8 ms·
> A successful launch doesn’t actually change the reality that it was and still is largely politically viable only as a jobs/pork program. This is sometimes se
by kube-system 4y ago
> A successful launch doesn’t actually change the reality that it was and still is largely politically viable only as a jobs/pork program.
This is sometimes seen as wasteful, on the surface, but there are very real benefits to doing things like this, even when it is much more expensive than alternatives:
1. having alternatives to other commercial ventures, which are subject to their own financial viability
2. having backup launch capability
3. maintaining more relevant talent in the US
4. maintaining institutional knowledge of cutting edge aerospace tech
5. maintaining aerospace industrial capability in the US
These are all generally good for furthering science and technology, and our economy, but it is critical in times of war (and as a deterrent to war)
The romantic nature of space is definitely the best way to sell these programs, but there are much more pragmatic reasons to be doing them.
- touch_abs 4y agoIm not sure you actually achieve any of this with the SLS, and NASA in general. 1 and 2 are irrelevant if the cost is too high for anything that isnt a political stunt, to be a real alternative it needs to be something that a commercial payload might plausibly choose. 3 and 4, are compromised by the political nature of NASA spending, I dont believe the current institution is capable of innovation. The talent of the people is uncertain, not due to the individuals, but the way work can become visible (also the hiring, promotion, and leadership determination is based on politics not merit) Apart from long range experiments, nasa is really the cutting edge at the moment. 5 is just another way tax money evaporates.
- yazantapuz 4y ago> I dont believe the current institution is capable of innovation But leaving aside the SLS, there are missions like the mars rovers and the james webb telescope, that I think show innovation and scientific success (but I do not live on the us, so i have an incomplete view).
- skissane 4y ago> 1. having alternatives to other commercial ventures, which are subject to their own financial viability SpaceX suddenly going out of business (as in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy) seems rather unlikely. The same is true of ULA, Boeing, Lockheed Martin, etc. Absolute worse case scenario would be Chapter 11, in which the business continues to operate under new ownership, and the current owners lose everything – but even that doesn't seem that likely. Anyway, the chapter 11 scenario is still a risk with the cost-plus procurement SLS model – Boeing (or Aerojet Rocketdyne, or Lockheed Martin) going through chapter 11 might not have doomed SLS/Orion, but it likely would have caused delays. In fact, it is open to doubt whether SLS/Orion-style cost-plus contracting has any real advantage over commercial from a bankruptcy risk perspective, for two competing commercial providers must have less bankruptcy risk than a single non-commercial government contractor > 2. having backup launch capability Multiple commercial providers, like they've pursued for commercial cargo and crew to ISS, and are still planning to pursue for Artemis HLS, would meet that just as well as an SLS-style program could. Given they likely could have afforded at least two commercial systems for the cost of SLS+Orion, it seems this actually gives worse backup than commercial does. > 3. maintaining more relevant talent in the US This doesn't seem relevant, given that the most likely firms to have provided NASA with a commercial SLS alternative – SpaceX, Blue Origin, ULA, Boeing, Lockheed Martin, Sierra Nevada, etc – are all US firms anyway. In fact, IIRC, the NASA procurement documents for commercial crew and cargo, and Artemis HLS, all said only US firms could respond. ITAR makes it a lot harder for US space firms to offshore jobs than most other industries. > 4. maintaining institutional knowledge of cutting edge aerospace tech While it is true that NASA doesn't own the engineering for the commercial programs, in the way they own SLS engineering, NASA engineers are still heavily involved in the commercial programs, for review/advice/consulting/sign-off/etc. This factor is the most plausible of all those you've mentioned, but it is unclear if having somewhat deeper engineering expertise among NASA employees (as opposed to US private sector space firms) is important enough to justify a procurement approach which costs billions over and above its commercial alternative > 5. maintaining aerospace industrial capability in the US This doesn't seem relevant for the same reasons as (3)
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> SpaceX suddenly going out of business (as in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy) seems rather unlikely. The same is true of ULA, Boeing, Lockheed Martin SpaceX is not critical to national security, and it—many times—came close to bankruptcy in its adolescence of the early 2010s. Aerospace, in the past, saw massive recessions where companies larger than SpaceX went poof. This will almost certainly happen again, once we’re done tooling up for China.
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoSure there are these benefits, but the real question is what would be the benefits of some alternative way to spend the money, and how does that compare? What if we made STEM degrees tuition free across the country? Surely that would result in a larger talent pool than simply paying NASA engineers to dig holes and then fill them up with rocket parts.
- GolfPopper 4y agoFor 3, and 4, I may be wrong, but my understanding is that the SLS is just continuing (and, with future engines, re-producing) the space-shuttle tech package. Which is, well, certainly not cutting edge, and not particularly relevant to anything else anyone is doing in the space-launch sphere. Now, just because no one else is doing it doesn't mean it's automatically bad, but it's a launch technology suite that was selected against for good reason in the post-shuttle era. The (eventual) launch of Artemis I made clear, for example, that cryogenic hydrogen is a really problem-prone PITA to work with.
- ethbr0 4y agoIf you're working with decades-long development timelines, it isn't the worst idea to use a modernized version of proven technology. Let SpaceX et al. take the technology risk, and support them via contracts. But it's an improvement on the prior approach to instead put space eggs in two baskets: {lower risk, conservative technology choices} + {higher risk, cutting edge technology choices}
- glompers 4y agoWe tend to think of risk management and secondarily the cost horizon of [re]building eroded technical competence, in the West, but hn commenter User23 also makes a point that is incredibly important and less often mentioned: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33939692 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33939692 > " 'Indeed, besides the Catholic Church, the Lutheran Church, and the Parliaments of Iceland and the Isle of Man, every organization [of 60+] in the western world that's been continuously operating since 1530 is a university.' -- https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD11xx/EWD1175.html https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD11xx/E... I believe this is why it's critically important that universities remain focused on their timeless mission rather than chasing secular fads. The Buxton index, described in the [link], is an incredibly important concept." It's natural that we would think technology startups compelling due to the way they succeed with difficulty and risk management competence. But if their Buxton index of planning horizon is limited by their runway, and a decade is considered an Uber-long horizon, how futuristic and exceptional are we ultimately talking? I agree with the parent commenter that the eggs in two baskets serve separately appropriate purposes.
- altacc 4y agoI'd add that whilst people generally have a low trust in governments, I personally have zero trust in corporations and the idea of access to space being solely the preserve of commercial entities is an uncomfortable one. Historically both governments and companies have acted for self interest and detrimentally to everyone else but governments still have more accountability than corporations, which are beholden to a profit seeking board. Governments do things that are not profitable but advance society, for profit entities don't.
- robertlagrant 4y ago> Governments do things that are not profitable but advance society, for profit entities don't. The simplest way to understand if society wants something is if it will pay for it. > the idea of access to space being solely the preserve of commercial entities is an uncomfortable one It shouldn't be. Until SpaceX, the only way to the ISS was a Russian-controlled system. Would you prefer that to SpaceX today? Or is it better to have companies - that are regulated - follow money rather than the whims of whomever is currently in charge?
- gbear605 4y ago> The simplest way to understand if society wants something is if it will pay for it. That’s society’s preferences weighted by how good each person is at making money, but it doesn’t represent society as a whole. If a person is disabled or uneducated and can’t hold a job, that person should still get an equal say in society’s preferences even though they have no money with which to express their preferences.
- dotancohen 4y ago> 1. having alternatives to other commercial ventures, which are subject to their own financial viability Alternatives to what? Commercial manned capsule ventures already have alternatives. Specifically, the only US manned capsule today, Dragon, has alternative capabilities being developed by SpaceX itself in the form of Starship, and Boeing has a capsule that keeps failing milestones but is being developed. If you are referring to the rocket, then the SLS is not compatible with any other rocket in use for any purpose, due to the SRBs. All commercial payloads are designed with smoother liquid-only rockets in mind - designing for an SRB launch adds considerable weight to the birds. > 2. having backup launch capability Backup to what? What can the SLS launch that would go on another rocket? > 3. maintaining more relevant talent in the US This is true. > 4. maintaining institutional knowledge of cutting edge aerospace tech The SLS is not cutting edge. It's refactoring 1970's technologies. The Orion capsule might be considered modern, but again it's not cutting edge in any sense of the term. > 5. maintaining aerospace industrial capability in the US Since the CRS program has been underway, this has not been in danger.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> which are subject to their own financial viability Or are run by folks with sleep deprivation issues...
- joshvm 4y agoOn 4, SLS is also a strategic partnership with ESA and other external agencies. ESA is supplying the service module for example.
- Veedrac 4y agoThese are common but post-hoc justifications. Government launch monopolies have suppressed a lot of competition in the market, that would exist in plenty if the money was fairly spent. A particularly salient example in light of Russia's war is that Congress repeatedly underfunded the Commercial Crew Program in favor of over-funding SLS, while we were trying to wean off Russian dependence. But this is far from the only case. We could have had redundancy in Artemis by designing for commercial lift; half the money split between three providers would have given a lot more lift and a lot better cadence than SLS. We could seek out redundancy for SLS now, by buying rockets Artemis already requires, modified for SLS' flight profile, and spending a tiny fraction on, say, ULA and Blue's rockets. We would have more backup launch capabilities, and more relevant talent, and more institutional knowledge, if we just invested the money in open-market demand for products, rather than supporting and endorsing monopoly-making. Was Congress more up in arms over Starship HLS, or ULA EELV? Think what it says to the market when a government is more willing to give money to a company for forming a monopoly and to penalize them for flying commercial payloads, than in purchase of a product. The motivations for these programs aren't actually grounded in the betterment of the industry, nor of the US' launch capabilities in general. There is no way ~$100B on SLS/Orion is a sane allocation of money for that.
- kube-system 4y agoThey're not post-hoc at all, military power was the entire reason world powers went to space to begin with, not science. And private aerospace has highly monopolized themselves -- there's a reason there's so many hyphenated company names in this space. Consolidation is the natural evolution of large private companies in industries with high barriers to entry. The only mechanism we have to counter that is public spending that intentionally props up smaller players. SpaceX would already be out of business if it weren't for the US government swooping in to save the day. They didn't have a viable commercial business until later.
- themgt 4y agoChina just built a new space station by itself in about 18 months. A lot of these rationalizations for going the slow bloated pork route are going to evaporate as it becomes clearer we have a great power peer competitor. Hopefully it doesn't take a CCP flag flying on the Moon and people getting arrested for criticizing Xi Jinping Thought on Mars for the USA to finally get off its ass and realize being arrogantly wasteful and inefficient isn't actually a "deterrent to war" against a competent adversary.
- malfist 4y agoTo be fair, their space station is 3 modules and about the size of mir. It is significantly smaller than the ISS.
- AlgorithmicTime 4y ago
- pfdietz 4y agoThe ISS showed large space vehicles can be assembled from small modules that could be launched on the Space Shuttle. This is the major accomplishment of the ISS program. So what does NASA do? Decide (or be told to decide), "oh no, we need a launcher that can lift much bigger things, because OF COURSE we can't put smaller modules together in space."
- adventured 4y agoWe have no idea how long it took the Chinese Government to build their new space station. They lie about practically everything and the record is largely opaque with everything they do. If it took them ten years to bring it to fruition, they certainly would lie about it and pretend otherwise.
- zardo 4y ago> This is sometimes seen as wasteful, on the surface, but there are very real benefits to doing things like this, even when it is much more expensive than alternatives: Those benefits are from having government rocket program, not from having one where politicians micromanage the rocket design to the extent of dictating the choice of engine.