6 ms·
Lexus in development of a manual transmission for electric cars
- mozball 4y agoSkeumorphism in automotive design
- otabdeveloper4 4y agoPutting a literal ton of rechargeable AA batteries into a car form factor just so you can move one person 20 kilometers is already the peak of insanity, so why not go the whole hog on craziness.
- wilg 4y agoLook, if you want to complain that cars exist, fine. But they aren't going away, so we need to make them more CO2-efficient. Even if you could get rid of most cars, that wouldn't be enough, and it wouldn't be able to happen quickly enough to avoid electrification.
- otabdeveloper4 4y agoLithium batteries certainly aren't more CO2 efficient. You're just outsourcing the exhaust somewhere else.
- marssaxman 4y agoThat could only be true if you lived somewhere with an old-fashioned grid that had no renewables. Using an electric car means C02 emissions per mile will continue to drop over time, as utilities add new solar and wind capacity.
- Invictus0 4y agoAnd the emissions due to mining the lithium and cobalt? https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/how-much-co2-emitted-manufacturing-batteries#:~:text=Currently%2C%20most%20lithium%20is%20extracted,are%20emitted%20into%20the%20air https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/how-much-co2-emitted-manufac....
- ravenstine 4y agoWhoa, I've never seen this `#:~:text=` thing (apparently called "scroll-to-text"), but it seems to work on every page I try it on. How come I've never heard of this browser feature? https://caniuse.com/url-scroll-to-text-fragment https://caniuse.com/url-scroll-to-text-fragment Too bad it doesn't work on Firefox.
- burkaman 4y agoWhy post this question? The article you linked answers it clearly.
- elihu 4y ago"Particularly in hard rock mining, for every tonne of mined lithium, 15 tonnes of CO2 are emitted into the air." Estimates seem to vary, but this is claiming that there's about 12 kg of lithium in a 70 kwh Tesla battery: https://www.quora.com/How-much-lithium-in-kg-is-used-in-an-electric-car https://www.quora.com/How-much-lithium-in-kg-is-used-in-an-e... So, that's 180 kg of CO2 for enough lithium to make a large car battery. If your first quote is actually referring to 15 tons of CO2 per ton of lithium carbonate mined, then there's 63 kg of that, the mining of which causes about 945 kg of CO2 emissions. Burning a gallon of gas emits about 9 kg of CO2. A car that gets 30 miles to the gallon will burn about 6700 gallons of gas over a 200,000 mile lifetime, resulting in 60,000 kg of CO2 emissions. There are other environmental issues with mining lithium and cobalt and other energy costs involved in making the batteries, but CO2 emissions from mining is way down there on the list of things to be worried about.
- burkaman 4y agoIt's not even true then, a coal-powered EV results in less emissions than a gas-powered car because the EV engine is so much more energy-efficient.
- pfdietz 4y agoA combined cycle power plant can be more than 60% efficient (LHV). The efficiency of an IC car can be in the low 20%s. And cars burn a fuel with a higher C:H ratio than natural gas.
- ravenstine 4y agoThat is until our primary electrical sources aren't releasing sequestered CO2 from the earth's crust, assuming we get there before destroying ourselves. A lot of people do own EVs thinking they're saving the earth while being ignorant to where their electricity is coming from. That doesn't mean EVs aren't going to help us get there in terms of clean energy.
- burkaman 4y agoThis isn't true and you know it. Producing an electric car releases slightly more emissions than an ICE car, but as soon as you start actually driving them the EV has a far smaller carbon impact, even if your electricity is 100% coal (which it almost certainly isn't). EVs are way more energy-efficient than ICE vehicles. Something like 80% of the energy from the gas you put in your car is wasted.
- 543g43g43 4y ago>But they aren't going away Why? And if not, why can't we apply your argument to other things, eg, coal power plants? >Even if you could get rid of most cars, that wouldn't be enough, and it wouldn't be able to happen quickly enough to avoid electrification. Estimates for the lifetime CO2 savings of EVs vary from 40% to 70%. Assuming the be best case (70%), the CO2 impact would only be the same as "getting rid of most cars", which you say isn't enough.
- aussieshibe 4y ago> Why? Comfort, convenience, speed, separation from other people, etc, etc. Changing the balance there requires significant investment in alternatives which doesn't seem to be forthcoming (at least in my country). We can't apply the same arguments to power plants because we don't have to go to / see / interact with the power plant in order to use electricity. It just appears at the wall socket like magic. Where it comes from is functionally irrelevant to the consumer.
- 543g43g43 4y ago>Comfort, convenience, speed, Didn't realise these were valid arguments in the face of the Climate Catastrophe! >It just appears at the wall socket like magic. It's by far the most convenient and quickest to burn coal.
- somrand0 4y agowhat!? do you expect they should walk!? tyrant!!! lol (sorry for not being funny to you)
- everdrive 4y agoFrankly the limitations of electric cars might be a step in the direction of pushing out car culture. They’re more expensive, it’s not clear there are enough batteries for all the cars people want, and we may never solve the range problem. This might naturally push more people to public transit, albeit not all at once. The big issue in my mind is that public transit cannot be a solution _everywhere_, even if it could and should be greatly expanded.
- coss 4y agoThe hybrid plug-in models seem like a very good solution in terms of practicality and efficiency. Most can go 40 miles atm, which is a commute for most. Eventually cutting out fossil fuel work commutes for those who can’t work at home, or even the weekly run to wherever would eventually have a significant impact.
- everdrive 4y agoI couldn’t agree more, and we might look at a plug-in hybrid for our next model.
- Drunk_Engineer 4y agoE-bikes are a very good solution for trips not well served by public transit. And E-bikes do have manual transmissions, for those who like that sort of thing...
- amelius 4y agoDo they also make traditional motor sounds? What speakers are they using?
- grecy 4y agoI think there will be a few large auto makers that will have a manual EV, just to keep enthusiasts happy with fun driving. jeeps Ev wrangler prototypes have been manual so far.
- carlmr 4y agoIn some special cases a transmission may make sense on an EV. Electric motors are very inefficient at low revs. Most cars don't spend much time at low revs with a lot of torque output so this doesn't matter. But a car like a jeep that may haul a high load at low revs up a hill may be more efficient with a transmission. Of course you have to account for the weight of the transmission and its inefficiency as well to see if it makes sense overall.
- dogma1138 4y agoMost EVs already have gearboxes, this also isn’t really a transmission it’s just emulating one with haptic and auditory feedback.
- radiorental 4y agoWhen you say "gearboxes" as in traditional multi ratio transmissions? If so, are you 100% sure about that?
- pcl 4y agoIIRC the Tesla Roadster had a 2-speed transmission initially, due to engineering challenges with high-rpm bearings. But they struggled with the engineering challenges of high-torque transmissions, and eventually sorted out the bearing issues and went back to 1-speed.
- elihu 4y agoMost EVs have a single-speed gearbox. A few have multiple gear ratios, but it's not common. (It's not unusually for ICE vehicles converted to EV to retain a manual transmission, but conversions aren't being done in large numbers.)
- TheDesolate0 4y ago
- elihu 4y agoIt's not terribly clear from the article, but the headline is false: Lexus isn't developing a manual transmission for electric cars, they're developing software and controls that mimic the presence of manual transmission. I don't know why journalists think it's okay to engage in such blatant dishonesty. It's not just evo.co.uk: https://insideevs.com/news/625264/lexus-confirms-manual-transmission-for-evs-lfa-successor-may-get-it/ https://insideevs.com/news/625264/lexus-confirms-manual-tran... Jalopnik at least puts 'manual transmission' in single quotes: https://jalopnik.com/lexus-is-developing-a-manual-transmission-for-high-perf-1849857924 https://jalopnik.com/lexus-is-developing-a-manual-transmissi... These are headlines are better: https://www.theverge.com/2022/12/9/23501585/lexus-manual-transmission-stick-shift-ev https://www.theverge.com/2022/12/9/23501585/lexus-manual-tra... https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a42180807/lexus-built-an-ev-with-a-fake-manual-transmission/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a42180807/lexus-built-an-e...
- coldpie 4y agoMan, this is awesome. While my next car will be electric, I will be really, really sad to lose the clutch pedal. Shifting (with a clutch, paddle shifters are stupid) turns driving from a chore into a joy. Losing the clutch is going to turn driving 100% into a chore. I never thought a car manufacturer would actually make a fake EV shifter, and I'm still skeptical this will make it to market in any reasonably-priced car. But a convincing fake clutch pedal/shifter in an EV car would be a massive, massive checkmark in that car's favor.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoI've driven a stick forever. But I won't miss the clutch or the clutch pedal. Less to go wrong. Adding some kind of fake clutch/shifter where one isn't needed only adds more failure points. One of the big advantages of EVs is the simplicity of the drivetrain. This would make it not so simple and thus more prone to breakage. EDIT: Except, I guess in this case when it breaks the car will still function fine because it's not really connected to anything.
- coldpie 4y ago> But I won't miss the clutch or the clutch pedal. More power to you! EVs are great and I'm thrilled to see them catching on. But every time I have to drive an automatic I just want to slide into an early grave. No rev matching, no heel-toe downshifting, no holding on to a gear a little too long on an onramp, no deciding whether to downshift up a hill or coast down a hill in higher gear. Autos leave you with only the most mindless parts of driving. Zzzzz. No wonder they're building TVs into the dashboard now.
- xerox13ster 4y agoI tried to explain this at friendsgiving a few weeks ago. I think roads have gotten wider (and speeds higher and vehicles bigger as a result) to make people feel safe because people feel more out of touch with their vehicles now. People can't parallel park, but if you parallel park a few times on a hill in a standard, you _know_ your car. To be clear before I continue: I think all cars should go the way of the dodo and we can and should redesign our societies to not be dependent on them because we have the technology and resources to accomplish such a thing, we just waste them. Manufacturing electric cars IS NOT GOING TO REDUCE OUR FOSSIL FUEL EMISSIONS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I have never understood how anyone could think that. You have to mine for the batteries, the metal, you have to smelt it, is all that green? What about the energy to smelt it? To charge it? What about the environmental impacts of Lithium refining? What about the oil needed for all the plastic pieces inside? We absolutely need to abandon cars and start thinking realistically about how to accomplish it _yesterday_. But while we live on this highway to a mad max hell scape, there is an argument to be made for standard transmissions and their ability to keep the driver engaged and aware. There really is no time to text and drive, or a scenario where you can entirely check out while moving, as you will have to be aware of what your engine and transmission are doing. In an activity that breeds dissociation and distraction, while also demanding your full attention, a standard transmission is the fidget spinner that keeps you present. At least it does me.
- kkfx 4y agoIf this ABSURDITY will see the light I'll be finally convinced about Lebonian's stupidity of the masses... Oh, BTW as an EV owner (seeing the crappiness level of modern connected crapware inside the vehicle perhaps user is a better term, since the OEM is the real owner) I found MANY issues in such vehicles, one I do not found is the pleasure of driving without "engine regime steps" with constant torque and so on.
- infogulch 4y agoEye-rolling skeumorphism aside, the axial flux motor design has a power / torque / rpm profile closer to explosion-powered engine and could reasonably (?) be designed with an actual transmission. While axial flux motors are smaller than than induction motors, I doubt an axial flux motor + transmission can be more effective than an induction motor alone. Combining it with an explosion engine is more interesting though. The 2023 McLaren Artura uses an axial flux motor fused with the engine to maximize total power production even through low acceleration parts of a track, by running the engine while decelerating to charge the battery then the electric motor kicks in to boost acceleration on the flip side. See Engineering Explained's video about it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ICTi2Z_X5Kw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ICTi2Z_X5Kw