7 ms·
Solar panels open crop lands to farming energy
- tareqak 4y agoWhat about using that energy to emit light that plants can use at nighttime?
- nine_k 4y agoMany / most plants need some darkness to keep internal clocks properly functioning. So maybe the effective day could be extended a bit, but likely not a whole lot; IDK if the increase in growth would be worth the LEDs.
- ggm 4y agoThis is exactly the kind of problem linear optimisation a.k.a operations research (O/R) is designed to assess.
- giantg2 4y agoHere's some cool info about extended sunlight crops. https://www.amusingplanet.com/2015/10/alaskas-giant-vegetables.html?m=1 https://www.amusingplanet.com/2015/10/alaskas-giant-vegetabl...
- nine_k 4y agoImpressive! Alaska outperforming warmer regions due to longer days is not something I had expected.
- moloch-hai 4y agoPlants in fields typically get way more light than they need, as it is, and benefit from shade. Some pepper varieties show 3x yield, given afternoon shade. I wonder about powering UV LEDs under crop plants to control weeds.
- winReInstall 4y agoThere was a study in germany on this.. 20 % are enough for 80 % yield.. Sorry only have german link: https://www.oekolandbau.de/landwirtschaft/betrieb/oekonomie/diversifizierung/agrophotovoltaik-acker-und-solarenergie-optimal-kombinieren/ https://www.oekolandbau.de/landwirtschaft/betrieb/oekonomie/...
- UncleEntity 4y agoSeems like the use case for these would be as glass in a greenhouse, setting up and taking down for planting/harvest would probably require so much labor it wouldn’t be economically viable.
- defrost 4y agoAs this is a flexible film: https://www.armor-group.com/en/asca https://www.armor-group.com/en/asca I can see it being used in agricultural applications where shadecloth is used both to kill intense sunlight (eg: Australia) and to keep birds at bay. We have many large acreage areas fully under shade cloth here.
- moloch-hai 4y agoThis article promotes false assumptions. Ordinary solar can work fine in fields, because most plants don't use light beyond a few hours' worth, and endure the heat, after. A practical arrangement is bifacial panels in vertical fencerows running north-south, to pick up morning and afternoon sun, spaced widely enough for equipment to run between. Blocking morning sun preserves dew, and blocking afternoon cuts heat stress. Certain cereal crops get slightly lower yield from reduced light, but reduced water loss can make up the difference.
- giantg2 4y agoFor many varieties, you want the dew to evaporation of the plant in the morning. It reduces the risk of fungal diseases.
- sitkack 4y agoBut it sounds being able to control light/heat/moisture with panels can be beneficial, the mixture is site and crop specific.
- giantg2 4y agoThe article doesn't mention being able to control those things though.
- moloch-hai 4y ago> This article promotes false assumptions.
- maxerickson 4y agoI wonder how often interspersing the panels with crops ends up being better than packing the panels onto the most marginal portion of the land parcel. There's often ridges or whatever to deal with on a field.
- 4y ago
- locallost 4y agoEven if this is a good solution, there's probably so much space for capacity in e.g. parking lots and roads that I doubt there's a need for this, other than it being beneficial to the farmers. Which is a good enough reason, but the lack of space issues for solar panels are misleading. A sidenote on the first sentence in the article: I question the narrative that we are struggling to support 8 billion people because of lack of arable land. For instance I've seen estimates that 20-30% of perfectly good food is thrown away these days because it's not esthetically pleasing, e.g. a cucumber that might be of unusual shape. Also it's more economical to throw away food that you can't sell but is still good, than it is to give it away because then people would spend less which is bad for business. I don't know if this is a solvable problem, but it exists.
- kiba 4y agoThere's perfectly good food and then there's food that rots in our fridge, or food that rot before being harvested.
- phil21 4y ago> For instance I've seen estimates that 20-30% of perfectly good food is thrown away these days because it's not esthetically pleasing, e.g. a cucumber that might be of unusual shape. Also it's more economical to throw away food that you can't sell but is still good, than it is to give it away because then people would spend less which is bad for business. I don't know if this is a solvable problem, but it exists. I'm highly skeptical of this. I have direct experience as my family were (until covid) market gardeners who would sell to farmers markets, local supermarkets, and restaurants. Typically "nothing" gets wasted in these operations. You sell the prime produce at huge markups at the farmers markets, the mid-tier at the supermarkets, and the food service industry gives exactly zero care to the aesthetics of the produce so long as it's high quality and tastes good. I can't imagine this would be any different at an industrial scale, if anything the incentives become even greater. You sort your produce for the market vs. industrial use, and the latter is likely to be a far more reliable income stream. I doubt farmers are throwing away 30% of their product. Yes, there is a lot of loss along the way - but I'm not sure we can really do much better short of everyone growing everything locally.
- winReInstall 4y agoWish we could drive solar on empty fields in winter..
- giantg2 4y agoIsn't that the least efficient idea? You get minimal solar energy during that time of the year in most places and it eliminates the ability use a cover crop.
- jahnu 4y ago> There is no unused arable land on a planet that’s already struggling to support a human population that cleared 8 billion last month The amount of this land that is dedicated to growing food for livestock and the livestock themselves is simply astounding. Reducing meat consumption is a much simpler solution and I believe the one that will win out anyway. Complicated solar systems like this will only become relevant once we’ve addressed the low hanging fruit (pun intended) of overproduction of meat. Even precision fermentation is an easier to implement fix for land use, which looks increasingly like it can reduce our need for land to grow grains. See Solar Foods for example https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_Foods https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_Foods
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThe root cause of the problem was plainly mentioned: 8 billion people and counting. Solutions to problems ought to address root causes.
- tuatoru 4y agoThe Pareto principle applies. Most of the problem is caused by the top billion people ordered by income. If you have a tailor, that's you.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoNo. Unless you're happy to keep billions in abject poverty (and that does not ecen protect the environment) the aim is to have all humans on this planet live a good life in good conditions. Therefore it's not "us vs them" it's all of us together and the root cause is indeed the overall number.
- sveme 4y agoIf the top 1% would reduce their lifestyle to that of the next 10%, a lot would be gained right away. Private jets are evil.
- giantg2 4y agoInteresting idea. How's it going to work with the large equipment, allow rain through, and affect soil temperature?
- RobotToaster 4y agoIt seems an odd idea when we have so many roofs, car parks, roads, and other things that don't already use the sun we could cover in solar panels.
- Oxidation 4y agoSolar Roadways is a meme company for a reason. Paving with solar panels is a nightmare on pretty much every axis: installation, maintenance, cost, reliability, efficiency, safety, all of it. And while tessellating every surface with little panels gets more energy than not (and is the only option if that's all the land you own, like people adding panels to their own houses), it's dramatically easier and cheaper to lay out 1MW of panels in one 100m X 100m square, than 1000 hetrogenous 1kW panels mishmashed over dozens or hundreds of buildings. For large buildings, then, yes, it's a pretty clear win. The IKEAs in London have large arrays on their roofs, for example.
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoAnything that involves constructing precarious fragile structures over large areas of land is not a practical solution. Imagine wanting to harvest your crops and you can’t use any machinery because of all the structures. Or imagine there is a slight wind and it rips up 200k in solar panels.
- photochemsyn 4y agoYou just place the panels far enough apart that agricultural machinery can move up and down the rows (this also ensures plants aren't overly shaded). As far as wind resistance, robust design seems to solve that problem. https://www.pv-magazine.com/2022/11/16/baywa-velux-sign-europes-first-agrivoltaics-linked-ppa/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2022/11/16/baywa-velux-sign-euro... > "According to BayWa, the installation will have rows of panels spaced more widely than usual, to allow passage of agricultural machinery and the cultivation of cereals. In addition, the rainwater that falls on the modules will be collected and used for irrigation."
- nonethewiser 4y agoOr simply take the same amount of space and keep the solar panels and crops separate.
- photochemsyn 4y agoIntegration has benefits for many crops in many regions. For example, many fruits and vegetables develop better under some shade. See this USDA blurb: > "Commercial farms growing high value fruits and vegetables use shade structures to create protected environments. These growers benefit from bigger yields, better quality produce, fewer pests, timed crop growth, and resource conservation. Unfortunately, shade structure use is limited for many small and medium size farms who lack economy of scale. Commercial shade structures available today are very expensive to purchase and install as well as difficult and time-consuming to move." Solar structures mean the farms generate revenue from the shade systems, although initial cost-of-installation is high.
- natelegler 4y agoHere is my take as someone that is involved in farming in the Midwest. Both row crops and livestock: Taking out productive land to put in a solar farm is not practical. There are loads of acres that would be a perfect fit such as pasture land no longer being utilized for grazing. Or if there is pasture being used for grazing with sheep/goats would be another good place for these to be placed. Another suggestion would be utilizing the roofs of hog confinement buildings, poultry buildings, cattle sheds, machine sheds, etc. This also pertains to roofs in urban areas as well. I actually helped with a business putting up a new chemical shed to place solar panels on their roof. There are so many hog sites and poultry sites in my area that this would be a no brainer to try and push towards. Everyone saying eliminate or reduce meat consumption...all it is is a wish and prayer. It won't happen sorry that's just the cold hard truth so the above suggestion is what the world needs in a lot of situations...a compromise. The next suggestion is some sort of portable solar paneling during the non-growing season. Pull them out of the crop and field work has been done, and remove them before the next season begins.
- reportingsjr 4y agoFarmland in the midwest has been shrinking consistently for decades. Your comments would make sense if the opposite of this were true, and there was demand for additional farmland, but there isn't. Ohio reduced the amount of land it needed for farming by about 800,000 acres from 1997-2017 and in that period increase agricultural output[0], so it's not like the amount of food produced is going down! If people in rural areas NIMBY away solar power in these areas, more than likely the land is just going to have some exurban building plopped down on it. Also, I don't get the whole thing where people act like farmland is sacred and good for the environment. I like food, I understand the value of farms, but farmland is typically pretty awful for the surrounding environment. The area I live in Ohio has a whole handful of lakes, and any of them that are surrounded by farmland (and to a certain extent exurbs and suburbs) are incredibly polluted, to the point where you have to look at "forecasts" on ODNR's website to see if the water is healthy to swim in. 0: https://www.nass.usda.gov/Publications/AgCensus/2017/Full_Report/Volume_1,_Chapter_1_State_Level/Ohio/ohv1.pdf https://www.nass.usda.gov/Publications/AgCensus/2017/Full_Re... (check table 1 for historical data)
- photochemsyn 4y agoLarge-scale solar PV looks capable of integrating well with farming, particularly in arid to semi-arid regions, where partial shading doesn't reduce photosynthesis but does reduce evapotranspiration, meaning less water demand. This doesn't eliminate the need for either storage of PV power for use at night, or use of an alternative energy source (gas-powered turbines with rapid response times, etc.) at night, but clearly this could massively reduce demand for natural gas power during daylight hours. Of course, the investors in private utilities tend to also invest in natural gas companies, and they'd be losing revenue to the farmers and solar panel owners. This is certainly the case in California, and seems to account for the recent decision to limit net metering for solar PV producers who feed power into the grid. Note that this happened in a state where the political leadership makes lots of noises about supporting renewable energy and 'fighting climate change'.
- bee_rider 4y agoIt seems like interesting tech, but IMO we should start by putting down solar nearby highways (an appropriate distance back to avoid road debris). If we need more space, just remove a couple lanes (it should be fine because people should be shifting to public transit and work-from-home anyway). Then we can cover large chunks of the desert, lots of it is not really all that productive. I know it is an interesting environment and has some unusual animals to fill the weird niches, so we shouldn’t just totally cover it. But since we’ve already signed up for more deserts via climate change, surely we can panel-up some.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LatteLazy 4y agoWe already grow more than enough food for everyone. We should have less land dedicated to farming (or more accurately sucking up government subsidies) and return it to wildlife or social use.