7 ms·
I'm happy for their success. However, I'm dismayed that it was their inability to pay for healthcare that landed them in this (albeit good) situation. It's not
by satvikpendem 4y ago
I'm happy for their success. However, I'm dismayed that it was their inability to pay for healthcare that landed them in this (albeit good) situation. It's not a situation that should be forced on citizens in a modern country, for which this particular example is a feel-good ending, but there are many more (orders of magnitude more) feel-bad endings, so to speak.
- Y_Y 4y agoOur fortunes rise and fall together
- serverholic 4y agoHealthcare and basic income are crucial for moving towards the next stage of civilizaiton. Like you said, I'm really glad it worked out for them but so, so many people don't get so lucky or are willing to take such a big risk. How many more dwarf fortresses could we have if we gave people the safety net to follow their dreams? Instead of worrying about basic necessities like food, shelter, and healthcare.
- vkoskiv 4y ago> How many more dwarf fortresses could we have if we gave people the safety net to follow their dreams? So, so many. Linux is a good example. Linus has talked about how he was able to spend a lot of time on getting Linux off the ground because back in the 80s and 90s, study allowances in Finland were very, very generous. Took him like 8 years to graduate, and during that time he didn't have to worry at all about finding a job to pay rent and buy food. These days, the system is similar, but they do monitor your progress more closely and will cut off the allowance if you don't progress in your studies. (ask me how I know :P)
- serverholic 4y agoImagine if he had a boss breathing down his neck and daily standups lol. I don't think people realize how much our society saps our humanity and kills our creative energies and our desires to build things.
- spacephysics 4y agoI agree there is a problem with high healthcare costs, and food costs especially now. However what we saw with covid stimulus and unemployment wasn’t the “everyone’s now an artist” outcome that is suggested with UBI. We definitely saw creatives able to express and build their visions into the world, thanks to the money and additional time. But we also saw, and still have ongoing, many people who choose not to work [0]. Some percent of these people are suffering from substance abuse. Not to say this is purely the outcome of UBI, but I can’t imagine it helps those individuals with such proclivities for abuse. Personally I think we should have a good UBI at the least, qualified for individuals who make under a certain amount and who are able and working, or legitimately looking for a job. There’s a reason many trust fund kids go broke or dive into substance abuse. Sure there are examples of families who would not do this under similar circumstances, but giving out money for no work (assuming one is able to work), leads to hedonic pleasures unless the individual is purposely aware and trying to avoid such sand traps. [0] - https://www.bls.gov/web/empsit/cpseea38.htm https://www.bls.gov/web/empsit/cpseea38.htm
- patmcc 4y agoYou seem to be connecting UBI to the "Do not want a job now" category, but I don't think there's any reason to think covid stimulus/unemployment led to much growth in those particular numbers. See https://www.bls.gov/cps/aa2004/cpsaat35.pdf https://www.bls.gov/cps/aa2004/cpsaat35.pdf for the same numbers from 2003/2004; they're certainly higher now (~100k vs ~70k, but population increased, so more like 100k vs 80k if we equalize) but not that much higher. And at a glance the biggest increase is in 55+ - so possibly it's largely older people retiring rather than substance abuse or whatever. I do think UBI has risks, hopefully we can encourage useful pursuits, public works, etc.
- komali2 4y ago> but giving out money for no work (assuming one is able to work), leads to hedonic pleasures It sounds like you think this is bad. Why?
- atomicnumber3 4y agoCovid was not a great experiment. The stimulus checks were 6+ months apart each and would barely pay rent for the month in which they arrived for anyone not living in a shoebox. And UE has a lot of stipulations about you spending all your time trying to get a new job.
- Gigachad 4y agoMore people building dwarf fortresses means less people doing whatever they are right now. While some jobs may be completely pointless, I think we would quickly find that we actually need people doing boring jobs because society would fall apart without them and then no one gets to build video games.
- lmm 4y agoMaybe. I suspect the amount of actual work to be done has dropped a lot. Surely it's worth trying a few steps in that direction.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoThat doesn't follow. The maximum possible human attention span will still be 24 hours a day in the future. The current entertainment market already saturates this several hundred times over. Creating several dozen more dwarf fortresses won't do anything since they will just take attention away from each other. Since information can be replicated for almost nothing. Whereas physical labor can't be replicated nearly as easily.
- serverholic 4y agoI’d imagine the people offering those boring jobs would have to make them pretty appealing. Perhaps better pay, better work hours, etc. I don’t think jobs would go away like you seem to imply. When I say taking care of peoples needs I don’t mean giving everyone a mansion.
- bombcar 4y agoI believe they now have enough cash to emigrate to Canada if they wished to do so.
- chaostheory 4y agoCanada, like the US, has its own health care crisis. Wait times for medical care seem surreal. https://www.theglobeandmail.com/amp/canada/british-columbia/article-cancer-patients-treatment-wait-times/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/amp/canada/british-columbia/... https://ottawacitizen.com/news/local-news/ottawa-paramedics-were-at-level-zero-when-call-came-in-about-11-year-old-with-no-vital-signs/wcm/f0c6b02a-5cb9-42c3-a777-27b5ab3af15d/amp/ https://ottawacitizen.com/news/local-news/ottawa-paramedics-...
- pantalaimon 4y agoIs this a global issue now? Same in Germany.
- rjbwork 4y agoIn the name of profit and efficiency, all slack as been wrung out of our healthcare systems. Systems with no slack are brittle and prone to failure under stressors. As for stressors...gestures broadly.
- chaostheory 4y agoProfit? Aren’t all of your provincial healthcare systems publicly run and publicly funded? I feel that there are two issues. One is taxes. Canada already has high taxes, which does not pair well with low salaries and a high cost of living that isn’t too far from either the SF Bay Area or even NYC. The second is your confederation’s central government is weak. Your provinces have too much power, and they’re the ones controlling the healthcare systems which seem to be managed completely differently from one province to another rifht?
- 4y ago
- nonethewiser 4y agoThey decided to live off 30k a year with no health insurance. What did they think would happen?
- lmm 4y agoWould it have been any different if they did have health insurance? Under the US system I read plenty of stories of people who did everything right - had top insurance and lots of savings - but were still rendered destitute.
- wardedVibe 4y agofuck the poors, right?
- komali2 4y agoWould you rather live in a world where we don't have things like Dwarf Fortress? Their passion has been the game, as they understood it, they weren't able to make it and have health insurance (as I recall from the documentary, there were some issues getting remote jobs, and health insurance out of pocket is apparently prohibitively expensive in the USA). Why are you blaming them and not the system?
- Gigachad 4y agoThey always had the option to start selling the game. He could have put it up for sale years ago. He produced an enormous amount of value and chose to not collect the earnings until now.
- nonethewiser 4y ago> Would you rather live in a world where we don't have things like Dwarf Fortress? 1. we do have Dwarf Fortress. 2. It's not our collective responsibility to finance people who want to make art I'm not blaming the system because it's not the limiting factor here. They did not prioritize their financial security so why should society do it instead? They have all the tools to finance their lives yet opted not to. They learned this themselves and corrected it when they realized it was unsustainable. The worst possible scenario is subsidizing their previous lifestyle. Insurance not covering medically necessary procedures and hospitals charging exorbitant prices is a problem, not this.