4 ms·
How can you make logic gates with this?
by amelius 4y ago
How can you make logic gates with this?
- dtgriscom 4y agoAgreed: how is this a "circuit"? How does the output drive the input of another one of these? It looks like this is just "shine a laser at a material to change it, and then use another laser to detect the difference."
- adrian_b 4y agoYou can describe any transistor with the same words as "shine a laser at a material to change it, and then use another laser to detect the difference": "apply a voltage at a device to change it, and then use another voltage to detect the difference (i.e. to detect if a current passes)". This is an optical switch, like a transistor is an electrical switch. An optical switch that is not very efficient, because the transmission is varied only between 100% and 80%, but one that is very fast. It can be used in THz range mixers and oscillators.
- amelius 4y agoThat's not a good argument. I could say: "Put a voltage over a resistor and use an ammeter to detect the difference" and make a resistor look like a transistor which it clearly isn't.
- nullish_signal 4y agoThe comment above yours said "and then ... detect the difference", implying sequential action and a real change of state - not simultaneous action+measure. """Because the laser pulse is so fast, the water can switch states in a matter of picoseconds, which are trillionths of a second.""" Although after reading, I must agree that the time-scale feels quite ridiculous!! (EDIT: RE: "Capacitors can't be logic gates" below - Maybe. But if 1+0=1, and 1+1=2, then surely differentiating 0/1 vs 2 on the output creates an AND gate?) (I am "posting too fast" with 3 posts in the last hour. Sorry :)
- amelius 4y ago> implying sequential action and a real change of state - not simultaneous action+measure. Ok, replace resistor by capacitor :) I.e., run a current through a capacitor, then (some time later) measure the voltage over it. I don't recall anyone actually creating logic gates using capacitors only.
- adrian_b 4y agoNot at all. In the definition of any controlled switch, e.g. transistor, optical switch or any other kind, it is essential that there are two distinct quantities, e.g. voltages or light beams, one that controls the output state and one that provides power to the output circuit. A resistor corresponds to a tinted window, not to an optical switch.
- amelius 4y agoOk, with that addition, here is another analogy: I have one battery that I use to charge a capacitor. Then I have another battery in my voltmeter, which I use to measure the voltage over the capacitor. How does this make it possible to build logic gates with capacitors? Instead of trying to generalize the principle, why don't you explain how you can make logic gates using the technology of the article? And how can you tie these logic gates together without the signal becoming weaker between input and output?
- dtgriscom 4y agoNote that in a transistor, "another voltage to detect the difference" can be used to trigger another transistor, and so on. Until the laser reading the state of water can itself trigger a write in another water "switch", this is just a cute dead-end phenomenon.
- rohan1024 4y agoIf we do end up creating a processor using this, I wonder if it will need liquid cooling.
- jimmySixDOF 4y agoPresumably they can use cold water in the jets which itself chills the space. Nice fringe benefit If It Scales.
- ohyes 4y agoYou need to cool the laser presumably, I wouldn’t use water for that, however.
- cmmeur01 4y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluidics https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluidics
- amelius 4y agoThat doesn't involve a laser like in the article, and is probably much slower. I don't think you can get Terahertz speeds by just using Newtonian physics on water.
- ilaksh 4y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2860314/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2860314/ Microfluidic Photonic Integrated Circuits?
- mannykannot 4y agoWhile the paper's keywords list includes both microfluidics and photonics, nothing about the device is anything like an opto-fluidic logic gate. The laser is used to measure properties of cells suspended in the fluid, with the output light signal being processed by conventional photonics.
- danuker 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_computing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_computing > To replace electronic components with optical ones, an equivalent optical transistor is required. This is achieved using materials with a non-linear refractive index.
- adrian_b 4y agoLike with any switches, by connecting them in series and in parallel. Nevertheless, it is unlikely to use such optical switches for logic gates. The most likely application for them is in mixers and oscillators.
- dtgriscom 4y agoBut that's the problem: how does the "output" of one of these switches drive the "input" of the next one?
- adrian_b 4y agoThe question was how to make logic gates. There is no impediment for making a complex logic gate by an arbitrary series-parallel connection of the output light beams. The output of such a logic gate cannot be connected to the input of an identical logic gate, because the input and the output light beams have different frequencies. This is a problem common for many kinds of optical switches. It is likely that any conversion circuit that could be inserted between two such logic gates would be much slower than them, negating any speed advantage. This does not really matter, because such optical switches are not intended for making logic circuits.