6 ms·
Is that how Google ended up with eight chat apps while Search gets worse and worse every year?
by solardev 4y ago
Is that how Google ended up with eight chat apps while Search gets worse and worse every year?
- canadianfella 4y ago
- dmix 4y agoMonopolies tend to stick around much longer than other industries despite their lack of competence. Clayton’s book was mostly about Intel which operated in a competitive market with AMD and others. DuckDuckGo is great but it’s not nipping at their heels meaningfully.
- bobthepanda 4y agoIt takes a long time for any company to die, period. WeWork (or I guess now Twitter) style rapid flameouts are very rare. Most corporate deaths look like Sears. The writing on the wall was there for over two decades.
- master_crab 4y agoOn the wall for two decades?! Hell it was there for four decades, double that time. Walmart was running circles around Sears by the 70s.
- lumost 4y agoI kinda wonder if there is a type of employee who likes working at dying firms. Every year their job gets easier with fewer demands. Failure becomes kinda expected.
- doktorhladnjak 4y agoI’m reminded of someone I met at a party who actually worked for Sears. They’d spent many years at Amazon on the retail side of the business, in the earlier days of Amazon. Sears hired several people with this background in Seattle to turn their business around. Pretty quickly, they figured out upper management had no interest in their ideas to make Sears into a viable online retailer. Everybody left or started coasting. They all knew the company was doomed but cashed their paychecks. After all, that’s literally what they were being paid to do.
- parasubvert 4y agoWeWork is also very much alive.
- aaronbrethorst 4y agoSure, this month
- TeMPOraL 4y agoSo it has been for however many years since the purported "rapid flameout".
- m0llusk 4y agoWeWork is living dead, taking down and feasting on the flesh of the living. Their financials are so bad that there is no possibility of rescue, only the matter of the timing and details of end. Meanwhile the coworking space continues to be critical for an increasing fraction of the workforce. Those companies that actually live in this space by charging members fees that pay for the property and services required have a huge challenge competing with WeWork. It is a textbook case of venture capital doing terrible damage to an entire sector without actually contributing anything. The capital will be burned through and WeWork and other companies will die and then maybe we can start again for real. It is so frustrating.
- hnlmorg 4y agoWeWork is still going strong in London. Lots of offices and all of which are full.
- spoonjim 4y agoA full office only tells you about the revenue side of the business. Many businesses are popular with customers but go bankrupt
- hnlmorg 4y agoYeah, but I’m sure most of those businesses would have done their due diligence on WeWorks financials before moving in. Changing offices is an expensive exercise so they wouldn’t want to risk renting space from somewhere that is likely to go under in the next year or two.
- mejutoco 4y agoThe whole point of wework from a customer perspective is that you don’t have to commit to long 10-year leases. So wework leases long-term and the customers short-term. If the customers dry up wework still needs to pay their commitments.
- hnlmorg 4y agoWhere did I say 10 year leases? I specifically said 1 to 2 years knowing exactly how WeWork operates.
- mejutoco 4y agoNowhere did you say. My point is the dynamic I mention explains the problems of wework, and is not proved wrong by the argument you put forward, paraphrased, that "businesses have evaluated long-term risk of renting at wework so wework is not at risk"
- 4y ago
- alvah 4y agoTwitter? Seemed very much alive an hour ago.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoChatGPT is increasingly handling the bulk of my major queries, and that’s when its rate limited and hard to access (behind a sign up, behind captcha)
- HyperSane 4y ago
- unity1001 4y ago> Is that how Google ended up with eight chat apps Its more because they killed their already working, well-accepted Google Chat app, not seeing gigantic profit or any market control benefit from it. Somehow they thought it was a better idea to have some 'chat' through the browser - which resulted in whatever 'Hangouts' was. Prioritized 'engineering' and profits over users as its so normal for large public corporations. Then Slack and Discord came and wiped the floor with all of them.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoI’m willing to bet that that’s also how Google will be completely disrupted by an AI-first competitor. The execs will be too chicken to kill their current golden goose.
- wahnfrieden 4y agogoogle has the ai ability but no one has achieved cost scalability yet
- spaceman_2020 4y agoNo one doubts their ability. What one does doubt is the willingness of the suits to replace their wildly profitable business model with a new one. Kodak invented digital cameras but jettisoned it because they ate into its existing business. Will the same happen with Google?
- b112 4y agoIt already has started. Look at Meta, and how Apple borked their primary cash cow. Now, mostly due to concerns about state spying, many jurisdictions are passing enhanced privacy bills. On top of that, the entire planet now wants cash for news listings. And the EU is repeatedly extending its legislation, making Pii collection and tracking less and less profitable. The US keeps considering similar bills. Alphabet can lobby all it wants, but even so, these laws will be passed eventually. Google needs to smarten up.
- sacrosancty 4y ago
- urthor 4y agoA very very conservative prediction given the exact same thing happened to IBM, Sun, Burroughs, Yahoo to an extent, and infinitely many others.
- aix1 4y agoI am not totally sure what you mean by an AI-first competitor. Could you give a (hypothetical) example?
- SuperQue 4y agoGoogle ended up with a bunch of chat apps because the culture promotes building new over keeping things running. The first chat was basically an XMPP service. It was decent, it federated outside of Google, it was fully functional. It even supported group channels (XMPP conferences) internally. But I don't think that was ever exposed to the public. Then Hangouts was created. It was, per usual at Gooogle, a ground-up rewrite. IIRC not the same team. So they spent at least a couple years playing catch up to get feature parity with the XMPP chat. Worse, Hangouts was one of the first services to suffer from strict team-created "Personas" design philosophy. Any time anyone would complain about a feature, or miss-feature, it was flatly ignored because "You're not one of our Personas". It took years of complaints to get them to change their minds. By the time Hangouts was good enough to fully replace the previous service it was now boring and people left the team for other new projects. Because maintenance won't get you promoted. The other random chat services were basically experiential toys. Now we have Meet, which is is likely another case of "Hangouts is unmaintainable tech, we need to re-write it". Years of getting up to feature parity. And miss-features that won't get fixed.
- mejutoco 4y agoXMPP compatibility was amazing. I remember using one chat client to accept all the different chat services, including google one.
- detourdog 4y agoThe first sign of trouble to me was when google killed xmpp support. Prior to that everyone just logged into instant messaging on whatever device. Every decision since then has been pro-ad network technical competition.
- SuperQue 4y agoYea, it was great. But it was more lack of maintenance than anything. The original chat devs were passionate about open federation. The new devs were not. Add to that it was a big source of spam that nobody wanted to deal with. Apparently the team tried really hard to get more companies on board with opening up federation. But I think the only "major" service that did was what was left of AOL.