5 ms·
Cool. So, how does this impact consumers that never used Facebook, but that have shadow profiles for social network inference and ad tracking? Presumably, sin
by hedora 4y ago
Cool. So, how does this impact consumers that never used Facebook, but that have shadow profiles for social network inference and ad tracking?
Presumably, since Facebook has no way to contact those people, they will just shut down the no-logged-in-but-tracked half of their business in Europe?
(If you don't know what I mean by shadow profile: When you first create a Facebook account, it helpfully produces a prepopulated list of your friends, and links in a pile of consumer tracking data before the onboarding flow is done.)
- criddell 4y agoIt doesn't impact those consumers, but that wasn't what this action by the EU was trying to stop. It looks like this suit as all about users of Facebook and Instagram being forced to agree to tracking to use the service.
- nomel 4y ago> It looks like this suit as all about users of Facebook and Instagram being forced to agree to tracking to use the service. Is the reality that they'll be tracked regardless, just now through a thin veil of indirection (as with the shadow profiles)?
- aflag 4y agoI think tracking users without their consent is already illegal.
- tremon 4y agoTo be more specific: this ruling confirms that tracking users with only implied consent is illegal. What Facebook tried to do here is to make user tracking an integral part of their service by putting it in their TOS. The GDPR is quite clear that such tracking can never be a legitimate business interest and therefore a) users must agree to it explicitly, b) consent for tracking may be withdrawn at any time, and c) withdrawal of consent may not be tied to the rest of the service offering (i.e. a business may not refuse service if users decline to be tracked).
- nomel 4y ago> The GDPR is quite clear that such tracking can never be a legitimate business interest I assume the "can never" is actually a "should never", considering the profits that Facebook makes from it. ;)
- bluefirebrand 4y agoI assume it means that it legally can never be considered legitimate. Not that it can never make money.
- sofixa 4y agoDidn't Facebook stop doing this in the EU after Belgium fined them for it?
- BlueTemplar 4y agoAs a reminder, this is just the tip of the iceberg : The US has since 2001 built a techno-legal spying system that the Stasi would have been proud of (relying a lot on US companies, especially the GAFAMs), and worse, (ab)used it on non-US people, specifically people located in EUrope (especially as revealed by the Snowden scandal in 2013). Since this violates the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights, in 2015 the Court of Justice of the European Union has effectively declared US companies to be illegal in EUrope : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Schrems#Schrems_I https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Schrems#Schrems_I (Technically speaking, that's not strictly the case, but good luck having a business when you can't have access to your EU customer's personal data, which, depending on the context, includes things as basic as their IP address - and the context might change as your business evolves...) There have been attempts since 2015 between the US and the EU to try to find an agreement, but so far nothing has stuck, and it's hard to see how it can (unless the EU just chooses "denial" at some point), since, again, it's the whole US techno-legal spying system being in violation of EU fundamental rights that we're talking about.
- Hnrobert42 4y ago
- dangrossman 4y agoIt sounds fairly accurate to me. This is what killed the US-EU Privacy Shield program, twice. That was the government's attempt at creating a way for US companies like Facebook to legally process data of EU citizens under GDPR. It's been struck down by the EU courts, due to our federal government's spy powers and the CLOUD Act, that invalidate any claims US companies make about protecting personal data in their possession.
- Hnrobert42 4y agoI was referring to comparing the US intel operation to the Stasi.
- 4y ago
- canadianfella 4y ago
- jsemrau 4y agoDoesn't hurt to surface this video from Germany's CCC again https://media.ccc.de/v/35c3-9941-how_facebook_tracks_you_on_android https://media.ccc.de/v/35c3-9941-how_facebook_tracks_you_on_... I think they established well how this is done and that if you are not a user, they actually collect much more data.
- mrjin 4y agoEven if you dont't use Facebook at all, you can still be tracked by Facebook as lots of website you visit may contain trackers from it. So the plain fact is you get tracked by Facebook even if you are not a Facebook user. The info collected by those trackers might not be enough to identify you, but still good enough to feed tailored ads to you.