there, that’s a different story.
- DennisP 4y agoA panel in geostationary gets five times as much energy as a panel on the ground. It's like noontime sun around the clock, plus none of the light is blocked in the atmosphere. And the biggest advantage isn't that 5X, it's eliminating the need for overcapacity and storage. https://illumin.usc.edu/space-based-solar-power-a-new-path-towards-sustainable-clean-energy/ https://illumin.usc.edu/space-based-solar-power-a-new-path-t...
- jchw 4y agoI suspect this equation could some day change if pollution and other externalities become factored into the cost. If not in the U.S., then maybe elsewhere.
- flatiron 4y agoThe article was singing the praises of wind and solar though which are much simpler to construct, won’t blow up, and you can simply plop down in a lot of places. Honestly the nut we should be cracking is putting solar in our deserts and figuring out how to transmit the electricity. Tons of land with really not current uses and a whole bunch of sun shine.
- _Microft 4y ago> Honestly the nut we should be cracking is putting solar in our deserts and figuring out how to transmit the electricity. We have figured out the latter already. High-voltage direct-current transmission has losses in the low single digit percent per 1000km. China is transferring several nuclear power plants worth of power over thousands of kilometers already today. Edit: Wikipedia says that the Chinese connection I remembered has a capacity of 12GW over 3300km. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-voltage_direct_current https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-voltage_direct_current
- jchw 4y agoActually though, I do agree with that bit: you really can't do much better than solar and wind for simplicity. And I believe since this article was written, it has only gotten better. But, battery technology has been at a standstill for a while. New battery technology seems as far away as cold fusion some days. And without battery storage, I don't think you could really serve the world's power needs with just wind and solar. (But I'm also 100% a layperson, so hell if I know.)
- moloch-hai 4y agoBattery technology has been as far from a standstill as it would be possible to be. New chemistries, new electrolytes, new anodes and cathodes. Batteries are improving faster than almost anything else. But most of the world's energy storage is not and will not be chemical batteries.
- rich_sasha 4y agoRe wind being so cheap: it is currently because we have fossil backup. If fossil fuels and nuclear get phased out, we might wake up to a reality where, when the wind blows, energy is basically free, and when it doesn't, it is extortionately expensive. That might change the economics, for nuclear fission as well as fusion.
- api 4y agoThis already kind of happens in places with a lot of solar around noon. Not the extortionate part but the almost free when the system is saturated part.
- Gwypaas 4y agoBoth fission and fusion are awful at peaking. For peaker energy you want low capital investment and higher marginal costs. Fusion and fission are extremely capital expensive with quite hefty marginal costs through the steam side. They're simply awful at solving the last 20%. Even worse when they're undercut badly enough to never run for the first 80%.
- DennisP 4y agoWhether fusion is good at peaking will depend on which fusion technologies end up working. Helion for one would be fantastic at peaking. It's likely to be quite cheap, wouldn't use a turbine, and could run fusion pulses at whatever rate we need.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoit's still a pretty bad peaker. it's cheaper than a tomumak but it still needs a ton of capacitors and incredibly precise machining.
- DennisP 4y agoThey claim an electricity price of $0.01/kWh even before mass production kicks in. If they achieve that, the economics will work out fine.
- titannet 4y agoInteresting Argumentation. But why can't China build a fusion reactor?
- bell-cot 4y agoJust like China building lead balloons - they can. But, beyond prestige- and research-level efforts, they may have better uses for their money.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- SubiculumCode 4y ago"Why X will never happen (xxxx)" is always ballsy or stupid, and usually the latter.
- moloch-hai 4y agoYet, lead balloon transport will reliably not happen.
- fantyoon 4y agoIt seems to me that this article is not wrong, yet. Unless I misread, it argues that there will never be profitable power plants using fusion, rather than fusion being impossible.
- wfh 4y agoAgree with the article but, to me, demonstrates the reason why governments and regulators (and taxation authorities) make a difference here. E.g. if fossil fuels get a 200% tax then maybe nuclear/fusion (fission now) becomes more viable. Have to concede that wind and solar seem pretty good now, if combined with good grid-wide battery technology.
- rob74 4y agoLet's say good grid-wide energy storage technology - generating hydrogen or ammonia, pumped storage, whatever works. Lots of technologies, and none as challenging as fusion...
- Gwypaas 4y agoThe fusion question simply boils down to: How are you going to generate power with your fusion plant? Steam? Coal and nuclear are uncompetitive simply from the cost of the steam side. Today you can just about give a steam plant free energy and it still makes a loss. Solar or wind does not have this limitation. CCGT gas plants gets around it by having a turbine giving raw mechanical power and then utilizing the same awful steam side to get the last percentage points of efficiency at a much smaller required scale. Unless you can step around the steam turbine I am not so positive on fusions future outside of incredibly small niches. Coal still gets built where gas infrastructure does not exist, but that's about it.
- zmgsabst 4y agoHelion and similar methods side-step the issue by using (mostly) aneutronic fusion. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bDXXWQxK38 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bDXXWQxK38 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneutronic_fusion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneutronic_fusion Also, discussing solar and wind without discussing the base load/storage problem skews the discussion towards solar/wind. Steam plants don’t face those challenges in the way those two do; storage is as much a challenge for solar as steam is for nuclear.
- adaml_623 4y agoI would expand on your statement by saying that Helion is planning to generate electricity by directly extracting the kinetic energy of the particles created in the fusion reaction. And they need charged particles rather than neutrons. (I watched the video and really it's as simple as charged particles moving in and creating a magnetic field inside loops of metal which in turn generates a current that can be used. (Just add several dozen years worth of post-doc maths to sort out the details)
- jcampbell1 4y agoInterestingly, China has been steadily improving in steam. US coal plants average around 33% efficiency, and the latest coal plants in China are close to 50%. The way electricity price controls work in China if a plant isn’t at 300g per kWh or better, the more you generate the more you lose.
- gcheong 4y agoHow much do we spend in the US each year on military to ward off some supposed future threat to our existence? Is it deemed “economical” to do so? I think nuclear should be viewed in the same light given the threat we know that it solves for.
- mirzap 4y agoYou don't spend it for some future threat but to ensure safety of world oceans and to allow globalization and free trade (which benefits US the most). Without that power projection US wouldn't be the only tech/economic/military superpower.
- zip1234 4y agoIf the US can make it so oil is worthless, that would be a truly useful strategic endeavor from a geopolitics perspective. How many terrible regimes survive because they have money from oil? An abundance of energy should be a great stabilizing force on the world.
- anodari 4y agoOverall, the reasoning in the text appears to be valid. It is true that the cost to build a fusion reactor may never be cost-effective compared to solar and wind energy, but from a human and scientific perspective, it makes sense to continue researching and developing fusion technology. It is possible that in the future, we may need fusion power for space exploration or other purposes, and it is important to continue pursuing this technology in order to advance our understanding and capabilities in this area.
- Decabytes 4y agoAnytime alternative sources of clean energy come up there are always comments about the problem with using them (What happens if there is no wind, water, sun etc), or about storing excess energy (we can't create a reliable battery network). The reality is that the fossil fuel sources we currently use had tons of engineering issues that had to be solved for it to work at scale. It took decades but we got there. I'm confident with enough bright minds we can solve all of these problems with clean energy. It will just require time and energy and actual investment that isn't lobbied against by big oil. For example I'm confident that if we commit to nuclear energy we can find a way to get reactors built in under five years. And even if we didn't if enough were being built in parallel you could have one being onlined every year in every state just like how a new phone comes out every year, even though it takes years of development to make the next one.
- Veedrac 4y agoThis article is good in some ways and mistaken in others. Particularly, as a criticism of the ITER/DEMO path to fusion, it is correct. That was never a viable path to commercial fusion. The mistakes made, or else those allowed for but not predicted, listed without particular order, * Not all fusion requires turbines. Eg. Helion's designs don't. * Most if not all renewables require either energy storage, or much better energy transport, which must be factored into their price. * The size of commercial magnetic confinement plants is not well represented by DEMO, given new high temperature superconductors. * (Personal opinion) The cost of fission plants is mostly a consequence of regulation, and this dominates the financial aspect. That said, the idea that fusion has extremely tough cost competition from solar and wind, and that it will get increasingly tougher over time, is (and has turned out to be) absolutely true.
- qayxc 4y agoI wouldn't think of wind and solar as competition to fusion. Fusion power would have a different role in future electricity grids. Both would be complementing each other, rather than being a replacement. Solar and wind are comparatively cheap and quick to deploy and are great solutions for decentralised power generation. Wherever reliable continuous power is required, however, other methods of power generation have to step in. This could also still change of course, depending on how storage technology progresses. But the cheap super-battery is probably just as ambitious as fusion power is today.
- pfdietz 4y agoThey really are competitors, in the sense that intermittent sources, and fixed cost dominated sources, are both inflexible, and compete with each other on that basis. Cost optimized solutions for the grid typically contain a lot of one and little or none of the other.
- guilamu 4y agoI think we are not that far away from the "cheap super-battery": https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2022/10/catl-will-mass-produce-sodium-ion-batteries-in-2023.html https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2022/10/catl-will-mass-produce... Does this qualify as "super-battery", you tell me, but it's pretty good and cheap and could easily scale for storage of solar and wind.
- deltree7 4y agoThis is exactly the reason why we need lots of Billionaires. Sure, Fusion may be risky for Bankers. It won't be for Billionaires or even ultra-rich eccentric Billionaires. Billionaires can also take lots of risk with their capital. Once again the Author dismisses human ingenuity and singular obsession of people to make things happen. Money is the worst reason. You can always print Money (We printed $10 Trillion of them). What Next? Is there anything fundamentally expensive about the raw materials used? If not, you can reduce the cost to it's commodity prices. The commodity prices itself will collapse to ~$0 if energy and labor is ~$0. Finally you need labor. With ChatGPT and Robots, labor is also ~$0 So, never is absolutely the wrong choice of word
- dale_glass 4y agoThat's silly. Say, Musk is worth 169 billion. UK's Hinkley Point C is somewhere around 25 billion. Now, maybe that particular plant is a special problem child, but I wouldn't expect to have a new, untested yet technology built for cheaper than a troublesome nuclear one. So Musk can build a total of 6 of those, probably a good deal less because that's just theoretical wealth -- he'd have to sell everything he owns, and wouldn't get the full price for that. To build more he'd need more money. To get money, those plants need to make a profit, and pay off their loans. At that construction price it's virtually certain they never will. So the attempt would probably die at that -- at most 6 plants, producing power at a price nobody wants to pay. They either idle since nobody's buying, or sell at a huge loss until money runs out.
- deltree7 4y agoIf you have a 10,000 Billionaires, you wouldn't run into this problem
- vilhelm_s 4y agoThis is kind of silly. Yes, nuclear is more expensive than wind, but this is irrelevant because (as the article also acknowledges) you can't replace nuclear with wind, you need something that works when the wind is not blowing. Rather, the tradeoff is between nuclear power and carbon-based power (and also hydro, but most places already built all the hydro power that geography permits). And the problem is that nuclear is also more expensive than natural gas power plants. However, those are slowly ruining the planet, and if you take the cost of climate change into account, the carbon is much more expensive. The solution is for the government to either subsidise nuclear or tax carbon, to account for the externalities. This still won't make fusion power attractive right now, but in a couple of centuries we will be running out of the most accessible uranium deposits, at which point fusion might look better.
- dale_glass 4y ago> This is kind of silly. Yes, nuclear is more expensive than wind, but this is irrelevant because (as the article also acknowledges) you can't replace nuclear with wind, you need something that works when the wind is not blowing. But, nobody cares! See, because there's not a single party responsible for everything with sane priorities. People will build wind because it makes a profit. People won't build nuclear because it doesn't. This will keep going until you end up with a heavily wind-powered system that lacks stability, but nobody building plants will care about that. Eventually power goes out, and solutions will be sought, but nuclear still won't be profitable. One possible solution is overbuilding. Have lots of wind and solar. Another solution is interconnection -- maybe half the power gets burned in transmission losses, but if you need it, you need it. And probably there will be a lot more interest in grid storage.
- riskable 4y agoThe argument the author seems to be trying to make is that fusion power will never be realistic because it'll be too expensive. Then goes on to explain why it's expensive today. You could make the same exact argument about wind and solar a few decades ago. Also, there's a TON of assumptions in the arguments he's making. For example, he takes an existing fusion reactor design and assumes every one built from now until forever will be exactly the same or that they'll even use the heat->steam method of energy extraction. When it comes to fusion you can extract energy energy from the charged particles themselves via Aneutronic Fusion (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneutronic_fusion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneutronic_fusion) and skip that 1-meter-thick lithium shielding and a whole lot of other expensive things.
- DubiousPusher 4y agoThere are straight up inaccuracies in this article which makes the know-it-all tone even more insufferable. For example, they claim the sole reason nuclear is declining in the West is because of capital. This is straightforwardly not true. Politics have played a huge role, most notably in Germany.
- UIUC_06 4y ago> makes the know-it-all tone even more insufferable Oh, you mean that he refers to actual business costs where no one else does?
- willnonya 4y ago"There are straight up inaccuracies in this article which makes the know-it-all tone even more insufferable." They call that "the internet". To be fair politics are a factor in the economics. Looking at the US the politics. Especially in California, make building or expanding nuclear power much lore expe since than it really should be.
- vajrabum 4y agoPolitics includes history which none of this discussion has. It's more than a little scary how many nuke plants in California were built in seismically active spots no sane engineer would have chosen if the risks were properly understood at design and construction time, and California likely doesn't have the plants most at risk. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna42103936 https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna42103936
- dale_glass 4y agoPolitics are hugely related to economics. If nuclear was making bank, the industry would have the capital to beat the political problems. Eg, suppose for a second we make a nuclear power plant that can profitably sell power for half the price that anything else on the market does. Well, you're a smart business person, so you don't price yourself at 50% of the competition. You price yourself at say, 90% of the competition, so you're still the cheapest, but now have a crazy profit margin. And with that huge profit margin you can do things like having elaborate security systems to reassure people, donate to politicians, run PR campaigns, build cool stuff to buy people's love, etc. You'd have a very straightforward comeback of "shut us down and everything gets more expensive". There's a reason why oil despite being a nasty, dirty and accident prone business isn't going anywhere.
- Cupertino95014 4y agoI'm not a power engineer, but his reasoning about the overall cost per kilowatt hour seems impeccable. He's dealing with the overall costs and their likely trends. Most of the comments are techno-optimism: "fusion has to work; therefore it will work."
- js8 4y agoWe already have a fusion reactor, so I don't see the point of building another small one here on Earth.
- DennisP 4y agoIt's a great reactor, it's just too bad the transmission lines go down every night.
- js8 4y agoBut so does the local supermarket.. I think we can learn to live with that.
- DennisP 4y agoActually my local supermarket does not go down every night. Neither do my home electricity, street lights, lots of factories, etc. Having power available on demand all the time is a huge advantage and fusion could well beat battery-backed wind/solar for that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- FiatLuxDave 4y agoNever is a very long time. And the big thing I don't see this article discuss is how cost curves change over time. I remember reading articles in the 1990s using the same logic to say how electric cars were never going to happen because although electric cars were improving, internal combustion cars were also improving and so electric cars would never be better. Most technologies have a sigmoid adoption curve and something resembling an inverted logarithmic cost curve. Does wind power beat the pants off of fusion, and even fission right now? Of course it does! But where is wind power technology in its lifetime compared to them? Is wind power going to cost 10 times less 200 years from now? Maybe, but I don't see that as a given. Wind power is really hitting its stride right now, so it's kind of like comparing your favorite sports team against whoever happens to be winning right now, and saying "oh this is inevitable". Of course the winning team right now happens to currently be the winning team. Wind wasn't the inevitable winner in 1920, and I have no idea how the Golden State Warriors will do in 2191 either, assuming they are around. So, unless "never" really means "not anytime soon", you need to look at what fusion can do instead of what it can do with existing design concepts. Fusion is fully capable of direct conversion, even without aneutronic fusion, as long as you are willing to throw away waste heat on par with internal combustion engines. My own D+D design included this feature back in the 1990s. The reason why you don't see the big projects focus on this is because it does you no good until you actually have enough fusion for ignition (or an equivalent state), and on most designs it would be an added cost or complication. It's too bad, because I actually agree with what the article says in the final paragraph (and I've been saying that since 1995). Fusion development does have a real issue with a need for funding, and how that funding is obtained and directed. It would be nice if we did better in this generation. But give it a couple of hundred years, and it's likely that will change at some point. Never is a very long time.
- Gwypaas 4y ago> as long as you are willing to throw away waste heat on par with internal combustion engines Here in lies the problem. Waste heat on a powerplant scale is expensive to deal with. Ask any coal plant.
- FiatLuxDave 4y ago
- avidphantasm 4y agoTitle should be: “Why fusion will never happen in a market-based context”. If fusion plants can be shown to be carbon negative (i.e., can be used to draw carbon out of the atmosphere by powering mineralization, etc.), we will absolutely try to build them at some point, regardless of the cost. Expecting markets financed by bankers to build them is ridiculous. The assumption is that markets factor in all costs, which they don’t and likely never will. This is the problem with markets, they are fundamentally dumb, or at least naïve and blinkered; they don’t know that there are things they don’t know. This is why we can’t solve the climate crisis through market-based systems alone.
- moloch-hai 4y agoNote that solar PV cost has come down by 3x since that was written, and wind similarly. There is no expectation that those will bottom out soon. It does mean that to keep the cost of full systems falling, we need cheaper installation methods, such as rolling out rather than bolting up frames.
- russdill 4y agoI think we've come to accept the externalities of wind and solar (land area, visual changes to landscape, etc) because the costs of those externalities are so much less than the alternatives. They still exist though. Fusion is probably too late to solve climate change, but I think it's a laudable goal to one day replace renawables such as hydro, wind, and solar farms with fusion.
- geysersam 4y agoYes, indeed. Compared to drastically altering the planets climate, drowning most coastal cities, causing a mass extinction event and disrupting the freshwater supply of billions, visual changes to the landscape does seem like the minor issue.
- jmyeet 4y agoIt's always interesting to see how well older articles age. At 10 years old, this one has aged pretty well. The article makes the main point that a lot of the costs of a theoretical fusion plant are the same as those for a fission plant, namely a way of turning heat into power. It also claims that 2/3 of the costs of a nuclear plant are for that conversion. If you look at energy costs by source [1] you see the wind and solar are already 4-8 times cheaper than fission. We're not really any closer to solving the profound technological challenges that existed when this was written 10 years ago. The most optimistic estimates still put fusion at decades away. My view is that our long-term power generation will come from space-based solar collectors. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source
- bluedino 4y agoWe haven't even been doing controlled nuclear reactions for 100 years yet
- compsciphd 4y agoI'd note that this is being somewhat obtuse on my part, but one could argue that all solar energy is really a fusion byproduct.
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoGeneral Fusion is building their test plant in the UK right now.