8 ms·
Yep. Mercedes has these limitations not because their tech is less capable than Tesla's but because Mercedes is a real car company with real engineers and a go
by lolinder 4y ago
Yep.
Mercedes has these limitations not because their tech is less capable than Tesla's but because Mercedes is a real car company with real engineers and a gold-standard reputation to maintain.
Tesla, in contrast, is a software company that is trying to take "move fast and break things" into the two-ton 75mph vehicle space, with predictable results.
- revnode 4y agoSo Mercedes' solution is to offer a product that isn't usable? Why bother releasing it?
- ahakki 4y agoWith it's current limitations, the only application for Mercedes' solution I can think of is during heavy traffic on highways. But calling it "not usable" does seem a bit harsh. Of course if you prefer, move fast and brake... maybe
- ethanbond 4y agoTraffic on highways is also by far the most frustrating part of driving basically for the same reasons it’s an easy-ish target for automation, so seems like a pretty good place to start. IMO that’s just good product strategy.
- lolinder 4y agoIt's perfectly usable in its intended scope: it allows you to focus on other things while driving in heavy traffic. When they're confident that they can do so safely, they'll extend it to other situations. Mercedes explains the purpose in their press release: > Conditionally automated driving on suitable motorway sections where traffic density is high > During the conditionally automated journey, DRIVE PILOT allows the driver to take their mind off the traffic and focus on certain secondary activities, be it communicating with colleagues via In-Car Office, surfing the internet or relaxing while watching a film. In DRIVE PILOT mode, applications can be enabled on the vehicle's integrated central display that are otherwise blocked while driving. https://group-media.mercedes-benz.com/marsMediaSite/en/instance/ko/Mercedes-Benz-receives-worlds-first-internationally-valid-system-approval-for-conditionally-automated-driving.xhtml https://group-media.mercedes-benz.com/marsMediaSite/en/insta...
- BuildTheRobots 4y agoHow heavy does the traffic need to be, I wonder? Based on that I'm assuming it's following other vehicles rather than following the road, which does make me wonder what happens when you get a clump of DRIVE PILOT vehicles which are all trying to follow each other. Edit: It seems like it needs a vehicle ahead and under 60kph and uses a mix of other vehicles and road markings. It seems quite usable (but I still have to wonder how many vehicles you can get to follow each other in a chain): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0yiPaKfKLZs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0yiPaKfKLZs
- binarymax 4y agoIt’s useable in certain situations that have a high probability of safety, and allows them to capture data and grow the program safely over time.
- vanilla_nut 4y agoTesla's solution offers a product that occasionally tries to kill you and people around you. The only reason it doesn't is because drivers are forced to pay attention and take over at a moment's notice at all times. Mercedes' solution is a car company taking actual responsibility for their software. If they feel the lawsuits/insurance claims/legal snafus are worth the risk, that means their software is probably pretty damn good in that limited scope. Otherwise they could literally bankrupt the company with lawsuits! That's a lot more confidence inspiring to me than Elon's repeated pie-in-the-sky claims.
- newaccount74 4y agoWhen I commuted in the city, there was a traffic jam almost every day, and I'd be stuck 15-20 minutes driving at walking speed. On especially bad days it could be up to 45min. If I could have read my emails in that time it would have been really nice.
- pantalaimon 4y agoThe proper solution to this is trains
- philippejara 4y agoeveryone knows that public transport is the solution to it but I can't buy a railroad track and a train to take to work so people are going to do what they can do
- Zagill 4y agoYou can't personally buy a railroad but you can vote for people who will apply your tax dollars towards it instead of oil subsidies and auto bailouts :)
- philippejara 4y agolet's not turn this into a chain of saying obvious things that everyone involved already knows about, it's not going to add to the conversation and -hopefully- nor will it give you internet points in this website.
- tsimionescu 4y agoIt's the other way around. Tesla is selling an extremely expensive beta test that you can't use at all anywhere in any conditions with any kind of safety expectations. Mercedes is selling a product that has a small set of well-defined cases where it can actually be used.
- _the_inflator 4y agoTesla's mockery during the bull market is finally coming to an end. Being cocky and funny without delivering great results is simply embarrassing. I think Mercedes and other automakers have a good chance to bypass Tesla now since Elno is captivated by his Twitter acquisition.
- rnk 4y agoI think you mean to say Elmo
- klipt 4y agoCome now, Elmo and Elon may both be childish Muppets, but Elmo at least has the excuse of actually being a child in an educational kids show.
- jethro_tell 4y agoIDK, it seems like the people doing the work might have a better grasp on delivering for tesla than musk. I don't imagine tweeting promises that the engineers know they can't keep is that useful.
- bnjms 4y ago> I think Mercedes and other automakers have a good chance to bypass Tesla now since Elno is captivated by his Twitter acquisition. I’ve been disappointed in Elon for some time and feel society may have already taken him for all of his good ideas. So I’d bet the opposite. This is a chance for Tesla to recover and match the established auto makers. And the only chance they’ll get.
- snotrockets 4y agoSo far, Tesla has been incapable of stepping up to be a major car manufacturer. There are many small car manufacturers, some build exquisite cars that are technological and design marvels, but what Ford realized early, and Nagoya perfected (just consider how many modern op practices originated there!) is that it's not about the machine, but about the infrastructure. This is both pre-sale, where you have to build a lean, mean, fast pipeline from vendors to assembly, and post-sales, where you have to have service infrastructure that spans continents, if not the world. Tesla so far shows very little signs of being able to do either. And just like Whitley failed and ended up being bought by Mumbai, my personal bet (caveat lector!) is that Tesla-the-brand might survive, but Tesla-the-car-manufacturer would end up a subsidiary of a Chinese car manufacturer, who has the car manufacturing chops, but can't build a brand.
- traceroute66 4y ago> Mercedes is a real car company with real engineers and a gold-standard reputation to maintain. Not only that, but they have a quality reputation to uphold with their domestic (German) and regional (European) market. Your average discerning German car buyer (i.e. the sort who has a Porsche 911, or a higher-end Audi/BMW/Merc) in their garage will swiftly tell you about numerous problems with the Tesla before they've even sat in it. Panel gaps, for example. They mean a lot to your average discerning German, and your average Tesla has them by the bucket load. In fact, the German in-joke is that the reason Tesla built a factory in Germany is so that the Germans could (try to) teach them how to fix the panel gaps. :-)
- sho_hn 4y ago> In fact, the German in-joke is that the reason Tesla built a factory in Germany is so that the Germans could (try to) teach them how to fix the panel gaps. :-) Speaking more seriously on that front, there's been the acquihire of Grohmann Engineering.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>so that the Germans could (try to) teach them how to fix the panel gaps Not a Tesla owner or fan but I have a question that's really bugging me now: Which customers really care about panel gaps? Do average joes, SUV driving soccer moms or suburban white collar workers go around with a ruler measuring their panel gaps with others like "yeah your Tesla is cool and all, but sorry, my Audi A5 has much tighter panel gaps which is what matters most you know"? When has the panel gap became "the benchmark" indicative of car quality beyond the body shell? Like, if the panel gaps are the only thing you can find wrong in a car, then it must be a really really good car, right? Is there any proven evidence that the panel gaps corelate to quality and reliability of the rest of the car, or is it just a myth of the car enthusiasts community that got spread around and went too far? I get it, some Tesla are unreliable and built poorly, but it's not because they have big panel gaps. The reverse is also true for many cars, so this isn't a rule. Sure, if you want to measure and compare panel gaps, then by all means go ahead and measure panel gaps, but please don't pretend they mean anything more than that, and that it's somehow an indicative for the car's overall quality and reliability, because so far there hasn't been any proof of this correlation.
- jsjohnst 4y ago> Mercedes is a real car company with real engineers and a gold-standard reputation to maintain Totally agree with all your points against Tesla, but “gold-standard reputation” for Mercedes? Based on what? They are consistently rated as one of the worse brands reliability wise (Tesla usually being worse, but still).
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y ago"Nothing's more expensive than a cheap Mercedes." Because they have a reputation of breaking down a lot, and a "cheap" Mercedes is still a Mercedes which is fixed using Mercedes-priced parts.
- SoftTalker 4y agoIt's interesting. I only buy older used cars. Mercedes is a brand I have owned a couple of times. Outside of a few specific engines and models, they are mechanically very reliable and very solidly built. Moreover, especially the older cars, are quite easy to work on for a home mechanic. Parts are readily available and are not really more expensive than for any other car I've owned, which includes several other German as well as Japanese and American brands. If you are in that market, and stick with the older models that are proven to be reliable, they are pretty safe buys. Like any used car, a lot depends on the care given by the prior owner, but people who buy Mercedes cars new tend to have at least above-average income, and can afford to maintain them properly.
- jacquesm 4y agoI've put well over a million km on Mercedes vehicles and not a single breakdown. That's anecdata, but compared with the other vehicles I've driven whose brands I will not mention their record for me at least has been outstanding. That said: the newer generation is not for me, I had a C-class with automatic emergency breaking try to murder me twice and I've sold it and gotten something much older without that kind of accessory.
- 4y ago
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoThe difference between breaking Firefox nightly and writing software for a nuclear power plant.
- areoform 4y agoI feel that casting TSLA as a company without “real engineers” isn’t helpful nor is it truthful.
- lolinder 4y agoFor me, the measure of whether an engineer counts as "real" is if they're empowered to say no. You can have hundreds of qualified people who are called "engineers" and would be excellent in another environment, but if the culture is "If I say jump, you ask how high" you don't have an engineering culture, you have an autocracy.
- haberman 4y agoAgree. Which makes it all the more frustrating that popular press focuses on irrelevant distractions, like the fact that if you try really hard, you can defeat the protections designed to ensure that the driver is ready to take over: https://www.consumerreports.org/autonomous-driving/cr-engineers-show-tesla-will-drive-with-no-one-in-drivers-seat/ https://www.consumerreports.org/autonomous-driving/cr-engine... A car is never going to prevent a determined individual from doing stupid things. But it is a big problem that people who are trying to be responsible are misled about what Tesla's "Full Self Driving" can actually deliver.
- misiti3780 4y agoTesla isnt a real car company? Please climb back under your rock.
- panick21_ 4y agoYeah its not like Mercedes cheated the world on emission and with that killed many more people then Tesla Autopilot ever will. And Mercedes simply does not have the ability to produce something like FSD Beta from Tesla no matter how 'real' their engineers are.
- malermeister 4y agoMercedes already produced something better than the FSD beta: Actual L3.