11 ms·
I find it strange that the charts only go down to 20°F, when for example at the moment I write this comment, it's -5°F (-21°C) in Bismarck, North Dakota. And s
by crazygringo 4y ago
I find it strange that the charts only go down to 20°F, when for example at the moment I write this comment, it's -5°F (-21°C) in Bismarck, North Dakota.
And sub-zero Fahrenheit temperatures are pretty common in the winter across the Northeast, especially at night. "Normal" driving conditions extend way below just 20°F.
- dwighttk 4y agoMaybe there aren’t many people driving EVs there
- rconti 4y agoWell they're quite common in nordic countries; of course, the population of nordic countries tends to be in the southern latitudes.
- whoisthemachine 4y agoWhile they aren't as popular in the Dakota's, there's quite a few EV's in Minnesota, where the temperature ranges are similar (1 degree Fahrenheit at the moment).
- dwighttk 4y ago> It includes aggregated and anonymized data from 7,000 vehicles in the Recurrent community from across the United States as well as tens of thousands of data points from on-board devices that provide data on energy usage. Maybe some more Northerners should join Recurrent?
- FartyMcFarter 4y agoIf that's the case, it might be even more important to show this data so that people there can decide whether to start getting EVs.
- LinuxBender 4y agoI'm in the Rockies, about 6300' elevation and the temp in the winter is often sub-zero with extremes being around -25F but only a few days usually. None of the locals have an EV but I have seen them on the highway going up to Yellowstone so I have not been able to ask them about range. The UPS drivers here will soon have a couple EV delivery trucks. I talk to them all the time so perhaps that will be useful data I can relay. It won't be graphs, just happy or grumpy driver anecdotes. I hope they give the drivers good heaters.
- dwighttk 4y agoIf you know any Pepsi distributors see if you can get some numbers on the Tesla semi… ;)
- j33zusjuice 4y agoI don’t understand it either. Lows well under 20°F are fairly common in the US. The _average_ temperature in the winter is in the mid-20s where I currently live.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mrits 4y agoWe are sub 20F next week in Austin,Tx. I'm going to IL for the holidays where it looks like will be -7F for Christmas.
- Sakos 4y agoI figure 20F is just sufficient to prove their thesis (effects of cold on EV cars). I don't think it purports to be an all-encompassing study, especially since there are variables like cabin heating which can have significant effects on range in lower temperatures.
- Grim-444 4y agoAt even colder temps than that EV batteries start having even more problems, for example they become permanently damaged if charged at freezing temps or below, so even more energy has to be used to heat the batteries for the batteries to be able to accept a charge.
- karmelapple 4y agoAgreed, and that’s as someone who grew up in North Dakota and now lives in the milder northeast US, near the ocean. ’d also be interested in seeing it colder for trips back to ND, sure. But the majority of folks in the US live in places where it isn’t as brutal as a North Dakotan winter, so doing a study at 20 F seems reasonable to me.
- remarkEon 4y agoCame here to say that (am in Minnesota for Christmas holiday, where it’s currently 1°). It gets much colder than 20°F for extended periods in the Midwest. Is there just not a large enough sample of EV driving in those temperatures to extend the graph?
- KennyBlanken 4y agoExactly. They likely didn't have enough data, because a)it doesn't actually get that cold for very long, even in the coldest parts of the US and b)there aren't many people in those locations (North Dakota, grandparent comment's home state, has the same population as Boston, Massachusetts. Not the region - just the city itself) and c)there aren't many EVs, either - due to lack of infrastructure for them, lower income levels, and (drumroll please) their lower ranges. Contrary to the knee jerk reaction some people seem to be having, this isn't an conspiratorial attempt to pull the wool over the eyes of Real Americans(TM). I don't understand the reaction, anyway - ICE vehicles plunge in range with cold temperatures too, and there are a bunch of reasons why EVs seem well-suited to rural life. The range reduction doesn't mean squat when the longest average commute in the US - Maine - is 10 miles. Who cares if your 300-350 mile EV only gets 200 miles, when that's still 20 days of commuting, and every hour your car is in your garage, it's "gassing up" with no intervention on your part beyond a few seconds to plug in a cord when you get home? FYI, looking at a smattering of temperature charts, "much colder than 20 degrees for extended periods" is a slight exaggeration for Minnesota.
- remarkEon 4y agoI guess I meant “extended periods” to mean “longer than two weeks”, which is about how often I’d fill up the gas tank when growing up there. Average temp in January through March is below 20°F per Wikipedia for most of the state. Regardless, I agree there’s still good use cases for EVs in cold climates.
- tantony 4y agoI have owned a Model 3 in Iowa while living in an apartment with no garage. This was at the beginning of the Covid lockdown where it stayed unused for extended periods of time. The battery was cold-soaked in temps below 20F. Whenever I drove the car, I had almost zero regen-braking, reduced acceleration and the range was decreased by about 30%. For short commutes, that would persist throughout. But whenever I went on longer trips, a one hour drive would get it back to its original performance. The range would stay a bit lower due to higher energy use (~330 Wh/mi instead of 240 Wh/mi in the summer). The navigation would account for this when planning trips and also pre-condition the batteries prior to going to superchargers. On average it added maybe one extra charging stop during road-trips.
- quickthrowman 4y agoAgreed, I’m in MN and it’s 5F. Starting next Wednesday, we have a forecast for 5 days in a row where the highest temp is 4F.
- D13Fd 4y agoIt’s probably due to lack of data. To some extent, the further the temp is from the mean, the harder it is to find a time and place to test.
- barbariangrunge 4y agoAs I’m sitting here reading this, it is -35 C after windchill. The reason we didn’t get an ev is because we are getting the sense that the companies that make them do not take Canadaian weather into account It looks like some of those manufacturers only lose 3% of their range in weather like this, but that’s estimated. The verified numbers are far lower?
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoYour car doesn't feel wind chill. I drive an EV in Canadian winter all the time. Not at all an issue. Range loss is a thing but it's not like the car stops working. In fact it starts more reliably and heats up more quickly for me. And I start mine remotely while it's still plugged in, so the cabin is warm and ready to go without wasting battery energy. And can do this safely in the garage without concerns of carbon monoxide poisoning or stinking up the garage. Aside: I wish people in this country would stop reporting wind chill temps as if they're some sort of accurate measure of anything. They're only useful as a relatively subjective measure for people who aren't dressed properly.
- wolfram74 4y agoMight be more accurate to describe it as cars generate more windchill from driving than the weather station is likely to experience from wind?
- leereeves 4y agoDoesn't the cold have the greatest impact when the car isn't moving, because the car warms itself while driving? And the reported wind chill matters when the car isn't moving.
- wolfram74 4y agoIn the best case scenario where the car is in a garage, I've heard that you can pre-emptively bring it up to temperature on grid power and a great deal of the cold-induced range loss goes away. Might still work for outdoor parking, just a bit less shielded of an environment.
- thinking4real 4y agoEveryone’s repeating they find this strange. Is it really strange? I’ve been excited for EVs all my life. But there’s a certain level of propaganda that’s come with them. Explicitly talking about their downsides seems to be taboo. Like you’ll get downvoated or banned on many social media platforms for doing it.
- PaulBGD_ 4y agoI think it’s because most people who are pro electric understand their downsides, and usually the downsides are presented as dismissal (eg why buy an electric, you have to stop when you’re traveling cross country.) It’s kind of a boring topic unless there’s something new to discuss.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- itsoktocry 4y agoThis is the exact opposite of my experience, on many, many car related forums. EVs are presented as a panacea, doing everything an ICE can do, only better. It's not true. There are tradeoffs.
- thinking4real 4y agoI think you’re lying to yourself because you’re an EV fan. You have to consider what the pushers are saying and if there’s sufficient pushback when they’re misaligned. Currently that doesn’t happen. Currently you face everything up to deplatforming for speaking against the narrative that EVs are the one true solution.
- criley2 4y agoQuite the opposite, I find every thread about them (including this one) to be entire dominated by the naysayers who claim they are repressed but in actuality are the loudest and most visible voices. It's a bit ironic you claim "propaganda" and "downvotes".... in the most upvoted, top thread on this post, a thread which is highly skeptical/negative to EV. These days I find it difficult to find real-world data or anecdotes from EV real owners amongst the tidal wave of gasoline vehicle operators predicting how terrible an EV would be (and justifying their ego/decision to not buy one).
- Philip-J-Fry 4y agoI assume it's because temperatures like that during the day (when most car travel takes place) is less common than at night. It's more representative of the general use case.
- mdorazio 4y agoThe majority of Americans do not live in areas that get below 20F average for extended periods of time. Your particular use case is atypical, especially for EV buyers, so it isn't shown.
- Teever 4y agoAs a Canadian I guess data from events that Americans rarely experience isn't really that useful or interesting.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoNorthern Minnesota and North Dakota are pretty cold, not to mention parts of Alaska.
- mdorazio 4y agoIf you want data on outside-the-normal situations, you shouldn't expect it to come from blogs or news posts targeted at average users. Here's a more technical blog with some data on lower temps based on telematics driving data: https://www.geotab.com/blog/ev-range/ https://www.geotab.com/blog/ev-range/
- chmod775 4y ago> Your particular use case is atypical Norwegians alone account for ~5-10% of Tesla's global sales in recent years. I don't think it's far fetched to assume that at least one tenth of all Tesla vehicles (and other EV vehicles in that price class) are driven in areas that do routinely experience longer periods below that temperature. It's likely much more than that, because in Europe you can easily find these temperatures many places far south of Norway.
- mdorazio 4y agoDid you even bother to look up average temperatures by month in the populous parts of Norway before posting this? It doesn't get that cold: https://www.climatestotravel.com/climate/norway/oslo https://www.climatestotravel.com/climate/norway/oslo
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoI'm in Fargo and one of my coworkers recently got a Model 3. It's going to get much colder in the coming week and I'll be asking him about what kind of mileage he's getting. Edit: Just looked through r/Fargo and found this thread on EVs here https://www.reddit.com/r/fargo/comments/wvdud0/evs_in_fargo/ https://www.reddit.com/r/fargo/comments/wvdud0/evs_in_fargo/
- orasis 4y agoTwo winters ago I tried to drive my model 3 across North Dakota - never will I do that again. Range was cut in half and I had to stop at every single supercharger.
- mjevans 4y agoThe charts should _all_ have the same range and scale so that they can be visually compared. As it stands they appear optimized for maximizing the data acuity of each individual car without consideration for visually comparing curves between cars.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]