8 ms·
"Binance has said it holds more than $60bn in assets, enough to honour withdrawals. The company’s disclosures do not include its liabilities, which makes it dif
by Animats 4y ago
"Binance has said it holds more than $60bn in assets, enough to honour withdrawals. The company’s disclosures do not include its liabilities, which makes it difficult to ascertain its financial health."
Possibilities:
1) They're insolvent. Liabilities exceed assets. (Like FTX.)
2) Their accounting is so screwed up they can't produce a balance sheet. (Like FTX).
3) They have a large number of interconnected corporate entities and nobody has the big picture. (Like FTX).
4) They have enough assets on the books to look solvent, but many of those assets are overvalued or internal transactions. (Like FTX).
OK, crypto people. Full GAPP audit or we all assume you're broke.
If you have assets in an un-audited exchange, get them out now.
- janejeon 4y agoIt is telling that a firm like Jump Crypto has pulled hundreds of millions of dollars from Binance. If smart money is getting out, you might want to get out before the doors close: https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2022/12/13/binance-withdrawals-surge-as-concerns-about-its-reserve-report-spook-traders/ https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2022/12/13/binance-withdraw...
- jacquesm 4y agoExactly, and one more: they may have been shuttling money around from account to account to look solvent but aren't.
- janejeon 4y agoIsn't this exactly what Tether is accused of doing?
- marvin 4y agoSomeone mentioned the early-banking era wheelbarrow of gold travelling around from bank to bank just in time to make the audit.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat's such a funny mental image, seeing the guys with the wheelbarrow trying to make it to the bank just in time for the auditors to appear and everybody is sitting around like it's perfectly normal and trying not to breathe too hard.
- ethbr0 4y ago> 3) They have a large number of interconnected corporate entities and nobody has the big picture. (Like FTX). This isn't true, is it? FTX had <5 corporate entities, right? The issue was more with (1) and (2).
- patio11 4y agoFTX had more than 100 entities. You can find the org chart in the bankruptcy filing or here: https://qz.com/ftx-bankruptcy-filing-reveals-a-remarkably-convoluted-c-1849797496 https://qz.com/ftx-bankruptcy-filing-reveals-a-remarkably-co...
- cj 4y agoSource: Page 30 https://pacer-documents.s3.amazonaws.com/33/188450/042020648197.pdf https://pacer-documents.s3.amazonaws.com/33/188450/042020648...
- ethbr0 4y agoOof. The preliminary corporate outline in Appendixes B of the filing is a lot. I guess presumably you'd want to compartmentalize risk via corporate structures in as sprawling of a business as FTX was (especially if you were aware you had terrible internal controls), but it does beg the question of what nature of business each of these entities was engaged in. I.e. if they conducting actual business and so their existence helped firewall other FTX entities, or if they simply existed on paper for accounting fraud
- europeanguy 4y agoIt wasn't a "as sprawling of a business as FTX was". It was a shell game.
- ethbr0 4y agoFTX (in total) was an entity that operated in most countries in the world, under their regulatory regimes (if existent), across four(+?) major, different lines of business. That's not a "one corporate entity + a few international ones" type of endeavor.
- bushbaba 4y ago5) they print more tether when needed to handle withdrawals. But such massive tether prints can cause market issues.
- superjan 4y agoIsn’t Tether controlled by bitfinex?
- digitaltrees 4y agoThe large exchanges were shown to have a signal chat group to coordinate activities. Total illegal collusion in any other financial institution but hey crypto is the Wild West. Not that outlandish to think they collaborate when necessary.
- FireBeyond 4y agoOh there's a lot more to it than chat groups. Bitfinex loaned money to Tether. On the loan contract, three people, we'll call them AB, CD, and EF, signed the contract on Bitfinex's behalf. On the other side of the contract, Tether signed the contract for the loan. The three people on the loan signatories page for Tether? AB, CD, and EF.
- charcircuit 4y ago5) Like tether they are solvent despite all the people screaming for an audit
- ivalm 4y ago> Like tether they are solvent Right, but tether isn’t solvent either
- HDThoreaun 4y agoThat doesn't explain why they just cancelled their audit.
- willcipriano 4y agoIf you believe that you must be using all that corporate paper to smoke something.
- drexlspivey 4y agoGetting downvoted for suggesting a company might be solvent.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> downvoted for suggesting a company might be solvent The comment said they are solvent. Not that they might be. Given the present facts and circumstances, that’s unfounded. (EDIT: Never mind.)
- Lerc 4y agoNo they didn't. The "5)" was indicating a further option. That is very much a suggestion and not a statement of fact.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoFair enough. It’s a remote possibility for a company with literally no known legal structure and under criminal investigation in multiple jurisdictions, but sometimes unicorns fart rainbows.
- loeg 4y agoIt’s “GAAP.” Generally Accepted Accounting Principles.
- choppaface 4y agoAll of the above and: 5) Binance does significant money laundering for Iran and Russia, so any complete picture of their balance sheet would invite sanctions and international retribution. https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/exclusive-crypto-exchange-binance-helped-iranian-firms-trade-8-billion-despite-2022-11-04/ https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/exclusive-crypto-ex...
- richardhod 4y agoThis is interesting. Do you have any good links for the Russian connection!
- m00dy 4y ago
- meowtimemania 4y agoCould you expound?
- echelon 4y agoIs Coinbase audited?
- xwdv 4y agoCoinbase is going out of business the old fashioned way: losing a lot of money.
- digitaltrees 4y agoLame. Where’s the innovation.
- dicomdan 4y agoWhataboutists have arrived to protect China-owned Binance
- echelon 4y agoEven though I'm crypto agnostic, I'm diversified. I have some funds in Coinbase, but I don't really want to go to the trouble of maintaining a hardware wallet. I'm way more likely to lose a wallet or mismanage it than not. As an anecdote, I had several million dogecoin from 2014 or so as a joke, which I think amounted to several hundred thousand dollars just a few years back. I couldn't find, figure out, or be bothered with moving it to an exchange before that blew over. As for Binance, I had funds in it too before they closed their core operations in the US, and getting it back out was an extreme hassle. As far as the substance of your comment, you'll find that my comment history is pro-Democracy, pro-Capitalism, so I'm not sure what you're on about.
- ninethirty 4y agoYou could split between Gemini and Coinbase if you are dead-set against a hw wallet.
- landemva 4y ago
- StanislavPetrov 4y agoI don't ever entrust any exchange with my crypto. That being said, this episode will be a far better test of Binance's solvency than any audit. The proof is in the pudding. Either they have the reserves to cover the withdrawals or they go belly up.
- jefftk 4y ago> Full GAAP audit or we all assume you're broke. FTX passed a GAAP audit and was still broke. Safer just to take custody of your coins while your still can. 2021-08-27: "Both FTX and FTX.US have completed requirements to pass the US Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) audit" https://blockworks.co/news/ftx-joins-coinbase-kraken-with-us-gaap-audit-pass https://blockworks.co/news/ftx-joins-coinbase-kraken-with-us...
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> FTX passed a GAAP audit Do we have a source mentioning the auditor?
- jefftk 4y agoPrager Metis for international, Armanino for US: https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/11/11/meet-the-metaverse-night-clubloving-audit-firm-that-presided-over-ftxs-financials/ https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/11/11/meet-the-metave...
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoPrager Metis and Armanino worked with FTX, but I can’t find anything showing they completed an audit. (Far from blameless. Both seem riddled with issues [1].) [1] https://www.ibtimes.com/crypto-auditors-under-fire-ftx-meltdown-highlights-fundamental-need-exchanges-change-audit-3644551 https://www.ibtimes.com/crypto-auditors-under-fire-ftx-meltd...
- mtmail 4y agoOP quoted "have completed requirements to pass" so that might be the start of the audit, not passing.
- jefftk 4y ago"CoinDesk obtained the audited financial statements of West Realm Shires, also known as FTX US, and FTX Trading Ltd., the combined offshore Bahamas-based entity that includes an exchange catering to non-U.S. customers and Alameda, the proprietary trading operation. It’s not clear why FTX commissioned two different audit firms to audit its 2020 and 2021 financial statements. The reports by Armanino LLP, which signed the report for the U.S. operation, and by Prager Metis LLP, which signed the opinion for the offshore operations, were issued at the end of March 2022." https://www.coindesk.com/layer2/2022/11/18/a-complete-failure-of-corporate-controls-what-investors-and-accountants-missed-in-ftxs-audits/ https://www.coindesk.com/layer2/2022/11/18/a-complete-failur...
- that_guy_iain 4y agoFor me, it's the ruthlessness of dumping all the FTT tokens they had to crash FTX to buy it (which went pear shape once they saw FTX's books) makes me think that they're probably not in a strong of a position as they say they are. We see this all the time. Exchanges saying they're strong and assets are safe until suddenly a few hours later they're not.
- lavventura 4y agoThey have constant income. Their mostly daily gains are coming from liquidating people in futures not matter market crashes or not.
- actionablefiber 4y agoThere are some possibilities. Binance could have just done so knowing that FTX's demise would concentrate their own market share. They also could have (sensibly) not wanted toxic assets on their books - FTX's book value was/is deeply negative so holding tokens correlated to a basically insolvent entity and/or buying them is just a bad trade that hurts their financial position. It's ruthless but I don't think it says anything about their finances. Their play made sense whether they were strong or weak.
- LargeTomato 4y agoI agree with this. There are many reasons why Binance would say they'd buy FTX and there are just as many reasons for why they would back out of the deal. Binance reneging on the deal doesn't say anything about the state of their finances other than that they might not have been in a position to take on 32B in liabilities.
- hgsgm 4y agoIf they were weak, crashing FTX risks crashing themselves.
- CPLX 4y agoIs there some other action you can recommend for someone holding FTT tokens other than selling them immediately for the best price you can get?
- coffeebeqn 4y agoThey also have the potentially very dangerous BNB. If some of their assets are in that company coin to smooth the waves then they could have a crash very similar to FTT
- femto113 4y ago> If you have assets in an un-audited exchange, get them out now. This is Mexican standoff. The only "value" crypto assets have comes from exchanges that will trade them for fiat. If crypto holders stop trusting exchanges and pull all their assets that will cause the exchanges to fail and those assets will then be worth nothing. On the other side if exchanges try to earn the trust of holders by becoming "fully transparent" it will be revealed that there's not nearly enough fiat reserves to support the current valuations. (It does no good for Binance to prove they have a reserve of $18B of Tether to back the $18BN BUSD marketcap if turns out Tether is actually mostly backed by Bitcoin that only has a USD value because it can be traded for BUSD...)
- jacquesm 4y agoTrue, but the first out that manage to sell them for fiat through some other way even at a substantial discount are going to be off substantially better than the last.
- femto113 4y agoI assume that by "get them out" the parent meant "move your crypto from an exchange to a wallet you control". If your end goal is to be out of crypto altogether it would make far more sense to just sell while the exchanges are still open.
- blueprint 4y ago> If crypto holders stop trusting exchanges and pull all their assets that will cause the exchanges to fail and those assets will then be worth nothing. maybe you havent heard but it's possible to send "crypto" (lol) directly from person to person
- bragr 4y agoSend me 10,000 bitcoins and I'll send you a pizza.
- 4y ago
- chaosbolt 4y ago
- MuffinFlavored 4y agois any exchange audited?
- oblio 4y agoAudited? Isn't that what TradFi and Fiat Currency companies do? Ewww, gross!
- shawabawa3 4y agoCoinbase is public and audited by a big 4 accountant every year (quarter?)
- colinjoy 4y agoFor some reason I just had WireCard cross my mind.
- stevebmark 4y agoAny investor who believes any exchange has the assets they say it does deserves to lose their money. It takes a special kind of ignorant blindness not to see that "reserves" are all based on fake, wash-trade inflated cryptocurrency valuation, and it's all a house of cards. Like FTX. Like all of them.
- raven105x 4y agoIf you have assets in any* exchange, get them out now. Using regulated exchanges defeats the whole point. Fiat transaction fees are lower / nonexistent compared to CC ones so if you want to gamble on the relative value of something just stick to the stock market, and if you want to send currency on something that is regulated by a government anyways, might as well use Fiat. The only thing regulated exchanges do is profit by losing you value via fees and then some more via taxes while carrying risks of being rugged or having "your" assets frozen. Just... why?
- SheinhardtWigCo 4y agoExchanges provide a lot of added value, at least ones that aren't run by criminals or idiots. Wallet keys stored on a phone or laptop, or even a hardware wallet, are generally less safe than the reserve wallets of a major exchange. I can lose the device, it can break or be stolen, etc. Writing down recovery phrases and stashing them in the sock drawer doesn't feel very safe either. And if something happens to me, I feel quite sure that my family will get any crypto I have in my Coinbase account, but much less sure that they'll be able to recover any non-custodial wallets.
- raven105x 4y agoRE: personally stored keys are less secure ...this is very subjective. You don't "hand" your wallet keys to an exchange: you don't even have them. Meaning "your" CC is a lot like "your" USD in a bank: subject to taxes, send restrictions, asset freezes, IRS audits, and a whole host of other unnecessary and inconvenient crap. Being taxed on CC gains relative to the USD is ultimate hypocrisy. It's like being taxed on swiss francs or yen you hold if the exchange rate changes... except instead of an unlimited write-off for losses like traditional forex, the cap is $3000 to form a one-way YoY tax valve. Literally nothing about the government's stance on or (severe lack of) understanding of cryptocurrencies makes any sense other than it definitely reminds me of good ole' Reagan: "If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." RE: if something happens to you ...that is an excellent point. You wouldn't get this without an exchange, yeah. If subjecting yourself to all of the above to reap this benefit is worth it to you, that's a favorable tradeoff to make and one you definitely should.